Your presale validation code has been accepted.
Click the
button to order your tickets.

Osmo Vänskä /// Music Director

Recent Articles

Happy Holidays!

From all of us at the Minnesota Orchestra, we wish you a wonderful, musical holiday season!



Musicians in the Spotlight

This season, six Minnesota Orchestra musicians take center stage as featured soloists! Take a moment to get to know each of them (including their favorite superheroes), then mark your calendar to hear their magnificent music at Orchestra Hall!

Upcoming Performances 


Vänskä Conducts Barber, Copland and Shaw

Featuring Gabriel Campos Zamora, clarinet

Jan 10-11 >>


Vänskä Conducts American Nomad

Featuring Charles Lazarus, trumpet

Jan 12-13 >>


Bizet, Mozart and Vivaldi

Featuring Roma Duncan, piccolo

Jan 31 - Feb 2 >>


Vänskä Conducts Beethoven and Sibelius

Featuring Tim Zavadil, bass clarinet

Apr 25-27 >>


Erin Keefe Plays Bernstein's Serenade

Featuring Erin Keefe, violin

May 3-4 >>

Osmo Vänskä Shares News

At the 2017-18 annual meeting, major news was shared on two fronts. We highlighted the artistic and financial milestones of the Orchestra’s 2017-18 season and Osmo Vänskä announced plans to conclude his tenure as Music Director of the Minnesota Orchestra in August 2022.


Osmo Vänskä Announces Plans to Conclude his Tenure 

Osmo Vänskä announced plans today at the Minnesota Orchestra’s annual meeting to conclude his tenure as Music Director of the Minnesota Orchestra in August 2022.

The 2021-22 season, his final as music director, will mark his 19th year at the helm of the Minnesota Orchestra, capping what is widely considered one of the great musical partnerships in Minnesota Orchestra history. Beyond 2022, Vänskä and the Minnesota Orchestra will maintain their musical relationship, with Vänskä returning for ongoing concert engagements.



Minnesota Orchestra Reports Fiscal 2018 Balanced Budget

The Minnesota Orchestra’s 2018 Annual Meeting celebrated the artistic and financial milestones of the Orchestra’s 2017-18 season, a year in which the Orchestra received a Grammy nomination and added to its Mahler symphony cycle; launched its first full-Orchestra Sensory-Friendly concert; toured to Mankato, Chicago, London and, in a first for a U.S. orchestra, South Africa—and achieved a balanced budget.

Read more >> 

Thank you to our audiences and donors for their wholehearted support which has made the achievements of the past season possible!

Three Memories

By Kevin Kling

One holiday Mary and I went to our niece's violin recital. Seven little girls in a row, ranging in ages from four to six, playing "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star". Almost immediately the bow of our niece got caught on one of the pigtails of the girl standing next to her. It would not pull free.

So she persevered, playing the entire piece with the head of the girl in pigtails whipping back and forth in time with the tune. Afterward, everyone agreed that our niece had a future in music.

As a collector of stories, I'm especially fond of the holidays. It's a heightened time when no matter the pre-planning or good intentions something always goes awry. As everyone knows these mishaps, mayhems and maladies make for the best stories.

We have one family story involving my grandparents. When they were newlyweds they asked the local preacher over for a holiday supper. This was during the time of Prohibition and my grandfather had recently made some homemade 'elixir' and it was in the basement in the process of 'getting good'. During the meal, some of the jars started to explode. Everyone, including the preacher, knew exactly what that sound meant. Without missing a beat my grandfather turned to my grandmother and said, "There going your peaches, Honey". "There go your peaches, Honey" is a catchphrase in my family ever since for when a situation has clearly gone off the rails.

One of my fondest memories falls in 1980. I was performing in England over the holidays and missing my family very much. To take my mind off of the homesickness I went to see a play called "The Dresser", starring Tom Courtenay and Albert Finney. It's about a friendship between two men and a ragtag group of performers in a London theater during World War II. The couple sitting next to me looked to be in their 80's and quite likely had served in the war or been subjected to the bombing raids that devastated London. As an air raid siren sounded in the play the man reached over and gripped my hand. When the bombs stopped he released, never looking over to me or acknowledging the gesture. Later on the entire audience sang together as the cast led us in "A Nightingale Sang in Berkeley Square". Automatically everyone took hands and swayed back-and-forth. When the song ended, this time the man didn't let go of my hand and held it clear to the end of the play.

Hear more of Kevin's incredible stories at "Home for the Holidays" with the Minnesota Orchestra on Dec. 14, 16 & 20 >> 

Kevin Kling’s plays have been produced in the Twin Cities and around the world. His collaborations with composer Victor Zupanc include For the Birds for Zeitgeist, The Burning Wisdom of Finn McCool with the Metropolitan Symphony Orchestra and, most recently, The Best Summer Ever for the Children’s Theatre Company. A frequent commentator for TPT’s Almanac, NPR and MPR’s All Things Considered, Kling was named the Minneapolis Story Laureate by then-Mayor R.T. Rybak in 2014. He grew up in Osseo, Minnesota, and graduated from Gustavus Adolphus College. More:

Musical Perspectives

Students from the South African National Youth Orchestra reflect on their August 2018 Immersion Experience with the Minnesota Orchestra and what is next in their musical lives.

By Isha Ranchod

“When you go to these courses, you come back home with this fire, and you want to spread it – let everyone else catch onto it because it’s such a great feeling to have!”

Young French horn player Hayley Uithaler’s face lights up as she tries to describe her sentiments. Uithaler is a member of the South African National Youth Orchestra (SANYO), a nonprofit organization dedicated to the training and development of South Africa’s young musicians.

SANYO students felt a rush of adrenalin for two days straight when the Minnesota Orchestra joined the ensemble for what was called an Immersion Experience in August 2018, as part of the Minnesota Orchestra’s five-city tour of South Africa.

For the SANYO members, the impact of the Minnesota Orchestra's visit continues well after the Orchestra has left. Over two months later, the Orchestra is remembered and discussed with vivid excitement by all those who took part in this experience. The Minnesota Orchestra has since begun its new season. How has life moved on for the young orchestra members from South Africa?

Five of these young musicians shared their thoughts.

Small Things Matter Most

Kutloano Bookholane (viola, 15) and Refilwe ‘Fifi’ Moeketsane (bass, 16) were taking part in SANYO’s annual orchestra course for the first time. They started as participants of the Mangaung String Program in Free State, South Africa, which targets historically disadvantaged children by setting up string lessons in some of the province’s primary schools. Both Kutloano and Fifi began as violin pupils, but chose to change to their respective lower-registered instruments after about a year of playing the violin.

The top players in this string program, such as Kutloano and Fifi, get promoted to join the Bochabela String Orchestra, made up of strings, congas and shakers, all used together to play catchy African beats, traditional tunes and much more.

When I asked Kutloano what he thought of the Minnesota Orchestra’s performances he saw as part of the Immersion Experience, he says incredulously, “Didn’t you hear them play? Didn’t you hear a world class orchestra?” He added then that it also made him aware that the small things in the music are the things that truly matter the most.

What really made this an immersive experience is that it was so much more than just being given tickets to two performances. SANYO students participated in a side-by-side rehearsal with the Minnesota Orchestra, conducted by Music Director Osmo Vänskä himself, in which each young player sat next to his or her professional counterpart, making it very personal to each individual. This side-by-side rehearsal was supplemented by masterclasses for the various sections or instrument groups.

"I was so scared I couldn't talk."

I asked how Fifi felt when she woke up on the morning of the side-by-side rehearsal, when they would meet a major American orchestra for the first time. She had told herself to be calm and relax, playing it down in her mind during the build-up. But when she got there, she says she sort of broke down.

“I don’t know what happened. I was so scared that I couldn’t talk to anyone, and my voice was just non-existent. It was so overwhelming, but in a very exciting way.”

She soon recovered, thanks to Minnesota Orchestra bass player David Williamson, with whom Fifi was paired. Over and above giving her tips and intonation exercises, he encouraged her not to be afraid while playing. “I learnt to be confident, because he kept on telling me that I’m good, even though I wasn’t so sure about it at the time.”

For most of the SANYO members, this was the first time they witnessed, let alone interacted with, a professional orchestra of this caliber. One exception to this, however, is Gilah Kellner (violin, 15), who, just 14 years old at the time, was SANYO’s concertmaster for this orchestra course. Gilah was selected as one of three SANYO members to visit the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra in Amsterdam in May this year. With this experience behind her and to compare to, she described the Minnesota Orchestra enthusiastically.

“They are a very good orchestra, and they move together. They really exaggerate dynamics, making the tiniest sound, and then beautiful large sounds, playing energetically and in such an expressive manner.” Of Osmo Vänskä she says, “He’s very passionate and I think that is brilliant. He also conducts in a way that shows he knows what everyone is doing—he is extremely knowledgeable.”

Gilah, who is based in Johannesburg, is home-schooled, but hopes to do her post-secondary studies in music performance in America or Germany. She also performed as a soloist in the National Youth Concerto Festival just a month ago. Kutloano, on the other hand, wants to first study something along the lines of mechanical engineering in South Africa, before pursuing a music career overseas in Europe. And Fifi, who was of two minds about it before the Immersion Experience, is now considering a career in music, having spoken to Minnesota Orchestra musicians and seen how much they enjoy what they do.

Musical Waves

This year, the ages of the SANYO members ranged from 12 to 26 years. Two zealous music students from Nelson Mandela University in the coastal city Port Elizabeth, Hayley Uithaler (horn, 22) and Chadley Johnson (trombone, 21), were part of the brass section, and have been since 2016.

Both Hayley and Chadley had been researching their Minnesota Orchestra counterparts and sections well before the Immersion Experience. Chadley joked that he didn’t even need to be introduced to his section or his mentor, Minnesota Orchestra Principal Trombone R. Douglas Wright, since he recognized them all immediately.

I asked Chadley what he felt the impact of the experience to have been. He explained that as a musician, you go through waves, and last year had been the most stagnant in his progress, not just in terms of technical ability on his instrument, but also in his motivation to practise and his outlook on the future. He explained that when SANYO brought in a few of the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra members to their Summer course in December 2017, it sparked something in him. “With the waves that you go through, having the Minnesota Orchestra members here re-sparked it. So the great part of these courses is you get refueled, and until the next course, you’ve got what you need to carry on—it equips you to go forth alone.”

Play and Deliver

Hayley bonded very well with her counterpart, Minnesota Orchestra horn player Ellen Dinwiddie Smith, not only because she was generous, open and willing to share her knowledge and advice.

“Ellen expressed to me that there will be days when it will feel as if it’s not a good day for you, but even on those days, you still need to put your mind in the right place to be able to play and deliver. Now I’ve seen an entire orchestra that does that. So now you kind of crave that kind of environment from everyone around you, but it was just nice to know that they are human and relatable. Some of them still have performance anxiety! They gave me tips on how to deal with it.”

Hayley plans to do a Postgraduate Certificate in Education after she graduates, and although she wants to teach, she is emphatic that she won’t stop playing in ensembles and orchestras when she does.

Chadley was the concerto soloist in the Nelson Mandela University Orchestra’s concert in September, and he wants to take a Master’s degree in performance—ideally in another country—once he graduates. He says he will start preparing and researching universities, auditions and scholarships soon.

There were three recurring themes with all five of these young SANYO members. Firstly, they all  loved being able to have dinner with the Minnesota Orchestra members, being able to talk freely, get to know each other, and ask questions that didn’t necessarily relate to Sibelius’ Symphony No. 2, the music that was rehearsed in the side-by-side experience. Nevertheless, they did all take away new perspectives and techniques for their respective instruments. Finally, they all wished that they had even more time with the Minnesota musicians, be that in the form of masterclasses, lessons, or just another meal together.

After my interview with Hayley and Chadley, I gave them the opportunity to add their own questions. They asked in unison:

“When is the next Immersion Experience?”

Isha Ranchod is a freelance writer based in Port Elizabeth, South Africa. A SANYO alumna, she worked as an assistant project manager for SANYO during the Immersion Experience. Ranchod completed a degree in Music with Psychology as her second major with Cum Laude. She holds being a feminist and a member of the Indian diaspora as two major facets of her personality, and she is a passionate dog lover.

Photos by Travis Anderson and Sean Burke

Young People's Concerts: Teacher Reviews

The Young People’s concert season kicked off on October 23rd with Watch the Orchestra Grow. Over the course of two days, more than 6,000 students filled Orchestra Hall to enjoy the music of Mozart, Beethoven, and more. Check out what the teachers and parents had to say!


“This experience was amazing for my students. My school, in particular, is very high poverty and kids come from very diverse backgrounds. Providing them with this experience is, for a lot of the, a once in a lifetime opportunity. I'm hoping some of them were inspired to continue on with music into their middle school years!”



“My son has been writing "symphony movements" on the piano since our field trip.”



“Well, they wouldn't stop talking about the percussionist with the whip on the Percussion Mvt of the Britten piece, so he did a wonderful job! Overall, the kids were enamored with being inside the hall and how cool of an experience it was.”



“I would give your concert series an A+ for educational value. I'm deeply appreciative of the opportunity to expose my children to the beauty of music. Thank you!”



“I loved the concert. I love everything that you all do for our students in helping to educate them and promote classical music in a positive and super fun manner. I'm looking forward to next year!”



“Thank you for your time and effort in gifting this experience to the students in the Twin Cities! We love coming to the orchestra!”


Join us at an upcoming Young People's Concert >>

Welcoming Two New Orchestra Musicians

We are excited to welcome two new musicians to the Minnesota Orchestra this winter. Felicity James has been appointed associate concertmaster and Erich Rieppel has been appointed principal timpani. We look forward to seeing them onstage at Orchestra Hall soon!

Felicity James, violin

Felicity James joins the Minnesota Orchestra as associate concertmaster in December 2018, having previously served as concertmaster of the Verbier Festival Orchestra, the Colburn Orchestra, and the Aspen Philharmonic Orchestra, and as a substitute with the Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra and the Seattle Symphony. In addition to competing in numerous international violin competitions, she has appeared as soloist with orchestras all over the United States, including the Seattle Symphony under the direction of music director Ludovic Morlot. An enthusiastic chamber musician, she has performed frequently in ensembles at the Verbier, Sarasota and Aspen Music Festivals as well as with the Colburn Chamber Music Society and the Los Angeles Da Camera Society, and has had the honor of collaborating with Gary Hoffman, Clive Greensmith, Ani Kavafian, Anthony Marwood and the Calidore String Quartet. James recently earned her Bachelor of Music degree from the Colburn Conservatory of Music, where she studied with Robert Lipsett and worked closely with Arnold Steinhardt and Clive Greensmith.

She starts her position with the Orchestra on December 10, and will serve as concertmaster for the Home for the Holidays and Beauty and the Beast concerts from December 14 to 22.

Erich Rieppel, timpani

Prior to his appointment as principal timpani of the Minnesota Orchestra, Erich Rieppel held the same title at New World Symphony under Michael Tilson Thomas in Miami Beach, Florida. He has performed as principal timpanist with the Seattle Symphony, Detroit Symphony and New Jersey Symphony, among others. He has held the posts of associate timpanist of the Chicago Civic Orchestra, substitute timpanist with the Louisville Orchestra and Charleston Symphony, and principal timpanist of the Terre Haute Symphony and the Columbus Indiana Philharmonic. He has experience in arts administration, college teaching, music librarianship and conducting. A native of Minnesota, Rieppel grew up near Marshall, Minnesota, engaging in the many musical activities the area had to offer. He attended Indiana University for his bachelor’s and master’s degrees where he studied a variety of percussion with John Tafoya, Kevin Bobo, Steve Houghton and Michael Spiro. He has also studied with many other prominent musicians including Josef Gumpinger, David Herbert, Ed Stephan, Shannon Wood and Tom Freer. In his free time, Rieppel plays hockey. 

Earlier this month, Rieppel performed and recorded Mahler’s Seventh Symphony with the Minnesota Orchestra, and he will officially begin his new role with the ensemble on December 30.


First Timer's Guide to Orchestra Hall

We know what you're thinking. An orchestra concert. Audiences formally clad in tuxes and gowns. A light smattering of polite applause. An uncomfortable seat with lots of shushing. Not an ideal way to spend your Saturday night, right?

Forget about it.

We’re proud that Orchestra Hall is a welcoming environment for all. Here are a few frequently asked questions that will help make your first Orchestra concert experience more comfortable.

What do I wear?

We get this question a lot, but rest assured, there's no dress code at Orchestra Hall. You might see tuxes and gowns for special celebratory performances. You might see business casual or professional looks for folks on a special night out. You might also see regular street clothes. Be you. Be comfortable.

When should I arrive?

The earlier the better! Doors open two hours before your performance, and activities typically begin an hour before the first notes. Whether its a chat with a guest artist, an interactive exhibit or a performance, each pre-concert activity is designed to provide context to what is happening on stage and build connections with our community.

Do I need to know anything about the program?

Our musicians envy those who are experiencing this great music for the first time. There are surprises around every corner. Sit back or lean in.

Getting to know the program before the concert is a great way to get the most out of your concert experience. Your program magazine is a treasure trove of information about each piece of music and the musicians on stage. We'll also email you the week of the performance with your ticket details along with some extra info about your concert.

When should I clap?

Half-hearted applause has no place in Orchestra Hall. We love and are extremely grateful for an enthusiastic and energetic audience, no matter the piece. We do, however, ask that you hold your applause until the very end of each piece.

Take a quick peek at your program to see if there are multiple movements, or section of the larger work, listed next to each piece of music. If so, hold your applause to the last movement on that list. If you’re nervous, wait for cues from those around you. Our superfans will show you the way.

When can I take pictures or video?

Think movie theater etiquette. While we don't allow videos or photos while the musicians are performing, we highly encourage you to capture your time with the Orchestra before or after the performance, or during intermission. Use #MNorch so we can give them a like and share our favorites!

When can I use my phone?

Two hours device free? Sounds like paradise.

If device separation gives you a little anxiety, we get it. Please silence your phone when you enter the hall and try not to look at your phone while the musicians are performing. The light from your screen can be a little annoying for your seat neighbors.

How long is the intermission?

Most concerts include a 20-minute intermission. Plenty of time to use the restroom, stretch your legs, pick up a drink, or skim through your program to get hyped for the second half.

Where can I ask more questions?

At Orchestra Hall, we have incredible ushers and volunteers, always standing by to answer any questions that come up. If you have questions before your performance, reach out to our ticketing team at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. or find us on social media.

About Orchestra Hall

Our bright, beautiful and expansive lobby provides plenty of space to roam around and explore before and after your concert. Stop by a bar to grab a drink or snack, check out the merchandise cart, or explore the pre-concert activities.

Orchestra Hall, home of the Minnesota Orchestra since 1974, is known as one of the best acoustic spaces in the world. In 2012, the hall was renovated to create long-awaited upgrades and additions throughout the building. There are 114 cubes on the ceilings and walls. They bounce the sound all over the place so everyone can hear our Orchestra play. But that also means that if you talk from your seats, the musicians can hear you too!

Enjoy your performance! We’re looking forward to welcoming you to Orchestra Hall.

Donors are the Heart of the Minnesota Orchestra

For over a century, enthusiastic Orchestra patrons have made generous contributions to guarantee our ability to present awe-inspiring performances for the community each season. We are grateful for this outpouring of generosity that helps to sustain our remarkable Orchestra. Equally heartening are the unique Minnesota Orchestra stories these donors have shared through the years. Read some of their unforgettable experiences that have inspired such generous support at every level.

“I started coming to the Orchestra over 40 years ago. I was a police officer who just needed an escape from all of the violence and issues that were impacting our residents and the music was a refreshing and uplifting experience.”


“The Minnesota Orchestra collaborated with my high school, gave in-class demonstrations, offered concert tickets, etc. That series of interactions was one of the highlights of being a student in an inner-city high school.”


“In turbulent times, music calms the soul and transfixes the listener; it transforms all who listen no matter what gender, race, or ethnic background.”


“I am a pianist. When I was in the middle of preparing for auditions to graduate school for piano performance, I had a serious accident that prevented me from playing for well over three years.  I knew I needed to find something to fill the emptiness left by not being able to play. The MN orchestra literally helped save my life.  It became my oxygen tank and has been filling my soul ever since.”


“As a retired secretary, I don’t have very much money but I give what I can. I wish it could be more, so I decided to become a volunteer. I am also an ambassador, encouraging friends and acquaintances, to attend concerts”


“I began regularly attending MN Orchestra concerts when my children were young. We were annual subscribers to the Family series concerts, and also went to the pre-concert educational presentations. My children developed a love for music, and a love for this organization that has continued into their adult years. Arts, particularly music, are so important to preserve and nourish!”


Thank you for your support!


Music for All

Guest blogger Mandy Meisner learns how the Minnesota Orchestra’s Sensory-Friendly Concerts are making Orchestra Hall inclusive for all audiences. Sensory-Friendly Concerts at Orchestra Hall are designed for patrons of all ages and abilities, including individuals on the autism spectrum and those with sensory sensitivities. The 2018-19 series includes five concerts featuring the full Orchestra and three featuring solo instruments or small ensembles, beginning with a performance by cellist Katja Linfield in the Target Atrium on November 20.

I was taught we have five senses. You can imagine my surprise when I learned today’s scientists have identified nine: sight, hearing, taste, smell, touch, thermoception (heat and cold), nociception (pain), equilibrioception (balance and gravity) and proprioception (body awareness). Our bodies are a constant symphony of input and output of the information around us in a much more expansive way than I thought.

A symphony orchestra performance may look, sound and feel very different to each of us. With this in mind, in recent years the Minnesota Orchestra has introduced a new series of Sensory-Friendly Concerts designed for everyone to enjoy, no matter how we process those nine senses. The idea originated five years ago with a handful of Orchestra musicians who wanted to create a welcoming environment for young people on the autism spectrum. They gave small-scale performances in the community, and eventually in Orchestra Hall’s Target Atrium, that were well-received. Now the Orchestra has expanded the Sensory-Friendly series to include three small ensemble performances and three full-Orchestra Family Concerts each season.

starting small

Back in February, this is how I experienced my first small-ensemble Sensory-Friendly concert:

We gather in the glass box of the Target Atrium, escaping from the winter cold, a smattering of different ages and ilk. Without the formal protocol of a standard classical concert, the energy spills out with heartfelt vocal responses, jitters and tapping. Minnesota Orchestra musicians Pamela Arnstein and Kathryn Nettleman talk in easy conversation about the works being performed, the instruments and bits of their lives. Even before the music starts, we feel as we are all friends.

And when it does start, the room is transformed. The music itself is reflected in the responses of the audience. Universally, we are calm. We are moved by the story the music tells, quiet and soothing in parts, humming and chortling in rhythmic delight in others.

A young man, looking dapper in a crisp white shirt, black suspenders and bow tie, comes on stage to perform on his cello. He is the first cellist with Down syndrome to play in the varsity orchestra at school. His sound is clean, confident and straightforward. He beams with joy.

There is a second youth performer. He sits stiffly at the piano, his face unemotional. But his music is filled with great expression and sweetness, and that is all we need to know him.

adding the full Orchestra

Six months later, I attend the first full-Orchestra Sensory-Friendly Family Concert, when the Hall is flooded with families. Whole families, many for the first time, are experiencing a Minnesota Orchestra concert, together. No one is left behind. In the lobby, a large table holds gobs of colorful clay that are shaped into trees and animals in the small, dimpled hands of children. There are stations throughout Orchestra Hall, creative welcoming islands.

Before the concert begins there is quiet chatter, the flutter of arms and swishing of pigtails. The host, Lyndie Walker of Toneworks Music Therapy Services, speaks in a clear, slow cadence about courage and triumph, bravery and perseverance.

No one is required to sit still, be silent, or clap only in the “right” places. Instead, everyone is welcome to express themselves and experience the music in their own way. We are human prisms; the music goes through and we become a spectrum of indescribable colors.

The music flows over us, each piece offering a different sensation: Aaron Copland pounds through my chest; Harry Potter is whimsical, hopeful and adventuresome; West Side Story’s plaintive lines tug somewhere deep. Cellist Nygel Witherspoon enters with his signature cloud of curly hair. His playing is tender and melancholy for one so young. Conductor Akiko Fujimoto finishes the concert with the blazing end of the Firebird.

When the music ends, sounds and motions of delight can be seen and heard throughout the Hall. Next to me, a family of four lingers. A young woman with impossibly thick hair held back in a barrette rocks back and forth, glowing. Her name is Carly. She is 20 years old, and this is the first time she has listened to the Minnesota Orchestra. She had been receiving music therapy for the last 15 years and was visibly enjoying the performance, vocalizing enthusiastically in parts, shaking in others.

I spoke with Carly’s mother, Lisa, who shared with me her appreciation in having this opportunity to bring not only Carly, but their whole family. This was in fact the first time they could all come together. Later, I tell her the Minnesota Orchestra will offer a Sensory-Friendly environment for all the family concerts in the 2018-2019 season.

News that feels good for all of our nine senses.

Photos by Greg Helgeson and Scott Streble.

The Minnesota Orchestra’s 2018-19 Sensory-Friendly Family Concerts include Carnival of the Animals; The Tin Forest; Joyful Rhythms, Joyful Sounds; and a three-concert solo and small ensemble series in Orchestra Hall’s Target Atrium.

Q&A with Kevin Puts

In Minnesota Orchestra concerts November 15, 16 and 17, the Orchestra performs Inspiring Beethoven by Pulitzer Prize-winning composer Kevin Puts, who has also served as the director of Minnesota Orchestra's Composer Institute since 2014. This marks the Minnesota Orchestra premiere of this work. We asked Puts about how to approach new music, what inspired him to write Inspiring Beethoven and his role in the Minnesota music scene.

Osmo Vänskä with Puts at a Future Classics rehearsal.

This is a big month for your music here as Minnesota Opera performs your opera Silent Night at about the same time as the Minnesota Orchestra’s performances of Inspiring Beethoven. Do you have any stand-out memories of your music being performed in Minnesota?
The Twin Cities have become such a warm and welcoming musical home for me, and the performances of my music by Osmo Vänskä and the amazing Minnesota Orchestra have been some of the most electrifying I have ever heard. The fact that my music is being performed by both the Minnesota Orchestra and Minnesota Opera within a month of each other is kind of mind-boggling to me!

Tell us about your orchestral work Inspiring Beethoven.
It was commissioned by the Phoenix Symphony for a Beethoven festival way back in 2000, when I was just out of school. I had the idea of beginning the piece like the first movement Allegro of Beethoven's Symphony No. 7, but then taking a less optimistic turn! I was imagining Beethoven finding the inspiration to write that Allegro, which is one of the most uplifting and beautiful movements in all of music—for me anyway. 

What are you listening to lately?
I seem to be randomly dropping in on various Bach cantatas online. It's just unbelievable music, and he wrote so much of it and with such apparent ease.

How do you encourage listeners to approach a new piece of music?
With an open mind and with breathless anticipation! There is nothing in the world like hearing a piece which no one has heard before, and which reflects the time we live in.   

When you aren’t composing, what do you do for fun?
I play tennis, mostly with my eight-year-old son! I love the sport but never learned it well as a kid, so I get sort of crazy about it trying to improve my game, especially during the summer when the outdoor courts are open and my son is out of school. We live in the New York area, so it all leads up to the U.S. Open in early September. 

Attend the concert >> 

More about Kevin Puts >>

A Resounding Resurgence: The Music of Florence Price

Florence Beatrice Price was the first African American woman to have her work performed by a major American orchestra. During our American Expressions Festival in January, the Minnesota Orchestra performs her Third Symphony—which received its world premiere this very week in 1940. And this weekend audiences can hear the piece that first put her on the map as a great American composer, when the Minnesota Philharmonic Orchestra performs her First Symphony at Ted Mann Concert Hall.

In a New York Times story, musicologist Douglas Shadle noted that “Our understanding of American modernism of the 1930s and 1940s is not complete without Price’s contribution.”

Price was born in on April 9, 1887, to a mixed-race family in Little Rock, Arkansas. The daughter of a music teacher and a dentist, she excelled early both academically and musically, attending the New England Conservatory by the age of 14 to study piano, organ and composition.

Becoming the First of a Kind

Premiered by the Chicago Symphony in 1933 as part of the Chicago World’s Fair, Price’s Symphony No. 1 in E minor inspired immediate praise and became the first symphony by an African American woman ever performed by a major American orchestra. The Chicago Daily News, Chicago Herald & Examiner, Chicago Defender and Music News all lauded Price’s symphony, and First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt highlighted the premiere in her national newspaper column, My Day.

Price’s musical language is often compared to that of Antonín Dvořák and is said to have influences of black British composer Samuel Coleridge-Taylor’s music. Indeed, all three explored various “folk” music as inspiration for their melodies, rhythms and musical forms. In Price’s First Symphony, the songful, simple and gently-syncopated themes of the opening movement clearly bear that character, as do the hopping, turning, hand-clapping, thigh-slapping and foot-stomping rhythms in the juba dance of the third movement.

Click for more about Minnesota Philharmonic's upcoming performance of Symphony No. 1.

Preview the work:

Inspired by the Chicago Renaissance

Price’s Third Symphony premiered on November 6, 1940, at the Detroit Institute of Arts, in a concert by the Michigan WPA Symphony Orchestra. This was the group with whom Price earned her widest exposure particularly due to great support from the group’s conductor Valter Poole. The same concert featured Price as the soloist for her own Piano Concerto in One Movement.

In a departure from the First Symphony, Price did not intentionally use specific ideas or melodies associated with African American music or dance for her Third Symphony. However, her musical output at that time was greatly inspired by many of the artists and intellectuals who were at the heart of the Chicago Renaissance of the 1930s—including Langston Hughes, Richard Wright and Margaret Bond—and who were changing the role of African American artists during the 20th century.

Click to learn more about Minnesota Orchestra's performances of Symphony No. 3.

Preview the work:

And Now A Resurgence

Despite enthusiastic reception of these works, Price’s music slowly slipped from public consciousness, for reasons quite clear to the composer herself. In July 1943, Price wrote to Serge Koussevitzky, then-conductor of the Boston Symphony, confidently describing her own “two handicaps – those of sex and race."

Following her death in 1953, Price’s music fell into obscurity in the U.S., even as it gained recognition in Canada and Europe. Only at the beginning of the 21st century has public interest accelerated in the United States. American orchestras are programming and recording her works more frequently, critical editions of the first and third symphonies were created in 2008 by musicologists Rae Linda Brown and Wayne Shirley, and in 2009 a newly-discovered collection of Price’s manuscripts—including two of her violin concertos which have since seen been performed and recorded—caught the attention of musical media outlets across the nation.

“Florence Price is a representation in music of what it means to be a black artist living within a white canon and trying to work within the classical realm,”  says Marquese Carter, a doctoral student at Indiana University, as quoted in The New York Times

Price’s music will see a total of ten performances by the Minnesota Orchestra this year. In addition to the January 12 and 13 concerts, the complete Third Symphony will be performed at Symphonic Adventures concerts in January and February, and selected movements will be played at Young People’s and Family Concerts in May 2019.

The Minnesota Orchestra thanks Brian Edward Dowdy for contributing to this story. Dowdy conducts the Minnesota Philharmonic Orchestra in a performance of Florence Price’s Symphony No. 1 on Saturday, November 3, 2018, at Ted Mann Concert Hall in Minneapolis. For more information, visit

“Sharing the Harvest” solo art exhibition

Minnesota Orchestra audiences were introduced to the artwork of Mary Pettis in June 2017, when the Orchestra hosted her Beyond the Surface solo exhibition through the OH+ program in conjunction with the Orchestra’s concert of French impressionistic music.

Audiences have clamored for more, and next month Pettis will present her third Orchestra Hall solo art exhibition, Sharing the Harvest, free and open to the public at the Orchestra’s November 15, 16 and 17 performances of music by Kevin Puts, Dmitri Shostakovich and Ludwig van Beethoven. Read on as writer A. Catherine Duthie (MA) describes the exhibit and a few of its paintings, and explains how they connect to the music on the concert program. Join us at Orchestra Hall next month for the full musical and visual experience!

Inspired by the works and themes in the November 15-17 concerts, Mary Pettis’ exhibition Sharing the Harvest complements the musical program by praising creative synthesis and culmination. Much like the pieces to be performed, this show is about the coming together of contrasts; of the inner and the outer worlds, of restraint and of expression; of honoring the past and of embracing the present.

The first work on the program is modern composer Kevin Puts’ Inspiring Beethoven, which pays tribute to Beethoven, imagines his unusual creative process and incorporates portions of his Seventh Symphony. In a similar manner, Pettis’ subject matter is imbued with familiarity and respect for works preceding it. A walking path bathed in dim evening light, water lilies draped across a gently moving stream, fields dotted with transient ponds; these are timeless motifs and have been employed by countless artists. And like Puts, Pettis has transformed and shaped these familiar elements to express the inner mind and sentiment of the creator. In fact, many paintings in this collection are not literal depictions of scenery, but an abstracted design to reflect their internalized spirit. While her painting Road to the Sea was inspired by the contemplative walk between the Scottish village of Stonehaven and its Dunnottar Castle, you would not be able to photograph its likeness in nature. And yet, it contains the experience of the path. Look long enough and you can feel the cool mist around your ankles, the air heavy with the smell of moss and sweet gorse. Road to the Sea expresses the internal experience of the artist, in the same way Puts’ Inspiring Beethoven expresses the internal experience of the composer.

Road to the Sea by Mary Pettis.

Beethoven differed from his predecessors in that he looked inward to express what was going on in the outer world. Most of his symphonies, including the Seventh Symphony heard in full at these concerts, broke the established musical boundaries and rules of the time to reflect his passion, his instability, his torture, and his triumph. Once he establishes the ideas and motives in his work, he explores them from every possible angle, employing every possible structure, voicing, and development. Pettis continues this dramatic tradition by infusing her paintings with tonal control and motivic development. The simplest motif of water is explored from multiple perspectives within the show. Her painting Molto Vivace is a compilation piece of about a dozen smaller studies that Pettis painted on location as notes to herself along the north shore of Lake Superior between Duluth and Grand Marais. It reminds us of the power that this precious, yet ever-present element holds. The many waterfalls have worn away at the heavy basalt as they continue to carve paths for themselves, and we as the viewer are placed in the middle of this continuing action. Minnehaha Falls in Autumn depicts this forward motion from afar, and we see the unity of direction and movement of the falls and rivers. Through this, we see a more orchestrated, purposeful portrayal of moving water and the constant push and pull it has with its environment. In contrast, the small pond in October Fields is a point of cool respite amidst the warm browns and reds of the long autumnal grass. And in Placido, the reflective stream serves as a living, breathing environment, nurturing lilies, reeds, and even a little frog (what a reward for looking deeper!). Pettis depicts her variations on the theme of water with environmental precision, evoking initial familiarity, awareness, and reverence.

Minnehaha Falls in Autumn by Mary Pettis.

Shostakovich’s mastery of orchestration and texture are the deliberate subjects of his Second Cello Concerto, which the Orchestra will perform with soloist Anthony Ross. At times, the sparse cello and percussive exchanges sound a simple line between the audience and silence. At others, the orchestration is so thick and lustrous that it is easy to get swept away in the wave of sound. Immediately when considering texture in visual art, we look for the physical tactile variation in the paint itself. In Pettis’ Edge of Twilight, we can nearly see the canvas itself through the shadows on the edge of the pond. This thinness further strengthens the heavy impasto highlights sparkling along the gentle windblown ripples of the roadside pond. However, just like in the Concerto, there is more to texture dynamics than simple physical layering of instruments. Shostakovich also uses rhythmic diversity and syncopation to create sharp, smooth, crisp layers and textures within his work. In similar ways, texture is also created in paint by layering different levels of chroma on top of one another. The contrast in chroma enhances the overall vibration and impression on the viewer’s eye. You can find an example of this in the lit warm violets and greens in Molto Vivace. In every form that comes forward, for example, the closest rock formation and the closest cascade of water, the vivid, purer colors were layered on top of a more quiet, subdued echo of the hue underneath.

Edge of Twilight by Mary Pettis.

In summary, Sharing the Harvest serves as a coalescence celebrating tradition, development, and integration. Pettis’ paintings play on the exploration of a theme, the reflections between the inner and outer worlds, and the balance between intellect, perspective, and expression. It is an invitation extended to us, encouraging us to experience paintings as one would experience music—through time, contemplation, and awareness of the long history and tradition that informs it.

Mary Pettis is the ninth American woman painter to be named an ARC Living Master™ by the Art Renewal Center. This distinguished honor is defined, in part, as: “an artist who has mastered all of the building blocks of great art...creating fully professional works of art, as well as some identifiable masterpieces...has successfully created a body of work which demonstrates accomplished facility in their craft that compares to the masters of prior centuries…”. She is also a Signature Member of the American Impressionist Society, American Society of Marine Artists, and Oil Painters of America. For a full biography and more information, visit

Pick Six: Minnesota Orchestra Recordings

For those looking to begin—or expand--a classical collection, audiophile Matthew Philion compiles this short list of Minnesota Orchestra recordings that should be in your music library.

Antal Dorati Conducts Music of Respighi, Mercury Records Olympian Series

A 1954 recording with the Minneapolis Symphony and Dorati, playing the Italian composer’s Church Windows and Roman Festivals. Though recorded in mono, the release has been praised for its performance and outstanding sonics. Now available in a high-definition digital download, this historic account sounds better than ever.  

Antal Dorati Conducts Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture and Capriccio Italien, Mercury Living Presence

Actually the second time Dorati and the Orchestra recorded the audience-favorite 1812 Overture, and the first time in stereo. This 1958 account offers thrilling playing, with sonics that have not been equaled in the past sixty years.    

Stanislaw Skrowaczewski conducts Music of Ravel, Vox Records VoxBox Set

This set of Ravel’s orchestral works has been celebrated since its release over 40 years ago. Taped in Orchestra Hall in fall 1975, they were the first recordings in the then-new venue, and with a new label. The performances are idiomatic and engaging, with just the right amount of French lightness and Spanish precision. The sonics perfectly capture a world-class orchestra in a world-class concert hall.

Edo de Waart Conducts Richard Strauss’ Sinfonia Domestica and Suite for Winds, Virgin Classics

Maestro de Waart recorded three albums of Strauss’ music in the early 1990s. Along with the famous tone poems were several early chamber works for winds, including the Suite for 13 Instruments. The playing is delicate, tuneful, and light—a nice counter-balance to the composer’s large-scale works for orchestra. 

Eiji Oue Conducts Music of Copland, Reference Recordings

Recorded by the audiophile label Reference Recordings in 2000, the centennial of Copland’s birth, this album gives detailed and driving accounts of Appalachian Spring, Fanfare for the Common Man, and the Third Symphony. It’s also available on vinyl, for a true audiophile experience.   

Osmo Vänskä Conducts Sibelius’s First and Fourth Symphonies, BIS Records

This album, which won the 2014 Grammy Award for Best Orchestral Performance, offers listeners lesser-known Sibelius works. Maestro Vänskä balances the late-romanticism of the First Symphony with the austere sonic landscape of the Fourth, bringing out terrific playing from the ensemble.  Listeners will likely never hear better performances of these works, both recorded in glorious surround sound in Orchestra Hall.    

Matthew Philion is an attorney, writer, teacher, former classical music DJ, and amateur trombone and euphonium player. He has been a fan of the Minnesota Orchestra since attending his first concert in 1978—a laser light show at the St. Paul Auditorium featuring music from Star Wars and The Planets.


Peak of Perfection: Recording a Musical Legacy

By Matthew Philion 

This fall, the Minnesota Orchestra continues recording the symphonies of Gustav Mahler for the BIS Records label. In November, Maestro Vänskä and the ensemble will tackle—first in concerts and then in recording sessions—one of the composer’s most challenging works: the Seventh Symphony, a genuine orchestral showpiece. 

It’s a minor miracle that today’s orchestras record at all. Committing to tape a world-class ensemble like the Minnesota Orchestra is an expensive and complicated undertaking, especially with a work like the Mahler Seventh—it requires essentially the entire roster of orchestra musicians, as well as additional instruments like tenor horn, guitar, and mandolin.

So the question arises: why do symphony orchestras continue to record?

First, a professional-quality commercial recording is a sonic postcard that carries an orchestra’s sound and style to the rest of the world. For example, in the 1950s and 60s, the Mercury Records label frequently recorded the Minneapolis Symphony (now known as the Minnesota Orchestra, of course), as part of their Living Presence series. Through a combination of expert playing, effective marketing, and the label’s unequaled technical abilities, the Orchestra garnered worldwide attention almost overnight. Those recordings set standards of performance and sound quality that continue to this day.

Recordings also motivate an ensemble to play near the peak of perfection. Before a recording date arrives, each player has mastered a work’s challenging parts, they’ve rehearsed the piece together, they’ve presented it in concert two or three times. The recording sessions that follow allow them to demonstrate their very best musicianship. As the Minnesota Orchestra’s Principal Trombone R. Douglas Wright puts it, “Every time we record, we grow and improve as an orchestra. The recording process is somewhat like taking the orchestra’s playing and putting it under a microscope. During play-backs, we really get to hear what we sound like in a much more objective way than we do while sitting on stage. When you’re putting something out there that’s going to last forever, it really inspires you to be meticulous in your approach to playing and listening." 

Conductors have unique challenges in making that “perfect” recording. For the Minnesota Orchestra’s series of albums featuring the music of Jean Sibelius, Music Director Osmo Vänskä had daunting competition—his own highly regarded recordings of the same works made with a different ensemble earlier in his career. It’s a testament to Vänskä’s ability to learn new insights from the scores that classical listeners responded so well to his “new” Sibelius, leading to a Grammy award in 2014 for Best Orchestral Performance for the First and Fourth Symphonies. 

Finally, orchestral recordings are kinetic documents that preserve an ensemble’s legacy. A case in point: conductor Antal Dorati’s classic 1957 stereo recording with the Minneapolis Symphony of Aaron Copland’s Rodeo, which sounds as fresh and idiomatic now as the day it was put to tape. It’s a vibrant performance that caught a moment in time: the conductor’s skill with Copland’s music, the acoustics of the hall (Northrop Auditorium), the musical styles of the individual players, even the unique instruments they played. Listeners enjoying the Minnesota Orchestra’s recent performance of Saint-Saëns’s Third Symphony (performed in the newly updated Northrop) could marvel at the continuing perfection and relevance of their hometown orchestra, sitting in the same hall that Antal Dorati made famous with his recordings over a half century ago.

Maestro Vänskä and the Orchestra’s first releases in the Mahler series—the Second, Fifth, and Sixth Symphonies—reveal a true affinity for the Austrian composer’s sound world. Upcoming releases will undoubtedly add to the ensemble’s heritage of classic, timeless recordings—and offer future generations a musical snapshot of this singular moment in Minnesota Orchestra history. 

Matthew Philion is an attorney, writer, teacher, former classical music DJ, and amateur trombone and euphonium player. He has been a fan of the Minnesota Orchestra since attending his first concert in 1978—a laser light show at the St. Paul Auditorium featuring music from Star Wars and The Planets.

Celebrate the Holidays at Orchestra Hall

The spirit that fills the stage at Minnesota Orchestra’s holiday concerts spreads throughout the entire building with a variety of additional performances and activities, making Orchestra Hall the perfect place to celebrate the season with your loved ones.

As you make your holiday to-do lists, be sure to include time to enjoy these holiday extras and, of course, to experience the music!

  • We have partnered with Simpson Housing Services, a local nonprofit that helps thousands of people experiencing homelessness find the housing, support and shelter they need in times of personal crisis. At each performance throughout December, we will be collecting donations of specific items. Look for collection bins in the Orchestra Hall lobby.

Dec 1: New and gently-used hats and mittens
Dec 8-9: Coffee Grounds
Dec 14-20: New and gently-used pajamas
Dec 21-22: New and gently-used hats and mittens

  • Take your family photo in front of our holiday displays, brightly-lit trees and other decorations in the lobby throughout the season.

  • Decorate gingerbread houses at concerts from December 14 through 20

  • What better combination than puppies and holiday music? Visit with adoptable dogs and learn about adoptions through Secondhand Hounds before the Home for the Holidays concert on Sunday, December 16.

  • Listen to the Twin Cities Bronze handbell ensemble before the concert on Saturday, December 8. This ensemble is one of our annual favorites! 

  • If your holiday traditions involve a family movie night, then plan to join us on November 24 and 25 at the Jurassic Park concerts—which include a dinosaur display from the Science Museum of Minnesota—or at the Convention Center on December 22 for screenings of Disney’s animated classic Beauty and the Beast.

  • Relax and enjoy live jazz music in the lobby before concerts on December 1, 9 and 15.

All of these activities are free and open to the public, including many others such as holiday craft stations, storytelling and plenty of photo opportunities. In addition, holiday-inspired food and beverages will be available for purchase. We invite you to make Orchestra Hall your family’s home for the holidays!





Getting the Band Back Together: Orchestra Notes from Dessa

Fresh off a successful two-night collaboration, Dessa recaps her recent performances with the Minnesota Orchestra and tells us what it's like to collaborate with conductor Sarah Hicks and the Orchestra musicians. 

If you’ve spent your career touring the club circuit, performing with an orchestra isn’t just an aesthetic departure; it’s bodily disorienting. For starters, the music is coming from the wrong direction. On amplified stages all over the world, you hear the music from the monitor speakers at your feet. But in my first rehearsal with the Minnesota Orchestra in 2017, I realized that all the sound was behind me—meaning the little cups of my ears were facing away from all the action. It took a moment to just to get my sea legs.

As we worked through our charts, the players moved through the dynamic passages like a school of fish: enormous swells of strings and blasts of brass would bloom and then contract into small, patient moments, much more delicate than would be possible on most pop stages. The many parts and pieces fit together like a pocket watch—a pocket watch the size of a whaling ship. As we worked together, our timing also naturally flexed, an unfamiliar sensation for someone accustomed to performing with the unvarying tempos of produced music. The orchestra was an enormous, organic thing. The task at hand felt a little like surfing—learning to ride a wave as it curled overhead.

We played two back-to-back shows together in April 2017, both to sold-out rooms. I wrote a series of dramatic monologues to lace the songs together. The concerts were two of the proudest moments in my career.

When Grant Meachum, the Director of Live at Orchestra Hall, asked if I’d like to return to perform a pair of shows in early October of 2018, I jumped at the chance. After confirming with the orchestra, the first call I made was to Andy Thompson, the multi-talented musician whose arrangements consistently impress the orchestra’s librarians and members. Pop songs must be completely re-imagined to make full use of the orchestra’s skill and horsepower. An arranger must be profoundly musical; mindful of each instrument’s range and relative volume; and the charts must be meticulous—clean, crisp, and precise. Sometimes, as we select songs for our set, Andy will text me to ask if I would prefer to move a particular tune up or down in register to avoid unduly cumbersome fingering in the strings or woodwind sections. Last year, he turned in 999 pages of charts to the orchestra. Happily, Andy agreed to arrange another round of songs for the 2018 show.

The final, finishing touch of an orchestral arrangement is often the performance direction: a few words in the score and parts that indicate the general vibe or attitude of the piece. They are also, in my opinion, a lot of fun to write. Here are a few of the performance directions that Andy I worked up for this year’s shows:

The next collaborators to rope in were vocalists Aby Wolf, Cameron Kinghorn, Matthew Santos and Ashley DuBose, and drummer Joey Van Phillips. Aby again agreed to serve as Vocal Director, which meant she’d write and record vocal lines for each singer, which we’d memorize before meeting to rehearse.  Ashley DuBose graciously hosted a few of the early rehearsals—here’s a clip of us working through the treatment for “Jumprope” in her apartment.

Video by Dessa

And here’s a moment on stage at Orchestra Hall, singing along to a MIDI rehearsal audio file of “Sound the Bells.” Matthew, Cameron, Ashley and Aby are all seasoned musicians with their own solo careers; they’re not only great voices, but talented and seasoned performers. Rehearsing in the space allows us to fine-tine blocking, mic techniques, and plan where to train our eyes during particularly dramatic moments. (It also allowed Ashley to come up with that cool dance-circle thing during the last chorus of “Jumprope.” So damn fresh.)

Video by Keegan Burckhard

When it’s time to rehearse in earnest with the orchestra, conductor Sarah Hicks takes the wheel. If you haven’t yet seen her live, Sarah is very much a performer—she can do comedy, drama, and shtick, and does so with relish and an arched eyebrow. She’s at once commanding, funny, curious, and kind. On more than one occasion we’ve had the chance to trade notes about our respective careers—both somewhat unconventional. A minor parallel, but one that delighted me: we both make unusual demands of stagewear. While I’m jumping and stretching in the fitting room—stress-testing outfits for the rigor of a rap show—she’s taking special care to select shirts that are pleasing from the back; the view afforded to the house for most of the evening.

Video by Frank Merchlewitz

In the many months since our last shows, I’d had the chance to get to know many members of the orchestra personally; I’d accompanied their summer tour of South Africa, as a reporter for Minnesota Public Radio’s Classical station. (You can read through some of that coverage HERE.) And so walking out to center stage, I could see friendly faces that I knew by name—Kathy at her harp, Silver at the cello, Doug and Chuck back in brass. Orchestra Hall is an arresting room—striking and elegant—but walking out to center stage had the feeling of a reunion too. We were getting the band back together.  

I wanted to make it clear to attendees that this performance would not be a reprise of last year’s—we led with a new arrangement, new monologue material, and I entered in a sequined cloak designed by [the madly talented] Joynoelle.

Photo by Tony Nelson

As a general rule, my material runs pretty dark—a lot of melancholic harmonies, driving rhythms, some noir references. So in a live setting, humor keeps the evening balanced. To punctuate the end of the song “Shrimp” (which closes with the lyric always a bridesmaid, never an astronaut), my friend and teammate Becky created half a dozen astronaut bouquets to be thrown overhead by Aby, Ashley, and Sarah (who managed a one-handed toss without missing a beat with her baton).

Photo courtesy of Dessa

A couple of weeks after the fact, I’m still sleeping off the big tour that culminated in the orchestral shows. A serious “thank you” is due to everyone who put in some serious time and talent to pull off a couple of epic nights. In addition to those mentioned above, a quick shout out to Jay Perlman on the amplification, Vickie on the lights, and Ash on the killer projections. In the lobby, DJ Fundo, puppeteers Liz Schachterle and Kalen Keir; and dancers from DeadPool slayed. Thanks all.

And of course, to all those who attended, thank you for arriving willing to move and be moved.

To stay abreast of my upcoming shows, read some new writing, or just to say hello, swing by the new website: You can also find me on Instagram (@dessa), Twitter, or Facebook (@dessadarling). I’ll be touring the UK during the first half of November, but will return to deliver a speech and perform a few songs at Northrop Auditorium on Nov 16th. To check out the performance schedules of the vocalists who joined me onstage at Orchestra Hall, you can connect with them on Twitter at @abywolf, @AshleyDuBose @CDKinghorn, and @MatthewSantos.

See you at the next one,    


Proud to Serve: Military Veterans in the Minnesota Orchestra

In honor of Veterans Day, we salute current and former members of our country's Armed Forces. The Minnesota Orchestra is fortunate to have a number of military veterans among our current and retired musicians and staff. We asked some of them to tell us about their military experience and how it contributed to their roles in the Minnesota Orchestra.

Julie Gramolini Williams, oboe
As a member of the United States Air Force from 2002 through 2004, oboist Julie Gramolini Williams served as a Senior airman and Principal Oboe for the USAF Band of the West, also performing with the band’s woodwind quintet and working in both the music library and the auditions department. Williams comes from a long line of military veterans, including her father—a recipient of two purple hearts—who fought with the Army in Vietnam. In addition, both of her grandfathers served, one in the Merchant Marines and one who fought in World War II and the Korean War as a member of the Navy. Three of her uncles are veterans, one each having served in the Air National Guard, Marine Corps and the Army.   

The photo above was taken during a ceremony in which Williams (along with the other members in the band) was awarded The Air Force Achievement Medal.

“I was proud to serve my country in the way I best could (by playing the oboe) especially after 9/11 occurred; a time when this country needed healing,” Williams said of her military career. “Despite this, I knew that I ultimately wanted to perform in an orchestra. The work that I did in the military gave me the drive to practice hard and achieve my goal of winning an orchestra job.” Within a year of her departure from the Air Force, Williams won a position with the Omaha Symphony, and soon thereafter she earned her current position with the Minnesota Orchestra. 

Marcus Valerio, Vice President of Finance and Operations
Also a former member of the Air Force is the Orchestra’s Vice President of Finance and Operations Marcus Valerio, who served as Airman 1st Class and a military policeman from 1994 to 1998, in locations in both the U.S. and Saudi Arabia. His brother, uncles and grandparents all had military careers, including service during World War II and in Vietnam.

This photo is from 1995 when Valerio was in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

Valerio’s military work and current role in finance have something significant in common, as he explains: “The same passion that motivated me to serve in the military also drives my desire to serve the nonprofit community. Through military service, you learn that there is a mission that is greater than any one individual and that each job or skill plays an integral role in accomplishing whatever the mission may be. I have found the same to be true at the Minnesota Orchestra. Whether you are the great Osmo Vänskä, a violinist or an accountant like me, we all have the privilege and passion to live the Orchestra’s mission daily—enriching, inspiring, and serving our community as an enduring symphony orchestra.”

Paul Gunther, retired Minnesota Orchestra Principal Librarian
Paul Gunther retired from his role as Principal Librarian of the Minnesota Orchestra in 2017, after working with the Orchestra for more than 30 years. A skilled percussionist, Gunther was a Staff Sergeant in the U.S. Army from 1967 to 1969, stationed in Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri. His mother was a U.S. Navy Officer in the Women’s Reserve and his father a U.S. Army Master Sergeant; both served during World War II. Gunther’s military career was his first full-time job and thus started a professional trajectory that led to his long-term post with the Minnesota Orchestra.

Minnesota Orchestra musicians, from left to right: bass player Robert Anderson (Army), oboist Julie Gramolini Williams (Air Force), librarian Paul Gunther (Army), retired bass player Cliff Biggs (Army), retired stage manager Timothy Eickholt (Army), retired trumpet player Ron Hasselmann (Army), retired clarinetist Joseph Longo (Army), retired clarinetist Chester Milosovich (Army), and retired violinist Edward Stack (Air Force)

Robert Anderson, bass 
Robert Anderson, a current member of the bass section, joined the Minnesota Orchestra in 1974. For the three years prior to his appointment in Minnesota, he was a staff musician in the U.S. Army Band “Pershing’s Own.” It remains the premiere musical ensemble of the U.S. Army, with its headquarters adjacent to Arlington National Cemetery in Fort Myer, Virginia.

Anderson noted that the U.S. Army Band is an organization that comprises several bands, an excellent chorus, a jazz and rock band, and a string section. “We string players used to play for state dinners at the White House as well as other White House functions. We also played at the State Department from time to time,” he explained. “Of course, playing for the president could be a rather stressful experience, so this was good training for a long career in performing.”

“This image shows the string section from the current website of U.S. Army Band ‘Pershing's Own.’ When I was in the band there were no women, but now they have many. The band has distinctive blue uniforms that no other branch of the Army wears.” - Robert Anderson

In 1970, a performing career was the goal for Anderson, a recent college graduate—but he also felt that he had additional responsibilities:

“It was during the time of the Vietnam War. Although most of us were eager to move along with our professional careers in the civilian sector, we all knew we had an important job to do, so we took it seriously when it came to performing. I have kept this ethic throughout my career.” 

We are grateful to our U.S. military veterans for their dedication and service. Please join us for a special Veterans Day celebration at Orchestra Hall on Saturday, November 10, as the U.S. Naval Academy Glee Club performs with the Minnesota Orchestra.  Click here for ticket information, including military discounts >>



Celebrating YPSCA, young talent and the Minnesota Orchestra

The Young People’s Symphony Concert Association (YPSCA) is excited to start a new season of activities that encourage a love of great music in young people. One particularly thrilling project is the annual Young People’s Concerto Competition (formerly called School Music Auditions).

It draws talented young musicians from throughout the region and rewards the top contestants with a variety of prizes, some of which offer opportunities to perform before discerning audiences.

This coming season’s prizewinners are sure to be just as impressive as the superb musicians who took top awards in the 2018 Competition. Notable among last year’s winners is pianist Emma Taggart, 15, who will be featured at several Minnesota Orchestra Young People’s and Family Concerts this season.

Pianist Emma Taggart, top winner of the 2018 Concerto Competition, is pictured above performing at YPSCA’s annual luncheon last April.

Taggart, of Blaine, was showcased at YPSCA’s annual luncheon last April, when members and friends gathered at the Woman’s Club of Minneapolis for a program spotlighting student musicians who had won top prizes in YPSCA’s competition.

In the four photos above: 2018 Concerto Competition prizewinners Nita Qiu,15, of Woodbury; Kirill Nazarov, 17, of Faribault; Catherine Carson, 16, of Northfield; and Maria Chirinos, 18, of Faribault,  performing at YPSCA’s annual luncheon.

At the luncheon, Margee Bracken, Chair-elect of the Minnesota Orchestra’s Board of Directors and a longtime advocate for music education, shared her enthusiasm for the Orchestra’s upcoming ventures and YPSCA’s part in many of them.

Minnesota Orchestra Board Chair-elect Margee Bracken speaking at YPSCA’s annual luncheon.

Work on the 2019 Competition is already underway: the deadline for applications is December 3, and the Prelims and Finals will take place at Orchestra Hall next January 26 and February 3, respectively. Visit for more information. And join YPSCA to share in the excitement—perhaps as a 2019 volunteer!

Mahler, Bernstein and Me

By C. C. Yager

Music is a door to memory, and I will happily sail through that door the first weekend of November when the Minnesota Orchestra performs Mahler’s Seventh Symphony. That particular music reminds me of a time in my life when music offered a wonderful adventure if I kept my ears and heart open—my first concert in Vienna!

I was a college student, a music major, studying in Vienna, Austria, for my junior year. My first concert that fall was at the Musikverein with the Vienna Philharmonic conducted by Leonard Bernstein. Leonard Bernstein! We didn’t know what the program was when we arrived 75 minutes before the Musikverein opened its doors and found a line had already formed. As we waited more people arrived. When the doors finally opened, we sprinted with everyone else to find an usher who sold us the standing-room-only tickets. We had a fantastic view of the stage, the gold and red decor, and the golden Greek statues along the walls in the Golden Hall, but we had to stand for another hour before the concert began. I slipped out to buy programs while my friend held our spot. That’s when we learned what Bernstein would be conducting that evening.

Only one piece on the program: Gustav Mahler’s Symphony No. 7 in E minor. Mahler! I could hear my parents groaning that Mahler’s music was just noise, wasn’t music at all, not like Bach or Mozart or Beethoven or even Sibelius. My friend and I discussed leaving, but we’d already invested an awful lot of time and money into this little adventure so we decided to stay and see what happened.

The hall filled, every seat taken, and soon the crystal chandeliers dimmed. When Bernstein strode onstage, his short height shocked me. I’d expected him to tower over the orchestra, but there was no mistaking that profile or mane of graying hair. His downbeat came even as the applause died away.

The symphony’s first notes surprised me. They were quiet, a dirge-like rhythm played in the strings. Where was the loud bombast, the dissonance, the noise? A horn I’d never seen before played a melody of descending notes unlike any I’d ever heard. I doubt my parents would have called it a melody, but to me it sang, laying the dramatic musical groundwork for the symphony. This music defied night’s darkness with flashes of defiant light from the brass, and strings bursting out in a manic tempo, and the entire orchestra engaged in a struggle among its sections. A conversation had begun.

The second movement reminded me of a music hall march with a definite Austrian lilt, followed by a funny little hitch to the rhythm before the strings contributed some schmalz. Its title is “Nachtmusik,” German for “serenade.” This serenade was like watching a drunk romantic couple dancing a little off beat. A subdued Bernstein guided the musicians and us through the dance, at times bouncing on his feet to the rhythm, precise and clear in his stick technique, and thrilling to watch. Gone were the flamboyance and physicality of his youth.

The third movement, the scherzo, was my music. I fell madly in love with it as I listened. Restless and spooky, the sound reminded me of dead leaves rustled by a Halloween breeze. Its direction from the composer, “schattenhaft,” means “shadowy.” I thought this music must have represented the shadows of a neurotic mind. Not devilish or evil, just restless and dark, and by the end, I was imagining the couple from the second movement sidling in and out of the shadows along a Viennese street.

The fourth movement returned to the serenade with a solo violin followed by mandolin. Mandolin. In a symphony! Well, that was different. This movement was much slower than the first serenade, more lyrical in nature, sweeter in its harmonies, like a lullaby for that couple who finally made it home and were talking about their evening. I started thinking about what “night” meant to me, all the different activities that could occur at night, and realized Mahler had thought of night not in a sinister way but as another part of human experience.

The final movement burst out of the darkness with a blaze of timpani and brass. The music was triumphant, celebratory and joyous. Then Mahler tiptoed down the hall with the music so as not to disturb the slumbering drunken couple. But he didn’t remain quiet for long. This movement became a tug of war between the triumphant music and the quiet lilting music, but Triumph prevails in the symphony’s final notes.

Mahler: music or noise? Audience members were the only people making noise that night with loud clapping and foot-stomping, calling Bernstein back on stage five times until he stepped back onto the podium and conducted the entire final movement again. We stayed for every note.

The Vienna Philharmonic and Leonard Bernstein had introduced to me that night a new person with an interesting mind and way of expressing himself. Mahler had been dead for 63 years, but I felt as if he were very much alive and I’d listened to him speak all that evening. I felt full and was flying high from the new sounds, rhythms and orchestral colors I’d heard.

Wow, were my parents ever wrong.

C. C. Yager is a writer who has worked for the Minnesota Orchestra in the Marketing Department and in Ticketing Services. She has a BA in Music and often combines her knowledge of music with her writing as in her first novel, Perceval’s Secret. Her blog “Anatomy of Perceval” can be found at

Hear the Minnesota Orchestra and Music Director Osmo Vänskä perform Mahler’s Symphony No. 7 at Orchestra Hall on November 2 and 3.

Revisiting Old Friends

If you’re the type of person who seeks out unique, once-in-a-lifetime opportunities, then this list is for you. Along with a series of new pieces this season, the Minnesota Orchestra will perform several works that are rarities here, having graced the Orchestra’s music stands only once or twice in its 115-year history. Here are a few of the highlights.

Let’s begin with a look back to a performance on March 29, 1935, at Northrop Memorial Auditorium, with Eugene Ormandy at the Orchestra’s helm. This concert opened with Jenö Hubay’s orchestration of Bach’s Chaconne from Partita No. 2, an arrangement which has not been performed by the Minnesota Orchestra since. It seems a perfect fit that Music Director Osmo Vänskä has programmed its return—after more than 80 years—for the ensemble’s upcoming performances at Northrop Auditorium in October 2018. Orchestra violinist Pamela Arnstein explains, “All of us violinists have played the great and challenging Chaconne by ourselves. I'm looking forward to hearing and playing this version.”

Another work by Bach that makes a Minnesota Orchestra return this season is his Christmas Oratorio. Last December the Orchestra and the Minnesota Chorale presented the first three cantatas of this large-scale work; this December they will perform the second half to complete the oratorio. The last time these final three cantatas made their mark on the Orchestra’s audience was in 1958, and only once before that—in December 1919.

The Minnesota Chorale

Principal Cello Anthony Ross’ solo performances with the Orchestra are fan favorite concerts in Minnesota, and so are the most-familiar and beloved cello concertos by composers such as Dvořák, Elgar and Schumann. But we’re in for another treat in November when Ross performs Shostakovich’s Second Cello Concerto for the first time ever at Orchestra Hall. It has seen one Orchestra performance, in 1970 before the Hall was built, with then-Principal Cello Robert Jamieson and conductor Gunther Schuller.

Anthony Ross performs in the Tchaikovsky Marathon with the Minnesota Orchestra, January 2018

The Minnesota Orchestra’s Featured Composer for the 2018-19 season is John Harbison, whose music we hear on classical and chamber programs throughout the season including a world premiere in October. On New Year’s Eve, the Orchestra performs his Remembering Gatsby: Foxtrot for Orchestra for the first time since 1991, under the direction of Edo de Waart. Though the work was composed in 1985, it will be new to many of us at the Minnesota Orchestra. “John Harbison was one of a handful of composers whose work made me fall in love with new music,” says violist Sam Bergman, who is excited about this concert and the others this season that feature Harbison’s music.

John Harbison

Sergei Prokofiev’s Seventh Symphony was his last, completed not long before his death on March 5, 1953. The very next season (1953-54), the then-Minneapolis Symphony Orchestra led by then-Music Director Antal Dorati performed the nostalgic symphony at Northrop Memorial Auditorium, and then subsequently took the work on tour to school auditoriums and gymnasiums across the Midwest, Connecticut and New York. The Symphony has not been played by the Orchestra since that tour, but will be heard again in March this season. “I love Prokofiev,” says bass player Matthew Frischman. “His music is some of the most innovative, colorful and influential ever written. You can’t help but to be intrigued by the sounds he could produce from an orchestra!” 

Nathalie Stutzmann conducts Prokofiev's First Symphony, October 2017

Don’t miss your chance to hear these works—we hope you’ll join us!



From Orchestra Hall to Ethiopia

In her first concerts with the Minnesota Orchestra in April 2017, Minneapolist native rapper-vocalist-writer Dessa shared with us an EnviroRider developed by the Minneapolis-based Effect Partners. When she returns on October 5 and 6 to perform again with the Orchestra, Dessa’s EnviroRider does, too. We are thrilled to partner with her for both the music onstage and in ways that reach far beyond Orchestra Hall. 

An EnviroRider suggests a wide range of actions that we can undertake to give back to the environment before, during and following the performances. While Dessa is not alone in the music industry in making this extra effort, she has worked very closely with us to broaden the Orchestra’s environmental reach, planning unique activities at Orchestra Hall, and encouraging musicians, staff and audiences to continually be environmentally conscious.

One of these efforts involves the Orchestra’s participation in a CO2 Emissions Offset program. Vermont-based climate solutions company Native Energy has worked with our staff to calculate the total estimated cost of emissions for energy use at the October 2018 Minnesota Orchestra concerts with Dessa. In return, the Minnesota Orchestra will donate that amount to the Ethiopia Clean Water Project. This donation will help to provide upfront funding for the installation of Hydraid® water filters in homes across Ethiopia—reducing greenhouse gas pollution and bringing clean air and water to Ethiopian families.

The Minnesota Orchestra and its Environmental Sustainability Committee have remained committed to finding ways to give back to the environment including reducing CO2 emissions, decreasing food waste, supporting local sustainable agriculture and generally reducing the music industry’s environmental impact. Among the many efforts currently in place at Orchestra Hall are the Bike to Orchestra Hall program; composting and recycling options throughout our performance and administrative spaces; and a variety of partnerships with local organizations including Metro Transit, Move Minneapolis and Green Minneapolis.

If you are attending the concerts with Dessa on October 5 and 6, or any other Orchestra Hall event, you are part of this community effort!

Thank you!


Get to Know the OH+ Listening Station Composers

The Minnesota Orchestra’s upcoming season features the work of many great American composers, including Florence Price, Missy Mazzoli, Libby Larsen, and Amy Beach. Enjoy pieces by these four composers in our OH+ listening station, curated by Hymie’s Vintage Records, and read on to learn more about their lives and when you can hear the Orchestra perform their work during the 2018-2019 Season!

Florence Price

Florence Price


  • Born in Little Rock, Arkansas, Florence Price was the first African-American female composer to have a symphonic composition performed by a major American symphony orchestra.
  • She studied at the New England Conservatory of Music, where she received degrees as an organist and music teacher. After graduation she returned to the South, but worsening racial tensions convinced Price to move to Chicago in 1927.
  • In 1932 she won four Wanamaker prizes, including “top prize for a symphonic composition.”
  • Price composed more than 300 works, ranging from small teaching pieces for piano to large-scale compositions such as symphonies and concertos, as well as instrumental chamber music, vocal compositions, and music for radio.
  • During renovations of an abandoned house in Illinois in 2009, the new owners of the home discovered piles of musical manuscripts, books, and documents belonging to Price, who had used the house as a summer home. The materials contained many Price scores that had been presumed lost.
  • You can hear Price’s Symphony No. 3 during our American Expressions Festival in January.

Missy Mazzoli photo by Marylene Mey

Missy Mazzoli

(b. 1980)

  • Missy Mazzoli is one of the most successful and innovative contemporary American composers; Time Out New York called her “Brooklyn’s post-millennial Mozart.”
  • Mazzoli holds degrees from the Yale School of Music, the Royal Conservatory of the Hague, and Boston University. She has taught composition at Yale and currently is part of the composition faculty at the Mannes College of Music.
  • Her musical style is a blend of many genres and influenced by everything from classical music to indie-rock.
  • Alongside chamber and orchestral works, she is also a very successful operatic composer.
  • An alumnus of the Minnesota Orchestra Composer Institute, Mazzoli spent one week working with musicians of the Orchestra in 2006. The week culminated in a performance of her piece, These Worlds in Us.
  • You can hear These Worlds in Us at Orchestra Hall March 14-16.

Libby Larsen photo by Ann Marsden

Libby Larsen

(b. 1950)

  • Libby Larsen was born in Wilmington, Delaware but grew up in Minneapolis. She graduated from the University of Minnesota with a Bachelor of Arts in Theory in Composition, Master of Arts in Composition, and PhD in Theory and Composition.
  • A prolific composer, Larsen has a catalogue of over 500 works, and has been hailed as “the only English-speaking composer since Benjamin Britten who matches great verse with fine music so intelligently and expressively” by USA Today.
  • A passionate advocate for contemporary composers and their work, Larsen co-founded the Minnesota Composers Forum, now the American Composers Forum, in 1973 to assist composers in a transitional time for American arts.
  • The Minnesota Orchestra named Larsen a composer-in-residence in 1983. She was the first woman appointed resident conductor of a major American Symphony orchestra.
  • Larsen wrote Symphony: Water Music for the Minnesota Orchestra, which premiered the piece in 1985. The four movements evoke images of water in varying states of movement—from languid water on a sweltering summer day to water whipped up by a fierce gale.
  • You can hear Symphony: Water Music at Orchestra Hall March 21-23.

Amy Beach

Amy Beach


OH+: Connecting our community with the music

Q&A with Composer Kareem Roustom

Minnesota Orchestra's 2018-19 season includes many works new to the Orchestra's repertoire, and the first of these is a work titled Ramal by Syrian-American composer Kareem Roustom. Get to know the composer before his Minnesota Orchestra debut on September 27, 28 and 29.

What should we know about Ramal before the Orchestra performances this month?
Ramal was commissioned by the Daniel Barenboim Foundation, and it was premiered by Barenboim and the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra in 2014. The work itself is inspired by the rhythm of classical Arabic poetry as much as it is by the writings of the late Edward Said who, along with Barenboim, founded the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra. The work is very rhythmic in that it takes a set poetic meter, breaks it apart, develops it and then rejoins the broken parts again at the end of the work. On an emotional level, it is a work about seeing something break apart but hoping that it will come back together again. In this instance it is Syria, where I was born and raised.

How do you encourage listeners to approach a new piece of music?
An open mind, of course, is always welcome when confronting the unfamiliar. I recently read an interview with composer and conductor Pierre Boulez where he said that confronting a lack of variety at classical music concerts is a lot like going to a museum that only has 17 or so paintings, and all from roughly the same time period and place. So perhaps listeners might try to imagine that scenario when confronting some new pieces on a concert program.

Where do you find inspiration for your work?
Inspiration for me comes first and foremost from the people for whom I am composing the work and the occasion for which I am composing it. I love the challenge of variety. From there I am able to explore the many possibilities that arise from the occasion—sometimes it is poetry, sometimes it is humanistic or social justice advocacy, or sometimes it is an abstract musical exploration. The musical material itself is less important than what one crafts with it.

Who are your biggest supporters?
My wife, without a doubt. After that I’ve been very fortunate to have the support and encouragement of maestro Daniel Barenboim who has asked me to compose two works: Ramal and my recently completed Violin Concerto No. 1. I’ve also been very grateful to maestro Donald Runnicles for his continued championing of my work at the Grand Teton Music Festival, where I was composer-in-residence this past summer.

What are some of the challenges that today’s composers face in the classical music industry?
The challenges faced by composers are the same faced by performers, namely finding and sustaining audiences. I think we need to strive to belong to our communities and to find a place where are best serving them. This can take many forms but the intent must be there from the outset.

What have you been listening to lately?
I am currently going through a Stravinsky listening and reading period. Shortly before that, as I was writing my first violin concerto I was listening to quite a few concertos including some recent wonderful ones by Oliver Knussen, Thomas Adès and Kaija Saariaho. I’ve also been exploring some music by composers who blend cultures, like Cuban-American composer Tania León.

What projects are next for you?
I am very grateful to have quite a few projects coming up and these include the forthcoming release on CD of my Clarinet Concerto: Adrift on the Wine-dark Sea, which was recorded this past May in Berlin by clarinetist Kinan Azmeh and the Deutsches Symphonie-orchester.

At the end of the Clarinet Concerto recording session in Berlin with (left to right) clarinetist Kinan Azmeh, vocalist Dima Orsho, conductor Manuel Nawari, composer Kareem Roustom and engineer Florian Schmidt.

In March 2019, my Violin Concerto No. 1 will be premiered in Berlin at the Pierre Boulez Saal, by violinist Michael Barenboim and the Pierre Boulez Ensemble. The piece that I’m currently working on, which is for the Boston-based string orchestra A Far Cry and the Lorelei Ensemble women’s chorus, will have its premiere in Boston in May 2019 and is based on a new translation of Homer’s The Odyssey. After that there is a commission from the Grant Park Music Festival in Chicago for a work for choir and orchestra (June 2019 premiere) based on poems by Walt Whitman, a commission from the Dallas Symphony for what will be my second violin concerto for their principal second violinist Angela Fuller-Heyde, as well as two other projects for a festival orchestra in the U.S. and an orchestra in southern Germany.

What are you doing when you aren’t composing?
Spending time with my family, reading history and swimming as often as possible.

For tickets and more information >>

Meet President & CEO Michelle Miller Burns

As the Orchestra launches its season opening concerts, President and CEO Michelle Miller Burns welcomes audiences to the 2018-19 season.

"Hello, I’m Michelle Miller Burns, President and CEO of the Minnesota Orchestra, and it is my pleasure to welcome you to the Orchestra’s 2018-19 season.

Recently, I had the privilege of seeing Music Director Osmo Vänskä and the musicians in action on the Orchestra’s South Africa tour.

I was impressed by their commitment to excellence throughout the tour. Not only in performances, but also in their interaction with students and audiences in every community we visited. It was inspiring to see those musical and cultural connections being made.

I know that connectivity is part of the magic here at Orchestra Hall and I look forward to being a part of it this year.

Osmo and the musicians have prepared an outstanding season for you with a focus on vibrant, American music. Some of it new. Some of it tried and true. All of it performed masterfully.

Whether you are a long time subscriber or a first-time concertgoer, I hope you will introduce yourself to me and the musicians before or after your next performance.

Thank you and we look forward to seeing you at Orchestra Hall."

Welcome our Newest Musicians

The Minnesota Orchestra is excited to welcome three additional musicians to its roster this season. Violist Jenni Seo has been appointed Assistant Principal Viola, a position held since 2010 by recently-appointed Principal Viola Rebecca Albers; cellists Minji Choi and Erik Wheeler have been appointed to section positions.

Jenni Seo, viola

Korean violist Jenni Seo comes to Minnesota after performing in the viola section of the Baltimore Symphony during its 2017-18 season. She is a frequent substitute with the New York Philharmonic, Los Angeles Philharmonic and New York City Ballet orchestras, and makes reoccurring appearances at the Music at Menlo, Montecito, Bad Leonfelden, Keuka Lake and Perlman Music Program festivals. She has appeared on stage alongside Itzhak Perlman, Lynn Harrell, Donald Weilerstein and David Finckel, as well as members of the Cleveland, Takacs and Juilliard String Quartets. She has been presented by the WQXR Midday Masterpieces series, the Harvard Club of New York and at the Neue Gallery. The winner of the 2011 ASTA National Solo Competition, Seo received undergraduate and graduate degrees from The Juilliard School, where she was a student of Cynthia Phelps, Heidi Castleman and Steven Tenenbom, and served as principal viola of the Juilliard Orchestra.

Minji Choi, cello

Korean cellist Minji Choi joins the Minnesota Orchestra after playing with the Santa Barbara and Eugene Symphonies. She began studying cello at age six and gave her first solo performance at the age of twelve in Kumho Art Hall. She studied at the Korean National University of Arts under the tutelage of Myung-Wha Chung and Kangho Lee. She has also studied with Philippe Muller at the Paris Conservatory, where she received her master’s degree, and she recently earned an artist’s diploma from the Colburn Conservatory of Music, studying with Clive Greensmith. She has won numerous competitions including the Ehwa- Kyunghyang Competition, Ye-Jin Competition, Nan-Pa Competition, Eum-Yoen Competition and the Tea-Gu Broadcasting Competition, among many others. As a soloist, she has been featured with the Teagu Philharmonic Orchestra, Guri City Orchestra, Gunpo Prime Philharmonic Orchestra and Karol Szymanovski Philharmonic Orchestra. She has played as a substitute musician with the Los Angeles Philharmonic and the New York Philharmonic under the baton of Alan Gilbert. She has also served as principal cello of the Paris Conservatory Orchestra, Pacific Music Festival Orchestra and Verbier Festival Orchestra. 

Erik Wheeler, cello

Houston-born cellist Erik Wheeler began his musical studies with Diane Bonds at the age of five. He has also studied with Steve Laven, Lynn Harrell and Brinton Smith, and with Desmond Hoebig at Rice University, where he earned his undergraduate degree, and at The Juilliard School with cellist Richard Aaron. While at Rice, he performed Tchaikovsky’s Rococo Variations with the Shepherd School Chamber Orchestra as the winner of the school’s concerto competition, and served as principal cellist for the Shepherd School Symphony Orchestra. He has performed chamber music alongside world-renowned artists including Jon Kimura Parker, Philip Setzer, Lawrence Dutton, Timothy Eddy, Kim Kashkashian, Susan Starr and Charles Wetherbee, and has appeared as a soloist with numerous orchestras including the Houston Symphony. Wheeler’s parents are both musicians, and his father Lawrence was Co-Principal Violist of the Minnesota Orchestra in the 1970s. 

 Seo and Choi join the Orchestra for Season Opening concerts on September 21 and 22; Wheeler begins his new position with the Orchestra in January 2019.

A Moment with Emanuel Ax

Seven-time Grammy-winning pianist Emanuel Ax joins us on September 21 and 22 to open the season with Brahms’ exquisite Second Piano Concerto. We spoke with him about the challenges and joys of this extremely difficult piece, and about his 44-year relationship with the Minnesota Orchestra.

When you see that your next concert venue is in Minnesota, what do you think about?
Minnesota was one of the first places I ever played with a major orchestra—at Northrop Auditorium and with Stanislaw Skrowaczewski (in 1974 and 1977). It was very exciting for me, a great thrill. I’ve always loved both Minneapolis and Saint Paul, and I’m just excited about coming back.

The program from one of Emanuel Ax's first performances with the Minnesota Orchestra

How have you grown as a musician since those early performances?
Well, I don’t have the slightest idea, to be honest. I keep practicing, hard. But I keep feeling that I have so much more to learn, and that hasn’t changed at all. I hope I’m playing more intelligently and communicating better than I did then. But I can’t really say; that’s more of a question for people who come to the concert. 

What are you looking forward to about the upcoming Minnesota Orchestra concerts?
I haven’t been to Minnesota since I played with the Orchestra’s musicians during the lockout. So, I’m glad that people are back and working and it’s all good news.  I’m very excited to see Osmo Vänskä again and I’m very excited to be with the Orchestra, so I’m anticipating it with a lot of pleasure. And of course I’ll be nervous. I hope I play well. 

How do you stay at the top of your game?
I think all pianists are working hard and working ahead because we have a lot of notes to play, so I’m always trying to do that and be ready when the concert comes. And with all of the traveling that I do, the first thing my management team does is line up practice time at each place when I arrive. I plan my days around that. It’s really the most well-planned part of my life! 

What is the greatest challenge about Brahms’ Second Piano Concerto?
The challenge is simply that it is very, very difficult. It’s hard physically. It’s hard mentally. It’s long. It’s very involved and like a piece of big chamber music. You have to be very connected to everything else that is going on onstage.

What is your greatest joy about the piece?
Brahms’ Second Concerto is so evocative and so wonderful and so deep that it’s always a pleasure and a thrill to work on it…but scary! I first performed this piece almost 40 years ago. The Brahms concertos have been part of my life for a very long time.

This season, the Minnesota Orchestra is highlighting American composers. How would you describe American orchestral music?  
Well I think that’s very hard to answer. I think there is an unmistakable flavor of American music that you hear in composers like Bernstein, Copland, Roy Harris and others from that era, a kind of American sound that is very open, very frank, very welcoming and very hopeful. But I think that now the world of composition is so international that it’s difficult to characterize by nationality. People from America go to Vienna to study. People from Vienna come to New York. People from the Far East go all over the world. There are teachers of all nationalities working everywhere. So, I think in that sense, the world of music has become very international.

What are some of your latest projects?
Recently, I’ve been performing the Brahms trios with Yo-Yo Ma and Leonidas Kavakos, and that’s been a wonderful, wonderful thing. Yo-Yo and I have been playing together in one thing or another for over 40 years now. Being onstage with him is one of the absolute greatest things that happened in my life. I’m grateful to whatever powers made it possible. And we both fell in love with Leonidas, so it’s been really fun over the last couple of years. 

And I’ve learned a couple of new pieces that I like a lot. One in particular that I performed last year is by a Viennese composer named HK Gruber.

Otherwise, one of the most important things in my life is that we have grandchildren. They are three-and-a-half year old twins, and we’re very blessed. I’ll see them this coming weekend. We haven’t gotten them much into music yet, but I’m hoping to learn more songs that they can sing along to, so I’m going to be working on that in the next bit.

Hear Emanuel Ax with the Minnesota Orchestra, September 21 and 22 >>

Experience New Music With Us

The modern symphony orchestra has been built on centuries of musical traditions. Orchestral musicians have each trained for thousands of hours in classical techniques which have stood the test of time. Listeners might find familiarity and comfort in works by the great pillars of orchestral composing, such as Beethoven, Mozart, Tchaikovsky and—especially here in Minnesota lately—Sibelius and Mahler. However, in this art form, there will always be room for new ideas, new voices and new sounds. 

Here at the Minnesota Orchestra, we've always found great value creating and performing new music. We've commissioned or premiered more than 300 compositions, and we even have a full "Future Classics" concert each year dedicated to new music during the annual Composer Institute. During our 2018-19 season, we have programmed more than a dozen works that the Orchestra has never performed before, each of them new to many of our musicians' repertoire and our audience’s ears.  

How will you decide which ones you want to experience for the first time with us? Here’s a quick look through our season to help you choose. Click on titles to learn about performance dates and details.

Below are three great opportunities to be among the very first in the U.S. or even the world to experience new works:

John Harbison: What Do We Make of Bach? for Orchestra and Obbligato Organ

This world premiere celebrates the newly-restored pipe organ at Northrop on the campus of the University of Minnesota, with organ virtuoso Paul Jacobs as the soloist in his Minnesota Orchestra debut. And if you love this piece, there are more opportunities this season to hear Harbison’s music, because he is our 2018-19 Featured Composer.

"The orchestra is given the task of establishing the premise, and the organ part introduces an idea of the voice of the old German master speaking in modern terms…The organ part consists of both the strangest, most bizarre elements of the piece as well as those that are most rooted in tradition.” – Paul Jacobs


Mark-Anthony Turnage: Martland Memorial for Percussion and Orchestra

Martland Memorial is a unique tribute to the late British composer Steve Martland. Its composer and soloist—Mark-Anthony Turnage and Grammy-winning percussionist Colin Currie, respectively—were both friends of Martland, who died in 2013. The Minnesota Orchestra’s performances will be the U.S. premiere.

Geoffrey Gordon: Prometheus

The U.S. premiere performance of Prometheus features the Minnesota Orchestra’s own bass clarinet player Timothy Zavadil as the work’s soloist in a rare opportunity to hear a solo bass clarinet with the Orchestra. Plus, there is another new piece on the same program: Tómasson’s Second Piano Concerto (see below for more).

Other works new to the Orchestra’s library this season include: 

John Adams: Gnarly Buttons

A frequently-appearing name in Minnesota Orchestra programs, composer John Adams’ features solo clarinet in Gnarly Buttons, spotlighting clarinet virtuoso Michael Collins in a lively work with small orchestra and a little bit of banjo. Preview the piece, with Collins as soloist >>

Kareem Roustom: Ramal

On the same program as Gnarly Buttons, but in a complete shift of style, Syrian-American composer Kareem Roustom’s Ramal is rhythmic and bustling, inspired by a pre-Islamic Arabic poetic meter. It will be the first time a piece by Roustom is performed by Minnesota Orchestra. 

Kevin Puts: Inspiring Beethoven

What was Beethoven thinking as he penned the joyful, vibrant, emotional notes of his Seventh Symphony? This is Pulitzer Prize-winning composer Kevin Puts’ imaginative response to that question.

Artie Shaw: Clarinet Concerto

Music from “The King of Clarinet,” Artie Shaw, has been heard on many a summer festival concert here in Minnesota, but this season Principal Clarinet Gabriel Campos Zamora brings Shaw’s Clarinet Concerto to the stage in January with Music Director Osmo Vänskä—who began his career as a clarinetist—on the conductor's podium.

Florence Price: Symphony No. 3

Composer Florence Price was the first African American woman to have her music performed by a major orchestra. Her southern roots and religious background run deep through her work, especially in this symphony that was commissioned at the height of the Great Depression.

Mason Bates: Garages of the Valley

Dedicated to former Minnesota Orchestra Music Director Edo de Waart, who conducts these concerts, Mason Bates Garages of the Valley was inspired by the masterminds who worked tirelessly behind the scenes on some of our greatest advances in technology (Apple, HP, Google, etc.) 

“We all have an image of zillions of lines of computer code whizzing down a screen, and I needed a way to bring that to life in a fresh and evocative way.” –Mason Bates


Sean Shepherd: Silvery Rills

Silvery Rills is a quick concert opener that gets its name from the words of “Home Means Nevada,” the composer’s home state song.

Haukur Tómasson: Piano Concerto No. 2

Honoring Minnesota’s many Nordic influences, this concert combines the talent of our Finnish Music Director Osmo Vänskä with Icelandic composer Haukur Tómasson and Icelandic pianist Vikingur Olafsson, who performed the premiere of Tómasson's Second Piano Concerto.

Victoria Borisova-Ollas: Kingdom of Silence

Another name new to the Orchestra’s library, Victoria Borisova-Ollas’ Kingdom of Silence is a dreamlike perspective of the afterlife, a kind of lullaby in memory of another composer, Nikolai Korndorf.

Browse the Minnesota Orchestra's complete season  >>

Northrop's Historic Pipe Organ

About the Northrop organ

The historic Northrop organ, Aeolian-Skinner’s Opus 892, was built between 1932 and 1936, and is one of the most notable concert-hall pipe organs in the United States. Its 6,982 pipes comprise 108 ranks and 81 speaking stops, ranging in size from 32 feet tall to the size of a pencil. The public face of the organ is the console, with four keyboards, a pedalboard and about 225 separate controls. The Northrop organ is the third-largest auditorium-based Aeolian-Skinner extant in the U.S. today. It was awarded the prestigious “Exceptional Historic Merit” citation by the Organ Historical Society in 1999.


Photo by Tim Rummelhoff

When the Minnesota Orchestra—then called the Minneapolis Symphony Orchestra—made Northrop its home beginning in 1930, the organ was used often, but by the late 1960s, it began to fall into disrepair. When Northrop’s building renovation began in 2011, the organ was carefully cataloged, crated and moved to storage, where it sat for several years waiting for the funding needed to repair and re-install the instrument. A generous bequest by the late Dr. Roger E. Anderson provided funds for the reinstallation of the instrument in the chambers above the stage and behind the proscenium. The reinstallation has been painstakingly carried out by Foley-Baker and Associates and culminates in the October 12 and 13 grand inaugural concerts by the Minnesota Orchestra. For more information about Northrop, visit

Johannesburg | Aug 18

On Saturday morning, August 18, the Minnesota Orchestra crew completed their final load-in of the tour at Johannesburg’s City Hall and the musicians boarded the buses for a short trek to the venue. Even the chilly winter morning couldn’t erase the afterglow of Friday night’s concert in Soweto!

City Hall, like so many of the venues in South Africa, has been the home of many historical and political events throughout its more than 100-year history. The Edwardian building has seen many political events on its steps from protest meetings to a bomb blast in 1988.

The setting for the concert was stunning—and although there were a few minor hiccups with a late start and seating, the crowd was attentive from the moment Vänskä lifted his baton. South African composer Bongani Ndodana-Breen and Dr. Makaziwe “Maki” Mandela, Nelson Mandela’s eldest daughter, were in the capacity crowd of more than 1,100.

What’s happening is a true and glorious exchange.

Scott Chamberlain, MinnPost

During the concert, pigeons flew back and forth from the proscenium arch to the window ledge high above the auditorium. The sun seemed to shine through the windows at the most opportune moments during Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony: the horn solo of the third movement, the “Ode to Joy” theme and the triumphant ending of the piece.

Vänskä returned to the stage after a standing ovation, conducting the orchestra and choir in “Usilethela Uxolo,” then turned the podium over to Xolani Mootane, who brought down the house with “Bawo Thixo Somandla.” Vänskä then returned to lead the ensemble in a final performance of “Shosholoza.”

But the music didn’t stop there. The Gauteng Choristers continued the singing into the hallways as they left the stage; stragglers from the crowd looked on.

Minnesota Orchestra President and CEO Kevin Smith, who retires at the end of August, beamed at the post-concert farewell dinner. He thanked Classical Movements, the Orchestra’s tour partner, as well as the musicians, staff, patrons and donors who made the tour possible.

It is, “by all accounts, the biggest project the orchestra has ever done,” Smith said. “It’s hard to know where it goes from here, but … I think the orchestra will continue to be more adventurous and expansive in how it works and with whom it works and where it goes.”

President and CEO Kevin Smith
Story by Jenna Ross, Star Tribune

“There were so many dimensions to this tour,” said Smith. “The fact that it has gone so beautifully from beginning to end—it gives me goosebumps thinking about it.”


We are immensely grateful to the Music for Mandela corporate consortium sponsors for making this project possible: Ecolab, TCF, Medtronic Foundation, Land O’ Lakes, Inc., 3M, U.S. Bank, Thor Companies, Target and Pentair.

We recognize an anonymous couple for their generous contribution to fund the Minnesota Orchestra’s tour. We also recognize the Douglas and Louise Leatherdale Fund for Music supporting the work of Osmo Vänskä.

"It's bigger than ourselves and it’s bigger than our own perspectives. We have to share it with the world. And that’s what we did here.”

First Associate Concertmaster Susie Park
Story by Jenna Ross, Star Tribune

Photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

Soweto | Aug 17

Four musicians jumped on a bus in Johannesburg on Friday morning, August 17, headed to Soweto to attend a special Books for Africa event. Their day began with solo and chamber music performances for hundreds of students at Missourilaan Secondary School and ended with a grand Orchestra concert at one of South Africa's most historic venues.  

“Oh, shoot I forgot my concert clothes,” said violinist Natsuki Kumagai as she settled onto the bus, jumping up to run back to her room. For the musicians, the day would be nonstop: school event, zipping straight to rehearsal, then a group dinner, evening concert in Soweto and a 60-minute bus ride back to Johannesburg. 

When the musicians arrived at the school, hundreds of students, ages 13 and up, were assembled in a windswept courtyard, wearing proper blue school uniforms. Missourilaan Secondary School has known difficult days its leaders have said but, led by Principal Julius Van Rensburg, they are intent on propelling the school to new heights and preparing its 1,260 students to face the world.

The Saint Paul-based nonprofit Books For Africa is donating 40,000 books to this community, some 12,000 of which will find their way here. “We want to partner with Missourilaan and make it a place of excellence,” said Judge LaJune Lange, Minnesota’s Honorary South African Consul, who also attended the event.

Gathered school choirs, comprised of students and teachers, sang songs of welcome and several students offered poems. Ashidy Adams, 17, read a poignant hand-written poem about Nelson Mandela from a small notebook.

“He was steadfast, unshakeable, rooted to stop oppression so that I can taste freedom, not just catch a glimpse of it.”

August is a windy and dusty month in Johannesburg, and Minnesota Orchestra musicians arrived without clothespins, which are often used to clip music to stands in blustery weather. When it was his turn to play, Principal Flute Adam Kuenzel instead asked for student volunteers for the job. Manny Laureano, principal trumpet, told the students, “You have changed me. I am going to play this piece differently from ever before because of your reception today.”  Violinists Natsuki Kumagai and Michael Sutton received a rock star ovation when they play a duet.

Afterwards, the musicians struggled to explain the experience. “It was literally indescribable because it was not about things that were palpable,” said Laureano. “There was absolutely no wall between [the students] and their emotions. And when it was time to listen, they were attentive and beautifully so.”

It's filled with history. This is a place where organizers, including Nelson Mandela, now-Archbishop Desmond Tutu and Oliver Tambo worked to overcome apartheid.

Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

Regina Mundi Roman Catholic Church is a hallowed venue; it served as a center of organization for freedom fighters during the violent apartheid struggle and later it was the site for an early Truth and Reconciliation hearing when victims of apartheid faced their oppressors. Arriving at the simple A-Frame church, Orchestra musicians and staff felt the weight of that history.

“Nelson Mandela was a true world leader,” said clarinet player Tim Zavadil. “And this venue was the epicenter of the fight for equality.”

Outfitting the sanctuary to serve as a concert hall required months of planning, spearheaded by Classical Movements’ Johan Van Zyl and Minnesota Orchestra Technical Director Joel Mooney. Bollards had to be removed (and then replaced) from the front entrance to allow access for the trucks with equipment. A stage was carefully built out over the altar to accommodate the mass 200-person orchestra and choir, and rented lights were hung from the ceiling.

The concert was recorded by Minnesota Public Radio and a four-person MPR crew—Host Brian Newhouse, Producer Bradley Althoff, Technical Director Zachary Rose and Engineer Michael Osborne—buzzed around the space, testing sound levels and gear. They arrived with 1500 pounds of equipment, including back-up battery power in case of a power outage.

Following the concert, producer Althoff rushed a thumb drive containing the complete broadcast back to the Orchestra’s Johannesburg hotel to upload it in time for the 7 pm Central broadcast in Minnesota on Friday evening.

Minnesota Orchestra's concert in Soweto is an ode to joy in many languages

Jenna Ross, Star Tribune 

By concert time, it was already dark—late winter lighting—as the crowd filed in. Audience members mingled with musicians as there is no dedicated “backstage” space at the church. MPR’s Newhouse set up at a single microphone to the right of the stage, ready to relate the experience to radio listeners.

This is a nation of singers, but none of the audiences on the tour so far have come close to the full-throated vigor with which the Soweto crowd sang.

Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

The U.S. Consul General for Johannesburg Michael McCarthy welcomed the capacity crowd: “I can’t wait to hear what happens when we throw together the Gauteng Choristers, the Minnesota Orchestra and the Minnesota Chorale!”

What happened was magic. When the first “Freude” of Beethoven’s Ninth rang out, the energy in the venue was electric. To hear the “Ode to Joy,” that blazing hymn celebrating the togetherness of humankind, sung in this revered space, where people fought and died to achieve equality, was overwhelming.

The audience crescendo grew over the second half of the concert, as the Orchestra and choirs transitioned into a series of African songs: Akhala Amaqhude Amabili, Bawo, Ruri and the infectious call-and-response song, Nelson Mandela. There was no ambiguity in the audience feedback; this crowd was singing, dancing, and waving arms overhead, exuding appreciation.

Afterwards, 17-year-old reporter Mpho, who was attending the concert as part of a Children’s Radio Foundation delegation, offered her assessment. “I liked that the Orchestra tried to cater to South Africans” with some of its musical choices, she said.

Two long-time Regina Mundi parish members, who lived the struggle here, reveled in the concert afterwards. “It took me far away,” said one. “But it was too short. It could have been five hours and we don’t mind.”

For our musician travelers, there is still a sense of the surreal about the whole experience. “Life changing,” is how Kumagai described it in an end-of-day Instagram report.

And for Osmo Vänskä: “It was a dream,” he said. “And now it is happening.”

Photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

His Sacrifice

By Ashidy Adams, a student at Missourilaan Secondary School

He never showed his scars

He held the nation on his shoulders as if it were a coat, shining with diversity

He never revealed that he too

Bleeds on the inside

He remained hopeful

And that manifested into human form

He was steadfast


Rooted to stop oppression so

That I can taste freedom

Not just catch a glimpse of it

He defied every rule set for a people of color

His actions

Made me bolder

Than a den of lions

To be African

He wore his wounds

Like a crown

Bestowed only to royalty

We never saw the pain

He hid behind his smile

That made atmospheres change

He embraced the chaos

Because he saw the rainbow after the storm

Nelson Mandela

His name

Still resonates after 100 years

In the hearts of the nation

Who bled for

Their freedom

Long live his sacrifice!

Pretoria | Aug 16

On Thursday, August 16, the Orchestra performed their third concert of the South Africa tour, in the Aula Centre at the University of Pretoria. Before the performance, however, Minnesota Orchestra musicians fanned out around the campus, working with students from the University and from the South African National Youth Orchestra.

Conductor Gerben Grooten led Osmo Vänskä through the picturesque University of Pretoria campus to a small classroom in the fine arts building, where he would spend the afternoon leading a master class with seven of Gerben’s conducting students.

Gerben, who serves as resident conductor of the University of Pretoria Orchestras, has built a solid conducting studio on campus. His students range from first to fourth years and come from a variety of instrument backgrounds. At first, the room is quiet when he asks for questions.

“This is like in Finland,” Vänskä said. “No one wants to start.”

Soon the questions started rolling in. “How much does being Finnish influence your interpretation of Sibelius?” one asked.

“It doesn’t hurt to be Finnish and conduct Sibelius,” Vänskä said. “But there are many non-Finnish conductors who do it very well too. If we hear something again and again, that makes us think it is our music. When you repeat something, you can become a specialist.”

Students asked questions about stage fright, baton technique, rehearsal preparation and communication with musicians. Vänskä offered a general rule with good humor: “The more you speak, the more the players hate you. It is always better to go with body language.”

And some parting words that are the essence of the Vänskä philosophy:

“The composer is the highest order. We are performers and we must follow the composer.”

Resilience is an important quality for conductors, especially on tour. Following the student session, Vänskä zipped onto a bus with a small group of musicians and staff to attend a reception at the U.S. Ambassador’s residence in Pretoria. The U.S. Mission in South Africa has been a generous supporter of the Minnesota Orchestra South Africa tour.

Three string principals—Erin Keefe, Susie Park and Rebecca Albers—played a little Dvořák, and then conductor and musicians headed back to the Aula Centre to prepare for the evening’s concert.

Classical Movements CEO and Founder Neeta Helms welcomed the crowd. “We’ve been having a lekker time,” she exclaimed. “Lekker” is the Afrikaans word for superb or fantastic.

Then, Jessica Lapenn, Charge d’Affaires at the U.S. Mission in South Africa, spoke, praising the Orchestra and the audience for being part of the celebration around Mandela’s 100th. “All of you being here reaffirms our belief in arts and cultural affairs as a way to sustain relationships,” Lapenn said. “The musicians of the Minnesota Orchestra are citizen diplomats and represent the very best of the U.S.” 

Lapenn concluded her remarks, describing how music brings unity from diversity and that orchestras are the perfect example of this: a group of individuals with tremendous abilities who work together toward a common end goal. For an orchestra, that shared goal is to bring beauty and empathy to our shared humanity. “That’s the spirit of Nelson Mandela that we need to move his legacy forward.”

"It was these young musicians who inspired the Minnesota Orchestra's tour."

Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

Many students from SANYO and the University of Pretoria were in the audience as well as students from LEAP Science & Math School and Field Band Foundation of South Africa. The crowd was electric—responding enthusiastically to the Orchestra’s performance. As Vänskä acknowledged each individual section of the orchestra, the students in the crowd cheered loudly for the musicians they had shared the stage with earlier that day.

Photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

Pretoria | Aug 15

The Orchestra headed to the University of Pretoria on Wednesday, August 15, for an afternoon side-by-side rehearsal with the South African National Youth Orchestra (SANYO) and an evening rehearsal with the Minnesota Chorale and Gauteng Choristers.

Music Director Osmo Vänskä guest conducted SANYO in 2014 and his experience left a lasting impression an became an impetus for the Orchestra’s South Africa tour. Celebrating its 54th year, SANYO has become one of South Africa’s most successful institutions, nurturing the musical development of the country’s finest young musicians.

Gerben Grooten, principal conductor of the Pretoria Symphony Orchestra and a lecturer in conducting at the University of Pretoria, welcomed the Minnesota Orchestra and SANYO musicians at the top of the rehearsal. Grooten explained that the hallmarks of the American ethos—drive, energy, pioneering spirit—are much needed in South Africa, and that having the Minnesota Orchestra work side-by-side with SANYO was an incredible opportunity for the young musicians. 

"I literally have no words to describe this feeling. It is really cool, so I am really happy I am here."

Casey Jacobs, 18 (SANYO Violinist)
 Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

He said not many orchestras come to visit South Africa, and he instructed the SANYO students to lean in and seize the moment, ask questions and learn from the experience.

“You also have a gift to share with the Minnesota Orchestra,” he told the students. Grooten then presented Vänskä and concertmaster Erin Keefe with South African gifts: Biltong (dried, cured meat) and drinking glasses featuring images of South Africa’s “Big 5.”

Vänskä spent the afternoon rehearsing Sibelius’ Symphony No. 2 with the students, in preparation for their performance this weekend. Throughout the first movement of the piece, Vänskä encouraged the ensemble to “play as soft as possible.”


At one point in the second movement, Vänskä asked that only the Minnesota Orchestra musicians play a particularly lyrical, melodic passage. Casey Jacobs, a violinist in SANYO who hails from Gordon’s Bay, outside of Cape Town, later gushed to her Minnesota Orchestra stand partner Michael Sutton, “That was so beautiful!”

During the rehearsal, Sutton swapped bows with Jacobs. “Your bow is nicer than mine,” Jacobs quipped. “We can swap violins, too!” Sutton chuckled.

“You see, there are many, many different languages that we speak when we play. And depending on who the conductor is, they might want a different language.”

Manny Laureano, principal trumpet
Story by Jenna Ross, Star Tribune

Sophia Welz, managing director for SANYO, explained that the ensemble's membership mirrors the diversity in South Africa.

“We have 78 musicians from a wide range of places and backgrounds,” she said. “While there may be more than 1,000 km between us, everyone here is working toward a common, shared goal. It doesn’t matter where you are from or who you are.”

The ensemble hosts anonymous auditions each year and every student’s selection is based on merit. In addition to musical coaching and training, the organization also offers courses on instrument repair and arts administration, creating a very well-rounded educational program for the young musicians.

Welz emphasized the importance of the immersion project with the Orchestra.

“This type of experience is a real confidence builder for them. Side-by-side rehearsals are like a booster shot,” she said. “While this might be a small amount of time together, it’s extremely intense and it makes a lasting impression with these students.”

After the side-by-side rehearsal, the musicians and SANYO students enjoyed dinner together at Adler’s, a nearby eatery on campus.

Not every orchestra would be so enthusiastic about the community engagement programming. But most of the Minnesota players seem sporting, many seem enthusiastic and some seem deeply moved during the outreach events.

 Dessa,Classical MPR

Then, the Orchestra returned to Aula for their first rehearsal with the combined choir of Minnesota Chorale and the Gauteng Choristers, with SANYO students in the audience.

On Thursday, August 16, the students will spend the day working one-on-one with musicians in masterclasses and chamber music sessions. In addition, Vänskä will lead a conducting workshop and the Orchestra's administrative leaders will present an information session with SANYO students who are interested in arts administration.

Photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

Durban and Johannesburg | Aug 13-14

Musicians enjoyed a free day on Monday. Some spent the time in sunny Durban, while others opted for a trek to Pilanesberg National Park, roughly three hours drive from Johannesburg, for a short and sweet safari experience at Bakubung Lodge, complete with lions, hippos and giraffes.

Back in Johannesburg, 50-some members of the Minnesota Chorale—who arrived in this capital city on Sunday—met their choral counterparts from South Africa’s Gauteng Choristers for the first time on Monday evening in a rehearsal conducted by their respective leaders, Kathy Saltzman Romey and Sidwell Mhlongo. Osmo Vänskä jumped into the mix on Tuesday night, leading a combined rehearsal at the National School for the Arts. “Whether you are coming from Johannesburg or Minneapolis,” he said. “It is great to see everyone!”

"The Gauteng Choristers are internationally acclaimed, and one of three South African choirs to perform at the funeral of President Nelson Mandela in 2013. The Minnesota Chorale will join the Minnesota Orchestra Friday as its first-of-its-kind tour of South Africa culminates in a concert at Regina Mundi, a Soweto church that played a significant role in the country's struggle during — and after — apartheid."

— Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

Both choirs have been planning for this collaboration for over a year, expanding their repertoire to include new pieces in different languages and, in the case of the Minnesota Chorale, each singer has personally raised the funds to support a tour 10,000 miles from home. Osmo seemed pleased with the result. “I really like the sound you are producing right now,” he said, following a run-through of the African song Akhala, which is sung in Zulu.

"A choir from Minnesota and a choir from South Africa sang together Monday night for the first time. It felt, somehow, like the hundredth."

— Jenna Ross, Star Tribune

He was flanked by Saltzman Romey and Mhlongo, who called out their own bits of advice to bring the choirs together. “Singers, you must sing ‘held,’” said Saltzman Romey midway through Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony. “If you sing ‘hell’ that means something else.”


On Wednesday night the choirs will come together for a final rehearsal, this one involving the Orchestra, and then it’s time to raise the curtain on this long-in-the-works collaboration, with a Friday night performance in Soweto and Saturday afternoon finale in Johannesburg. But tonight, the reality hasn’t quite sunk in yet. “It is still hard to believe we are here,” marveled Saltzman Romey.

Safari photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

Durban | Aug 12

The Orchestra landed in Durban on Saturday night, immediately feeling the more temperate weather of this busy port city known for expansive Indian Ocean beaches and a subtropical climate in the “garden province” of KwaZulu-Natal. A cheerful band of Orchestra wind players headed out first thing on Sunday morning to join the young musicians of the KwaZulu-Natal Youth Wind Band in rehearsal.

The youth ensemble is led by conductor Russell Scott, who explained that the band is made-up of cream-of-the-crop wind musicians from the across the KZN province, with many students traveling long distances to attend the weekly Saturday rehearsals. “We push for high standards,” he said. “We are proud to break barriers and make music together.”

Scott led the band in the “Jupiter” movement from Holst’s The Planets, as well as an African piece called Patta, Patta (“Touch, Touch”) that he arranged for wind ensemble. Following a performance by a Minnesota Orchestra wind ensemble, professionals and students broke into small sectionals to get to the nitty-gritty of their instruments and parts.

Associate Principal Percussion Kevin Watkins met with student percussionists to discuss the art of timpani playing. “It’s good to practice singing the notes to learn the pitches,” he said. “If you get your ear really close to the timpani, you can hear the pitch perfectly.” 

In a separate practice room, tuba player Jason Tanksley—the Minnesota Orchestra’s Rosemary and David Good Fellow—met with six young tuba and euphonium players to drill into The Planets. “You don’t have to play it too loudly,” he said. “Try it pianissimo.” 

Upstairs, bass trombone player Andrew Chappell was offering a masterclass on breathing. “Try to hear and feel how the breath relates to the sound,” he advised. “The better the breath, the better the sound. And eventually, forget about the breathing and just think ‘I am taking in my sound and letting out my sound.’”

Trombone students started to hit their stride. “I love the satisfaction in that passage,” one said.

“Yes!” Chappell affirmed. “You should feel that you made your statement.”

The KZN Wind Ensemble students will have a chance to hear the Orchestra make its statement at Sunday afternoon’s concert at Durban’s stately City Hall.

“Let it fly, so it is a little more colorful. I think it is more important to hear the entrances than the exits.” — Principal Clarinet Gabriel Compos Zamora

On Sunday afternoon, the Orchestra headed to Durban City Hall for a quick touch-up rehearsal and early evening concert. A quintessential example of Edwardian Neo-baroque architecture, Durban City Hall was completed in 1910 and was considered very bold in its design at the time. As the buses pulled up to the venue, many musicians stopped to take notice of the gorgeous exterior of the building.

Upon entering City Hall, musicians dodged wardrobe cases on stage, backstage—and even out in the house. With very little space in the backstage area, double bass and cello cases stood at the back of the stage and percussion cases just down the steps from stage left.

Tarps were hung in the hallway around the corner from backstage to create a men’s dressing area. Accessing backstage required going on to the stage—which proved to be somewhat challenging as orchestra staffers transported cases of water bottles backstage when the touch-up rehearsal began.

The concert began a special performance from the Clermont Choir, conducted by Brian Msizi Mnyandu. Orchestra members looked on, standing at the back and sides of the house. An outgrowth of the Clermont Catholic Church Choir, Clermont Choir was founded in 1992 and specializes in many different genres of music with a focus on choral, classical and African indigenous music. Based in Durban, the group has 60 members, most of whom reside in the metropolitan area. The choir performed a captivating short three-song set that had the audience clapping and cheering along.

Neeta Helms, president of Classical Movements, then welcomed the crowd and introduced Sherry Zalika Sykes, U.S. Consul General in Durban. Sykes shared that one of the highlights of her job is to welcome American visitors to South Africa and to build bridges between our two countries. She added that the Minnesota Orchestra musicians are some of America’s best diplomats, sharing their music and touching the lives of so many South Africans.

Music Director Osmo Vänskä then came to the stage, leading the Orchestra in both the South African and American national anthems. Sibelius’ En Saga opened the program, followed by Bongani Ndodana-Breen’s Harmonia Ubuntu, featuring Goitsemang Lehoybe.

At intermission, the smell of samosas wafted through the hallway and the crowd made its way to the refreshment area outside of the auditorium. During the break, an Orchestra staffer spoke with a group of students from Inanda Seminary, one of South Africa’s oldest schools for girls. Founded in 1853, the school is based in Inanda, a township about 15 miles northwest of Durban. Twenty-four students from the school were able to attend the concert, thanks to the Medtronic Foundation. Students Philasande and Zamakhosi shared their excitement about the event—that this was the first orchestra concert they and their classmates had ever attended. Zamakhosi, a choir student, spoke about Goitsemang Lehoybe’s performance. “Her singing was beautiful,” she said. “Hearing that kind of singing was new to me—I’ve never heard someone sing like that!”

Minnesota Orchestra brings its music, outreach to Durban, South Africa

— Photos and audio from Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

Although more restrained than the Cape Town audience, the crowd of nearly 1,000 came to life in the second half, with many cries of  “Bravo” at the end of Bernstein’s Overture to Candide. A young girl gasped loudly and squealed “Yes!” when the iconic opening notes of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony filled the cavernous space. The audience leaped to their feet at the end of the piece, giving the ensemble a standing ovation.

For the encore, the Orchestra once again performed “Shosholoza.” As was the case in Cape Town, the crowd didn’t recognize it at first. Once the musicians started singing, the crowd, including the students from Inanda Seminary, went crazy, singing along and dancing in the aisles.

Post-concert, as the crew began to prep for the load-out, the girls sang their own version of "Shosholoza" at the front of the stage, with many musicians filming the performance with their phone.

Concert photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

Cape Town | Aug 10-11

The spirit of Nelson Mandela was alive as the Minnesota Orchestra kicked off its South Africa Tour with a performance at Cape Town City Hall on Friday evening, August 10.

The Orchestra’s performance marked the second orchestra concert in the newly refurbished hall, which recently reopened after a 9-month, 27 million Rand ($2 million USD) renovation. Part of the venue’s recent transformation included a statue honoring Nelson Mandela on the same balcony where he first addressed the nation as in 1990 as a free man.

Before the concert, the vibe in the foyer of the recently remodeled venue was electric. South Africans of all backgrounds and ages entered through the doors of the historic venue located on Darling Street across from the Grand Parade, the main public square of the city and home to a bustling marketplace. Once inside the auditorium, some of the younger audience members took selfies and classical music aficionados thumbed through the program book.

The energy of the crowd carried backstage to the musicians and crew, despite the tight quarters. 14,000 pounds of instrument and wardrobe trunks, coupled with many musicians resulted in traffic jams, all of which were taken in stride and good humor.

U.S. Consul General Virginia Blaser welcomed the sold-out crowd, praising the Minnesota Orchestra’s tour--the first by an American orchestra--and their musical diplomacy efforts. The concert was also attended by a contingent of officials from the U.S. Consulate.

Students from the Children’s Radio Foundation, some of whom had never been to a concert before, were in attendance, as well as students from Nelson Mandela University, ERUB Children’s Choir and other organizations.

The audience was instantly captivated by the opening piece, Sibelius’ En Saga, which demonstrated the Orchestra’s trademark broad dynamic range. During the whispering pianissimos at the end of the work, there wasn’t a sound in the hall and the audience erupted in applause once Vänskä lowered the baton.

"Thank you for bringing your years of practice and corporate rehearsal to the shores of Africa and enthralling us with your artistry."

— Audience member

Goitsemang Lehoybe, one of South Africa’s favorite sopranos and an alumna of the University of Cape Town, was the soloist for native son Bongani Ndonana-Breen’s Harmonia Ubuntu. Commissioned by Classical Movements in honor of the Orchestra’s South Africa tour, the piece received its premiere in Minneapolis in July, but this performance was the South African premiere. Mandela’s words and Xhosa-influenced rhythms and melodies are featured in the work, which was well-received by the hometown crowd. At the conclusion of the performance, there were multiple cries of “Bravo” from the audience and several curtain calls for Lehoybe.

"During a rousing, sold-out show Friday, the former president’s words, sung by a soaring soprano, once again hung in the air."

— Jenna Ross, Star Tribune

The second half of the concert featured two audience faves—Bernstein’s boisterous Overture to Candide, followed by Beethoven’s masterful Fifth Symphony.

Music Director Osmo Vänskä then returned to the stage with three encores—two pieces by Sibelius, Tanz-Intermezzo and Finlandia, with the beloved South African song “Shosholoza” in between. At first, when the Orchestra began playing “Shosholoza,” there wasn’t much reaction from the crowd. But once the musicians started to sing the words, the audience erupted in cheers, clapping and singing along.


"A couple of people said they'd never been to a classical concert before and were blown away. One woman said that she was seeing colors and recognizing nature in the music."

— Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

Although the Orchestra’s time in Cape Town was brief, many meaningful connections with the community were made.

Saturday Engagements

The Orchestra divided on Saturday. About 30 musicians headed to the Artscape Theatre Centre in downtown Cape Town to rehearse and coach student members of the Cape Town Youth Philharmonic. Led by Osmo Vänskä, the ensemble worked—and then worked some more—on Shostakovich’s Festive Overture and Sibelius’ Finlandia. “Maybe you need to know the story of Finlandia,” Vänskä said and explained its importance in Finland’s quest for independence from Russia. “When you play, you need to say something,” he said.

The talented students in this Youth Philharmonic range in age from 16 to 24. “I really like what you are doing,” Vänskä told them. “You are fixing things so quickly.  Thank you for all you have given today to me and to us.”  

The other members of the Minnesota Orchestra bused to the Eurecon Primary School in Elsie’s River Township. Students, parents and small siblings congregated to greet and perform for their guests from Minnesota.

“Parents and students, thank you for coming to school on a Saturday,” said Brendon Adams, leader of the musical ensemble 29:11 and one of the forces behind this visit. “Minnesota Orchestra, we are happy you are here, joining us not just at Cape Town City Hall but in our community.”

The school’s Intermediate Choir, comprised of 10 to 13-year-old students, sang a plaintive welcome, “I am a Small Part of the World,” conducted by Donovan Meyer-Adams. Meyer-Adams is the school’s computer science and math teacher but he does double duty as its choir director. He said his students held a special rehearsal on last week’s national holiday to prepare for today’s performance, rehearsing songs in Afrikaans, English and Swahili.

Minnesota Orchestra string, woodwind and brass ensembles then took the stage, each explaining a little about their instruments and how they produced sound—demonstrating by squeaking reeds and buzzing lips—before playing short chamber pieces.

“Most of these kids aren’t regularly exposed to classical music or instruments,” said Meyer-Adams. “This gives them an idea of what the sounds that come from these instruments are like.”

Trombonist Doug Wright brought down the house with an ever-favorite demonstration. “One of the really cool things about the trombone is that it can make race car sounds,” he said. “This is why you all want to play trombone, right?“

“It’s an honor for us to be here,” he concluded. “Thank you for the invite.”

"The youngsters howled with laughter as the reed players demonstrated the quacking sound of their mouthpieces, but they really loved it when musician Steven Campbell demonstrated how low his tuba could go. The building seemed to shake as he pretended to collapse under the effort, and then it rang with laughter."

— Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

The gathered audience—over 200 parents, students, musicians and Orchestra patrons—moved outside to a central courtyard for a mix-it-up series of performances featuring Praise Dancers, the ensemble 29:11 and some jamming Orchestra musicians, including trumpeter Charles Lazarus, who riffed with 29:11. Rapper-singer-essayist Dessa took the microphone to rap her gratitude. “I hope you see in our faces how happy we are to be here,” she said. 

Under a bright late-winter sun, Brendon Adams, 29:11, Orchestra brass players and the assembled audience wrapped it up with a rowdy version of “Welcome to Cape Town,” the Ghoema melody the brass ensemble learned from students earlier in the week.

“The feelings students felt today is something they will remember,” said Meyer-Adams. “It is nice to know you are appreciated . . . and that you count.”

Concert and Elsie's River photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

Cape Town | Aug 8-9

Minnesota Orchestra musicians arrived in bright and breezy Cape Town on Wednesday morning, and if any spirits were lagging after the 11-hour night flight, a welcome-to-the-city performance by a traditional, brassy Kaapse Klopse band—this one called Happy Sounds Youth Development and comprising students from 12 to 18—helped to revive them.

Cape Town, perched between the Atlantic Ocean and Table Mountain, is the breathtakingly beautiful home to around 5 million people today; formerly it was home to one of the world’s most famous political prisoners, Nelson Mandela, who was incarcerated on Robben Island for nearly two decades. A group of 20-some musicians headed straight from the airport to the Victoria and Alfred Waterfront for a tour of this site, a fitting start to the “Music for Mandela” tour.

A rocky 40-minute ferry ride delivered the musician tour group to the Island, which officially became a museum site in 1997.  All visitors to Robben Island are greeted by a quote from freedom fighter Ahmed Kathrada: “While we will not forget the brutality of apartheid, we will not want Robben Island to be a monument of our hardship and suffering. We would want it to be a triumph of the human spirit against the forces of evil, a triumph of wisdom and largeness of spirit against small minds and pettiness, a triumph of courage and determination over human frailty and weakness.”

In South Africa, Minnesota Orchestra makes grim visit to Mandela's former prison cell

-Jenna Ross, Star Tribune

Former political prisoners on Robben Island now serve as its tour guides, speaking first-hand about the cause they fought for and the living conditions they endured. Every tour ends with a humbling walk to the small cell that Nelson Mandela occupied in his time on the Island. 

At the end of this sober visit, violist Sam Bergman posed a question to the tour guide, “When you were imprisoned here, did you have hope that the anti-apartheid struggle would eventually be won?”  Without pausing, the former-prisoner-now-guide answered, “We knew we would win. We were fighting for a just and noble cause and that saw us through.”

"For me it's not even that this puts music in perspective. This puts life in perspective."

From a story by Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

This day that began in the Northern hemisphere ended with a flourish at Cape Town’s famed Gold Restaurant, which specializes in North African, sub-Saharan and Southern African foods, all accompanied by electrifying African drumming, dancing and singing. And so this music and cultural exchange has begun.

Board Chair Marilyn Carlson Nelson welcomed the assembled tour group by saying, “The world needs the music you make.”

"Put on your dancing shoes. Cape Town welcomes you!"

Thursday was a free day for Minnesota Orchestra musicians and a holiday—National Women’s Day—for the students of the Cape Music Institute but both Orchestra professionals and music students opted to forego a day-off for the chance to participate in a music exchange together.

"The students greeted the Brass Quintet with song, launching into "Welcome to Cape Town," a rollicking piece lauding the city, its people and its natural beauty."

-Euan Kerr, Minnesota Public Radio

Faith Pretorius is an administrator at the Cape Music Institute, a professional school tucked into Athlone Stadium in Cape Town that offers both music and life training for super-talented 18 to 24-year-olds, many of whom come from challenging circumstances. “I tell the students that your gift cannot take you where your character cannot go,” Pretorius says.

In a crowded room—full of fellow students, administrators, and media—music students demonstrated that character, singing a joyful song, Ghoema-style.

Ghoema music, as one student explained, derives from a slave tradition, merging big band, jazz, calypso, reggae, San and Xhosa musical influences to create a totally unique, winsome sound. “Welcome to Cape Town,” the students sang. “Enjoy the party. Put on your dancing shoes. Cape Town welcomes you.”

The brass ensemble—Charles Lazarus, Douglas Carlson, R. Douglas Wright, Michael Gast and Steven Campbell—reciprocated with a little Bach, Piazzolla and Bernstein, which elicited raucous cheering from the students. “You are the best audience ever,” commented Doug Wright. “Does someone want to teach us this Ghoema piece?”

In a high point of the morning, the brass ensemble sight-read the swinging “Welcome to Cape Town” tune, flanked by student instrumentalists and vocalists who showed them the ropes. “There are no word to describe this,” said Pretorius. “We are a small school, a family, and students, you have made us proud today. Minnesota Orchestra musicians, thank you for empowering our students.”

The ensemble 29:11, which recently lit up the Twin Cities in a series of Minneapolis performances, includes many alumnae from the Cape Music Institute; this morning’s workshop concluded with a drop-in visit and performance from 29:11 of the moving Nkosi sikelel iAfrika. When asked about the impact of the day, Pretorius answered simply, “Music brings us together.”

These students and Orchestra musicians will come together again on Saturday in Elsie’s River township to perform their newfound shared song, “Welcome to Cape Town.”

Students and the Orchestra brass ensemble pose in front of Athlone Stadium, home of the Cape Music Institute, as well as two Cape Town Premier Soccer League teams.

Gusts of winter wind made performing a challenge at the Victoria & Alfred Waterfront but these hardy brass players were not easily deterred. Gathering armfuls of sheet music that almost blew into the harbor, the musicians re-clipped the music to their stands and carried on.

The V&A Waterfront is one of the city’s main tourist attractions, even on a brisk winter day.

Photography by Travis Anderson. Follow along throughout the tour on our South Africa landing page.

BBC Proms | Aug 6

On August 6, the Minnesota Orchestra made a triumphant return to the BBC Proms, the world’s largest classical music festival, with an all-American program. Music Director Osmo Vänskä led the Orchestra in a performance of Bernstein’s Overture to Candide, George Gershwin’s Piano Concerto in F, featuring Inon Barnatan as soloist, and Charles Ives’ visionary Symphony No. 2.

"With the Minnesota players alert and precise from the get-go, it opened the programme with a burst of vitality that mellowed into warmth..."

-George Hall, Financial Times (London)

Keeping with tradition, the Prommers injected their humor into the concert experience—applauding Concertmaster Erin Keefe as she sounded the ‘A’ on the piano to tune the orchestra and shouting “Heave, Ho!” as the stage crew lifted the lid of the piano in anticipation of Barnatan’s performance. After his performance, the Prommers wanted more, stomping their feet as a request for an encore, and the soloist obliged, returning to the stage to perform a virtuosic, playful and improvisational rendition of Gershwin’s I’ve Got Rhythm.

"This was as fine a reading as I've heard in years, up there with the greats… Barnatan's encore, Earl Wild's Virtuoso Étude on 'I got Rhythm', was swish and light-fingered, classically cool with a dizzy suggestion of Domenico Scarlatti two-hundred years on, cigars and a bourbon for backcloth: superb."

-Ateş Orga, Classical Source

Although there were moments of informality and humor, the full house of eager fans was rapt by the Orchestra’s performance throughout the evening.

After a rousing conclusion of the Ives Symphony, the audience erupted into thunderous applause. As he returned to the stage for the encore, Vänskä spoke about the Orchestra’s South Africa tour in celebration of Nelson Mandela’s Centenary and dedicated the Orchestra’s encore, Shosholoza—a traditional South African song—to the people of South Africa.


Mary Miller, a resident of Brighton, Sussex, shared her enthusiasm after the concert with an Orchestra staffer. “The Orchestra played extremely well,” she said, “and it was a real treat for us to hear an all-American program.”

Belfast native Andrew Sloan said he enjoyed his first-ever Proms concert, adding that he’ll be back the next time the Minnesota Orchestra comes to town.


The concert, broadcast live across Minnesota on Classical MPR and throughout the U.K. on BBC Radio 3, was the prelude to the Orchestra’s five-city tour of South Africa, which begins this week in Cape Town with a series of engagement activities and a sold-out concert at Cape Town's City Hall on Friday evening.

Musicians and staff arrived yesterday afternoon at Royal Albert Hall for rehearsal in preparation for the evening’s concert. Photographer Travis Anderson captured a behind-the-scenes look during the rehearsal.

Minnesota Orchestra Music Director Osmo Vänskä and Concertmaster Erin Keefe enter Royal Albert Hall for the Orchestra’s afternoon rehearsal.

The low brass section rehearses the encore, Shosholoza, a traditional South African song. Sung by Mandela while he was imprisoned at Robben Island, the tune has unofficially become the country’s second anthem. 

"Finally, the concert’s knockout punch: the encore of the South African miners’ song Shosholoza, the country’s unofficial national anthem, delivered with bone-shaking panache by the orchestra’s singing musicians. South Africa, look out." 

-Geoff Brown, The Times 

Principal Trumpet Manny Laureano uses a Greek fisherman’s cap as a mute in the Gershwin piece. In the score, Gershwin called for the crown of a felt hat. Laureano, like other trumpeters, has experimented with different types of felt and felt hats, but found that his authentic Greek fisherman’s cap produces the purest sound and intonation.

Rehearsal and behind-the-scenes photography by Travis Anderson. Concert photography by Chris Christodoulou.

For complete media coverage, please visit our Press Room page.

The Piano Tuner Behind It All

As the Orchestra concludes its 2017-18 season at Orchestra Hall, it offers a big round of applause for someone who is not normally in the concert spotlight: retiring piano tuner Jerry Ouska, who served the Orchestra, its pianos and world-famous pianists for 34 years. By Dan Wascoe

If Jerry Ouska dreams about his former job after retiring this summer, he shouldn’t be surprised if those dreams have soundtracks.

Ouska, 70, has tuned the Minnesota Orchestra’s pianos since 1984, regularly tweaking three nine-foot Steinway concert grands, often to the particular preferences of guest soloists. During Sommerfest extravaganzas, he tuned up to five pianos.

He also learned to deal harmoniously with the guest soloists.

“There are so many personalities,” he said, and they know just how they want their instrument to sound.

A few soloists during Ouska’s tenure—Alfred Brendel, for example—brought their own pianos. Others brought their own tuners. Vladimir Horowitz brought both.

Usually, however, a guest artist samples each of the Orchestra’s three in-house grands, testing the touch, the brightness, the overall sound.

“They go back and forth trying them” before choosing one for the performance, Ouska said.

After that, “I’m always here for the first rehearsal,” when the chosen piano is played on stage at Orchestra Hall. Then he consults with the pianist about adjustments, perhaps changing the tone or touch on just a few keys, depending on the piece and the soloist’s performance style. Some artists “just beat on the piano,” he said. “They can be way stronger than most people understand.”

Besides preparing a piano for such power, a technician’s work must be delicately precise. Pressure on individual keys should be 50 grams when depressed and at least 24 or 25 grams coming back up, he said.

Ouska has personally rehabbed a couple of the Orchestra’s pianos, which are either owned outright or provided by Steinway through its Concerts and Artists Department.

He majored in music at Indiana University, where he met his wife, Nancy; she played piano and flute, he played trumpet. Later he sold pianos before becoming a technician. Steinway was pleased with his warranty repair work and sent him to a piano factory for further training. He worked twice with famed Steinway technical chief Franz Mohr.

After the Ouskas moved to Minnesota, Nancy worked in sales for Schmitt Music, Steinway’s dealer in Minnesota. That relationship came into play in 2006 when the Orchestra decided to trade in its “Old 300” grand, which had been in service for more than 30 years.

At the time, the Metropolitan Airports Foundation was seeking a concert grand to place in its main concourse at Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport’s Terminal 1. Ouska said Foundation officials were “enthralled” by Old 300’s pedigree at Orchestra Hall, where it had been played by the likes of John Browning, Alicia de Laroccha, Garrick Ohlsson, Jeffrey Siegel and the duo of Ferrante and Teacher. The Foundation agreed to buy it after Schmitt touched up the casework.

Even though the mechanism was in good shape, he said, the piano by then “looked like an old beater.”

Old 300 remains in service at the airport, and although Ouska says, “it wouldn’t be a star piano today” in concert halls, “it was a really good piano back in its day.”

Ouska said he’ll feel “a good deal of sadness” about leaving the Orchestra but as he moves from tuning to gardening and boating, he also is bound to feel a sense of relief. His tuning schedule was rigorous and pressure was intense because “world-class pianists depend on your work. If they’re unhappy, it gets back to the conductor, and the musicians know it.” In addition, if a piano should break down during rehearsal or performance, those musicians’ time “is really expensive.”

That’s why much of his job has required preventive maintenance. In his 34 years with the Orchestra, he recalled only twice when a piano string broke during a concert.

What happened then?

“You keep going until the movement ends,” he said, when a technician can pull the broken string out of the way.” (Most notes are sounded on three strings.)

But if the break occurs in the last movement, nothing can be done and the pianist and orchestra must power through.

Dan Wascoe is a retired reporter and columnist for the Minneapolis Star Tribune and performs with vocalist Baibi Vegners as Nuance/a duo.


Performing at the Proms: a Q&A with Inon Barnatan

“One of the most admired pianists of his generation," according to The New York Times, pianist Inon Barnatan recently played with the Minnesota Orchestra in January for the Tchaikovsky Marathon and the Midwest Tour. Last year, he debuted at the world's largest classical music festival, the BBC Proms; he returns to the prestigious venue next month with the Orchestra to perform Gershwin's Piano Concerto in F.

Hear the complete program live in Minneapolis a Tour Send-Off concert, August 1 at Orchestra Hall.

What is it like to walk out onto the stage as a soloist at the BBC Proms? It really is indescribable–one of the most thrilling experiences one can have as a performer. I made my debut there last year (playing Ravel’s Piano Concerto in G major with the BBC Symphony Orchestra), and I have not been able to stop talking about how incredible it felt going out in front of so many enthusiastic and discerning people. It’s one of the best classical music audiences in the world, the space itself is beautiful, and just walking out on stage is intoxicating.

What was the highlight of your debut performance there last year? The wonderful thing about it, besides just being there, was how intimate it actually felt on stage. As soon as we started playing, it felt like we were in a living room. It’s surprisingly comfortable and intimate, in contrast with the epic scope of the place.

How do you think your performances with the Minnesota Orchestra earlier this year will contribute to the Proms concert on August 6? I think musical relationships are always helped by experience—the deeper the relationship with other musicians, the better the performances. The more comfortable you feel with an orchestra or conductor, the more you feel you can trust each other. I feel very close to the Minnesota Orchestra musicians; walking out on stage with them feels like we are performing as a united front, that we are on the same page from the beginning. 

Barnatan, with Osmo Vänskä and the Minnesota Orchestra, at Chicago's Symphony Center, January 2018. Photo: Greg Helgeson

What do you enjoy most about Gershwin’s Piano Concerto in F? It’s a great piece that doesn’t always get the musical credit that it deserves. There is more to it than the fun, jazz aspect; it’s actually a complex and interesting piece and a great presentation of what Gershwin did best, which was combine classical and jazz into something new. I get to indulge my jazzy side, which I rarely get to do, while combining classical and jazz, two of my great loves. 

How do you manage such a busy schedule of concerts? I’m also always planning ahead, so it is important that I practice not only what I am playing now, but also what I will be playing next. Also, I just try to steal time at home as much as possible. As much as I really enjoy the travel and concerts, I try to balance my schedule to make sure I have time away from the piano and music. I find that this sense of balance is very important.

What are your favorite places to perform or visit as you travel?  The BBC Proms are high on my list—I lived in London for 10 years and it has always been one of my favorites.

Beat the road construction blues and enjoy the music!

We totally agree with you: road construction in the Twin Cities is making it tough to get around right now! The Minnesota Orchestra is still here and working hard to create world class performances for you at Orchestra Hall, and we don’t want traffic cones and detours to spoil your summer concert experience.

We recommend that you leave home early and spend some extra time in downtown Minneapolis and at Orchestra Hall, where you can experience a lot more than just the evening’s concert. Here are ten tips from us to help you ease the construction woes and fully enjoy your visit. 

  • Take the Light Rail Blue Line or Green Line to avoid the construction all together. It’s a 10 to 15 minute walk to Orchestra Hall from the Nicollet Mall station.

  • Speaking of Nicollet, have you visited downtown since this street re-opened last fall? New features include a “Light Walk,” an “Art Walk,” artist-designed lanterns and a restored clock sculpture on the corner outside Orchestra Hall.

  • Metro Transit is offering FREE RIDES to the International Day of Music events at Orchestra Hall on July 21. Click here to download your pass.

  • Go green and Bike to Orchestra Hall! Did you know that several of our Orchestra musicians bike to Orchestra Hall every day for rehearsal? If you bike to a concert, stop by the box office and let us know by showing your helmet or gear. We have a special discount coupon for you that is good for 50% tickets to select upcoming concerts. 

  • Come early and have dinner downtown. There are many great restaurants within a few blocks of Orchestra Hall. Check out our list of nearby dining options.

  • Throughout this summer, Orchestra Hall is home to an educational exhibit about Nelson Mandela, curated by our friends at the University of Minnesota; in addition, artists from Homewood Studios and Juxtaposition Art in North Minneapolis and Interact Center in Saint Paul have their artwork on display; and children from Way to Grow’s preschool classes created a community out of decorated boxes. Doors open two hours before each performance, and at noon for the International Day of Music on July 21.

  • Come early on specific dates and listen to our free pre-concert talks, where you can learn more about the programs and performers for the evening’s concert. Additional musical performances are often happening in the Target Atrium and Orchestra Hall lobby spaces before and after concerts, too. Check out the event page on our website calendar for your particular concert choice to find out more.

  • Increase your daily dose of classical music as you drive. The Minnesota Orchestra won a Grammy Award for its recording of Sibelius’ Symphonies No. 1 and 4, and was recently nominated for another Grammy for our recording of Mahler’s Fifth Symphony. We have many recordings that you can listen to on your way to Orchestra Hall! Or check out our Spotify playlists to hear previews of upcoming concerts.

  • Not the driver? Scroll through the #MNOrch social media pages on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter as you make your way here. You’ll find plenty of great photos, details about upcoming events, links to interviews with our musicians and more.

  • And don’t forget to visit all of our Sommerfest food and merchandise vendors, and enjoy a pre-concert happy hour at the Orchestra Hall bars! 

For current information about road construction and traffic, please visit Move Minneapolis or Minnesota Department of Transportation.

Akiko Fujimoto Named Associate Conductor

The Minnesota Orchestra announced this month that Akiko Fujimoto, who joined the Orchestra’s artistic roster as assistant conductor in 2017, has been named associate conductor for the 2018-19 season.

In her first year in Minnesota, Fujimoto served as a cover conductor for Classical subscription and Live at Orchestra Hall concerts, conducted the Orchestra’s Common Chords performances in Mankato in April, led Young People’s concerts throughout the season and led educational sessions with high school students on the Orchestra’s January 2018 tour to Indiana and Illinois. This summer, she conducted the Orchestra’s annual Symphony for the Cities concerts (July 9 to 15)—which featured free outdoor performances in Minneapolis, Plymouth, Winona, and Hudson, Wisconsin—and led the ensemble’s first full-orchestra Sensory-Friendly Family concert on July 14 at Orchestra Hall.

“Working with the Minnesota Orchestra this season has been a dream come true,” said Fujimoto. “I am truly grateful for the opportunity to continue absorbing the sounds of this Orchestra and to continue learning from the mentorship of Music Director Osmo Vänskä.”

The Minnesota Orchestra’s assistant and associate conductor roles offer a wide variety of conducting opportunities within the organization. Additionally, these conductors serve as a link to the community, participating in engagement activities, school visits and collaborations with other Minnesota arts and cultural institutions.

“Akiko has been a welcome addition to our conducting staff,” said Director of Artistic Planning Kari Marshall. “She has shown great commitment to the Orchestra’s education initiatives at Orchestra Hall, on tour and through our high school Symphonic Adventures program, and she has developed a strong working relationship with musicians and staff throughout her first season with the Orchestra. We look forward to continuing these relationships as she steps into the associate conductor role.”

About Akiko Fujimoto

Akiko Fujimoto joined the Minnesota Orchestra in September 2017 as assistant conductor after serving five and a half seasons as the associate conductor of the San Antonio Symphony, where she conducted classical, pops, education and baroque concerts as well as ballet. As a guest conductor, she has performed with the Houston Symphony, Corpus Christi Symphony Orchestra, Round Rock Symphony Orchestra and Fort Wayne Philharmonic. Additionally, she has conducted Canada’s National Arts Centre Orchestra as a participant in the Young Conductors Program and the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra at the St. Magnus Festival. Prior to arriving in Texas, she served as the conducting associate for the Virginia Symphony Orchestra.

Fujimoto has extensive experiences working with young musicians, starting at Harvard University where she directed the Mozart Society Orchestra and at Stanford University, with her leadership of the Stanford Symphony Orchestra. In Virginia, she held the positions of Director of Orchestras at the College of William & Mary and Music Director of the Williamsburg Youth Orchestras. Born in Japan, Fujimoto moved to the United States at age 14 and attended Stanford University where she studied music and psychology. She holds master’s degrees in choral and orchestral conducting from Boston University and the Eastman School of Music.


Harmonia Ubuntu

Bongani Ndodana-Breen

Born: August 1975, Queenstown, South Africa; now living in Cape Town, South Africa

Harmonia Ubuntu

Premiering: July 21, 2018

In geographic terms, Minnesota and South Africa are separated by some 9,000 miles. Musically speaking, though, they’ve rarely been closer than this summer, as the Minnesota Orchestra presents a Sommerfest celebration of South Africa’s most famous statesman, the late Nelson Mandela, on the centenary of his birth; collaborates with South African soloists, ensembles and composers; and tours Mandela’s home country in the first-ever visit there by a professional U.S. orchestra. Central to this “Music for Mandela” project is the world premiere of Harmonia Ubuntu by Bongani Ndodana-Breen, one of today’s leading South African composers. The new work honors Mandela and the ideals he stood for, such as peace, freedom, reconciliation and ubuntu—a Nguni Bantu term which Ndodana-Breen explains is “the knowledge that one’s humanity is tied to the humanity of others or humanity towards others.”

New orchestral works are often funded by ensembles or individuals, but Ndodana-Breen’s Harmonia Ubuntu was commissioned for the Minnesota Orchestra’s South Africa tour by a different sort of musical organization, the international touring company Classical Movements, through its Eric Daniel Helms New Music Program. After proposing the commission last year, Classical Movements—which is managing the South Africa tour—gave the Orchestra a list of recommended South African composers.

Ndodana-Breen’s music stood out to Music Director Osmo Vänskä, and collaborative discussions ensued over how the new piece could best connect with the Mandela celebration. The incorporation of Mandela’s own words appealed to all parties, but rather than following the model of a work such as Copland’s Lincoln Portrait that employs spoken narration, Ndodana-Breen elected to have Mandela’s words sung by a soprano—an artistic choice which allows the listener to hear those words in a wholly new way.

The premiere of Harmonia Ubuntu marks only the start of the work’s international journey. Next month the Orchestra will perform it during all five stops on the South Africa tour: Cape Town, Durban, Pretoria, Soweto and Johannesburg.

about the composer

Dr. Bongani Ndodana-Breen has written a number of works which relate to or are inspired by his country’s struggle against apartheid and for liberation. One of his most acclaimed is Winnie, The Opera, based on the life of Winnie Mandela, who was married to Nelson Mandela for more than three decades and was a fellow leading figure of the anti-apartheid movement. (Winnie Mandela herself attended the opera’s premiere in April 2011.) His other recent major operatic and orchestral works include Three Orchestral Songs on poems by Ingrid Jonker, the oratorio Credo, which is based on South Africa’s historic Freedom Charter with libretto by Brent Meersman; Mzilikazi: Emhlabeni, a sinfonia concertante for piano and orchestra; and the short opera Hani.

Ndodana-Breen’s orchestral works have been performed around the world by ensembles including the Indianapolis Chamber Orchestra, Vancouver Opera Orchestra, Symphony Nova Scotia, Hong Kong Chinese Orchestra, Belgian National Orchestra, Kwa Zulu-Natal Philharmonic, Johannesburg Festival Orchestra, Johannesburg Philharmonic and Cape Town Philharmonic. In addition to his symphonic and opera writing, he has composed a wide range of choral, small ensemble, chamber and solo music.

Commissions have come from institutions such as London’s Wigmore Hall, the Vancouver Recital Society, Madame Walker Theatre in Indianapolis, the Hong Kong Arts Festival, Luminato Festival Toronto and the Haydn Festival in Eisenstadt. Among the many honors conferred on him are the Standard Bank Young Artist Award in 1998 and recognition as one of Mail & Guardian’s 200 Young South Africans in 2011. From 1999 to 2007 he directed the Canadian new music organization Ensemble Noir, which he led on tours to Ghana, Nigeria and South Africa.

The English text sung by soprano in Harmonia Ubuntu is a composite of phrases from writings and speeches of Nelson Mandela, the Nobel Peace Prize-winning leader, philanthropist and human rights advocate whose centenary (officially July 18, 2018) is being celebrated worldwide this year. Mandela’s extraordinary life experience—including 27 years as a political prisoner for his opposition to the apartheid regime, followed by his election to the presidency of a government that pursued a “truth and reconciliation” model of honest accountability and healing—lends great moral authority to his words. The particular lines Ndodana-Breen has chosen, the composer explains, “reinforce our common humanity and inspire courage over adversity....[Mandela’s] message is one of reconciliation, forgiveness, freedom and justice and love for our fellow man. More importantly, we are reminded that it takes courage to pursue these ideals.” Ndodana-Breen’s notes on Harmonia Ubuntu follow.

remarks from the composer

“Nelson Mandela was far more than a statesman, but an exemplar of the African values that underpin “ubuntu”—the knowledge that one’s humanity is tied to the humanity of others or humanity towards others. The harmony referenced in the title has the obvious musical connotations, and it can be argued that ‘ubuntu’ is a form of harmony in the context of how we relate with fellow human beings. Ubuntu is the Nguni Bantu philosophy that underpins Mandela’s writings and his beliefs (also made famous by Archbishop Desmond Tutu). Finally, ‘Harmonia,’ from Greco-Roman antiquity, is rationalized as closely allied to Aphrodite Pandemos, the love that unites all people, the personification of order and civic unity, corresponding to the Roman goddess Concordia. The music itself (in terms of the musical language emphasis tonality and African cyclic rhythms) reinforces this idea of ‘harmony.’

“The text of Harmonia Ubuntu is a composite of phrases from writings and speeches by Mandela that reinforce our common humanity and inspire courage over adversity. The sung text rises above the rancour we often witness in the world, a reminder of the great humanitarian ideals Mandela stood for and why he was an inspiration to us all. His message is one of reconciliation, forgiveness, freedom and justice and love for our fellow man. More importantly, we are reminded that it takes courage to pursue these ideals.

Harmonia Ubuntu begins with an introductory figure in the lower strings. In the culture of the Xhosa of the Eastern Cape of South Africa, this figure is often termed ‘ukuhlabela’—a short musical introduction by a lead singer before everyone else joins in. This is a common trait in music from various traditions in Africa where the leader starts with a teasing ‘short start’—the leader sings or plays his opening introduction upon which everyone respond with their answer. The answer in Harmonia Ubuntu is a fanfare figure that makes three appearances in the piece, heralding the beginning and roughly the middle and end sections. Given that this work focusses on Nelson Mandela (and his Centennial), it can also be said that the fanfare alludes to the ‘statesman’ side of Mandela, South Africa’s first black president, coupled with the fact that he is regarded as a traditional prince of the Thembu people (who are Xhosa speakers). His father was Chief Mphakanyiswa Gadla Mandela, principal counsellor to then Acting King of the Thembu, Jongintaba Dalindyebo.

“The musical ideas that frame this work are largely derived from the musical universe of Southern Africa. For example, the musical language is influenced by modes which are often associated with the Xhosa hexatonic scale. This is a six note scale that comes from the overtones created by musical bows (mrhube, uhadi) used over centuries by the Xhosa people. Aspects of the interlocking patterns in Harmonia Ubuntu looked beyond South Africa’s political borders, to the traditional mbira (African thumb piano) an instrument prevalent among the Shona people of what is now Zimbabwe. An aspect of mbira music alluded to here is not only in the constructing of a musical theme but the dynamic between a ‘kushaura’ (lead part) and ‘kutsinhira’ (following part)—a curious musical architecture where themes interact a note apart. This rhythmic counterpoint lends the music a trance-like and also a dance-like quality. The Shona mapira ceremonies are where the people ask ancestral spirits for guidance and intercession, in a trance-like state. There is a section in the music when the soprano alludes to this by singing words that do not have a lexicographical meaning but are certainly part of a deeply rooted (and felt) ancient Xhosa vocabulary. Music in African society is not an abstraction, it is informed by sophisticated aesthetic principles.

“The ‘Western’ compositional approach (see: Chernoff, J. M. The Rhythmic Medium in African Music. New Literary History, vol. 22, no. 4, 1991, p. 1096) ‘tends to rely on a single metric pulse unified on the downbeat: rhythmic movement is generally straightforward and is often articulated as an attribute.’

“In the context of traditional African music (not influenced by the hymnody of Christian missionaries) the stylistic preference is for responsive rhythmical interaction (heterophony is uninteresting to the ear in traditional African music). Also from a movement (dance) point of view this would lack flair. It is not uncommon in certain types of African music that the pulse of one performer (or group of performers) falls exactly in the middle of the pulse of another’s. Chernoff characterises these traits as tendencies ‘toward multiple rhythmic lines defined with reference to one another: frequently, the rhythms have different starting points and different timing.’

“Also, repetition forms a crucial aspect in the architecture of this piece. Repetition unveils dimensions of the music for the performer and listener that Gerhard Kubik (Kubik, G. Theory of African Music Vol. 1 University of Chicago Press 2010. p. 78) observed in his study of Kiganda and Kisoga xylophone music: ‘To make all the inner dimensions of these musical picture puzzles gradually visible to oneself the total pattern must be repeated again and again. Only then is it possible to follow the conflicting inherent lines. If there were no repetitions, if the Baganda musicians had tried the kind of horizontal development of their art found in European classical music, there would be no chance for listeners and performers to appreciate this music in its highly developed vertical dimension.’”

a note on instrumentation

Harmonia Ubuntu is scored primarily for standard orchestral instruments, but Ndodana-Breen adds two percussion instruments of African origin: the Wasembe rattle, which is played with quick downward motions, causing the gourd slices to move up and down the connector stick—and the djembe, a rope-tuned, skin-covered drum shaped like a goblet and played with the bare hands.

Program note by Carl Schroeder.

Harmonia Ubuntu: in the words of Nelson Mandela

I learned that courage was not the absence of fear, but the triumph over it. The brave man is not he who does not feel afraid, but he who conquers that fear.

For to be free is not to cast off one’s chains, but to live in a way that enhances the freedom of others.

If you want to make peace with your enemy, you have to work with them. Then he becomes your partner.

In the end, reconciliation is a spiritual process. It requires more than just words. It has to happen in the hearts and minds of people.

I learned that courage was not the absence of fear, but the triumph over it.

We understand it still that there is no easy road to freedom. We know it well, that none of us acting alone can achieve success. We must therefore act together as a united people for reconciliation, the birth of a new world.

Let there be justice for all. Let there be peace for all. Let there be work, bread, water and salt for all.

There is nothing like returning to a place that remains unchanged to find the ways you yourself have changed.

After climbing a great hill, one only finds that there are many more hills to climb.

The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.

I learned that courage was not the absence of fear, but the triumph over it.

From the writings and speeches of Nelson Mandela.

Q&A with Associate Concertmaster Roger Frisch

Associate Concertmaster Roger Frisch's retirement at the end of August 2018 marks the end of a memorable 44-year career. Congratulations, Roger!

Minnesota Orchestra musician since: 1974
Position: Associate Concertmaster
Hometown: Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Education: Cincinnati Conservatory of Music, Indiana University School of Music

How did you come to spend 44 years with the Minnesota Orchestra?
I got this job through my first audition, as I was finishing up my master’s at Indiana University, and I’ve been here ever since. At the time I joined, I was—as I like to say—Principal Last Chair Violin. Everyone had permanent seats then; it’s a more recent development that our string section players rotate. I moved to Associate Concertmaster 35 years ago and during that time I have also served as guest concertmaster with a number of orchestras, but I’ve never wanted to leave this orchestra. Minnesota is a great place to raise a family. Considering all of the playing my wife Michele (Principal Flute with Minnesota Opera) and I have been able to do here, and—maybe most importantly—the close, supportive, family-like personality of this Orchestra, this was the ideal place to put down roots.

Roger, far right, with other Minnesota Orchestra musicians who are Indiana University alumni, onstage at Indiana University, January 2018

What were your first concerts like?
I started in the summer of 1974, right before Orchestra Hall first opened. The Orchestra was done performing regularly at Northrop and we did almost all of our summer concerts that year outside. I’d never been exposed to the Minnesota mosquito, but in my first few months I think I built up an immunity to them! My first regular season concert was the grand opening of Orchestra Hall in October 1974, with Stanislaw Skrowaczewski conducting.

What are your most memorable concerts with the Minnesota Orchestra?
There was a period when Klaus Tennstedt was our Principal Guest Conductor. I remember those performances as exciting, even dazzling. There was something about the collective personality of this orchestra at the time that matched his intensity so well. Early on during my time here, I was fortunate to work with Aaron Copland, Arthur Rubinstein and Nathan Milstein. I will never forget those concerts and what those great artists brought to their performances! Playing the violin solo from the movie Schindler’s List with the beloved composer John Williams on the conductor’s podium was also very meaningful to me.

Roger and Concertmaster Erin Keefe walking on the field for a Vikings halftime performance at U.S. Bank Stadium in September 2016.

Who in the Orchestra has been particularly inspiring to you?
The principal oboist when I joined in 1974 was Rhadames Angelucci, who also played with the Orchestra for 44 years. The guy just loved music. During my first few years in the Orchestra, I would just watch and listen to him; it was like a master class every rehearsal.

What do you predict for the Minnesota Orchestra’s future?
When I got this job, I was studying with the legendary violinist Josef Gingold, who told me that the overall level of orchestral playing after four decades of his career, in the NBC and Cleveland Orchestras, was so much higher than when he first started. I could say those exact words today. It’s hard to imagine that things can get any better than they are now, but I know they will.

Are you excited to end your Minnesota Orchestra career on tour?
Yes! We have been on some incredible tours during my tenure. It was so special that we were able to go to Cuba in 2015, and now we’re going to South Africa. Experiencing different cultures has been a passion for Michele and me, but we’ve never been to Africa and it has been on my bucket list for a very long time.

Roger, center, on the Minnesota Orchestra's historic tour to Cuba in 2015

What does retirement hold for you?
I’ll certainly continue to teach and play, but there are so many other things I want to explore that go beyond that. Michele and I love to travel and we have a two-month visit to Provence, France, planned for summer 2019, as well as ministry concerts in Kiev. Also, there is a reason my kids are all in business professions. I love dealing with the business angle of things and I want to explore that more. 

How would you sum up your long tenure?
It boils down to this: I feel remarkably fortunate to have lived out my dream of playing in a top orchestra. I have loved this career from beginning to end.

 Read more about Roger Frisch >>

A Sensory-Friendly Concert For All

The Minnesota Orchestra invites you to mark your calendar and spread the word about the Family Concert on the afternoon of Saturday, July 14. The concert, which features music by Leonard Bernstein, Igor Stravinsky, John Williams and other favorite composers, will be the Orchestra’s first full-ensemble Sensory-Friendly Concert.

If you’re wondering what a SensoryFriendly Concert is, the short answer is: it’s a concert where all are welcome, whether you’ve come to many concerts before, or are entering Orchestra Hall for the first time. Sensory-Friendly Concerts are designed for all audiences, including individuals on the autism spectrum and those with sensory sensitivities. Small-ensemble SensoryFriendly Concerts in the Target Atrium have been so well-received in recent seasons that the Orchestra is extending the experience to the July 14 full-Orchestra concert as well as Family Concerts throughout the 2018–19 season. The musical experience onstage at the July 14 concert follows the typical Family Concert format, but in a relaxed environment where audience members are welcome to be who they are and enjoy music with family and friends.

“One of the greatest things about music is that everyone responds to it in ways that are unique to who they are,” says Assistant Conductor Akiko Fujimoto. “I am thrilled to conduct our first full-Orchestra Sensory-Friendly program, and to welcome those who might not have yet had the opportunity to hear live orchestral music in a concert hall.”

Audiences are invited to come early on July 14 for pre-concert activities, including opportunities to try orchestral instruments, engage in creative movement, participate in collaborative art-making and meet Orchestra musicians. Accessibility features for this concert include ASL interpretation, assisted listening devices, open captioning, and large print and Braille programs. Accessible seating is available for all concerts. For full program and ticket details, as well as pre-visit stories, tip sheets, accessibility information and other specifics, visit

Sensory-Friendly concerts are sponsored by PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.

Celebrating Kevin Smith

When Kevin Smith joined the Minnesota Orchestra as interim President and CEO in July 2014, the Orchestra was emerging from a 16-month lockout, with questions lingering about its ability to raise donations, sell subscriptions and re-establish relationships.

“There was a significant lack of trust throughout the organization,” Smith recalls. “We focused on building back trusting relationships, and that was the foundation for everything that came next.”

What followed was a remarkable resurgence of the Orchestra, both at home and abroad. Under Smith’s leadership, the Orchestra has balanced its budget for the last three consecutive years; grown its concert attendance by 12% and its earned revenue by almost 25% over the last four years; increased its number of donors by 5% in the same time period; and established a collaborative “Minnesota Model” approach to governance that is noteworthy in the industry.

Perhaps no project has more exemplified Smith’s tenure than the Orchestra’s 2015 tour to Cuba. After conceiving the idea in December 2014—right after relations between the two countries began to thaw—Smith galvanized the Orchestra team to plan and pull off the historic visit in six short months, raising funds and managing daunting logistics to bring two cultures together through music. The Orchestra’s current Music for Mandela project, including an August tour to South Africa, bears the same audacious hallmarks.

After that tour, Smith re-enters retirement but his legacy will go down in Orchestra history—as a creative leader who spent four exceptional years with the Minnesota Orchestra, just when it needed him the most. The community is invited to attend a reception and complimentary champagne toast in the Orchestra Hall lobby following the August 1 performance to celebrate Smith and the achievements of his tenure.

A Tribute to President and CEO Kevin Smith

We can think of no better way to salute Kevin’s legacy than to dedicate support in his honor and assure that the Orchestra balances its budget for the fourth consecutive year under his leadership. Join the musicians and staff in honoring him today.

Give today >>

Happy Fourth! A Classical Music Playlist

Happy Fourth!

Are you looking to add a classical music spark to your 4th of July BBQ? We've pulled together some of our favorite pieces for you and your friends and family to enjoy!

A Life with Music

By Dr. David Hilden

“That’s a pretty heavy responsibility, Dad. I’m only 12.”

So said our son, Alex, when I informed him that when I am dying at some distant future time I want him to play a recording of the second movement from Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony. Even if I am only partially conscious, maybe especially if I am only partially conscious, I want that five-note rhythmic motive to carry me off to wherever one goes at that moment. I’m not joking around here.

A decade later, Alex called me from his Oberlin College dorm room to happily inform me that “They were singing your song!” Singing? What song? Apparently there was an a cappella group singing my favorite Beethoven movement. What a good kid for remembering my wishes. I never did hear that vocal arrangement and I’m not sure what old Ludwig would have thought of people singing the violin part, but there you go.

My fondness for Beethoven goes back a few more years…

While I was in high school in south Minneapolis, there was a hand-painted sign on the cafeteria wall that said “Go to Prom. If The Boss were here, he’d go.” Thus began my lifelong obsession with Bruce Springsteen. My friends and I thought we were oh-so-cool going around with our Boss T-shirts. We also thought our ability to quote lyrics from The Who was super retro and a bit subversive. It’s fair to say that the Minneapolis Public Schools were not exactly a bastion of orchestral music back in 1980.

So it was perhaps a bit strange that it was during high school when I also discovered Ludwig van Beethoven. Somehow there was a guy in our little friend group who had the complete Beethoven set with Herbert von Karajan conducting the Berlin Philharmonic. These awesome performances undoubtedly lost a bit of their awesomeness after we had dubbed them from scratchy vinyl records to cassette tapes. I remember road trips listening to bad recordings of the Ninth Symphony on the car cassette and on our Walkman players―of course it had to be the Ninth―and I was blown away.

I marveled at the little tug-of-war between the sections in the opening of the fourth movement when Beethoven teased us with bits of each preceding movement. My heart raced as the strings frenetically played while the full chorus sang. I wondered who Elysium’s daughter was. I held my breath for the looooong “vor Gott” of the chorus. It was glorious.

Still listening on homemade cassettes, I expanded beyond the Ninth and soon came to treasure all of Beethoven’s symphonies. I now know that as perfect as the Ninth is, it is really the Seventh Symphony that is the best piece of music ever written. It’s a fact, look it up. (Although “Born to Run” by The Boss may lay claim to that title as well, but that’s a topic for another time.)

Some years later, I had a new revelation while listening to my hometown Minnesota Orchestra playing Beethoven’s Fifth in concert at Orchestra Hall. Did anybody know that there is music being played at the end of the third movement? I sure didn’t. I guess I always thought there was just a long pause there, since my cheapo cassette recordings didn’t seem to have any audible music in that section! But I leaned forward in my seat as Osmo Vänskä coaxed out of the musicians the most exquisite pianissimo I had ever heard…only to roar into the finale. Sometime later, I had the chance to speak to Maestro Vänskä in an airport baggage claim (a big thrill for me), and I told him that what most moves me is when the Orchestra plays quietly. He talked about how he works to make that crisp but ever-so-delicate pianissimo sound. Brilliant.

Now, some decades after I first heard the Ninth on that car cassette player, I’ve expanded beyond Beethoven. I’ve come to know the awe of Verdi’s Requiem. Dies irae—my oh my. I marvel at the precision of Tony Ross and the rest of the cellos. I just love it when the bass section—led by women!—draws out those sonorous low notes with huge bow strokes. I just about cry at the horn solo in Tchaikovsky’s Fifth. I have learned that Mahler could write a symphony―wow could he ever write a symphony! And most of all I have come to view a violin concerto as one of the greatest achievements of humanity, and to listen to James Ehnes, Joshua Bell, Hilary Hahn or Erin Keefe with the Minnesota Orchestra is an experience of pure beauty.

So now I have my seat in Orchestra Hall, middle section, just a bit to the left of center (better for soloists!), not too close but not too far back. I go a dozen times a year as a treat to myself. I go by myself not because I don’t have friends―I actually do have a couple friends―but because it is a retreat of sorts for me. I have my routines. Like my secret parking spot in the Hilton underground ramp. I tip the reliably-present accordion player in the skyway on the way into Orchestra Hall. I plant myself in my seat, I read every word of the program notes; I learn a bit about the composers. Sometimes I dress up a bit; often I’m in jeans. Sometimes I close my eyes and sometimes I just watch the left hand of one of the string players and wonder how such intricate movements are possible.

But ultimately the result is always the same, for it is the music that matters. Once again Maestro Vänskä and the incredible musicians remind me of just how grand life can be.

And I’m ever so thankful for that.

Dr. David Hilden, who traveled with the Minnesota Orchestra on its 2016 European Festivals Tour as tour physician, is the Director of Hospital Medicine at Hennepin Healthcare and serves as Associate Professor of Medicine at the University of Minnesota Medical School. He can be heard on the weekly Healthy Matters radio program on WCCO Radio and he produces a blog at

Photos by Travis Anderson

“The Energy from the Orchestra was Palpable”

Roderick Cox remembers highlight moments of his Orchestra tenure (and we’ve got video!)

When Roderick Cox conducts two Symphony in 60 concerts on July 27 they will mark his final Orchestra Hall performances as the Minnesota Orchestra’s Associate Conductor.

In anticipation of that farewell, we asked him to reflect on his action-packed three-year tenure with the Minnesota Orchestra, during which he conducted dozens of student performances, an inaugural collaboration with Shiloh Temple on Minneapolis’ northside and a Tchaikovsky Fourth that went viral and was described by the Star Tribune as “a highly auspicious subscription concert debut.”

The recent recipient of the Sir George Solti Conducting Award—America’s most prestigious honor bestowed on young conductors—Cox will focus on high-profile guest conducting engagements during the 2018-19 season.  Following the Orchestra’s August tour to South Africa, where he’ll lead rehearsals and a performance with the South African National Youth Orchestra, he will embark on a year that features debuts with the Los Angeles Philharmonic and Houston Grand Opera.

Please join the Orchestra on July 27 to cheer Roderick on to his next musical chapter and, for now, enjoy these video memories from Roderick on the past three seasons.

“I remember the children being so excited to participate in this performance with the Orchestra. It truly felt like a powerful moment in which we could all come together and share in the power and magic of great music.” 


"The climax of Rachmaninoff's Symphonic Dances is simply brilliant. I remember trying to cautiously push and prod the Orchestra to pump up the energy level one decimal at a time, leading to the final note. There is a great deal of rhythmic complexity in this part of the piece in which the conductor must stay centered and grounded to keep this massive train (the orchestra) firmly on its tracks. Conducting this piece with the Minnesota Orchestra will remain one of my favorite highlights from my time as associate conductor"


"It is sometimes scary doing a piece for the first time, and this definitely was one of those moments. It is a high energy piece with a great deal of tricky moments. I remember having to focus incredibly hard on navigating all the corners of this work while also delivering a high-energy performance."

"The energy from the Orchestra was palpable, you could feel it through the floor on stage. At the time, it was the biggest concert of my career, and here I was standing in front of this Orchestra leading the piece that inspired me to make the critical decision to become a professional conductor many years ago. I guess you can say that I had come full circle by this moment and was enjoying every bit of it. Tchaikovsky's Fourth Symphony will always hold a special place in my heart."

“It was a huge snow storm the day of the concert and I was afraid no one would show up to hear us perform. We had worked so hard planning this long overdue trip to North Minneapolis to play for a part of our community that is often neglected. The surprise came when I walked into the church and it was full of people, and I could sense a buzz in the air. I could see in the audience young black boys who were intentionally seated on the first couple rows there to see me in performance. The community embraced the Minnesota Orchestra that day. I was told by a critic that our collaboration on Handel's “Hallelujah Chorus” from Messiah was the most powerful performance of the work he had ever heard."

Inside the Classics: Speaking Truth to Power

By Sam Bergman, viola and host of Inside the Classics

When conductor Sarah Hicks and I set out to create an entire concert of protest music for the Minnesota Orchestra, the first challenge we ran into was that we would never be able to come close to including all the music that deserves inclusion on such a program. Most political music, of course, isn’t written for a full symphony orchestra – much of it is created by people struggling under the thumb of oppression, with little hope that their work will ever gain wider recognition. This is music born not of a desire for applause, but of a bone-deep need for amplification, recognition and hope.

What we are highlighting in our July 28 Inside the Classics concert, Speaking Truth to Power, is a strange corner of the universe of political music – fully realized symphonic works composed by people of relative privilege and comfort, as an effort to highlight the struggles of those less fortunate. They’re wonderful works of art, these pieces, and we’re immensely proud to be bringing them to the stage of Orchestra Hall. But there is so much more to listen to, and this playlist is intended as a small sampler to get you started down the road. Some of the music here is “Classical”; much of it is not. What these works all have in common, though, is a desire to promote justice; to throw light into the darkest corners of humanity’s all-too-regular inhumanity; and to lift the human spirit in such a way as to inspire us to do better.

Come Out by Steve Reich

“I had to, like, open the bruise up, and let some of the bruise blood come out to show them.” With these harrowing words, spoken on tape by a young black man beaten by New York police in 1964 and subsequently jailed for nine years, composer Steve Reich utilized then-new tape looping technology to create a work of art highlighting injustice and brutality in a way that felt like a gut punch to all who heard it. Reich was an avant-gardeist at the time; today, he is celebrated as one of the most influential composers of the last half-century. In 2016, Pitchfork published an outstanding essay celebrating the 50th anniversary of the premiere of Come Out. Read it here:

Paul Robeson: Here I Stand

Most of this playlist consists of individual songs and other musical works. This, however, is a full-scale documentary film released in 1999 about one of the greatest musicians and activists of the 20th century. Singer-actor Paul Robeson more or less gave up his career for his beliefs, which centered on the idea that black Americans were being systematically oppressed by a white majority that expected thanks for ending slavery while erecting new walls of oppression and brutality at every turn. He was also a dynamic labor activist in an era when the labor movement itself was rife with racism. Through it all, his rumbling, captivating bass voice was never silenced, and generations of young Americans (myself included) were raised on his songs, which became a gateway to his moral activism.

Manafiesto by Victor Jara

I first learned of Victor Jara through a song by the American folksinger Arlo Guthrie, and I vividly remember my eyes going wide when I heard the verse of that song in which Guthrie listed out the specific tortures that Augusto Pinochet’s government thugs subjected Jara to before shooting him dead in 1973 as an example to others who would dare stand up to the Chilean dictator’s brutal regime. Guthrie described Jara’s life as “like a shooting star… his hands were tender; his hands were strong.” Tenderness and strength are both audible in Manafiesto, Jara’s powerful tribute to musical activism. In the penultimate verse, he sings (in Spanish, of course) “A song has meaning when it beats in the veins of a man who will die singing, truthfully singing his songs.” Jara would die in just such a manner, but his legacy was beyond the reach of even the terrifying Pinochet.

Adrian by Mason Jennings

Inspired by Toni Morrison’s novel Beloved, this song by Minneapolis singer-songwriter Mason Jennings is somehow both harrowing and sweet. It tells the tale of a black man who, about to be lynched, somehow still finds the internal strength of character and godly spirit of forgiveness to tell his son to not give in to rage, but instead to carry his memory like a torch for others to follow. “As they set my last breath free / Turn your eyes but don’t fail to see / The love you feel inside your skin / We don’t fear death, my Adrian.”

Strange Fruit by Billie Holiday

And here is another view of the American lynching story, told through the unmistakable voice of one of the country’s greatest ever singers, Billie Holiday. It can be easy to forget how brave it was for Holiday to begin performing this song in 1939, especially now that it’s been taken up by several subsequent generations of performers. The lyrics are stark and brutal and almost clinical in their description of the unspeakable violence committed against innocent African-Americans by white mobs that were allowed to overrule every shred of human decency on their way to establishing…what? Superiority? Fear? Hopelessness for the black underclass? Holiday lays the truth of the matter bare in this song that still shocks and silences us today, with its barest of instrumental accompaniment and its refusal to turn away from the truth of what we are capable of.

Survivor from Warsaw by Arnold Schönberg

We don’t think of Arnold Schönberg as a particularly emotional composer most of the time. The 12-tone system of composition that he pioneered is, if anything, often parodied as anti-emotional, a sort of mathematically obsessive black hole of music, from which no traditional tonality can escape. But Schönberg’s music was, in fact, an entirely understandable (and even restrained) response to the overwhelming darkness that descended across Europe in the first half of the 20th century, and he felt a great responsibility to guide the next generation of European musicians toward a new musical tradition that would overcome the sins of the past and (his) present. In Survivor from Warsaw, Schönberg sets to music the words of a Jewish survivor of the Nazi concentration camps, but the story is related entirely in spoken text, a profoundly unusual and attention-grabbing decision for the time. The harrowing piece ends with the choir singing the Shema Yisrael, as if to say that no amount of hate can truly erase our basic humanity.

Brooklyn Train by Lucy Kaplansky

This may seem like a strange choice for this playlist, as it isn’t really a protest song, or even nakedly political in any specific way. But those of us old enough to have watched the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001 unfold will never forget the chaotic swirl of anger and fear that emerged in our country in the days and years that followed. The art that came out of 9/11 was similarly chaotic, even schizophrenic – country singer Toby Keith scored a major hit with a testosterone-fueled tirade, while composer John Adams was celebrated for his massive symphonic remembrance of the victims, On the Transmigration of Souls. Keith’s and Adams’ works will both be remembered as instructive historical documents of what America was like in that fraught and revenge-obsessed era, but for me, there will never be a more quietly perfect summation of what post-9/11 life in America was like for most of us than Lucy Kaplansky’s jewel box of a song describing a simple subway ride in the heart of the city that bore the brunt of the attacks on that sunny September morning. “Down below on iron veins / Rolling waves of subway trains / Rails of mercy cross the lives of men / Safe in the body of New York again.”

Just added for the 18-19 season

Live at Orchestra Hall

Hamilton Star Renée Elise Goldsberry

Sat Mar 9 | 8PM

Celebrate International Women’s Day with Renée Elise Goldsberry, Tony Award-winning vocalist from the original Broadway cast of Hamilton, as she performs original songs based on the poetry of Maya Angelou as well as a selection of Broadway standards.

Disney The Nutcracker and the Four Realms in Concert Live to Film

Sat Dec 22 | 2PM

All Clara (Mackenzie Foy) wants is a key – a one-of-a-kind key that will unlock a box that holds a priceless gift from her late mother. A golden thread, presented to her at godfather Drosselmeyer’s (Morgan Freeman) annual holiday party, leads her to the coveted key—which promptly disappears into a strange and mysterious parallel world. It’s there that Clara encounters a soldier named Phillip (Jayden Fowora-Knight), a gang of mice and the regents who preside over three Realms: Land of Snowflakes, Land of Flowers and Land of Sweets. Clara and Phillip must brave the ominous Fourth Realm, home to the tyrant Mother Ginger (Helen Mirren), to retrieve Clara’s key and hopefully return harmony to the unstable world.

Starring Keira Knightley as the Sugar Plum Fairy and featuring a special performance by Misty Copeland, Disney’s new holiday feature film “The Nutcracker and the Four Realms” is directed by Lasse Hallström and inspired by E.T.A. Hoffmann’s classic tale. 

Create your own series and secure your tickets today!

Create Your 2018-19 Series Now


Guest blogger Mandy Meisner waited more than 20 years to hear her teenage idol in person.

As an arts high school student in the 1990s, I had some unconventional idols. Others my age may have been swooning over Kirk Cameron and New Kids on the Block, but my music classmates and I had pictures of Joshua Bell on our walls. My best friend Katie and I would sigh over him in our dorm rooms, listen to him on the radio and obsess over his documentaries. We were his biggest fans.

It seems hard to believe that despite my devotion, it took another 25 years for me to finally hear him perform live last month with the Minnesota Orchestra. Here’s how the evening played out.

I arrive at Orchestra Hall for a rare Monday night concert, excited beyond belief. The energy is palpable, even in the lobby. After taking my seat, I think about Katie and the countless hours she spent practicing with her long fingers dancing over her viola, making etudes sound like a private concert.  I know how much she would have loved listening to tonight’s concert. I recognize a bit of our youthful exuberance in the young woman sitting next to me in the auditorium, fresh faced in glasses and a teal dress. Her name is Hannah, and this will be the first time she’s heard Joshua play. We bond over the exciting opportunity, and I later learn that she is a violin student of Minnesota Orchestra musician Aaron Janse who will be attending Vanderbilt in next fall on a full scholarship studying Political Science.

Mandy (center) with Hannah Bruns (right), a violin student of Minnesota Orchestra musician Aaron Janse, with Hannah’s mother Victoria at left.

When Joshua walks on stage to play Wieniawski’s Concerto No. 2, he exudes an approachability and pleasantness. There remains an element of boyishness to him. Perhaps it’s his hair that still sways across his forehead. He closes his eyes in preparation and when he begins it is everything I hope my idol will produce. It is perfection. Starting out with an incredibly lush sound that arcs throughout the Hall, his music clings to us in gooey phrases.

His technique is brilliant, nimble and sparkling. There is a wisdom and heaviness to his playing. His body sways to the music naturally, unsensational but heartfelt. During his rests, he is still with closed eyes and disheveled hair. There are long stretches of time that I forget to take notes because I am so enthralled in the moment.

Joshua’s second piece, Sarasate’s Zigeunerweisen, starts out painfully beautiful, evolving into energetic motion. It is so full of passion, we think we will explode from the sheer emotion. His precision is remarkable and ends in a glorious statement. When he is done, we are all on our feet, exclaiming our love and appreciation.

There is more to the concert, but I take it in as a dreamy aftermath. I am completely spent from Joshua Bell and my teenage memories.

Days later, I see a comment on Facebook from my friend Katie, who now lives in New York. She asks how the concert was. I tell her how much I wish we could have listened to him together. And then I remember, it was live-streamed by the Orchestra!

I think I’ll send her the link.


Get the Inside Scoop on Orchestra Rehearsals

Assistant Conductor Akiko Fujimoto shares insider tips on what to watch for while attending a Minnesota Orchestra open rehearsal.
Donors of $100 or more are invited to attend two open rehearsals each year, and the next is on July 19 at 10:00 a.m. If you're not yet a donor at this level, consider giving online today!
Program Notes: Vänskä Conducts Mahler's Fourth

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Stephenson: Pillars

James Stephenson’s newly-composed Pillars, a concerto for low brass and orchestra, was built out of a unique combination of influences: the composer’s vivid memories of his friend, trombonist Bill Zehfuss; a particularly exciting Minnesota Orchestra performance of music by Ginastera; and Stephenson’s own experiences playing Mahler symphonies in professional orchestras.


Mahler: Symphony No. 4

Mahler’s sunny Fourth begins with a discourse on a simple violin tune and ends with a child’s view of heaven, delivered by soprano. A hint of darkness comes in the second movement, where death’s fiddle leads a beguiling waltz; the ensuing Adagio, a serene set of variations, is among the composer’s finest

Full program notes: 

James M. Stephenson

Born: February 4, 1969, Joliet, Illinois; currently residing in Chicago


Premiering: June 14, 2018

When nine people were massacred in June 2015 at the Emanuel AME Church in Charleston, South Carolina, James Stephenson was deeply affected. His artistic response was to compose a work for chamber orchestra titled there are no words. The piece has since been played in several countries, notably by young people, who have communicated to Stephenson how much the music moved them. “This is why I compose: to try to reach people where words can’t,” he says. “I’m gratified that victims of that awful shooting continue to be remembered through my music.”

memories of a close friend

Pillars is about a different kind of memory rooted in that same South Carolina city—that of a close friend: Bill Zehfuss, the longtime principal trombone of the Charleston Symphony, who died in 2014 at age 52. A group of Zehfuss’ friends pooled resources through a Kickstarter campaign and commissioned Stephenson to compose a low brass concerto in his memory.

Stephenson is well positioned to do so. A graduate of the New England Conservatory, he played trumpet in professional orchestras for 17 years before becoming a full-time composer, and has a deeply ingrained sense about what brass players do best. He has extensive experience writing for orchestra, wind ensemble, chorus, soloists and chamber ensembles. More to the point, he has composed some 30 instrumental concertos, one for nearly every standard orchestral instrument, and several that feature multiple brass instruments. He is sensitive to the challenges of writing multi-instrument concertos. “It’s a difficult task, because you want to feature each player individually, but also—in this case—highlight the low brass as a section,” he explains.

This commission was different from others he has received, not only because Bill Zehfuss was a personal friend, but also because Stephenson and Minnesota Orchestra principal trombone R. Douglas Wright (“Doug” to friends) go way back: they played in a brass quintet together at New England Conservatory. In part, Zehfuss and Wright gave the piece its title. “Bill was tall, and Doug is tall; that’s one reason for the name Pillars,” Stephenson explains. Another explanation for the title is its three-movement structure. “I knew that one movement of this piece would be solely dedicated to Bill,” says Stephenson. “That became the second movement, and I felt it needed surrounding ‘pillars.’ Those are the first and final movements.”

His most important reason for choosing the title, however, was the determination and commitment from so many individuals who wanted to honor Bill Zehfuss, enabling this piece to come to fruition. “The initiators of the project were Wilson Ochoa, horn player and now Boston Symphony librarian, tuba player Michael Grose and bass trombonist Dan Satterwhite—all friends of Bill Zehfuss, of course,” Stephenson explains. “The widespread funding support they spearheaded was truly inspirational. People from all backgrounds—ranging from non-musicians to the most distinguished professional players—contributed from all over the world so that this piece might get created. The respect and love they showed for Bill made me think of them as pillars of our community.”

the music: surprising and satisfying

andante. The concerto opens with a chorale-like passage that functions like a slow introduction. “Doug [Wright] really wanted to feature the low brass quartet sound in a chorale; that’s why it opens with that,” says Stephenson. “Then they all play in unison, which is another beautiful sonority—and something that might surprise an audience. For me, a piece is always about surprising and then satisfying an audience. Then repeat that!”

passacaglia. Stephenson’s central movement, the “Zehfuss” movement, is titled Passacaglia. On one level, it is a bow to tradition—the passacaglia is an ancient form—but Stephenson stresses that his is not a literal passacaglia; for example, the bass line is not always present. “It retained enough of the characteristics for me to feel that I could use the term. This movement is all about Bill, and it features orchestral ‘tears’ as the principal motive.” This second movement incorporates the low brass cadenza, accompanied by reduced strings.

spirito. Stephenson wrote the finale with a Latin groove. He explains his reasons: “The last time I saw Bill was when I conducted the Charleston Symphony in a program of all Latin music that featured the orchestra’s brass quintet as soloists. Bill was standing adjacent to the podium—next to me—virtually all night. We went out afterward to celebrate and had a great time. This finale seemed like a suitable tribute.

“The other reason was my last performance here in Orchestra Hall, when the Minnesota Orchestra premiered my Violin Concerto Tributes in 2012. They opened those concerts with some Ginastera, and knocked it out of the park! So that memory played a part in what I wrote as well.” He adds that the finale uses sleigh bells in its ‘blues-y’ part, a conscious nod to Mahler, whose Fourth Symphony—which follows Stephenson’s work on today’s program—also features sleigh bells. Stephenson’s walking bass and jazzy passages, which veer between “raunchy” (his description) and passionate, contribute to a rousing finale for this piece showcasing low brass.

learning from the masters

Stephenson acknowledges a debt to Mahler—and every other composer he’s ever heard, living or dead. “Playing in an orchestra for all those years, those composers whose music I performed on a weekly basis became my teachers,” he says. “I listened carefully to how my colleagues reacted as they rehearsed and performed—both liking and hating it—and how the audience responded and, most importantly, what I found most interesting about their harmony, orchestration, melodies, counterpoint—and the risks they took.” All these factors have pulled together in Stephenson’s world premiere this weekend, which showcases both the talented Minnesota Orchestra low brass section and Stephenson’s own unique understanding of these instruments and the orchestra. His personal connection to Bill Zehfuss, whose memory Pillars honors, is an added bonus.

Instrumentation: 2 solo trombones, solo bass trombone and solo tuba with orchestra comprising 2 flutes (1 doubling piccolo and alto flute), 2 oboes, English horn, 2 clarinets, bass clarinet, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, china cymbal, splash cymbal, 3 suspended cymbals, 2 bongo drums, cabasa, conga drum, hi-hat, kick drum, ratchet, sand blocks, shakers, slap stick, sleigh bells, tambourine, temple blocks, triangle, suspended triangle, wood block, crotales, glockenspiel, vibraphone, chimes, xylophone, marimba, harp and strings

Gustav Mahler

Born: July 7, 1860, Kalischt, Bohemia

Died: May 18, 1911, Vienna, Austria

Symphony No. 4 in G major

Premiered: November 25, 1901

If Mahler composed a Pastoral symphony analogous to Beethoven’s, then this is surely the one. Opening with sleigh bells and lyrical, warm melodies, Mahler’s Fourth is the most endearing of all his large orchestral works, successfully enveloping us in the sunlit world of children.

The Fourth Symphony is traditional in its overall layout: four movements arranged sonata-allegro, scherzo/trio, slow movement and finale (in this case a rondo). Thus the Fourth is, for most listeners, immediately more accessible than other Mahler symphonies. Its lighter scoring (with no low brass; the trombone and tuba soloists featured on this program’s previous work are done for the day), shorter duration, clarity of texture and predominantly sunny character have all contributed to make it one of Mahler’s most popular works. Musicologist Michael Kennedy calls it his “happiest, least spectre-ridden symphony.”

last of the Wunderhorn symphonies

Mahler began work on his Fourth Symphony during summer 1899 and completed it in August 1900. The piece thus conveniently spans the turn of the century, and in many ways it is a symbol of Mahler’s bi-directional stance: reflective of the traditions that preceded him, and looking forward to the changes that lay ahead.

After completing the Symphony No. 4, Mahler moved for several years to an exclusively instrumental idiom for his symphonies. But the Fourth is spiritually and textually linked to the world of the first three symphonies, particularly Nos. 2 and 3, both of which use voices. These earlier symphonies, including the Fourth, are generally grouped together as the Wunderhorn Symphonies, since they all in some way draw upon Mahler’s settings of texts from Des Knaben Wunderhorn (The Youth’s Magic Horn). This collection of anonymous German folk poetry was compiled by Achim von Arnim and Clemens Brentano in the early years of the 19th century. Goethe valued it highly, and the collection remained influential in Germany’s romantic nationalist movement.

In the case of the Fourth Symphony, the most obvious Wunderhorn movement is the finale, which features a soprano soloist. Mahler originally planned to incorporate the song “Das himmlische Leben” (The Heavenly Life) into his Third Symphony. Listeners who know Mahler’s music will note a strong bond—sometimes even identical snatches of music—between the themes of the Third and Fourth Symphonies. He had worked on “Das himmlische Leben” as early as 1892; however, he took a while to find the appropriate musical forum for his ideas. In a letter to Natalie Bauer-Lechner, he wrote:

“What I had in mind was extremely hard to achieve; the uniform blue of the sky being much more difficult to render than all its changing and contrasting hues. Well, that’s the general atmosphere of the piece. Occasionally, however, it darkens and becomes phantasmagorical and terrifying: not that the sky becomes overcast, for the sun continues to shine eternally, but that one suddenly takes fright; just as on the most beautiful day in a sunlit forest, one can be seized with terror or panic. Mysterious, intricate and sinister, the Scherzo will make your hair stand on end, but it will be followed by the Adagio, which puts everything right again and shows that no harm was intended.”

The fourth movement song, delivered by soprano soloist, is an expression of joy, heaven perceived through a child’s eyes. After the journey of the three preceding movements, it is both our destination and our reward. For a composer who insisted he was the antithesis of Richard Strauss and a proponent of absolute music, this is a highly programmatic work.

tough love: a “persecuted step-child”

Ironically, the Fourth Symphony was not well-liked during Mahler’s lifetime, and it took a long while to work its way into public affection. When it received its New York premiere in 1902, one critic wrote: “Strauss’s Heldenleben and Thus Spake Zarathustra are clear as crystal waters in comparison with Gustav Mahler’s Fourth Symphony.” In a 1903 letter to the German conductor Julius Buths, Mahler refers to it as “this persecuted step-child that has so far known so little joy in the world.” Perhaps that is the reason Mahler continued to revise this and other works for almost ten years. More than a century after Mahler began to work with the Wunderhorn poetry, his music shows us a tender, joyous side to his personality, a childlike viewpoint that believes in a heaven where angels bake bread, fish swim happily into the net, and St. Peter looks benevolently on.

of special note: the scordatura scherzo

According to Paul Bekker’s 1921 study, Mahler described the first two movements of the Fourth Symphony thus: “A dream excursion into the heavenly fields of Paradise, starting in the first movement with lively sleigh bells and leading through alternatively smiling and melancholy landscapes to Freund Hein (Death), who is to be taken in a friendly, legendary sense, as gathering his flock and leading it with his fiddle from this world to the next.”

Mahler marked his second movement “In gemächlicher Bewegung. Ohne Hast” (Moving easily, without haste). His subtitle was “Freund Hein spielt auf” (Friend Hein strikes up). “Friend Hein” is a colloquial German reference to an ominous folk character who appears as a friendly fiddle-playing itinerant, gathering followers whom he leads to the great beyond. In short, he symbolizes Death.

The fiddle in question is intentionally mistuned, a technique called scordatura. It results in a peculiar, otherworldly sonority and also makes it possible to play pitches not available with conventional tuning. In this case, the concertmaster tunes his instrument up a whole tone. Most concertmasters use two violins for Mahler’s Fourth, one tuned normally (with the open strings G/D/A/E), and the other tuned up a whole step (A/E/B/F-sharp). The idea with the scordatura violin is to approximate the sound of a country village fiddler.

Mahler wanted an eerie quality, according to his friend Natalie Bauer-Lechner, who published her Recollections of Gustav Mahler in 1923. She reported that, when he revised the Fourth Symphony, he altered the violin solo, rewriting the part in D minor instead of E minor. “This makes it screeching and rough sounding,” she wrote, “as if Death were fiddling away.” The mysterious scherzo is a fleeting shadow in this otherwise sunny work.

Instrumentation: solo soprano with orchestra comprising 4 flutes (2 doubling piccolo), 3 oboes (1 doubling English horn), 3 clarinets (1 doubling E-flat clarinet and 1 doubling bass clarinet), 3 bassoons (1 doubling contrabassoon), 4 horns, 3 trumpets, timpani, bass drum, cymbals, sleighbells, tamtam, triangle, glockenspiel, harp and strings.

Program notes by Laurie Shulman ©2018. First North American Serial Rights Only.

Program Notes: Beethoven and Berlioz

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Beethoven: Violin Concerto
Here is one of the most exalted concertos for any instrument, deeply lyrical, poetic and imaginative. The opening Allegro is built on deceptively simple ideas—a repeating five-beat pulse and scale patterns—while the Larghetto is sublime and hymn-like. The finale is rousing and rollicking, with a main theme that presages the “Ode to Joy.”


Berlioz: Symphonie fantastique

In what musicologist Michael Steinberg called “the most remarkable First Symphony ever written,” Berlioz breaks the rules and oversteps the boundaries, creating an exhilarating, one-of-a-kind journey: the story of an artist and his obsession with an ideal woman.

Full program notes: 

Ludwig van Beethoven

Born: December 16, 1770, Bonn, Germany

Died: March 26, 1827, Vienna, Austria

Concerto in D major for Violin and Orchestra, Opus 61

Premiered: December 23, 1806

In the spring of 1806 Beethoven finally found time for new projects. For the previous three years, his energies had been consumed by two huge works: the Eroica Symphony and the opera Fidelio. With the latter completed, the floodgates opened. Working at white heat over the rest of 1806, Beethoven composed the Fourth Piano Concerto, the Fourth Symphony, the Razumovsky Quartets and the Thirty-Two Variations in C minor for solo piano. He also accepted a commission from violinist Franz Clement for a concerto and, as was his habit with commissions, put off the work for as long as possible. One contemporary, unnamed, wrote that at the premiere, on December 23, 1806, Clement had to sight-read portions of the work from Beethoven’s manuscript.

regal and lyrical, not showy

The Violin Concerto is one of Beethoven’s most regal works, full of easy majesty and spacious in conception (the first movement, lasting 24 minutes, is about as long as the final movement of the Ninth Symphony). Several features give this music its majestic character. It unfolds with a relaxed nobility, due in part to its unusually lyrical nature. We do not normally think of Beethoven as a melodist, but in this concerto he makes full use of the violin’s lyric capabilities. Another reason lies in the concerto’s generally broad tempos: the first movement is marked Allegro, but Beethoven specifies ma non troppo, and even the finale is relaxed rather than brilliant. In fact, at no point in this concerto does Beethoven set out to dazzle his listeners: there are no passages here designed to leave an audience gasping, nor any that allow the soloist consciously to show off. This is an extremely difficult concerto, but a non-violinist might never know that, for the challenges of this noblest of violin concertos are at the service of the music itself.

the music: a surprising opening

allegro ma non troppo. The concerto has a remarkable beginning: Beethoven breaks the silence with five quiet timpani strokes. By itself, this is an extraordinary opening, but these five pulses also perform a variety of roles through the first movement—sometimes they function as accompaniment, sometimes as harsh contrast with the soloist, sometimes as a way of modulating to new keys. The movement is built on two ideas: the dignified chordal melody announced by the woodwinds immediately after the opening timpani strokes and a rising-and-falling second idea, also stated initially by the woodwinds. Beethoven delays the appearance of the soloist, and this long movement is based exclusively on the two main themes.

larghetto; rondo: allegro. The Larghetto, in G major, is a theme-and-variation movement. Muted strings present the theme, and the soloist embellishes that simple melody, which grows ornate as the movement proceeds. A brief cadenza leads directly into the finale, a rondo based on the sturdy rhythmic idea announced immediately by the violinist. But this is an unusual rondo: its various episodes begin to develop and take on lives of their own. One of these episodes, in G minor and marked dolce, is exceptionally haunting. After it is developed briefly, it vanishes, never to return. The movement drives to a huge climax, with the violin soaring high above the orchestra, and the music subsides and comes to its close when—almost as an afterthought, it seems—Beethoven turns the rondo theme into the graceful concluding gesture.

Instrumentation: solo violin with orchestra comprising flute, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Hector Berlioz

Born: December 11, 1803, La Côte-Saint André, Isère, France

Died: March 8, 1869, Paris, France

Symphonie fantastique, Opus 14

Premiered: December 5, 1830

No disrespect to Mahler or Shostakovich, but Symphonie fantastique is the most remarkable First Symphony ever written.

Berlioz composed it in 1830, when much that was new and forward-looking was in the air, particularly in the social, political and scientific spheres. The Parisians had torn up their cobblestones and gotten rid of a king who believed in Divine Right; the British parliament would soon enact the first in a series of reform bills designed to enfranchise the middle class; America experienced the Nat Turner revolts and the first effective moves towards abolition.

It would be surprising if music had not exploded as well. When the 1830s were over, Chopin had written his Etudes and Preludes, Schumann had done most of his important work for solo piano, and Liszt’s transcriptions and original compositions practically constituted a reinvention of the piano. Paganini vastly expanded the possibilities of the violin, and important technical advances were achieved in the design of wind instruments.

the “new music” of Berlioz

From today’s vantage point we can see fairly easily that the beginnings of a new music were to be found in two places where not every observer in 1830 would have thought to look: in the works of Beethoven and Bach. And the better we know the Symphonie fantastique, the more clearly we can sense in it the presence of Beethoven and of that classical tradition Beethoven brought to so remarkable a pass.

At the same time, however deeply he was in debt to Beethoven, Berlioz strove to write “new music.” He succeeded. The fantastique sounds and behaves like nothing ever heard before. It takes off on paths Beethoven could never have imagined; that it was written just three years after the death of Beethoven is a fact to stagger the historical imagination.

the composer in love

In 1827, at the Paris Odéon, Berlioz saw a performance of Hamlet by a company from London. It was a distinguished group, whose leading men were Edmund Kean and Charles Kemble, two of the most renowned actors on the English stage. Performing the younger female roles was Harriet Smithson, a 27-year-old actress with whom Berlioz fell instantly and wildly in love. He wrote to her repeatedly; he heard gossip about an affair between her and her manager. This hurt him, but it also provided enough distance to enable him to plan and to begin work on the symphony—whose subject was an artist “with a vivid imagination” who falls in love with his “ideal” woman, experiences hope and doubt, then an opium-induced dream in which he sees himself being executed for killing his beloved; after his death she appears to be “only a prostitute” taking part in an orgy at “a foul assembly of sorcerers and devils.”

The premiere took place on December 5, 1830. Two years later Berlioz presented a sharpened and improved version of his symphony, now with a sequel whose script was full of unmistakable allusions to his passion for Miss Smithson. She was in Paris again, and she was persuaded to attend Berlioz’ concert on December 9, 1832. They finally met, and on October 3, 1833, they were married. The whole business was a disaster. By the time they separated in 1844, Smithson was no longer performing, as an accident had put an end to her career. She died in 1854, an alcoholic and paralyzed; Berlioz supported her financially until her death.

a fantastic symphony

Berlioz wrote several programs for his autobiographical and in every way fantastic symphony. Excerpts from the note he published with the score in 1845 are indicated with quotation marks.

reveries – passions. A young musician, “the artist,” sees and falls hopelessly in love with a woman who embodies the charms of “the ideal being of whom he has dreamed.” In his mind she is linked to a musical thought, and both “the melodic image and its human model pursue him incessantly like a double idée fixe….The passage from this state of melancholic reverie, interrupted by a few fits of unmotivated joy, to one of delirious passion, with its movements of fury and jealousy, its return of tenderness, its tears, its religious consolation—all this is the subject of the first movement.”

The subtly shaped idée fixe is the melody that violins and flute play to an accompaniment of nervous interjections by the strings when the Allegro begins.

a ball. Whether the artist is engaged in festivities or contemplating nature, the “beloved image appears before him and troubles his soul.” The first three dozen measures paint for us the ballroom with its glitter and flicker, its swirling couples, the yards and yards of whispering silk. All this becomes gradually visible, like a new scene in the theater. This softly scintillating waltz is exquisitely scored.

in the country. The artist is calmed by the sound of shepherds piping, by “the quiet rustling of the trees gently disturbed by the wind,” but wondering if his beloved might be deceiving him, he feels a “mixture of hope and fear...ideas of happiness disturbed by black presentiments.” This scene speaks very much from a new sensibility, yet it is also here that we most feel the presence of Beethoven, particularly the Beethoven of the Fifth and Pastoral Symphonies. Berlioz’ piping shepherds are mutations of Beethoven’s nightingale, quail and cuckoo, but there is nothing in music before this, or since, like the pathos of the recapitulated conversation with one voice missing. As a picture of despairing loneliness it is without equal.

march to the scaffold. “Having become certain that his love goes unrecognized, the artist poisons himself with opium.” But rather than dying, he “dreams that he has killed the woman he loves, that he is condemned, led to the scaffold, and that he is witnessing his own execution.” In this stunning march, an instant knockout, Berlioz’ orchestral imagination—the hand-stopped horn sounds, the use of the bassoon quartet, the timpani writing—is astonishing in every way.

dream of the witches’ sabbath. The artist sees himself “in the midst of a frightful assembly of ghosts, sorcerers, monsters of every kind, all come together for his funeral.” The melody representing his beloved is now “no more than the tune of an ignoble dance, trivial and grotesque…she takes part in the devilish orgy…funeral knell, burlesque parody of the Dies irae…”

As we enter the final scene, with its trim thematic transformations, its bizarre sonorities—deep bells, squawking E-flat clarinet, the beating of violin and viola strings with the wooden stick of the bow, glissandos for wind instruments, violent alternations of ff with pp—its grotesque imagery, its wild and coruscating brilliance, we have left the Old World for good.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 oboes (1 doubling English horn), 2 clarinets (2 doubling E-flat clarinet), 4 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 2 cornets, 3 trombones, 2 tubas,  timpani, field drum, bass drum, cymbals, chimes, 2 harps and strings

Program note excerpted from the late Michael Steinberg’s The Symphony: A Listener’s Guide (Oxford University Press, 1995), used with permission.

Program Notes: Bernstein and Walton

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Bernstein: Fancy Free

In Bernstein’s best-known ballet, three sailors compete for female attention during a 24-hour shore leave in New York. Tension builds between the characters until the three dance variations—Galop, Waltz and Danzon—when, in the waning hours of their leave, the sailors all vie for the same woman.

Bernstein: Chichester Psalms

This choral masterpiece sets Hebrew text from three Biblical Psalms to chorus, orchestra (sans woodwinds) and a large percussion section that contributes compelling colors. Bernstein himself described the Psalms as “simple and modest” and “tonal and tuneful” in a poem he wrote about the work.


Walton: Belshazzar’s Feast

Walton’s rich and evocative oratorio combines two brass choirs with an oversized orchestra and double chorus, as well as a baritone soloist who takes on the voice of major characters at critical moments in a story that is at moments mysterious and chilling, exultant and brilliant.

Full program notes: 

Leonard Bernstein

Born: August 25, 1918, Lawrence, Massachusetts

Died: October 14, 1990, New York City

Fancy Free, complete ballet music

Premiered: April 18, 1944

Listeners trying to place Fancy Free in their mind’s ear will break into a big smile as soon as they hear the opening riff, for this is the predecessor music to the better-known On the Town. Fancy Free was Bernstein’s first complete stage work, a collaboration with dancer and choreographer Jerome Robbins. Bernstein was in only his mid-20s, but his career had begun to skyrocket.

The ballet, about three sailors on shore leave, was a conscious attempt to perk up morale during the war. Robbins wanted something specifically American and contemporary that would address the reality of wartime, and incorporate popular music and dance. Bernstein obliged, and conducted the ballet's premiere at the old Metropolitan Opera House on April 18, 1944. Robbins danced one of the three sailors’ roles. The ballet was a smash hit, receiving 163 performances its first year.

The scenario, attributed to both Robbins and Bernstein, follows:

“With the sound of a juke box, the curtain rises on a street corner with a lamp post, a side street bar, and New York skyscrapers pricked out with a crazy pattern of lights, making a dizzying background. Three sailors explode onto the stage; they are on shore leave in the city and on the prowl for girls. The tale of how they meet first one, then a second girl, and how they fight over them, lose them and in the end take off after still a third, is the story of the ballet.”

“theatre music at its best”

Fancy Free’s seven movements address the traditional tension in the battle of the sexes. Bernstein’s score successfully blends elements of jazz, folk music, blues and romance—even a fleeting 12-tone passage in the drunken fight scene. The ballet resonated because it dealt with a plausible contemporary situation, without romanticizing it. Joan Peyser has written: “His music is theatre music at its best. Never strained, sentimental, or phony, it is hard-edged in its urban sexuality....Aggression is at least one of the ingredients.”

The jazzy syncopations of the sailors’ entrance establish the live-for-the-moment atmosphere, where the pursuit of a good time is the prime objective. Bernstein’s brilliant use of jazz piano, trap-set percussion effects, and muted trumpets combine to evoke the bar. He portrays each of the three sailors in, respectively, the Galop, Waltz and Danzon Variations.

Recognizing Fancy Free’s theatrical potential, Bernstein and Robbins enlisted the assistance of Betty Comden and Adolf Green as librettists, to develop the ballet into a full-length Broadway musical. On the Town opened in December 1944, and was later made into a successful film starring Gene Kelly, Frank Sinatra, Vera Ellen and Ann Miller. Although Bernstein insisted that On the Town was not merely an expansion of Fancy Free, and that the two scores were entirely different, they are clearly related in spirit and style. In fact, anyone who knows and loves West Side Story may even hear the seeds of that brilliant score in this early ballet. The Cuban-inspired Danzon segment of the Three Dance Variations is almost a pre-echo of the Puerto Rican music in the later musical.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo (1 flute also doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, suspended cymbal, cowbell, triangle, woodblocks, piano and strings

Chichester Psalms

Premiered: July 15, 1965

The Chichester of Leonard Bernstein’s choral masterpiece Chichester Psalms is in west Sussex, near the southeast coast of England. A town of about 25,000, it has a beautiful cathedral with the only separate bell tower of any medieval church in the British Isles. Since the 1960s, the cathedral choirs of Chichester, Winchester and Salisbury have combined forces in a summer music festival.

For the inaugural Southern Cathedrals Festival in 1965, Walter Hussey, the Dean of Chichester Cathedral, contacted the American composer Leonard Bernstein to inquire whether he would accept a commission. Dean Hussey explained that space constraints and a modest budget would not permit a full symphony orchestra. In addition to the combined cathedral choirs, Bernstein would be limited to instrumental resources comprising strings, a brass consort, and possibly piano, organ and percussion. Hussey had written, “I think many of us would be very delighted if there was a hint of West Side Story about the music.” Bernstein accommodated with a score that is melodious, jazzy, and—in the spirit of its sacred text—profoundly human.

a Biblical choral masterpiece

A setting of three Biblical Psalms in Hebrew, Chichester Psalms is Bernstein’s most frequently-performed choral composition and is a beloved work in the Bernstein canon. Its exhilarating, mostly tonal themes beckon the listener into the musical web, persuading us that the comparatively unfamiliar sound of Hebrew tongue and the occasionally clangorous passages are absolutely right.

Always sensitive to language, Bernstein colors the Psalm texts with the instincts of a born musician who believes in the meaning of the texts. The first movement draws on Psalms 108 and 100, capitalizing on the fanfare implications of “Awake, O harp and lyre! I will awake the dawn.” The second movement shares the pastoral Psalm 23 (“The Lord is my shepherd”) with the bellicose opening of Psalm 2 (“Why do the nations conspire, and the peoples plot in vain?”), while the finale brings resolution (Psalm 131, “ I have calmed and quieted my soul”) and Psalm 133's message of faith, hope, and brotherly love.

The results are spectacular, in part because of the unusual scoring. Bernstein preferred an all-male chorus with boys’ voices for the soprano and alto parts; however, he condoned performance by a mixed chorus like the one spotlighted in today’s performance, the Minnesota Chorale. He would not budge, however, on the boy soprano for the second movement solo. The Adonai introducing the 23rd Psalm is a pinnacle of the 20th-century vocal/choral literature. Its strains will resonate in your mind’s ear long after this evening’s performance is over.

Listeners who know and love Bernstein’s stage works—from West Side Story to the quasi-operatic Candide—will recognize his style. There are good reasons for the similarity. In part, it resulted from a suggestion that came with the commission—the aforementioned desire for “a hint of West Side Story.” Vibrant rhythms and a splendid sense of the right sound attend this music. The orchestration is arresting. Foregoing woodwinds altogether, Bernstein relied on brass, strings, voices and especially percussion for his sonic colors. Balancing jaunty spirits with spirituality, he produced a masterpiece in Chichester Psalms.

a bright spot in a difficult year

The first performance of Chichester Psalms took place in New York on July 15, 1965, with the composer conducting the New York Philharmonic in an all-Bernstein concert. Immediately afterward, Bernstein and his family traveled to England, where he oversaw rehearsals for the second performance in Chichester at the Southern Cathedrals Festival on July 31. In a letter to his friend Helen Coates after the English première, Bernstein wrote:

“The Psalms went off well, in spite of a shockingly small amount of rehearsal. The choirs [Winchester, Salisbury and Chichester] were a delight! They had everything down pat, but the orchestra was swimming in the open sea. They simply didn’t know it. But somehow the glorious acoustics of Chichester Cathedral cushion everything so that even mistakes sound pretty.”

Bernstein remained fond of this work. It was a bright spot in a year that had otherwise proved frustrating. After six seasons as the New York Philharmonic’s music director, he had taken a sabbatical during the 1964-65 season in order to composer. He intended to complete a musical based on Thornton Wilder’s The Skin of Our Teeth. Plagued by a number of problems, that project foundered and was canceled, causing disappointment and angst to Bernstein and his collaborators. Ever the pragmatist, however, Bernstein recycled much of the music from the discarded musical into the Chichester Psalms.

Instrumentation: four-part mixed chorus and solo boy soprano with orchestra comprising 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, suspended cymbal, bongo drums, rasp, slapstick, tambourine, temple blocks, triangle, wood block, glockenspiel, chimes, xylophone, 2 harps and strings

William Walton

Born: March 29, 1902, Oldham, Lancashire, England

Died: March 8, 1983, Ischia, Italy

Belshazzar’s Feast

Premiered: October 8, 1931

In the Biblical Book of Daniel, Belshazzar, the last King of the Mesopotamian city of Babylon, gives a splendid feast. During the festivities, a mysterious hand inscribes a prophecy of the monarch’s doom on the wall of the banquet room. That same night, Belshazzar is slain. The incident has given rise to one of the most frequently used Biblical phrases in common conversation: “to see the handwriting on the wall.”

Belshazzar’s dissolute dinner party, and its context of Israelite captivity and eventual freedom, also caught the imagination of the English composer William Walton, who composed a mighty oratorio with the feast as its musical centerpiece. Belshazzar’s Feast is one of Walton’s greatest compositions and one of Britain’s 20th-century masterworks, on par with Elgar’s The Dream of Gerontius and Britten’s War Requiem.

a project grows in scope

Walton initially undertook the project in 1929 at the behest of conductor Edward Clark, director of music at the BBC and husband of the composer Elizabeth Lutyens. Under the BBC’s auspices, Clark commissioned three composers—Walton, Constant Lambert and Victor Hely-Hutchinson—to write a work suitable for radio broadcast. The commission stipulated that the performing forces be limited to small orchestra (no more than 15 players), small chorus and one soloist, so as to fit into a broadcast studio.

Then in his late 20s, Walton was not yet financially self-sufficient. For some years he had resided with the wealthy and cultured Sitwell siblings, Edith, Osbert and Sacheverell, in London and Italy. With manuscript paper packed, Walton took off in December 1929 for Venice, where he and Osbert Sitwell talked through possible topics for the commission. Sitwell suggested the Bible’s Writing on the Wall, and persuaded Walton of the inherent drama in the fall of Babylon and its suitability for the project.

Adapting text from the Book of Daniel, Revelations, and Psalms 137 (lamenting) and 81 (exulting), Osbert Sitwell devised a narrative in three principal parts: the prophecy of Isaiah and the lament of the Jews in captivity; the actual feast with its climactic moment of the handwriting on the wall; and the hymn praising the God of Jacob upon the Jews’ deliverance from their oppressors.

From Venice, Walton and Osbert Sitwell traveled to Amalfi, where the Sitwells customarily spent their winters. There Walton began composing. By the time he returned to England in May, 1930, his score, tentatively entitled Nebuchadnezzar, or the Writing on the Wall, had expanded to two soloists with small orchestra and small chorus. By September, it had grown further, now requiring a large orchestra and double chorus. The work, renamed Belshazzar’s Feast, had reached the point where it was impractical for radio broadcast performance, and Walton opted to submit another piece in fulfillment of the BBC commission. The coup de grâce to the giant score purportedly came as a result of an off-the-cuff remark from the conductor Thomas Beecham when Walton first showed him the score. Walton related the story to Peter Lewis of the London Daily Mail in a 1972 interview.

“This is a work,” roared Beecham in his best seigneurial manner, “which shall never be heard. Since it shall never be performed, I advise you to throw in all that you can. Throw in, let’s say, a couple of brass bands for good and useless measure!”

Walton did. He added two brass choirs, each comprising three trumpets, three trombones, and tuba, and placed them on either side of the conductor. Combined with an oversized orchestra and double chorus, the brass choirs brought the performing forces to a head count and stage arrangement nearly identical to that of the Berlioz Requiem. Pagan, outspoken and flamboyant, Belshazzar’s Feast proved Sir Thomas Beecham wrong at its Leeds Festival premiere on October 8, 1931, and has done so repeatedly since. Its enormous success catapulted Walton to the forefront of British music, and the work remains one of his crowning achievements.

a lament, deadly night and hymn of praise

The three principal parts of Belshazzar’s Feast unfold without pauses. After the opening prophecy, we hear the lament of the Israelites, culminating in their affirmative belief that Babylon will fall. The second part is the feast itself, during which we learn of Babylon’s riches and her plunder of the sacred vessels from the temple in Jerusalem. King Belshazzar’s entrance catalyzes paeans of praise to false gods, which grow progressively more frenzied until the interruption by the handwriting on the wall. After we learn that Belshazzar has been slain that very night, the oratorio concludes with a mighty hymn of praise to the God of Jacob.

Walton uses the baritone soloist in key places to provide transition and to advance the plot, as in the boastful description of Babylon’s riches that launches the second part. The soloist also takes on the voice of major characters at critical moments, such as Belshazzar’s praise of the false god of gold, and later the voice of the mysterious hand as it inscribes its chilling message on the wall.

The oratorio has a rich and evocative orchestral score, with unusually prominent roles for brass and percussion and a significant amount of a cappella writing for both the chorus and the baritone soloist. A trombone fanfare heralds the opening prophecy of Isaiah (for a cappella men’s chorus). A subsequent trumpet fanfare announces King Belshazzar. Walton uses the two brass choirs both antiphonally and stereophonically, at moments of pagan revelry and exultant celebration.

Although the percussion section is not so visibly expanded as the brass, its members work exceptionally hard in Belshazzar’s Feast. They are stars in the brilliant double chorus of invocations to heathen gods. As each deity is praised, the orchestra paints its portrait in percussive, metallic colors: the god of gold with gong, tambourine, cymbals and drums in addition to brass, the god of silver with glockenspiel, triangle and saxophone, the god of iron with the anvil, the god of wood with xylophone and woodblocks, and the god of stone with slapsticks.

The climax occurs during the banquet when the debauchery is interrupted by the mysterious hand. A hush falls over the orchestra: silent except for tremolando chords played pianissimo—and sinister, skeletal commentary from the percussion: cymbals, castanets, bass drum and gong. The effect is spine-tingling and fearful, as the spectral hand begins to inscribe its damning assessment of the idolatrous king.

Instrumentation: four-part mixed chorus and solo baritone with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 3 clarinets (1 doubling E-flat clarinet and 1 doubling bass clarinet), alto saxophone, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, side drum, tenor drum, bass drum, cymbals, anvil, castanets, gong, slapsticks, tambourine, triangle, wood block, glockenspiel, xylophone, 2 harps, piano, organ, 2 brass bands (each comprising 3 trumpets) and strings

Program notes by Laurie Shulman ©2018. First North American Serial Rights Only.


Meet a Musician: R. Douglas Wright

Minnesota Orchestra member since: 1995
Position: Principal Trombone
Hometown: Hopewell, VA
Education: New England Conservatory; Boston University

In June, you’ll be one of four soloists from the Orchestra in James Stephenson’s Pillars, a concerto for low brass. What role did you have in this piece’s creation?
Jim and I have known each other ever since our freshman year at New England Conservatory. He was a terrific trumpet player back in those days and has since turned his considerable talents toward composition. We spent a lot of time playing music together throughout our college days in brass quintets and large ensembles. We even went on an orchestra tour together to Israel. So, there’s lots of history there. When Jim told me about a potential commission to write a low brass concerto, I got really excited and begged him to let us premier it. The concerto was to be in memory of Bill Zehfuss, the longtime principal trombonist of the Charleston Symphony, who had passed away several years prior, and the funding for the commission was being raised online. I sent word out to every trombonist and tuba player I know—all of us in the Orchestra’s low brass section helped spread the word. Many wonderful friends and family members of Bill’s and lots of low brass players chipped in to make this wonderful commission possible. Even a few non-low brass players chipped in.

What should the audience listen for during this piece?
In standard orchestral repertoire, the low brass section gets to play everything from beautiful, soft chorales to big, powerful climactic sections of symphonies, and just about everything in between, usually in a more supportive role. Jim really knows the sounds the low brass section is known for and he has done a terrific job of letting each member of the section shine individually as well as showing off what we can do together. We even get to play the melody!

What is particularly exciting about performing a concerto for low brass?
I find it gratifying and inspiring each and every time I get to play with my good friends in the low brass section. To get to do so out in front of the orchestra is a thrill! Since we rarely get the spotlight for more than a few measures at a time, I’m guessing that will present its own set of challenges. However, I anticipate that moving from the back row to the front of the stage for a week is going to be a lot of fun. It’s no doubt exciting for our viola section as well, who might appreciate the break from our bells aiming at the backs of their heads.

Tell us about a proud moment in your career?
I was extremely fortunate to have gotten the chance to perform with Leonard Bernstein as he conducted his next-to-last concert. The man was a musical giant and an inspiration unlike any other I’ve ever encountered. I still get chills thinking about what it was like to work with him. Kids, look him up on YouTube. You’ll be amazed!

What advice would you give to someone interested in pursuing a career in music?
Pursuing a career in music is challenging, to say the least, because there are so many people who want to do it. It takes a lot of work and dedication, perseverance, and a bit of luck, and some good teachers—I had some great ones! Even then, it can be tough. However, if you are driven and passionate about music, I can think of nothing more gratifying than touching people’s lives through music.

What do you do when you are not performing?
I teach trombone at Northwestern University’s Bienen School of Music in Evanston, Illinois. So, you’re liable to find me at the airport from time to time. I also enjoy throwing the football with my son when he’s home from college, watching my daughter play soccer, and walking through the Minnesota Landscape Arboretum with my wife. The air out there is amazing! 

Click here for more about R. Douglas Wright.

Click here for more about the world premiere performances of James Stephenson's Pillars.

"Sounds of the Cinema" - 2018 Symphony Ball

Thanks to the many community members and volunteers who generously invested their time, talents, energy, and financial support, the 2018 Symphony Ball was a spectacular success. More than 1,200 guests experienced the magic of music in the movies brought to life by your Minnesota Orchestra and special guest jeremy messersmith.

Take a look back at photos from Courtney Perry and Greg Helgeson.


Meet a Musician: Augustin Hadelich

Violinist Augustin Hadelich performs Beethoven's Violin Concerto in concerts with the Minnesota Orchestra on June 8 and 9, under the direction of German conductor Jun Märkl. We asked Hadelich to tell us about his favorite moments in this concerto, and about his greatest influences, travels and recent projects (including an animated short film). 

What are some of your earliest memories involving music?
I started playing the violin when I was five years old. I have two older brothers who were already playing the cello and the piano, and that was what made me want to make music, too. In the evenings my whole family would assemble at the piano and sing Schubert Lieder or parts of operas.

Who influences you most in your career?
The first time I heard a great violinist play was when I was seven years old, and had been playing the violin for two years: it was a performance by the Italian violinist Uto Ughi, and it changed how I viewed the instrument (I did not even have any violin records or CDs prior to that). Later on, the recordings of David Oistrakh were a major influence for me. Nowadays I mostly get inspired by the people I play with, conductors and chamber music partners.

Which moments in Beethoven’s Violin Concerto are especially meaningful to you?
Every time I play the slow movement of the Beethoven, I marvel at how perfect, how simple, intimate and human it is. Perhaps it gives us—just for a moment—an insight into some deep fundamental truth of our existence, a glimpse of what lies beyond. My feeling about Beethoven's greatest works is that the better you know and understand them, the harder it is to imagine a person being able to write something so extraordinary.

The first movement begins with four fateful notes in the timpani, a motive that appears throughout the movement, sometimes tranquil, other times in anger or defiance. The movement that’s most fun for me to play, though, is the last movement, a light-hearted rondo which always makes me smile.

As you travel around the world to perform, what are some of your favorite destinations?
My two all-time favorite places in the world are New York (where I’ve lived for the past 14 years) and Tuscany (where I grew up), but I feel lucky that I get to go to so many other exciting places! I’ve recently traveled to wonderful places like Amsterdam, Hong Kong, London, Tokyo and Hawaii. Since I’m there to work, I usually pick only one day to explore a bit, and focus on rehearsals and concerts the rest of the time. 

When you get a chance to attend a concert as an audience member, what do you love to listen to?
When I hear a great performance that moves me, I am reminded of why I do what I do! I travel so much that I don’t get the chance to go to as many concerts as I’d like. When I do I often stay away from the violin repertoire, because I can never switch my violinist brain off when listening to that repertoire. Piano recitals, voice recitals (Lieder for example), opera—it really depends on what’s on when I happen to have a free evening!

What do you do in your free time?
Many people don’t realize how much of my time is spent traveling, writing, thinking up programs and booking flights. I wish the only thing I did was play the violin; that’s the fun part! When I am home in New York, I like to get together with friends and play board games.

Do you have any recent projects you would like to share? 
I recently released an album of the 24 Caprices by Nicolò Paganini on Warner Classics, which was a big project and took about a year to make (although it feels like I worked towards it my whole life!). 

I also made an animated cartoon called “Fantasia dei Gatti” featuring Caprice No. 17—it is a caprice that always reminded me of meowing cats, and I collaborated with an amazing director, Paul Glickman, and animator, Tam King, to make this animated short film.

For more about Augustin Hadelich, visit

Click here for more about the concerts and to purchase tickets. 

Andrew Litton Prepares a June Triple Bill

By Dan Wascoe

When Andrew Litton returns to lead the Minnesota Orchestra June 1 and 2, he’ll bring to the podium three old friends—pieces he knows well but that seldom get performed in Orchestra Hall.

  • Belshazzar’s Feast by Sir William Walton (1902-1983) was last performed in Minneapolis 41 years ago (1977), with Henry Charles Smith conducting. Performed by orchestra and a full chorus (this year the Minnesota Chorale), it recounts the Biblical story of a disembodied hand writing a dire (and fatal) prophecy about a disrespectful king on a palace wall—giving birth to the phrase, “the writing on the wall.” Litton’s recording of the work with the Bournemouth Symphony in England won a Grammy in 1995.
  • Chichester Psalms by Leonard Bernstein (1918-1990) was most recently performed by the Orchestra in 1999 under Eiji Oue. It, too, will feature Biblical lyrics sung by the chorale plus baritone Christopher Maltman. Its rhythms and harmonies recall those in Bernstein’s West Side Story, but the psalms quoted in the lyrics are sung in Hebrew, not New York-style English. The piece was commissioned for a 1965 performance in England’s Chichester Cathedral.
  • Fancy Free, also by Bernstein, was written for a ballet and evolved into the Broadway show On the Town. Segments were included in the soundtrack for Alfred Hitchcock’s Rear Window. The piece was most recently performed by the Orchestra in 2009 under Mischa Santora.

For Litton, who was artistic director of the Orchestra’s Sommerfest programs from 2003 to 2017, choosing a program can hinge on factors such as the acoustics of a performance hall, special anniversaries (Bernstein’s 100th birthday this year), the capabilities of an orchestra, and the sensibilities of an audience.

Despite the Biblical roots of the Belshazzar and Chichester works, Litton said religiosity was not the basis of his programming decision. More telling was his familiarity with all three pieces, and his unabashed admiration for Bernstein. He added, however, that his experience with a piece doesn’t mean every performance he conducts will be identical.

Conducting is “a constant evolving experience” in which Litton tries to discover “what a composer meant to do—being true to the composer.” When learning an orchestral work, he may first play it on the piano, reflect silently for a while to “get the concept,” then listen to recordings, especially of performances conducted by the composer.

That still leaves room for variations and interpretation, he said: “The composer’s version is basically a blueprint.” The conductor’s role is akin to that of someone moving into an apartment; the structure remains from tenant to tenant but each might change the wallpaper.

Walton, a British composer, is “a tough sell in the United States,” he said, because his work is less known. Litton would like to change that, along with works of Edward Elgar.

That’s not necessary with Bernstein, perhaps the most well-known U.S. composer. As a youngster, Litton attended one of Bernstein’s Young People’s Concerts in New York. The program included Respighi’s Pines of Rome, and Bernstein himself played piano.

“I became fascinated with him,” Litton said. He admired Bernstein’s animation, his “complete dedication to music,” and his desire to share that passion with his audiences. And because his compositions have endured, so will his legacy, Litton said, unlike those of many conductors who do not also write music.

Minneapolis, he said, is “renowned for inventive programs,” made possible by well-educated audiences. But he still found himself carefully planning Sommerfest performances because summer and winter programs are “very different.” Nothing too heavy in those warm, humid months.

To succeed with adventuresome programs, he said, a conductor must build and earn an audience’s trust—exposing them to new pieces in a way that is “not painful, or at least not for long. You don’t just clobber them over the head” with unfamiliar music. Similarly, a guest conductor must approach an orchestra “with caution.” If the musicians must learn a new or unfamiliar piece, for example, they might need more rehearsal time. Even then, “there are certain repertoires only (an in-house) music director should do” because he knows the abilities of the players and can help them “get to the finish line,” Litton said.

His 14 years of experience with Sommerfest leads him to believe that despite the rarity of the Walton/Bernstein program, “there are no challenges there” that its players can’t handle.

What should Minnesota audiences expect from the triple bill that Litton will conduct in June?

“Music is all so heartfelt and expressive” that he hopes listeners simply “sit down and forget about their day.”

He added, however, it might help to “read up on your Bible stories.”

Dan Wascoe is a retired reporter and columnist for the Minneapolis Star Tribune and performs with vocalist Baibi Vegners as Nuance/a duo.

Common Chords: Mankato

Take a look back at the Minnesota Orchestra's recent stop in Mankato from April 25-27. This visit to the Minnesota River Valley is all part of the Minnesota Orchestra’s Common Chords program, which establishes partnerships between the Orchestra and Greater Minnesota cities, each culminating in its own unique residency.

Music In The Minnesota River Valley

Minnesota Orchestra musicians hit the high notes early on Wednesday, launching a multi-day Mankato residency at Mankato West High School at 8:15 am, followed by a pop-up performance at the Mayo Specialty Clinic and interviews at Radio Mankato. Junior visitors to the Children’s Museum of Southern Minnesota learned that a trombone can make sounds like a race car—and that a tuba can play really really low notes. Seventh and eighth grade music students at Prairie Winds Middle School gathered other insights, like how to articulate with precision—“If it says ‘accent,’ I want you to give more than you think possible,” encouraged violist Richard Marshall, as Orchestra string musicians played alongside the middle schoolers on Grieg’s In the Hall of the Mountain King. “I fell in love with music today,” said one middle school bass player after the experience.

Brass Quintet performing music of all genres (classical, jazz, blues, rags) for visitors at the Children’s Museum of Southern Minnesota.

Principal Tuba Steve Campbell demonstrating how low the tuba can go.

Brass and String quartets performing, chatting and working with music students at Prairie Winds Middle School.

The Brass Quintet wraps up their day at Radio Mankato, doing several interviews and testing the limits of how many brass players can fit (and perform!) in one small sound booth.

Sparking Music Memories

The Common Chords Mankato project opened its second day with a jaunt 20 minutes north to St Peter, Minnesota. Led by Assistant Conductor Akiko Fujimoto, the full Orchestra visited this picturesque community to play Tchaikovsky’s Pathétique in a noon hour concert for students at the brand-new St. Peter High School.

Violist Sam Bergman hosted the post-concert Q&A, where one student posed the question, “Why did you want to play in this band?” (Principal Cello Anthony Ross’ answer: “We get to make a living doing what we love in a great orchestra. We are fortunate!”)

The Brass and String ensembles headed back to Mankato for concerts at Mankato Brewery, playing amidst the gleaming brewing apparatus, and Old Main Village Senior Living Community, where one 103-year-old resident smiled wistfully at the end of the string performance. “The music reminds me of my father,” she said. “He played the mandolin.”

Tchaikovsky Wraps The Week

Mankato Area Youth Symphony students were among the first to arrive for the Minnesota Orchestra’s evening performance at Mankato’s Verizon Center on Friday, April 27. The student musicians met with their professional string and brass counterparts to pose questions, pre-concert. (A running theme: “How much do you practice?!”)

Assistant Conductor Akiko Fujimoto led the full-Orchestra performance in Verizon’s Grand Hall that featured Principal Second Violin Peter McGuire, a Mankato-native, in Mozart’s exquisite Turkish Violin Concert. The evening, and the Mankato Common Chords week drew to a dramatic close with the power and drama of Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No. 6.

The Minnesota Orchestra's innovative community engagement program, Common Chords, features weeklong residencies in Minnesota cities. Learn more >> 

Photos by Greg Helgeson

Giving Back: Getting to Know Minnesota Orchestra's First Good Fellow

Orchestra Hall is quiet and tuba player Jason Tanksley sits alone on the stage, performing some of the most challenging passages in the tuba’s repertoire. He plays behind a large opaque screen; on the other side sits a committee of Minnesota Orchestra musicians, each of whom is listening carefully. It’s a typical set-up for an orchestral audition, but this one is out of the ordinary.

Jason Tanksley is the Minnesota Orchestra’s Rosemary and David Good Fellow—and performing a “mock” audition is just one part of the advanced training that is now his job.

The Orchestra launched the Rosemary and David Good Fellowship last spring as a two-year program intended to enhance opportunities for African American, Latin American and Native American professional orchestral musicians early in their careers and to encourage greater diversity in the orchestral field. The first two participants, who began their fellowship experience in September 2017 after winning a competitive audition, are Tanksley and trombone player Myles Blakemore. Tanksley is now completing his first season with the Orchestra; Blakemore participated in the fellowship program for several months before winning a position in the New World Symphony.

The mock auditions help to prepare Tanksley for professional auditions that he hopes will eventually earn him his own permanent chair onstage in an orchestra. For the first mock audition, he explained that the Orchestra staff and musicians treated the entire experience as if it were the real thing. The musicians on the committee then gave individual feedback to Tanksley on his performance.

He has also been able to sit in during actual auditions throughout the year to test his ear and learn from what the audition committee hears from the other side of the screen. Tanksley, like many musicians, says he used to be scared by the idea of a committee that you can’t see. Among many lessons from observing the process up close, he says one thing in particular has eased his mind a little: “You know, the committee is really cheering you on and wanting you to do well, so they can hire you. They aren’t a bunch of monsters.”

As part of the fellowship, Tanksley also observes Orchestra rehearsals and concerts, and performs onstage in selected Orchestra concerts. He takes two private lessons each month with musicians from the Orchestra and is able to select who he’d like to work with. So far, he has had the opportunity to learn from Principal Tuba Steven Campbell, all three members of the trombone section and trumpet player Robert Dorer, and next on his schedule is a lesson with Principal Bass Kristen Bruya. When he’s working with musicians who don’t play the tuba, Tanksley says: “they don’t care if something is a challenging tuba part or not. They might not even know if it is. Instead, I’m getting their unique musical perspectives and new ideas about how my part fits into the context of a piece, or how we might work together across the ensemble.” 

When he first heard about the fellowship, Tanksley saw it as a great chance to grow as a musician, but also as an opportunity to inspire others. “I feel like, if I can do this, if a black kid from Detroit like me can sit onstage with the Minnesota Orchestra, I can show other kids that they can do it, too. That’s what I’d really like to do.”

“It’s important for me to give back, and to share my experiences. I want kids in my hometown and other places where classical music isn’t as easy to find to be introduced to it at an earlier age. I never had a tuba lesson or played in an orchestra until I got to college,” says Tanksley, who now holds music degrees from Wayne State University and Cleveland Institute of Music. “When I teach young students, I encourage them to audition for local youth orchestras and other groups, so they have greater access to classical music than I did when I was their age. One of my first students is now studying music at Bowling Green State University.”

Jason with Principal Flute Adam Kuenzel and a student musician from the Minnesota All-State Orchestra

Tanksley continues the fellowship for another year and plans to have many more lessons and mock auditions, plus performances with the Orchestra and engagement activities around Minnesota. “Two years is not very long,” he says, “so I’m trying to soak as much of this fellowship in as I can while I have the chance!” He’s also excited to travel with the Orchestra to South Africa this summer and be part of performances and educational engagement on the tour.

“The biggest takeaway from this year so far has been the confidence boost,” he says. “To be selected for this fellowship and to get feedback and advice from the musicians here—who are the real deal—about my own playing has really helped me understand how I’m doing as a musician and where I might be able to go in the future.”

For a recent educational visit to a Minneapolis elementary school, Tanksley adapted a violin solo into a piece for solo tuba. He loves finding new ways to share what the instrument can do and what is fun about music. 

Jason, performing for students and staff at a Minneapolis elementary school.

His favorite composer lately? Berlioz. There are two tuba parts in Berlioz’ Symphonie fantastique and Tanksley is thrilled to join Principal Tuba Steve Campbell onstage for the Orchestra’s June performances. He also performs with other Minnesota Orchestra brass musicians in a free event on Thursday, May 10, at BlackStack Brewing in Saint Paul, as part of the Orchestra’s Pint of Music series.

Jason with Principal Tuba Steven Campbell, far right, and a student musician in a side-by-side rehearsal with Minnesota All-State Orchestra.

For more about Jason or the Rosemary and David Good Fellowship program, visit


Program Notes: Britten and Schumann

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Britten: Sinfonia da Requiem

Britten’s three-part Requiem, written as an anti-war statement, opens with a mournful procession in which saxophone plays a striking role, proceeds into chaos and concludes with a prayer-like hymn.

Schumann: Cello Concerto

Distinctive for the sheer beauty of its content, this concerto represents Schumann’s lyricism at its best. Three movements flow without pause as the music’s mood changes from the sweeping passions of the opening to the brightness of the finale.


Vaughan Williams: Symphony No. 6

Vaughan Williams’ Sixth Symphony is restless and compelling, quiet and questioning, and unconventional in its approach—with an epilogue rather than a finale, and each movement connected to the next by a single sustained note.

Full program notes: 

Benjamin Britten

Born: November 22, 1913, Lowestoft, England

Died: December 4, 1976, Aldeburgh, England

Sinfonia da Requiem, Opus 20

Premiered: March 29, 1941

Britten’s Sinfonia da Requiem had a genesis as strange as anything in the history of music. An avowed pacifist, Britten left his native England as war clouds gathered in 1939, hoping to make his life and career in the United States, which was, for the moment, staying out of the European war.

While living on Long Island, Britten was contacted by the British Council with a remarkable proposal. The Japanese government, which was also staying out of the war for the moment, planned to celebrate the 2,600th anniversary of its ruling dynasty, and for that occasion, set for September 1940, it was commissioning works by a number of composers, Richard Strauss and Jacques Ibert among them.

Now the Japanese government invited Britten to write a work for the occasion, and he accepted, stipulating only that “no form of musical jingoism” be required. Britten hurried to complete the music, which he titled Sinfonia da Requiem, early in June 1940, and the Japanese government promptly paid him. (The composer used the money to buy an aging Model T.)

Then came a sour surprise. The Japanese authorities rejected the piece, claiming that its “melancholy” tone was inappropriate for their festive occasion. More specifically, they objected to the titles Britten gave the three movements—Lacrymosa, Dies irae and Requiem aeternum—claiming that these made the Sinfonia “purely a religious music of Christian nature” and thus insulting to the Emperor. Though they allowed Britten to keep the commission fee, they refused to perform the music, and the premiere was given by John Barbirolli and the New York Philharmonic on March 29, 1941.

an anti-war statement

Despite the titles of the movements, Britten did not regard the Sinfonia da Requiem as religious music. In fact, he intended it specifically as an anti-war statement. In an interview with a New York newspaper at the time of the premiere, Britten said: “I’m making it as anti-war as possible….I don’t believe you can express social or political or economic theories in music, but by coupling new music with well-known musical phrases, I think it’s possible to get over certain ideas. I’m dedicating the symphony to the memory of my parents, and, since it is a kind of requiem, I’m quoting from the Dies irae of the Requiem Mass. One’s apt to get muddled discussing such things—all I’m sure of is my own anti-war conviction as I wrote it.”

The question remains whether music—abstract sound—can express anti-war (or any other) sentiments. It is worth noting, however, that Britten would incorporate the titles of the three movements of the Sinfonia in his War Requiem of 1961, where he combines the Requiem text with Wilfred Owen’s poetry to create a clear anti-war statement. The Sinfonia da Requiem makes that same statement, but at an abstract, purely instrumental level.

The Sinfonia is concentrated music. Its three movements, in a slow-fast-slow sequence that is performed without pause, span barely 20 minutes, and Britten surprisingly anchors all three movements around the tonality of D: D minor in the stern initial movements, D major in the consoling finale. Further, Britten is not so interested in the classical symphony’s opposition of different themes and keys as he is in a sort of organic growth of seminal material. The work’s opening theme will return in modified form in all three movements.

the music in brief

lacrymosa. The Lacrymosa, which traditionally announces the day when mankind faces judgment, bursts to life with great explosions of sound that resolve into a numbed, steady tread. Against this dark pulse, cellos announce the movement’s swaying, rising main theme. Secondary material is based on the leap of a seventh, but the swaying motion of the opening is never far away, and after a thunderous climax, that rhythm leads the movement to its subdued close.

dies irae. The Dies irae, which Britten himself called a “formal Dance of Death,” is a tour de force for orchestra, with tremolo flutes, brilliant brass writing and great full-orchestra swoops and shrieks. In its central episode, the eerie sound of alto saxophone briefly recalls the symphony’s undulating opening theme before the violence returns. The movement rises to another climax, then shatters into fragments.

requiem aeternum. From those fragments the harp assembles a quiet ostinato pulse, and the Requiem aeternum opens with three flutes singing the movement’s consoling main melody. Britten’s friend W.H. Auden described the finale as “a movement of peace and quiet rejoicing,” and Britten asks for a tempo of Andante molto tranquillo. But this peace is not long-lived. Gradually the swaying melody of the beginning insinuates itself, and Britten plays this up to a tremendous climax before the furies subside and the Sinfonia closes with a prayer for peace in which D major is affirmed quietly but clearly.

Instrumentation: 3 flutes (1 doubling alto flute and piccolo), 2 oboes, English horn, 3 clarinets (1 doubling E-flat clarinet, 1 doubling bass clarinet), alto saxophone, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon, 6 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, suspended cymbal, tambourine, whip, xylophone, 2 harps, piano and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Robert Schumann

Born: June 8, 1810, Zwickau, Germany

Died: July 29, 1856, Endenich, near Bonn, Germany

Concerto in A minor for Cello and Orchestra, Opus 129

Premiered: June 9, 1860

On September 1, 1850, the Schumanns—Robert, Clara and six children—moved to Düsseldorf after six unhappy years in Dresden. Actually, Dresden was a lively musical center, not least because of Wagner’s presence there until 1849, but the Schumanns found it personally and artistically stultifying.

the Schumanns in Düsseldorf

Düsseldorf, where Schumann was to become municipal music director, had a reputation as a conductor-eating town, but Schumann badly wanted an orchestra of his own, and he was willing to give Düsseldorf a try. He arrived at his new Rhineland home in high spirits, and the Düsseldorfers did everything they could to make their new music director feel welcome, unleashing an exhausting round of speeches, serenades, celebratory concerts, banquets and balls.

But contentment was brief. Clara worried about social standards, especially “the breezy, unconstrained conduct of the women, who at times surely transgress the barriers of femininity and decency....Marital life is more in the easy-going French style.” (All she could do about the women was to avoid them.) Both Robert and Clara were distressed by the noisiness of their first apartment, although a Rhine excursion at the end of the month and a move to quieter quarters helped.

Through all this turmoil, Schumann’s creative energies were not to be suppressed: in just 15 October days he composed his Cello Concerto, and in what remained of 1850 and in 1851 he wrote the Rhenish Symphony, revised his D-minor Symphony into what he considered its definitive form (Symphony No. 4), and wrote two violin sonatas, the Märchenbilder for viola and piano, two substantial cantatas and several overtures on literary themes.

The day Schumann finished the Cello Concerto he conducted the first of his ten subscription concerts. Clara was his soloist in Mendelssohn’s G-minor Piano Concerto, and, except that Robert was miffed because she got more attention than he did, it went well.

Nonetheless, it soon became inescapably clear that Schumann was unequal to his new position, and in October 1852 he was asked to resign. The matter was smoothed over temporarily, but a year later he had conducted his last concert in Düsseldorf. Always subject to depression, Schumann threw himself into the Rhine on February 27, 1854. This suicide attempt was not his first. He was rescued and committed into Dr. Richarz’s hospital at Endenich, where he died two and a half years later.

a “wholly ravishing” concerto

The Cello Concerto—and this always comes as a surprise—is the first important one since the beautiful examples by Boccherini from the 1780s.

Clara Schumann was delighted by the Cello Concerto. “It pleases me very much and seems to me to be written in true violoncello style,” she noted in her diary on November 16, 1850. The following October she wrote: “I have played Robert’s Violoncello Concerto through again, thus giving myself a truly musical and happy hour. The romantic quality, the vivacity, the freshness and humor, also the highly interesting interweaving of violoncello and orchestra are indeed wholly ravishing, and what euphony and deep feeling one finds in all the melodic passages!” Robert, on the other hand, seems to have had reservations: he canceled plans for a performance in the spring of 1852 and he did not send it to Breitkopf & Härtel, his Leipzig publisher, until 1854. In fact, the first performance was posthumous, given by Ludwig Ebert at the Leipzig Conservatory on June 9, 1860, at a concert in honor of the composer’s 50th birthday.

the music: passion, lyricism and a swift finale

In the Cello Concerto, each movement is linked to the next, and the middle one, even while it blooms in gloriously expressive song, has something of the character of a bridge or an intermezzo.

nicht zu schnell (not too fast). The concerto begins with three solemn chords for woodwinds with pizzicato strings. Their immediate purpose is to usher in the solo cello’s impassioned melody, but we soon discover that they have more than a local function, appearing at many of the concerto’s important junctures and especially pervading the slow movement. They are not, by the way, static and unalterable; rather, Schumann constantly finds new harmonies, rhythms and colors for them, although they are always and instantly recognizable. And to make the bridge from the slow movement to the finale, Schumann turns the cello theme itself into a gripping recitative, fascinatingly shared by soloist and orchestra in a moment both tender and full of pain.

Like his Piano Concerto, Schumann’s Cello Concerto has no opening tutti, only a brief but striking gesture that introduces the soloist right away: the three rising chords for woodwinds, each accented by pizzicato strings. Quiet though it is, it suggests the opening of a theater curtain, and the performer who stands revealed is an inspired singer who gives us an expansive and constantly developing—that is, non-repeating—melody. Here is Schumann at his most personal, his most poignantly vulnerable. Only when this lyric utterance is done does the orchestra ground the music with a vigorous and impassioned paragraph. Clearly, though, Schumann means this to be the cellist’s day, and the soloist returns with another lyric and exploring song, one of great range and full of wide intervals. A brilliant passage in triplets ends the exposition. The development is a kind of contest between virtuoso display and lyricism, and the chugging triplets are constantly interrupted—almost rebuked, it seems—by reappearances of parts of the opening melody in ever more distant and mysterious keys.

langsam (slow). After the recapitulation, the opening wind chords return, now heard from a deeply strange harmonic perspective. This time, the cello responds not with its first melody, but with a brief transition that gently sets the music down in F major. The slow movement has begun, and Schumann gives us a new melody, one full of melancholy downward curves. Like a chorus of sympathetic mourners, woodwinds echo the ends of the phrases. The passage reminds us that Tchaikovsky was one of the great Schumann-lovers. The accompaniment is notable, for along with neutral pizzicato chords we hear a soft countermelody played by another solo cello.

sehr lebhaft (very lively). After the urgent recitative that forms the bridge into the finale, Schumann gives us a more swift-moving music than any we have yet heard in the piece. Unfortunately, it is likely to sound not brilliant but just damnably difficult. Schumann relies much on sequences, and it takes a special mix of planning and spontaneity to bring out the energy in this music. (The 1953 Prades Festival recording by Casals and Ormandy shows wonderfully what can be done.) The drooping two-note phrases from the slow movement are often heard in the background.

Schumann moves into the coda by way of an accompanied cadenza (an inspiration to Elgar and perhaps also to Schoenberg and Walton in their violin concertos). Many famous cellists, among them Casals, Piatigorsky and Starker, all of whom should have known better, have struck out 32 measures of Schumann’s music at this point and substituted grandly rhetorical unaccompanied cadenzas of their own.

But Schumann was right, he really was: in the last moments of this finale, which is so difficult to move purposefully forward, it is important not to bring everything to a halt but to keep the momentum going, as Schumann does with his in-tempo cadenza. When he emerges from this episode, one of the concerto’s most original and effective, Schumann shifts metric gears, going from 2/4 into a still peppier 6/8, a device Brahms found worth imitating, and often.

Instrumentation: solo cello with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani and strings

Program note excerpted from Michael Steinberg’s The Concerto: A Listener’s Guide (Oxford University Press, 1998), used with permission.

Ralph Vaughan Williams

Born: October 12, 1872, Down Ampney, Gloucestershire, England

Died: August 26, 1958, London, England

Symphony No. 6 in E minor

Premiered: April 21, 1948

Near the dawn of Vaughan Williams’ composing career, his collecting of traditional Norfolk songs had been a critical step toward the finding of his own musical language. At the time his Fourth Symphony came along in 1935, the 62-year-old composer of the opera Sir John in Love (source of the popular Fantasia on “Greensleeves”), as well as the Tallis Fantasia and The Lark Ascending, seemed fixed more firmly than ever as the dean of England’s “pastoral school.” Thus the sometimes harshly dissonant Fourth Symphony brought a real shock. “I feel that I have at last become master of my material,” Vaughan Williams wrote to a former student, “but it now seems too late to make any use of it.” Happily he was wrong, and 23 more years of work (including five more symphonies) lay ahead.

not a “War Symphony”

Using some material he had sketched in 1943 for a movie score, Vaughan Williams began his Sixth Symphony in about 1944 and completed it in 1947. The first public performance was given by Sir Adrian Boult and the BBC Symphony in London’s Royal Albert Hall on April 21, 1948. At the beginning of 1950, Vaughan Williams revised the third movement, Scherzo, clarifying some of the orchestration as well as adding a new countertheme for brass in a couple of places. This version of the symphony has become the standard.

Ending, as it does, in 11 or 12 minutes of chill, unbroken pianissimo, the Sixth Symphony hardly seems like a piece designed for success, yet the reception at the first performance was overwhelming, and it took only a little over two years for the work to achieve 100 performances. Vaughan Williams’ pleasure at having, as he liked to say, “rung the bell” and “done the real thing” was offset by the annoyance of people insistently imposing their extramusical interpretations on this work. In the 1930s, he had had a hard time persuading some people that the Fourth Symphony was not political and moral commentary about Hitler and Mussolini. In 1948, the year the Sixth Symphony premiered, Hiroshima was a recent memory, the Soviet Union had just cut off road and rail traffic between Berlin and the West, and nuclear war was coming to be an ever-present threat. But no, Vaughan Williams said, his bleak finale was not a depiction of a world flattened by The Bomb, and when Frank Howes, the music critic of The Times, referred to the Sixth as Vaughan Williams’ “War Symphony” (with capital W), the composer was aroused to real fury.

the music: full of anguish

allegro. Without question, the Sixth Symphony is a disturbing piece, full of anguish, and it begins with a cry. In defiance of the key designation in its title, E minor, the symphony begins resolutely one half-step up, in F minor. As Vaughan Williams himself points out, the music “[rushes] down and up again through all the keys for which there is time in two bars”; in other words, the harmony is exceedingly restless and unsettled. The mood, for the moment at least, is savage.

What Vaughan Williams calls “fussy” 16th-notes have been prominent from the beginning, and these continue while violins, woodwinds and horn introduce an impassioned new melody. It is immediately repeated in the bass with the fussy 16ths on top. When this agitation subsides, an oddly saucy accompaniment starts up, to which various woodwinds soon add a tune with a stammer. For a moment the sound gets to be quite Broadway, partly because the saxophone climbs into a high register where it is extremely prominent. There is one more theme to come, a spacious D-major tune that sounds like the old familiar Vaughan Williams. The saucy accompaniment continues right through this. Both melodies, the hesitant and the spacious, get some more play, after which there is a recapitulation—“just enough,” says Vaughan Williams, “to show that this is a Symphony [and] not a symphonic poem.” The spacious tune makes one more appearance, tranquillo, with harp accompaniment, and also in E major, which serves to settle the accumulated harmonic tension, though there is continuing argument between E major and E minor. The close is quiet.

moderato. The final E in the cellos and basses hangs over into the first measure of the second movement. In 1943, Vaughan Williams wrote the music for a film called The Flemish Farm, which Halliwell’s Film Guide describes as a “tolerable wartime flagwaver.” Not all of Vaughan Williams’ score made its way into the soundtrack, and he rescued two of the outtakes for the Sixth Symphony. This second movement’s first theme, a slow and sinister march, is one of them. Because of its rhythm (long-long-short-short-short), the studio orchestra always referred to it as “two hot sausages.”

A drumroll and a fanfare introduce an unharmonized pianissimo passage for the strings, which builds, then recedes. Suddenly the trumpets and timpani begin to insist on the “sausages” rhythm. When we first heard this, it was part of a theme; now it takes on a life of its own and is bent on destroying whatever thematic or other musical activity is going on. It cows the orchestra into silence; trumpets and drums, again pianissimo after their domineering forte, appear to have the last word. The English horn muses for a moment on the unharmonized string theme, but under its last notes, the persistent, destructive rhythm, now in the sullen, dark colors of timpani, bass drum and pizzicato low strings, reminds us that it is still there, that this nightmare could return.

scherzo: allegro vivace. The English horn’s last long C-flat constitutes the bridge into the third movement. It is a sardonic Shostakovich-esque scherzo, polyphonic in texture, and based on a theme with running 16th-notes. The saxophone adds a sleazy tune by way of a trio, and here I must quote Vaughan Williams’ good-humored program note for the first performance—in which he references the opinions of composer-writer Constant Lambert, his former pupil at the Royal College of Music:

“[The saxophone tune] is repeated loud by the full orchestra. (Constant Lambert tells us that the only thing to do with a folk tune is to play it soft and repeat it loud. This is not a folk tune but the same difficulty seems to crop up.)

“When [this] episode is over, the woodwind experiment as to how the [first theme] will sound upside down but the brass are angry and insist on playing it the right way up, so for a bit the two go on together and to the delight of everyone including the composer the two versions fit, so there is nothing to do now but to continue, getting more excited till the [saxophone] tune comes back very loud and twice as slow.”

epilogue: moderato. This time it is the bass clarinet which, descending through two octaves, builds the bridge into the Epilogue. Vaughan Williams describes this music as “[drifting] about contrapuntally with occasional whiffs of theme.” The two sections of violins lead off, all muted. The firsts show a definite bias toward F minor, the seconds then providing something like an E-major/minor corrective. After a time, flutes play the first violins’ theme in longer notes so that it sounds rather like a cantus firmus or chorale. The muted brass sigh three times, and a solo cello, unmuted but of course still pianissimo, responds to their dejection with a new musical idea. The oboe is the instrument that feels most free to sing out expressively in melodies of wide compass. The sounds themselves become ghostly, with string tremolandos and bell-like harmonics on the harp.

After one last “outburst”—a pianissimo outburst by the oboe—the strings take the symphony to its end. Vaughan Williams wrote that he “never had any conscience about cribbing,” and I suspect in these last measures he was cribbing from Strauss’ Also sprach Zarathustra. That work ends in a strange back-and-forth between high instruments playing chords of B major, and basses punctuating those chords with C’s. Vaughan Williams settles into an uncertain seesawing between chords of E-flat major and E minor, which have G as a note in common. The last chord, which finally disappears into the distance, is E minor, that being the symphony’s keynote, but the E-minor chord is in its most unstable distribution, with B in the bass, and so the effect is anything but definite. The conductor Andrew Davis, comparing this “unanswered question” close with the oscillations that usher Berg’s Wozzeck into silence, has observed that the Sixth Symphony “should not end with a sense of rest. A performance that sounds final is not a good performance.”

Whatever the intended meaning—and in fact, an exceedingly irritated Vaughan Williams said late in life that “a man might just want to write a piece of music”—the hushed music speaks so eloquently and so disturbingly on its own.

Instrumentation: 3 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, English horn, 2 clarinets, bass clarinet, tenor saxophone, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, suspended cymbal, triangle, xylophone, 2 harps and strings

Program note excerpted from the late Michael Steinberg’s The Symphony: A Listener's Guide (Oxford University Press, 1998), used with permission.

Program Notes: American Voices

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Copland: Suite from Billy the Kid

Designed as a one-act ballet, Copland’s suite follows the adventures of Billy the Kid as he travels across the Wild West. Tender string harmonies set the scene of wide open prairies, while clashing keys and cowboy tunes add excitement along the journey.

Beal: Flute Concerto

In Beal’s brand-new Flute Concerto, the virtuoso solo flute speaks above active but less demanding music from the orchestra. The opening movement’s focus is on the soloist’s dexterity and swift musical gestures, while the Rubato middle movement is gently beautiful and lyrical. The electric bass is prominent in the rapid-fire, jazz-laced finale.


Barber: Violin Concerto

In Barber’s concerto, the violin sings passionate, lyrical lines in the opening pair of movements, then delivers a whirlwind of triplet rhythms in the fast-paced finale.

Bernstein: Symphonic Suite from On the Waterfront

Bernstein transformed his only original film score into a single-movement symphonic suite highlighted by a solo horn that guides the orchestra through many of the movie’s main themes.

Full program notes: 

Aaron Copland

Born: November l4, 1900, Brooklyn, New York

Died: December 2, 1990, North Tarrytown, New York

Suite from Billy the Kid

Premiered: October 16, 1938 (original ballet)

Early in 1938 Aaron Copland was approached by Lincoln Kirstein, director of the Ballet Caravan, who wished to commission a ballet based on the life of Billy the Kid. But Copland was not drawn to this subject, and he felt a particular aversion to cowboy music: “'I have never been particularly impressed with the musical beauties of the cowboy song as such. The words are usually delightful and the manner of singing needs no praise from me. But neither the words nor the delivery are of much use in a purely orchestral ballet score, so I was left with the tunes themselves, which, I repeat, are often less than exciting. As far as I was concerned, this ballet could be written without benefit of the poverty-stricken tunes Billy himself must have known.”

Kirstein assured Copland that he need not use actual cowboy tunes in the ballet, but as the composer left to spend the summer of 1938 in Paris, Kirstein gave him several collections of cowboy songs to look over. And then a strange thing happened, softening Copland: “Perhaps there is something different about a cowboy song in Paris. But whatever the reason may have been, it wasn’t very long before I found myself hopelessly involved in expanding, contracting, rearranging and superimposing cowboy tunes on the rue de Rennes in Paris.” Copland uses theme-shapes, intervals and bits of rhythm from these tunes—we sense their origins and distinctive flavor without ever hearing the tunes in their original form.

the music: adventures in the frontier

The premiere of Billy the Kid was a success, and Copland arranged an orchestral suite from its music, preserving about two-thirds of the original score. The suite begins with The Open Prairie, which creates a sense of great space, and the steady tread of two French horns marks the appearance of humans within this vastness. Suddenly we are on a Street in a Frontier Town, full of dizzy human energy. Here Copland quotes “Old Grandad,” “Whoopee-Ti-Yi-Yo” and “The Old Chisholm Trail,” and a solo trumpet performs a Mexican Dance—specifically, a jarabe. A reprise of the opening prairie music leads to the Prairie Night (Card Game at Night)a nocturne for woodwinds, trumpet and strings—and this proceeds into the Gun Battle, with its booming drums and spatters of gunfire.

Celebration depicts the town’s relief at Billy’s capture. Eugene Loring, who danced the part of Billy at the premiere, had encouraged Copland to include a “macabre polka” as part of the ballet, and this was Copland’s response. This Celebration is built on dotted rhythms and the sound of a honky-tonk piano, but what gives this music its “macabre” dimension is its bitonality: Copland sets the dance-tune in C major and its accompaniment in C-sharp. The suite now jumps to Billy’s

Death—his final breaths are heard in the quasi tremolando solo violin. In the suite, Copland moves directly from Billy’s death to a reprise of the music for The Open Prairie, and Billy the Kid concludes out under the open sky of the vast prairies.

Copland’s score for Billy the Kid set the gold standard for music about the West. Its epic sense of space, use of cowboy tunes, and concise evocation of a raw frontier town—replete with honky-tonk revelry, gunfights and the lonely hero—have become part of the imagination of every subsequent composer who writes music about the American West.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo (1 flute also doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, suspended cymbal, guiro, slapstick, sleigh bells, tin whistle, triangle, wood blocks, glockenspiel, xylophone, harp, piano and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Jeff Beal

Born: June 20, 1963, Hayward, California; currently living in Agoura Hills, California

Concerto for Flute and Orchestra

Premiered: January 18, 2017 (third movement); May 3, 2018 (full concerto)

Jeff Beal may be best known as a composer of music for films and television, but his newly-written Flute Concerto has its origins not in Hollywood—nor the Washington D.C. of his Emmy Award-winning score for Netflix’s House of Cards. Instead the genesis came in Stockholm, Sweden, where Beal worked out the basic parameters of the concerto over coffee and conversation with flutist Sharon Bezaly in June 2015.

Beal recalls that inspiring meeting: “Sitting in Stockholm harbor on a beautiful sunny day, I had a long chat with Sharon about the concerto I would compose for her. The light of the northern summer sun bathing the harbor was a perfect metaphor for what she wanted: A concerto full of joy, energy and rhythm, with some of the eclectic jazz sensibilities of my scoring on House Of Cards.”

The seeds for the project were planted earlier in 2015 when Bezaly and BIS Records founder Robert von Bahr reached out to Beal, whose music they knew through House of Cards, and invited him to Stockholm to hear Bezaly play. “He came, listened to Sharon and was stunned,” says von Bahr. “He cleared away his much-better-paid schedule to compose her a concerto.”

Beal’s Flute Concerto, this week receiving its first-ever complete performance, is the latest in a series of world premieres given by Bezaly, a strong advocate of new music who is the dedicatee of more than 20 concertos—among them works by Kalevi Aho, Sally Beamish, Sofia Gubaidulina and Anders Hillborg. Bezaly comments: “Breathing life into the past, making it part of our present, is a great privilege for any performer. But a significant part of my vocation as a musician is the aspiration to inspire the great composers of our time to write new and ground-breaking music, so that future generations are able to breathe new life into our present, their past, in a perpetual celebration of timeless music.”

This particular project came near a time of personal grieving for Bezaly, which impacted the concept and structure of the piece. Beal further recalls from their conversation in Stockholm: “Sharon shared the story of her childhood in Israel, and her close connection to her mother who had also been her musical mentor, whom she had lost earlier that year. This, coupled with this emotional brief sense of Sharon’s personality, provided me a way into the piece. As painful as a loss of a parent can be, her deep affection for her mother was certainly part of my inspiration for the second movement. We also spoke about the beauty of memorable melodies, and kept returning to this idea of rhythm and energy.”

Bezaly performed the concerto’s third movement a handful of times in 2017, first with the Seoul Virtuosi Chamber Orchestra on January 18, 2017. The first and second movements have never been performed for audiences prior to this week, making this the world premiere of the concerto in its full form.

a multi-talented composer

Jeff Beal is hardly the first composer known primarily for films and television to find his way to the concert hall (another, James Newton Howard, will have his Violin Concerto heard at the Minnesota Orchestra’s upcoming Sommerfest), but he may be among the most multi-faceted. His early studies were as a jazz trumpet player—first spurred by the gift of a Miles Davis/Gil Evans record from his grandmother Irene Beal, who had been a pianist and professional accompanist of silent movies. After graduating from the Eastman School of Music, where he met his wife, operatic soprano Joan Beal, he pursued a career in New York City as a jazz performer, recording artist and composer.

In the mid-1990s Beal moved to Los Angeles, where in 2000 he made his breakthrough into film music by scoring the Academy Award-winning film Pollock. His notable projects since have included scores for the documentaries Blackfish, The Queen of Versailles and An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power; music for the HBO series Carnivàle and Rome; and the score and theme for Monk. In 2013 came the opportunity to score one of the first major online series featuring an A-list cast and director when Academy Award nominee David Fincher tapped him as composer for Netflix’s House of Cards. Overall Beal’s music has been recognized with 16 Emmy Award nominations and five Emmy wins, most recently in 2017 for season five of House of Cards.

For his film and TV projects, Beal follows the “do it yourself” mantra, as he composes, orchestrates, conducts, records and mixes the music himself. Much of the recording happens not within the confines of a Hollywood studio—but rather, in Beal’s own living room, where an entire string orchestra squeezes in to record for House of Cards. The well-known theme music for that show is a family affair: Beal supplies the lonely trumpet calls and piano arpeggios, his son Henry performs the relentless bass guitar riff, and his wife Joan lends her operatic voice beginning in the series’ second season.

Aside from his work for media, Beal has composed commissioned works for the St. Louis, Rochester, Pacific, Frankfurt, Munich and Detroit symphony orchestras. He has also written for the Smuin Ballet, Metropole Orchestra, Ying String Quartet, Debussy Trio, Henry Mancini Institute, Chamber Music Festival of Lexington, Los Angeles Master Chorale, Brooklyn Youth Chorus, guitarist Jason Vieaux and Minnesota-based men’s vocal group Cantus, which premiered Beal’s Beneath Thin Blanket in 2016.

the concerto in brief

The instrumentation of Beal’s Flute Concerto is smaller than that of many modern orchestral works, which appropriately clears a path for the solo flute. The brass “section,” for instance, consists of a single horn. The sole atypical addition to the orchestra is an electric bass guitar. Throughout the concerto, which comprises three untitled movements, Beal makes use of what he calls Bezaly’s “gorgeous tone throughout the entire register of the instrument and prodigious circular breathing ability.”

[quarter note = 106]. The tone of the concerto is set from the earliest measures: the virtuoso solo flute speaks above active but less demanding music from the orchestra. The opening movement’s focus is on the soloist’s dexterity and swift musical gestures rather than sustained melody. Harmonies are creative but gentle on the ears, and staccato articulation dominates.

[quarter note = 57] rubato. Here is the gently beautiful, lyrical music inspired by Bezaly’s affection for her late mother. Occasional rippling tremolos played by the two clarinets are among the distinctive touches, and the last word is given to rising solo violin.

[quarter note = 142]. The rapid-fire finale, in which electric bass plays a prominent role, brings to the fore some of Beal’s native language, jazz. Like other portions of the concerto, this has roots in Beal’s Stockholm meeting with Bezaly, following which she drove him through the city. Beal recalls: “Winding through the Swedish countryside, she showed me the impressive acceleration ability of her Tesla. This pedal-to-the-metal image of Sharon might have stayed with me, and certainly the third movement is not your father’s Oldsmobile.”

Instrumentation: solo flute with orchestra comprising flute, oboe, English horn, 2 clarinets, bassoon, horn, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, suspended cymbal, bongos, mark tree, temple blocks, tom-toms, triangle, glockenspiel, marimba, harp, bass guitar and strings

Program note by Carl Schroeder.

Samuel Barber

Born: March 9, 1910, West Chester, Pennsylvania

Died: January 23, 1981, New York City

Concerto for Violin and Orchestra, Opus 14

Premiered: February 7, 1941

In the golden days of the Renaissance and early Baroque age, most male composers began their musical lives as boy sopranos trained in church choirs. Ultimately, instrumental virtuosity superseded the human voice. By contrast, the 20th century’s Samuel Barber, a supreme American lyricist, was among the few composers of his time who studied singing. Gifted with a mellow baritone voice, he pursued a triple major in composition, piano and voice as a member of the charter class of Philadelphia’s Curtis Institute of Music.

Barber’s lyrical style also characterizes his instrumental concertos: the Violin Concerto premiered under Eugene Ormandy in Philadelphia in 1941, the Cello Concerto introduced by Raya Garbousova under Koussevitzky in Boston in 1946, and the Piano Concerto which John Browning premiered at Lincoln Center in 1962 and repeated here at Orchestra Hall in the 1980s.

like a human voice

Of all instruments, the violin may be closest to the human voice—and this is how Barber employs it, maximizing the instrument’s warmth and intimacy. However, the patron who commissioned the Violin Concerto had sought a different effect.

Samuel Fels, a wealthy businessman in Barber’s hometown of Philadelphia, proposed a vehicle for his adopted son, Iso Briselli, a violin prodigy. The young composer developed the first two movements of this Opus 14 while residing in the idyllic Swiss village of Sils Maria, but like other expatriate Americans, fled Europe after the Nazis invaded Poland. Back in Philadelphia, Barber presented the opening movements to Fels—but they did not please.

Fels had anticipated flashy music of the kind that triggers cheering, and this thoughtful discourse between soloist and orchestra was too lyrical for him. Barber responded by dashing off a showpiece finale demanding consummate skills—but this was judged too difficult! Soon, however, a promising Curtis student named Herman Baumel delivered a polished reading of the finale. Baumel also gave a private performance of the concerto with the Curtis Orchestra under Fritz Reiner and played it with the Philadelphia Orchestra in rehearsal before the official premiere.

Fels was unable to reclaim money already dispensed to Barber, who had spent it in Europe. So the businessman compromised by paying half the fee and surrendering the rights of first performance to the composer. The esteemed American violinist Albert Spaulding delivered the concerto’s premiere on February 7, 1941.

the concerto in brief

The traditionalist side of Barber as well as his progressive impulses—irregular rhythms and sometimes edgy dissonances—are shown to advantage in this moving work, which has commanded a solid niche in the repertory for more than half a century.

allegro. The music is not hard to follow. There are no contests here, only a harmony of dialogue between partners, the big orchestra and the little violin, cast as a wordless troubadour of intense personal emotion. The opening movement includes moments of dark agitation and high intensity, not unlike profound conversation. The passion is shared in the development and a full reprise incorporating a brief cadenza.

andante. Initially, the violin is silent, as an oboe delivers the slow movement’s introductory song. Cellos take up the singing, which spreads across the orchestra before—heralded by a horn solo—the soloist speaks out with a fresh idea, initially tranquil, but soon growing passionate.

presto in moto perpetuo. In abrupt contrast, drumming launches the spiky finale, a swift perpetual motion conclusion which sustains triplet rhythms almost throughout, especially in the rapid bowing of the soloist, driving headlong to the close. Energy is the essence of this bracing movement.

Instrumentation: solo violin with orchestra comprising 2 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani, snare drum, piano and strings

Program note by Mary Ann Feldman.

Leonard Bernstein

Born: August 25, 1918, Lawrence, Massachusetts 

Died: October 14, 1990, New York City

Symphonic Suite from On the Waterfront

Premiered: August 11, 1955

While both West Side Story and On the Town were made into successful motion pictures, On the Waterfront represents a distinguished Bernstein effort conceived for a film from the outset—and not for a “musical,” but as the cinematic equivalent of the traditional “incidental music” for stage plays.

Understandably enough, film composers at first followed the stage tradition of providing background music for individual scenes, but it did not take long for them to recognize the new medium’s inherent opportunities for a greater unity between the musical and dramatic elements. In the 1930s such composers as Sergei Prokofiev in the Soviet Union, Silvestre Revueltas in Mexico and Virgil Thomson in our own country were able to work in direct collaboration with their respective screen directors in developing and shaping films in which music enjoyed an unprecedented prominence. This new type of partnership led to films in which music was used not only to augment the dramatic mood, but frequently in place of words to create the various moods. Bernstein’s only contribution to this genre, his score for Elia Kazan’s 1954 production On the Waterfront, remains outstanding in this respect. The Symphonic Suite from the film is one of seven Bernstein works that the Minnesota Orchestra performs during 2018, the composer’s centennial year.

music from a violent milieu

Like West Side Story, which came a few years later, On the Waterfront deals with a violent milieu in the city Bernstein’s music captured so brilliantly in its various phases. In this case the subject is racketeering on New York’s teeming commercial docks, and the defiant response of one sensitive young longshoreman (“Terry,” unforgettably played by Marlon Brando) to the situation in which he finds himself.

It happens not infrequently that a composer writing for a film may produce more music than is actually used. Parts of Bernstein’s score had been cut in the editing of the film, and the composer was motivated to prepare a Symphonic Suite to salvage some of this music. The suite was completed on July 5, 1955, and was first performed on August 11 of that year by Bernstein and the Boston Symphony Orchestra at Tanglewood. In the program note for the suite’s New York premiere in 1960, Howard Shanet wrote:

“The film score of On the Waterfront lends itself especially well to conversion into concert music because it is so symphonically conceived from the very beginning. The score of the entire film is built from only five or six thematic ideas which, however, are constantly being combined with each other and transformed into new shapes to meet the changing dramatic requirements of the story. Because the original film score is not just scraps of background music but a tightly organized symphonic structure, the concert suite derived from it makes complete musical sense...even if the listener does not know what each theme represents in the film story.”

It is possible, however, to relate the suite’s five sections (played without pause) to parts of the film, as Shanet did in the following outline:

andante (with dignity). The broad theme that opens the suite serves also, in a much grander version, to end it. In the film, this music has the same double function: as the so-called Main Title it accompanies the opening credits and titles; but it recurs at the end of the picture, as the music to which the injured Terry makes his heroic walk in defiance of the racketeers’ power.

presto barbaro. This striking passage starts with the percussion instruments alone—softly at first, then rising to a climax. The whole passage then becomes the basis for what is essentially a set of variations, each working up to its own climax. In the picture this music is always associated with violence—sometimes warning of it in advance, sometimes actually accompanying it, sometimes recalling it. For example, the first time it is heard (for percussion instruments alone) the screen shows an ordinary street scene; but the shocking contrast between the prosaic, static street and the brutal, dynamic music produces an ominous warning of tragedy to come.

more flowing. This lyrical, melodious section, sung first by the woodwinds, but then taken up by all the other elements of the orchestra, is the “Love” theme in the picture. It is associated with the girl, Edie, whose love is responsible to a great extent for Terry’s conversion to the forces of good.

allegro non troppo, molto marcato. In the Symphonic Suite this section has the role of a scherzo, contrasting with the flowing quality of the love music that precedes it. In the film it is heard under the climactic fight between Terry and the racketeer Johnny Friendly.

a tempo. This is the return of the opening Main Title theme in its final transfiguration as Terry’s heroic walk to victory. Starting as softly as possible, it grows as it marches irresistibly toward the last powerful chord. In the final phrases the Love theme is blended with it. But it does not end on the conventional triumphal cadence of most Hollywood films; On the Waterfront, as William Hamilton observes in a brilliant essay on this subject, “requires a finality that does not say everything is going to be just dandy,” and the last measures are marked by discordant cries that remind us of the bitterness and suffering that have characterized this story of violence.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, E-flat clarinet, bass clarinet, alto saxophone, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, 2 timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, suspended cymbal, large and small tamtams, triangle, tuned drums, wood block, glockenspiel, vibraphone, chimes, xylophone, harp, piano and strings

Program note by Richard Freed.

Symphony Ball Q&A with Wendy Williams

“Sounds of the Cinema” is the theme of the Minnesota Orchestra’s 2018 Symphony Ball gala fundraiser, which takes place on Saturday, May 12. Complete details of the Orchestra’s performance are being kept as a surprise for unveiling at Symphony Ball, but Orchestra flutist Wendy Williams gave us a few clues and background on how the music was selected, and details about special guest performer jeremy messersmith.

What was your role in selecting the music for Symphony Ball?

WW: I chaired the Music and Entertainment Committee, a great mix of musicians, staff, board members and community volunteers. This is one of the things I love most about our Symphony Ball—that it’s a collaborative effort that involves all of us. We worked hard to winnow down hundreds of ideas to 30 minutes of music. We were inspired by the vision of Co-Chairs Karen and Lloyd Kepple for the theme this year and their idea to share beautiful, entertaining and inspiring music from the movies.

There is nearly 100 years’ worth of movie music to choose from. How did you go about narrowing the focus?

WW: We started with film genres: action, foreign, love, mystery, epics, etc., with movies in each category. We then looked for a mix of tempos, moods and styles as well as a mix of classical music and music composed for film. We wanted scores that would appeal to a diverse audience in age and background, and on a practical level, we had to keep an eye on costs as most film music is expensive to rent. Music is what gives movies their emotional and dramatic impact, and we had a great time listening to so many scores!

Which film scores might you pick to program that didn’t quite make it onto this year’s Symphony Ball program?

WW: The music of Bernard Hermann didn’t quite make it this year. His music for Hitchcock films is fantastic, but alas very expensive to rent and requires lots of rehearsal time.

How did you get singer-songwriter jeremy messersmith involved in Symphony Ball? And what’s his connection to film music?

WW: I’ll turn this question over to Grant Meachum, the Orchestra’s director of Live at Orchestra Hall.

GM: I met jeremy messersmith for the first time in summer 2017 in a “getting to know you” situation with Sarah Hicks, principal conductor of Live at Orchestra Hall. Sarah and I are both huge fans of jeremy’s music, and we wanted to get to know him and brainstorm ideas for how he might collaborate with the Orchestra. We learned quickly that jeremy and Sarah are both enormous Star Wars fans, and after that first meeting jeremy took us up on an invitation to become a regular visitor to Minnesota Orchestra concerts.

When the Symphony Ball committee began to discuss a film theme for this year’s Ball, I thought back to that conversation with jeremy—his love for film, the beautiful lyricism of his writing, and the theatrical scope of his music-making. This seemed to be the perfect opportunity to collaborate—and Wendy and my colleagues on the committee were quick to agree.

What will jeremy perform at Symphony Ball?

GM: Jeremy will be performing two original songs with the Orchestra, as well as the Henry Mancini/Breakfast at Tiffany’s classic “Moon River.” He has partnered with the brilliant arranger Andy Thompson to re-imagine his original songs in a style that is both cinematic and a natural pairing for the Minnesota Orchestra with the Twin Cities’ foremost singer-songwriter and Star Wars fan.

Anything closing thoughts on Symphony Ball?

WW: I’m thrilled about the mix of music we are offering this year: Bryan Nichols playing movie music in the lobby for the Party, DJ Ander Other and Synergy for dancing, the Orchestra’s concert and jeremy messersmith!

Symphony Ball takes place on the evening of Saturday, May 12, at Orchestra Hall and the Hilton Hotel. The evening’s activities include dining, auctions, dancing and a performance by the Minnesota Orchestra under Music Director Osmo Vänskä, joined by indie pop singer-songwriter jeremy messersmith. Visit for details and ticket information. RSVPs for Patron tickets (for the entire evening’s events), are accepted through Saturday, May 4, while Partier tickets (for all activities that follow the dinner and auction) are available through Tuesday, May 8.

Jeff Beal's Concerto for Flute and Orchestra

Jeff Beal may be best known as a composer of music for films and television, but his newly-written Flute Concerto has its origins not in Hollywood—nor the Washington D.C. of his Emmy Award-winning score for Netflix’s House of Cards. Instead the genesis came in Stockholm, Sweden, where Beal worked out the basic parameters of the concerto over coffee and conversation with flutist Sharon Bezaly in June 2015.

Beal recalls that inspiring meeting: “Sitting in Stockholm harbor on a beautiful sunny day, I had a long chat with Sharon about the concerto I would compose for her. The light of the northern summer sun bathing the harbor was a perfect metaphor for what she wanted: A concerto full of joy, energy and rhythm, with some of the eclectic jazz sensibilities of my scoring on House Of Cards.”

The seeds for the project were planted earlier in 2015 when Bezaly and BIS Records founder Robert von Bahr reached out to Beal, whose music they knew through House of Cards, and invited him to Stockholm to hear Bezaly play. “He came, listened to Sharon and was stunned,” says von Bahr. “He cleared away his much-better-paid schedule to compose her a concerto.”

Beal’s Flute Concerto, receiving its first-ever complete performance by the Minnesota Orchestra on May 3 to 5, is the latest in a series of world premieres given by Bezaly, a strong advocate of new music who is the dedicatee of more than 20 concertos—among them works by Kalevi Aho, Sally Beamish, Sofia Gubaidulina and Anders Hillborg. Bezaly comments: “Breathing life into the past, making it part of our present, is a great privilege for any performer. But a significant part of my vocation as a musician is the aspiration to inspire the great composers of our time to write new and ground-breaking music, so that future generations are able to breathe new life into our present, their past, in a perpetual celebration of timeless music."

This particular project came near a time of personal grieving for Bezaly, which impacted the concept and structure of the piece. Beal further recalls from their conversation in Stockholm: “Sharon shared the story of her childhood in Israel, and her close connection to her mother who had also been her musical mentor, whom she had lost earlier that year. This, coupled with this emotional brief sense of Sharon’s personality, provided me a way into the piece. As painful as a loss of a parent can be, her deep affection for her mother was certainly part of my inspiration for the second movement. We also spoke about the beauty of memorable melodies, and kept returning to this idea of rhythm and energy.”

Bezaly performed the concerto’s third movement a handful of times in 2017, first with the Seoul Virtuosi Chamber Orchestra on January 18, 2017. The first and second movements have never been performed for audiences prior to next month, making the Minnesota Orchestra's performance the world premiere of the concerto in its full form.

a multi-talented composer

Jeff Beal is hardly the first composer known primarily for films and television to find his way to the concert hall (another, James Newton Howard, will have his Violin Concerto heard at the Minnesota Orchestra’s upcoming Sommerfest), but he may be among the most multi-faceted. His early studies were as a jazz trumpet player—first spurred by the gift of a Miles Davis/Gil Evans record from his grandmother Irene Beal, who had been a pianist and professional accompanist of silent movies. After graduating from the Eastman School of Music, where he met his wife, operatic soprano Joan Beal, he pursued a career in New York City as a jazz performer, recording artist and composer.

In the mid-1990s Beal moved to Los Angeles, where in 2000 he made his breakthrough into film music by scoring the Academy Award-winning film Pollock. His notable projects since have included scores for the documentaries Blackfish, The Queen of Versailles and An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power; music for the HBO series Carnivàle and Rome; and the score and theme for Monk. In 2013 came the opportunity to score one of the first major online series featuring an A-list cast and director when Academy Award nominee David Fincher tapped him as composer for Netflix’s House of Cards. Overall Beal’s music has been recognized with 16 Emmy Award nominations and five Emmy wins, most recently in 2017 for season five of House of Cards.

For his film and TV projects, Beal follows the “do it yourself” mantra, as he composes, orchestrates, conducts, records and mixes the music himself. Much of the recording happens not within the confines of a Hollywood studio—but rather, in Beal’s own living room, where an entire string orchestra squeezes in to record for House of Cards. The well-known theme music for that show is a family affair: Beal supplies the lonely trumpet calls and piano arpeggios, his son Henry performs the relentless bass guitar riff, and his wife Joan lends her operatic voice beginning in the series’ second season.

Aside from his work for media, Beal has composed commissioned works for the St. Louis, Rochester, Pacific, Frankfurt, Munich and Detroit symphony orchestras. He has also written for the Smuin Ballet, Metropole Orchestra, Ying String Quartet, Debussy Trio, Henry Mancini Institute, Chamber Music Festival of Lexington, Los Angeles Master Chorale, Brooklyn Youth Chorus, guitarist Jason Vieaux and Minnesota-based men’s vocal group Cantus, which premiered Beal’s Beneath Thin Blanket in 2016.

the concerto in brief

The instrumentation of Beal’s Flute Concerto is smaller than that of many modern orchestral works, which appropriately clears a path for the solo flute. The brass “section,” for instance, consists of a single horn. The sole atypical addition to the orchestra is an electric bass guitar. Throughout the concerto, which comprises three untitled movements, Beal makes use of what he calls Bezaly’s “gorgeous tone throughout the entire register of the instrument and prodigious circular breathing ability.”

movement I. The tone of the concerto is set from the earliest measures: the virtuoso solo flute speaks above active but less demanding music from the orchestra. The opening movement’s focus is on the soloist’s dexterity and swift musical gestures rather than sustained melody. Harmonies are creative but gentle on the ears, and staccato articulation dominates.

movement II. Here is the gently beautiful, lyrical music inspired by Bezaly’s affection for her late mother. Occasional rippling tremolos played by the two clarinets are among the distinctive touches, and the last word is given to rising solo violin.

movement III. The rapid-fire finale, in which electric bass plays a prominent role, brings to the fore some of Beal’s native language, jazz. Like other portions of the concerto, this has roots in Beal’s Stockholm meeting with Bezaly, following which she drove him through the city. Beal recalls: “Winding through the Swedish countryside, she showed me the impressive acceleration ability of her Tesla. This pedal-to-the-metal image of Sharon might have stayed with me, and certainly the third movement is not your father’s Oldsmobile.”

Instrumentation: solo flute with orchestra comprising flute, oboe, English horn, 2 clarinets, bassoon, horn, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, suspended cymbal, bongos, mark tree, temple blocks, tom-toms, triangle, glockenspiel, marimba, harp, bass guitar and strings

Program note by Carl Schroeder.

Meet a Musician: Maureen Conroy

Minnesota Orchestra Member Since: 2017
Position: Principal Librarian
Hometown: Valencia, CA
Education: University of California, Santa Barbara; University of Michigan, Ann Arbor 

How did you decide to become a music librarian? 
When I went to school at Michigan, I was able to be a part of the work-study program. I chose to work in the Ensembles Library, which introduced me to the behind the scenes world of the music library. I enjoyed working there so much, I got in touch with the librarians in the Detroit Symphony Orchestra library to seek out an internship. I worked as an intern on the weekends throughout my master’s degree. The internship turned into a 32 hour-a-week job, and I filled the other hours with practicing, teaching and taking whatever gig came my way. I also took every horn audition I could. Then I took my first library audition in 2009 for the New York Philharmonic. I did better at that audition than I ever did at any horn audition and I was happier off-stage than on, so for me, the answer was clear. 

Tell us about your proudest career moment.
There are many proud moments—getting tenure with the Utah Symphony and winning the job here in Minnesota top the list.  

What has been especially exciting or challenging in your role at the Minnesota Orchestra?
I have never been on an international tour with an orchestra, so I am really looking forward to heading to South Africa in August. The new challenge for me is being in charge of all the music that gets performed. This orchestra goes through A LOT of repertoire. Keeping it straight and moving through the library can be overwhelming. Luckily, I have a great team in the library and we have each other's backs.   

Maureen's daughter Florence, helping add notes to the music.

When you are able to sit in the audience and enjoy a concert, what composers or performers are your favorites to experience?

I am still a brass player at heart, so anything that has wonderful horn writing tops my list, such as Mahler, Strauss and Wagner. I also appreciate that this orchestra commissions new works on a regular basis, so I am exposed to new ideas and timbres I haven't experienced before.  

Do you have any thoughts or advice for audience members?
Come to a concert you wouldn't normally attend! You may be surprised by how much you like something new.  

What is one thing the music librarians do in their job that would surprise most people?
We transfer all the bow marking from the principal string part to the entire section by hands. No photocopies, just pencil to paper. 

What advice would you give to someone interested in pursuing a career as an orchestra librarian? 
Explore the field by experiencing it firsthand! Seek out internships and guidance from people already doing those jobs. A strong musical background is a must; orchestral librarians are musicians first. 

What are you doing when you are not in the music library?
Spending time with my husband and 2 year old daughter, hopefully outside!  

Maureen with her husband and daughter. 

What Minnesota activity are you excited to try for the first time?
While I miss my Utah mountains for downhill skiing, I would like to get into cross-country skiing next winter. This summer, I am hoping to spend some time around Lake Superior 

What else should we know about you?
I briefly considered changing my major to art when I was in undergrad, where I worked as an illustrator for the school newspaper. I have had a children's book idea hanging in the back of my mind for long time. Maybe someday it will get out!


Click here to read more about Maureen. 


Program Notes: Osmo Vänskä and Joshua Bell

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Sibelius: En Saga
Hypnotic rhythms and dark orchestral coloring permeate this tone poem, which conveys the sense of a primordial adventure, fiercely urgent, and tragic as well as exhilarating.

Wieniawski: Violin Concerto No. 2
Wieniawski’s show-stopping Second Violin Concerto is rich in Polish tradition, featuring Gypsy rhythms and fiery fiddling. The work is dedicated to Wieniawski’s friend and fellow violinist, Pablo de Sarasate, whose own work follows this one on tonight’s program.

Sarasate: Zigeunerweisen (Gypsy Airs)
A riveting lament, embellished with an array of trills and dramatic ornamentation, leads to a furious, brilliant and breathtaking conclusion.


Beethoven: Symphony No. 7
Beethoven’s lively Seventh Symphony, famously called “the apotheosis of the dance” by Wagner, builds a series of astonishing musical moments from short, simple figures. The second movement, based on a repeating rhythm, has been an audience favorite since its premiere two centuries ago.

Full program notes:

Jean Sibelius

Born: December 8, 1865, Tavastehus, Finland
Died: September 20, 1957, Järvenpää, Finland

En Saga, Opus 9

In his mid-20s Sibelius studied for a year in Berlin, and then for another year in Vienna. He had at first intended to be a violinist, but in Berlin he heard the Aino Symphony of his senior compatriot Robert Kajanus, which was all the impetus he needed for giving a higher priority to composing, and to turn his own creative effort toward the furtherance of Finnish nationalism. Aino is one of the heroines of the Finnish national epic, the Kalevala; Sibelius’ wife was one of the numerous Finnish women named for her. Early in 1892 in Vienna, Sibelius completed the first of his own several works based on the Kalevala: the vast five-part symphony Kullervo, in which solo singers and a male chorus depict episodes in the life of the eponymous tragic hero. Kajanus saw to it that the Kullervo Symphony was performed in Helsinki that April, and its success prompted him to ask Sibelius for a shorter piece that could be performed more frequently. Sibelius responded, at about the time of his wedding, in June of that year, with En Saga, in which he recycled material from an octet for winds and strings he had composed in Berlin.

The new piece was not a success when the composer conducted the premiere in Helsinki, on February 16, 1893, but nine years later, when Ferruccio Busoni invited him to present En Saga in Berlin, he subjected the score to a major revision, which made such a positive impression when he introduced it in Helsinki on November 2, 1902, that it immediately took its place in the general repertory. (Kajanus, for his part, eventually gave up composing in order to devote himself to conducting Sibelius’ works; in his last years he went to London to make the premiere recordings of several of them.)

It was not until four decades later still, when he had written the last of his works and the world had celebrated his 75th birthday, that Sibelius said anything at all about the extra-musical significance of this work. At that time (the early 1940s) he remarked, “En Saga is the expression of a state of mind. I had undergone a number of painful experiences at the time, and in no other work have I revealed myself so completely. It is for this reason that I find all literary explanations quite alien.” Still later, according to his most distinguished biographer, Erik Tawaststjerna, Sibelius “answered an inquiry from abroad by saying that if one had to find a literary or folkloristic source for En Saga the atmosphere of the piece was far closer to the [Icelandic] Eddas than to the Kalevala.”

elemental forces

As Sibelius’ early symphonies show traces of Tchaikovsky and Borodin, En Saga might be said to owe something to such Russian works as Balakirev’s Tamara and Rimsky-Korsakov’s Skazka. (The latter title, in fact, has a meaning similar to that of En Saga, but with less fearsome connotations: “A Tale,” or “Legend,” or in some cases “A Fairy Tale.”) The freedom Sibelius gained by not attempting to tell a specific story or paint a specific picture, though, gives En Saga a universality and directness altogether beyond the scope of those charming and colorful works. This music may not actually make us “want to wrestle a polar bear,” as the enthusiastic Sibelian Olin Downes suggested on hearing En Saga in the 1930s. But it is powerfully evocative in a more general sense, and it may touch us on deeper levels—may convey a sense of some primordial adventure—involving elemental forces rather than individuals, and both tragic and exhilarating in its fierce urgency.

The themes, strong and persistent, seem to grow directly out of one another, in the nature of metamorphoses. The rhythms are hypnotic, the darkish orchestral coloring (with a bass drum replacing, rather than augmenting, the timpani) as deftly achieved as anything from Rimsky-Korsakov, Strauss or Ravel. The overall effect is one of striking originality, a style as unlikely to be successfully imitated or duplicated as it is to be mistaken for that of anyone but Sibelius himself.


2 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, bass drum, cymbals, triangle and strings

Program note by Richard Freed.

Henri Wieniawski

Born: July 30, 1835, Lublin, Poland
Died: March 31, 1880, Moscow, Russia

Concerto No. 2 in D minor for Violin and Orchestra, Opus 22

Most of the violin heroes from Paganini, who was born in 1782, to Adolf Busch, who died in 1952, were composers of considerable competence. It is different today, when a violinist such as Joshua Bell, daring to write his own cadenza for the Brahms concerto and doing so with flair and originality, is very much an exception among his colleagues.

Henri Wieniawski, born a half-century after Paganini, was one of the most esteemed Romantic violinist-composers. His mother, Regina Wolff, was an able pianist, and his uncle, Edouard Wolff, quite a celebrated one, as well as an active composer. At the age of eight, when Henri had already been playing the violin for some years, he was admitted to the Paris Conservatory, where he soon entered the class of Lambert Massart, one of the pedagogic eminences of the day. By the time he was 13, Wieniawski was a busy performer, usually with his younger brother Jósef at the piano, but in 1849 he returned to Paris in order to take up the serious study of composition.

always on the road

The violinist Leopold Auer recalled running into Wieniawski at the gambling tables at Wiesbaden, Germany. On tour with the great Anton Rubinstein, Wieniawski thought he had figured out a way to beat the system and bankrupt the casino; when that happened, he told Auer, he would give up concertizing, play only for his pleasure, and concentrate on composing. That happy day never arrived, and Wieniawski’s life was that of a traveling virtuoso. He lived in Saint Petersburg, where he was a ubiquitous presence on the musical scene, but his career constantly took him all over Europe. In 1872 he began a two-year tour of the United States, giving 215 concerts with Rubinstein in the first year alone, then continuing on almost as exhausting a schedule with the soprano Pauline Lucca.

Wieniawski returned to Europe with shattered health and a lot of money. He settled in Brussels, succeeding Henri Vieuxtemps at the Paris Conservatory. But being the sort of man who spent whatever he earned as soon as he could, he was under continuing pressure to stay on the road and play. A heart condition gave him ever more trouble. In November 1878 he collapsed during a performance in Berlin of his Concerto No. 2. His colleague Joseph Joachim was in the audience, and Wieniawski asked him to finish the concert for him. A month later, in Moscow, he was obliged to break off a performance of the Kreutzer Sonata after the first movement. Undeterred, he was soon off and running again, this time with soprano Désirée Artôt, who had once briefly been engaged to a young Tchaikovsky. Once again, though, the tour had to be called off so that Wieniawski could enter hospital in Odessa. When he died he was not yet 45.

For all his physical tribulations, Wieniawski was a cheerful sort and delightful company, a man who could never resist a pun and was a captivating raconteur. His marriage to an Irishwoman, Isabella Hampton, brought him much happiness. Accounts of Wieniawski’s playing invariably take note of its technical brilliance but remark even more on its fire and ardor. His compositions of course demand these qualities.

the concerto in brief

Wieniawski composed his Second Violin Concerto in 1862 and gave the first performance on November 27 of that year in Saint Petersburg, with Nikolai Rubinstein conducting. The score is dedicated to a fellow violinist-composer, Pablo de Sarasate, whose Zigeunerweisen (Gypsy Airs) follows the Wieniawski concerto on tonight’s program. The Concerto No. 2 is the only one of Wieniawski’s larger works to have taken a firm hold in the repertory, though a few modern violinists, notably Midori, have made a persuasive case for the Concerto No. 1, which is more pyrotechnical than the Second, but with less soul.

allegro moderato. The first of the Second Concerto’s three movements is an Allegro moderato, more lyric that excited, and Auer recalled that Wieniawski himself used to play it “rather quietly, more moderato than allegro.” There is, of course, enough brilliant passagework to constitute a barrier to all but the most secure fiddlers. For years, having come to know this concerto through Heifetz’s wonderfully played 1935 recording, I had no idea that Wieniawski had begun the movement with an extended orchestral exposition that introduces the main themes and that midway through there is a similarly broad passage for orchestra alone: Heifetz cut all that out and came straight to what he conceived to be the point, namely Himself. But these passages do attest to the seriousness of Wieniawski’s intentions and to his sense of proportion, and they are not badly carried out. He is not quite as adventurous, fluid and skilled as his older contemporary Henri Vieuxtemps, but he is streets ahead of such predecessors as Paganini and Heinrich Wilhelm Ernst.

romance. A shapely and spacious phrase for clarinet alone makes a bridge into the second movement, a Romance. Here Wieniawski is at his most likeable and touching best. The melody is lovely, and the accompaniment imaginative and euphonious.

allegro con fuoco–allegro moderato (à la zingara). The finale is designed to bring the house down, and for this purpose the soloist regales us with flying 16th-notes, a reprise of a wonderfully soulful theme from the first movement, and an absolutely irresistible spell of gypsy-fiddling abandon.

Instrumentation: solo violin with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani and strings

Program note by the late Michael Steinberg, used with permission.

Pablo de Sarasate

Born: March 10, 1844, Pamplona, Spain
Died: September 20, 1908, Biarritz, France

Zigeunerweisen (Gypsy Airs) for Violin and Orchestra, Opus 20

As a parting gift on tonight’s program, Joshua Bell delivers a second virtuoso showpiece by a Romantic-era violinist-composer: Spaniard Pablo de Sarasate’s Zigeunerweisen (Gypsy Airs). Sarasate was known in his day primarily as a performer, but he punched above his weight as a composer, rising to fame in the generation just after Paganini. His music, Zigeunerweisen in particular, is yet more evidence that the composers who have written most intelligently and virtuosically for violin have also been violinists—Vivaldi, Mozart, Sibelius, Bruch and Paganini easily come to mind. So, too, does Wieniawski, whose Second Violin Concerto (dedicated to none other than Sarasate) precedes Zigeunerweisen on tonight’s program.

royal connections and unmatched technique

Sarasate’s credentials as a violinist were formidable, earned at a very young age in spite of his origins in the musical backwater of Pamplona, the Basque city known for its annual Running of the Bulls. As is usually true with prodigious musical talent, one of his parents was a musician—in this case, his father, a violinist and military bandmaster who taught five-year-old Pablo the basics. Perhaps his biggest career break came when his playing caught the attention of her royal highness Queen Isabella of Spain, who sponsored Sarasate’s enrollment at the Paris Conservatory at the tender age 12, and gave him a 1724 Stradivarius violin. As a teen, Sarasate quickly rose to fame as a fearless virtuoso with an unmatched technique that won not only ardent fans, but major competitions in Europe as well. This launched an international touring career that brought him to America twice and regularly to London, where he took audiences by storm. Not since Paganini had a fiddler caused this kind of sensation. He inspired a number of important composers to write pieces for him: among them Bruch, Lalo and Saint-Saëns.

Early in his career, Sarasate began to perform his own works: extended, virtuosic fantasies based on themes from popular operas of the day. His fantasies on Bizet’s Carmen and Gounod’s Faust are bravura pieces that only the most gifted virtuosos need attempt. Regarding Sarasate’s idiomatic writing for the violin, the playwright and music critic George Bernard Shaw may have said it best when he declared that though there were many composers of music for the violin, there were but few composers of violin music.

a dash for the finish line

Perhaps Sarasate’s best-known work is Zigeunerweisen (Gypsy Airs), evoking the Gypsy fire of Romany life. Written in 1878 and recorded by every major violin virtuoso since, it has become a staple for violinists, often as a concert encore. Zigeunerweisen begins with about seven minutes of slow, soulful melodies, leading into a spectacular two-minute dash for the finish line—extremely demanding of the performer—that leaves audiences breathless.

Instrumentation: solo violin with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani, triangle and strings

Program note by Michael Adams.

Ludwig van Beethoven

Born: December 16, 1770, Bonn, Germany
Died: March 26, 1827, Vienna, Austria

Symphony No. 7 in A major, Opus 92

Beethoven turned 40 in December 1810, and things were going very well. True, his hearing had deteriorated to the point where he was virtually deaf, but he was still riding that white-hot explosion of creativity that has become known, for better or worse, as his “heroic” style.

re-imagining music

Over the decade-long span of that style, 1803 to 1813, Beethoven essentially re-imagined music and its possibilities. The works that crystallized the heroic style—the Eroica and the Fifth Symphony—unleashed a level of violence and darkness previously unknown in music and then triumphed over them. In these symphonies, music became a matter not of polite discourse but of conflict, struggle and resolution.

In the fall of 1811, Beethoven began a new symphony, his Seventh, which would differ sharply from those two famous predecessors. Gone is the sense of cataclysmic struggle and hard-won victory. Instead, this music is infused from its first instant with a mood of pure celebration.

Such a spirit has inevitably produced interpretations as to what this symphony is “about”: Berlioz heard in it a peasants’ dance, Wagner called it “the apotheosis of the dance,” and more recently Maynard Solomon has suggested that the Seventh is the musical representation of a festival, a brief moment of pure spiritual liberation.

But it may be safest to leave the issue of meaning aside and instead listen to the Seventh simply as music. There had never been music like this before, nor has there been since: this symphony contains more energy than any other piece of music ever written. Much has been made (correctly) of Beethoven’s ability to transform small bits of theme into massive symphonic structures, but here he begins not so much with theme as with rhythm: tiny figures, almost scraps of rhythm. Gradually he releases the energy locked up in these small figures and from them creates one of the mightiest symphonies ever written.

the symphony: small ideas transformed

poco sostenuto–vivace. The first movement opens with a slow introduction so long that it almost becomes a separate movement of its own. Tremendous chords punctuate the slow beginning, which gives way to a poised duet for oboes. The real effect of this long Poco sostenuto, however, is to coil the energy that will be unleashed in the true first movement, and Beethoven conveys this rhythmically: the meter of the introduction is a rock-solid (even square) 4/4, but the main body of the movement, marked Vivace, transforms this into a light-footed 6/8. This Vivace begins in what seems a most unpromising manner, however, as woodwinds toot out a simple dotted 6/8 rhythm and the solo flute announces the first theme. This simple dotted rhythm saturates virtually every measure of the movement, as theme, as accompaniment, as motor rhythm, always hammering into our consciousness. At the climax, horns sail majestically to the close as the orchestra thunders out that rhythm one final time.

allegretto. The second movement, in A minor, is one of Beethoven’s most famous slow movements, but the debate continues as to whether it really is a slow movement. Beethoven could not decide whether to mark it Andante, a walking tempo, or Allegretto, a moderately fast pace. He finally decided on the latter, though the actual pulse is somewhere between those two. This movement too is built on a short rhythmic pattern, in this case the first five notes: long-short-short-long-long—and this pattern repeats here almost as obsessively as the pattern of the first movement. The opening sounds like a series of static chords—the theme itself occurs quietly inside those chords—and Beethoven simply repeats this theme, varying it as it proceeds. The central episode in A major moves gracefully along smoothly-flowing triplets before a little fugato on the opening rhythms builds to a great climax. The movement winds down on the woodwinds’ almost skeletal reprise of the fundamental rhythm.

presto. The scherzo explodes to life on a theme full of grace notes, powerful accents, flying staccatos and timpani explosions. This alternates with a trio section for winds reportedly based on an old pilgrims’ hymn, though no one, it seems, has been able to identify that hymn exactly. Beethoven offers a second repeat of the trio, then seems about to offer a third before five abrupt chords drive the movement to its close.

allegro con brio. These chords set the stage for the finale, again built on the near-obsessive treatment of a short rhythmic pattern, in this case the movement’s opening four-note fanfare. This pattern punctuates the entire movement: it shapes the beginning of the main theme, and its stinging accents thrust the music forward continuously as this movement almost boils over with energy. The ending is remarkable: above growling cellos and basses (which rock along on a two-note ostinato for 28 measures), the opening theme drives to a climax that Beethoven marks fff, a dynamic marking he almost never used. This conclusion is virtually Bacchanalian in its wild power. No matter how many times we’ve heard it, it remains one of the most exciting moments in all of music. Beethoven led the first performance of the Seventh Symphony in Vienna on December 8, 1813—a huge success, with the audience demanding that the second movement be repeated.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani and strings

Program notes by Eric Bromberger.

Program Notes: Cameron Carpenter Plays Rachmaninoff

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Mussorgsky: Prelude to Khovanshchina
Delicate harmonies, sweet folk tunes and morning church bells animate this exquisite tone poem, extracted from an unfinished Russian nationalist opera, that depicts dawn on the Moscow River.

Rachmaninoff/Carpenter: Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini
A twisting Paganini melody is the basis for Rachmaninoff’s ingenious set of 24 variations. The famous 18th variation turns Paganini’s theme upside down, transforming it into a gorgeous, moonlit love song. Rachmaninoff wrote the solo part for piano, but tonight it is played on organ in an exciting new version that arranger-performer Cameron Carpenter calls “Rachmaninoff on steroids.”


Shostakovich: Symphony No. 5
Shostakovich’s Fifth, the most frequently performed of his 15 symphonies, is forceful and questioning. It imitates the form of a classical symphony until its icy third movement, scored without brass, as gorgeous melodies rise and fall. Dueling critics have interpreted the finale as either triumphant or bitingly sarcastic.

Full program notes:

Modest Mussorgsky

Born: March 21, 1839, Karevo, Russia
Died: March 28, 1881, St. Petersburg, Russia

Prelude to Khovanshchina

The most original voice among the “Mighty Handful” of five 19th-century Russian composers was that of Mussorgsky, who was both the genius of the group and its most unstable personality. When he died from the effects of alcoholism at age 42, he left several of his most important compositions unfinished, including the opera Khovanshchina, to which Rimsky-Korsakov then put his hand. While Mussorgsky’s Boris Godunov has become one of the most well-known Russian operas, Khovanshchina has held the stage far less often. In the meantime we must make do with the attractive orchestral episodes that have carved a place in the concert hall.

a prolonged project, rescued by Rimsky-Korsakov

As we know from Boris Godunov and Pictures at an Exhibition, Mussorgsky was an avid Russian nationalist. His most eloquent expression of the national soul was in songs and operas, while his purely orchestral efforts were minimal. In 1872 he began to collect historical and musical materials for Khovanshchina. The work dealt with the political disturbances under the regency which preceded Peter the Great’s full accession to the throne, probing the collision between the old feudalism and the czarist reforms, a crucial time in late 17th-century Russian history.

Instead of drafting a cogent scenario, Mussorgsky assembled fragments of a libretto, being carried away by the historical sources into which he delved. By 1873 he began to create the music, which occupied him intermittently until the summer of 1880. Noting his obsessive drinking, his friends worried about the future of the opera. Their fears were not unfounded, and Khovanshchina loomed importantly in the pile of unpublished manuscripts left at his death in 1881. It was the first work to be rescued by Rimsky-Korsakov. Once completed and orchestrated, the opera was produced by an amateur group in St. Petersburg on February 21, 1886. Rimsky-Korsakov omitted some passages that were subsequently orchestrated by Ravel and Stravinsky; Shostakovich also produced his own version and orchestration of the opera.

pastel washes of sound

The first act of Khovanshchina begins at daybreak in front of a church in a Moscow square. The tranquil, pastel washes of sound in the introductory Prelude evoke, in the composer’s own words, “the growing light of the rising sun,” depicting a dawn on the Moscow River. As orchestrated by Rimsky-Korsakov, the principal theme is announced by an oboe against shimmering background of tremulous and divided strings before being taken up by other colorful instrumental combinations. The image of bells, signaling early Mass, infiltrates the music.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, timpani, tamtam, harp and strings

Program note by Mary Ann Feldman.

Sergei Rachmaninoff

Born: April 1, 1873, Oneg, Novgorod, Russia
Died: March 28, 1943, Beverly Hills, California

Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, Opus 23, arranged for Organ and Orchestra by Cameron Carpenter

In the spring of 1934 Rachmaninoff, then 61, and his wife moved into a villa they had just built on Lake Lucerne in Switzerland. They were delighted by the house, its opulent size and its view across the beautiful lake. Rachmaninoff was especially touched to find a surprise waiting for him there: the Steinway Company of New York had delivered a brand new piano to the villa.

a tune that beckons composers

Rachmaninoff spent the summer gardening and landscaping, and he also composed. Between July 3 and August 24 he wrote a set of variations for piano and orchestra on what is undoubtedly the most varied theme in the history of music, the last of Niccolo Paganini’s Twenty-Four Caprices for Solo Violin. Paganini had written that devilish tune, full of rhythmic spring and chromatic tension, in 1820, and he himself had followed it with 12 variations. That same theme has haunted composers through each century since—resulting in variations on it by Liszt (Transcendental Etudes), Schumann (12 Concert Etudes) and Brahms (the two sets of Paganini Variations) in the 19th century, followed in the 20th century by Witold Lutosławski, Boris Blacher and George Rochberg. And there may be more to come.

After considering several titles for his new work, the composer settled on Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, a title that places the focus on melody and somewhat disguises the ingenious variation-technique at the center of this music. The first performance, with the composer as soloist, took place in Baltimore on November 7, 1934, with Leopold Stokowski conducting the Philadelphia Orchestra. Pleased and somewhat surprised by the work’s reception, Rachmaninoff observed dryly: “It somehow looks suspicious that the Rhapsody has had such an immediate success with everybody.”

bravura solos, brilliant contrasts

The Rhapsody has a surprising beginning: a brief orchestral flourish containing hints of the theme leads to the first variation, which is presented before the theme itself is heard. This gruff and hard-edged variation, which Rachmaninoff marks Precedente, is in fact the bass line for Paganini’s theme, which is then presented in its original form by both violin sections in unison. Some of the variations last a matter of minutes, while others whip past almost before we know it (several are as short as 19 seconds). The 24 variations contrast sharply in both character and tempo, and the fun of this music lies not just in the bravura writing for keyboard but in hearing Paganini’s theme sound so different in each variation. In three of them, Rachmaninoff incorporates the old plainsong tune Dies Irae (Day of Wrath) used by Berlioz, Saint-Saëns and many others, including Rachmaninoff, for whom this grim theme was a virtual obsession. Here it appears in the solo part in the seventh and tenth variations, and eventually it drives the work to its climax.

Perhaps the most famous of Rachmaninoff’s variations, though, is the 18th, in which Paganini’s theme is inverted and transformed into a moonlit lovesong. The soloist states this variation in its simplest form, and then strings take it up and turn it into a soaring nocturne. The 18th variation has haunted many Hollywood composers, and Rachmaninoff himself noted wryly that he had written it specifically as a gift “for my agent.”

From here on, the tempo picks up, and the final six variations accelerate to a monumental climax. The excitement builds, the Dies Irae is stamped out by the full orchestra, and suddenly, like a puff of smoke, the Rhapsody vanishes before us on two quick strokes of sound.

“Rachmaninoff on steroids”

Today’s performance of the Paganini Rhapsody is unlike any ever heard at Orchestra Hall: Cameron Carpenter will perform his own version of the solo piano part on the International Touring Organ (ITO), a one-of-a-kind instrument built for Carpenter by digital organ pioneers Marshall & Ogletree. The ITO is billed as the world’s first truly artistic digital organ, with sophisticated technology that reproduces the sounds of the finest historical organs, providing Carpenter with great flexibility in performances spaces and in his concert repertoire.

Unveiled by Carpenter in a 2014 performance at New York’s Lincoln Center, the ITO features a modular five-keyboard console; a processing system that utilizes samples from several organs key to Carpenter’s artistic development; and a “geographic” concert audio system scalable to venues ranging from concert halls to nightclubs, as well as open-air use and television.

Carpenter’s version of the Rachmaninoff Paganini Rhapsody, which debuted on July 17, 2015, with the Shanghai Symphony Orchestra under the direction of Long Yu, takes full advantage of the ITO’s capacities while leaving all the orchestral parts as originally written. Carpenter explains:

“In transcribing Rachmaninoff’s great exploration of Paganini’s theme, I haven’t changed one note or phrase of the orchestral material. That is fortunate, since Rachmaninoff’s writing is incredibly economical, lacking any extra notes or gestures. In the piano part, many interior melodies, figures and other events are given greater tonal contrast on the organ than is possible in the piano, and the organ’s much larger dynamic range—obvious in any comparison between the piano in general with any large organ, but even more extreme in the case of the International Touring Organ—is exploited to the maximum.

“When performing this work on the organ, I think of it as a kind of darkly theatrical, sinister magnification of the original that exaggerates its dynamic and emotional heights and depths to even more extreme degrees, while emphasizing the music’s prolific counterpoint in a way that makes it clearer and more structurally obvious than in the original. It is intended to be Rachmaninoff on steroids: the organ’s powers of perspective and contrast, its ability to indefinitely sustain tone, and to crescendo, tremulate and otherwise alter held tones, afford many technical capabilities of which no piano or pianist is capable; and these are utilized to the full. Rooted in the Dies Irae, a natural match for the organ’s usual imagery, this version strives at moments to invoke a pall of mythic doom, while its sensuous moments should be supercharged with unheard-of horsepower.”

Instrumentation: solo organ with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, English horn, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, triangle, glockenspiel, harp and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Dmitri Shostakovich

Born: September 25, 1906, St. Petersburg, Russia
Died: August 9, 1975, Moscow, Russia

Symphony No. 5 in D minor, Opus 47

Shostakovich’s Fifth is at once the most popular symphony since Mahler and the most enigmatic. It was composed in the aftermath of the savage January 1936 attack by Pravda on Shostakovich’s opera Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District, which probably had been ordered by Stalin himself. Before that, Shostakovich had been the bright young star of Soviet music, hailed as a product of that system and acclaimed around the world for his witty, sardonic music. Now, virtually overnight, he found himself in disgrace, his career in ruins and he himself perhaps ticketed for a labor camp.

After a great deal of soul searching, Shostakovich composed his Fifth Symphony very quickly (between April 18 and July 20, 1937), and its triumphant premiere in Leningrad on November 21 of that year signaled his artistic and political rehabilitation. One of the most striking features of this music is Shostakovich’s return to classical form, a move that has signaled capitulation to some Western critics. But it may well be that Shostakovich felt that there was justice in the Pravda description of his music as “fidgety, screaming, neurotic,” and that his music did need greater balance, restraint and stability.

intense drama

There is a great deal of superb music in the Fifth Symphony. This is an intensely dramatic score, so powerful that it is easy to overlook the control and unity of Shostakovich’s writing.

moderato. The first movement opens with ominous canonic exchanges between string sections, and these give way to the violins’ quietly twisting main theme. Almost incidentally, Shostakovich introduces the simple rhythmic motif (short-short-long) that will saturate and unify the entire symphony. There follows a beautiful episode: over string accompaniment that pulses along on the rhythmic motif, first violins sing a melody full of wide leaps. But the wonder is that this peaceful theme, which sounds completely new, is actually a subtle transformation of the powerful canonic introduction to the Symphony. This sort of ingenious transformation of material marks the entire Fifth Symphony.

The entrance of the piano signals the beginning of the development. It has been said that in this symphony Shostakovich does not so much develop his material as brutalize it, and now themes that had been peaceful at their introduction are made shrill, almost hysterical in their intensity. The movement reaches a climax on a furious tamtam stroke as brass stamp out the rhythmic motif. After all this fury, Shostakovich resolves the tensions beautifully: the themes now return peacefully and, with its energy spent, the movement ends quietly.

allegretto. Many have felt the influence of Mahler in the bittersweet second movement that waltzes past in quickstep time. Much of the fun here lies in the instrumental color—the sardonic solo clarinet, the solo violin’s slides in the trio and the rattling sound of the xylophone.

largo. The third movement is more complex. Its scoring is unique: Shostakovich eliminates the brass, divides the strings into eight parts, and gives a prominent role to the harp, piano and celesta. He wrote this movement in one great arc, and the Largo features lean textures, an icy sound and some of his most beautiful melodies. It rises to a great climax, then falls away to end quietly on the spooky sound of harp harmonics.

allegro non troppo. Out of this quiet, the finale rips to life with pounding timpani, ringing brass and boundless energy; an angular second subject arrives in the solo trumpet over whirring strings. The militaristic bombast of this movement has bothered some listeners, but Shostakovich rescues it by his stunning transformation of this bluff beginning. Gradually these themes are made to slow down and sing, and material that had been strident on its first appearance yields unsuspected melodic riches in the subdued center section. Shostakovich gathers his forces and drives the symphony to a triumphant, if somewhat raucous, close in D major.

interpreting the music

Music this dramatic cries out for interpretation, and ideological critics on both sides of the Iron Curtain have been happy to supply violently divergent explanations of its “meaning.” Prompted by authorities to provide a politically correct program, Shostakovich obliged: “The theme of my symphony is the stabilization of a personality. In the center of this composition—conceived lyrically from beginning to end—I saw a man with all his experiences. The finale resolves the tragically tense impulses of the earlier movements into optimism and the joy of living.” So existential an explanation even led to this symphony’s being labeled the Hamlet Symphony in some Soviet circles.

More recently, the Fifth Symphony has become the locus classicus of what might be called “The Great Shostakovich Debate” between two groups: those who regard this symphony as sincere and consciously heroic, and those Western critics who wish to rescue Shostakovich from his past and are unwilling to accept the proposition that great music might have been composed under the Soviet system. These critics have been able to accept this symphony only by declaring the entire piece ironic. Its triumph, they say, is hollow, a conscious nose-thumbing at a political regime that insisted on happy endings from its artists.

To such extremes have ideological critics been driven by their politics—and it is clear that the Cold War lives on in the minds of those engaged in this debate. Perhaps, in this century, it may be possible to approach Shostakovich’s symphony as it should be understood: as music. Heard for itself, it remains an exciting work, satisfying both emotionally and artistically. Far from being a capitulation, Shostakovich’s Fifth Symphony marks a refinement of his musical language and an engagement with those classical principles that would energize his music for the next 40 years.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, E-flat clarinet, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, tamtam, triangle, glockenspiel, xylophone, harp, piano, celesta and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Audience spotlight: My unexpected connection with the Minnesota Orchestra

By audience member David Steinmeyer

On a pleasant evening in the spring of 1983, I attended a performance by the Minnesota Orchestra at the College of St. Catherine. On the program was the Armenian Suite by Armenian-American composer Richard Yardumian. I had never heard it before, and I didn’t know what to expect, but as the Orchestra performed it, I was completely captivated. The audience applause was vigorous, and I felt the strong desire to shout out “Play it again!” But logic prevailed and I kept my peace. At the third appearance of the conductor, onto the stage came the composer himself, Richard Yardumian! This was almost more than my heart could bear.

The next day I was on the phone to the record shops trying to find a recording of that piece, but to no avail. I then called the Minnesota Orchestra and explained my situation, and a helpful person suggested that I talk with the composer’s daughter, Miryam, who was on the staff of the Orchestra. “What? Can this be?” I thought. Well, it was true, and Miryam passed my request on to her father.

A couple weeks later in the mail I received an LP recording of the Armenian Suite, with an autographed greeting from the composer and a short note from his wife. I asked Miryam if I might pay her father for the recording, but she said that no, it was a gift. I felt strongly that I must somehow reciprocate, so being an amateur photographer I made an enlargement of a nature photo, A Grasshopper at the End of Summer, and sent it to him in a handmade redwood frame. On the back I wrote: “The same God who made the universe, and you and me, also made the grasshopper.”

Richard responded immediately with a very generous letter, which included some deep philosophical thoughts, indicating a superior intellect. He said he hoped we might get together someday soon for what he called “a discussion of truth,” but two years later he was dead. Now, decades later, I continue to be grateful for my contact with this creative genius, and I still love to hear the Armenian Suite. Thus began my strong connection with the Minnesota Orchestra, which is now like family to me.


David Steinmeyer is a subscriber, Laureate Society member and donor, as well as an amateur luthier and a clarinetist. The photo at top shows David and his wife Gwendolyn Steinmeyer.

Are you interested in sharing your own “Audience spotlight” story? We invite you to email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

Program Notes: Liszt Piano Concerto

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Wagner: Siegfried Idyll
The Siegfried Idyll, one of Wagner’s few purely instrumental works, is lovely, warm and melodic music. Conceived as a love token from the composer to his wife Cosima, it was premiered as a surprise to her on Christmas morning, with the musicians performing on the staircase to her bedroom.

Liszt: Piano Concerto No. 1
The powerful main theme of Liszt’s First Piano Concerto, punctuated each time by winds and brass, finds key moments to recur throughout the work’s four movements, which are played without pause. Among the musical highlights are the cascading notes in the piano cadenzas, the poetic Quasi adagio second movement and the unusually prominent use of the triangle.


Schumann: Symphony No. 2
Echoing Schumann’s own mental strife, the Second Symphony opens in a troubled, shadowy landscape, with many of its melodies wandering or melancholic. As it progresses, the music grows in confidence and concludes with emotional, triumphant gestures.

Full program notes:

Richard Wagner

Born: May 22, 1813, Leipzig, Germany
Died: February 13, 1883, Venice, Italy

Siegfried Idyll

An understanding of Wagner’s lovely Siegfried Idyll requires some knowledge of the details of that composer’s irregular personal life. In 1864, at the age of 51, Wagner began an affair with 27-year-old Cosima von Bülow, the daughter of Franz Liszt and wife of pianist-conductor Hans von Bülow. Wagner and Cosima’s daughter Isolde was born the following April, on the same day Bülow conducted the first rehearsal of Tristan and Isolde. All concerned agreed to keep details of the situation a secret, and the infant’s birth certificate listed Bülow as the father, Wagner as the godfather. Cosima bore Wagner two more children, a daughter Eva in 1867 and a son Siegfried in 1869, and moved in with him in 1868. Finally, in 1870—after a six-year relationship and three children—the couple was married.

a Christmas surprise

That fall, Cosima became aware that Wagner was working on a project he would not describe to her, and for good reason: it was to be one of the best surprises in the history of music. On Christmas morning, Cosima, asleep with 18-month-old Siegfried, awoke to the sound of music. Her husband had secretly composed and rehearsed a piece for small orchestra, and now that orchestra, arranged on the staircase leading to Cosima’s bedroom, gave this music its most unusual premiere.

This music was not just a token of love and a Christmas present, but also a birthday present: Cosima had turned 33 a few weeks earlier. It is based on themes from Wagner’s (at that time still unperformed) opera Siegfried, but it also uses a child’s cradle song and other themes with personal meaning for Wagner and Cosima. Their private title for the piece was Tribschen Idyll: they were living at Tribschen on Lake Lucerne in Switzerland at the time, and Cosima felt that the music was an embodiment of their life and love in these years. When in 1878, pressed for cash, Wagner had the music published under the now-familiar title Siegfried Idyll, Cosima confessed in her diary: “My secret treasure is becoming common property; may the joy it will give mankind be commensurate with the sacrifice I am making.”

As good love music should be, the Siegfried Idyll is gentle, warm, and melodic. Listeners familiar with the opera Siegfried will recognize some of the themes, all associated with the young hero Siegfried: his horn call, the bird call from the Forest Murmurs sequence, and others. Wagner also quotes, in the oboe near the beginning, the old cradle song “Sleep, Little Child, Sleep.” At its premiere, this music was performed on Cosima’s staircase by an orchestra of 15 players, though the bass player was around a corner and could not see Wagner conduct.

Instrumentation: flute, oboe, 2 clarinets, bassoon, 2 horns, trumpet and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Franz Liszt

Born: October 22, 1811, Raiding, Hungary
Died: July 31, 1886, Bayreuth

Concerto No. 1 in E-flat major for Piano and Orchestra

The sudden spurt in physical growth achieved by Beethoven’s Eroica Symphony presented Romantic-era composers with new problems in musical organization and form, problems that affected not only big pieces like Berlioz’s Symphonie fantastique, but also comparatively short ones such as Liszt’s First Piano Concerto.

Sketches for this concerto go back to about 1830, and Liszt worked on the score in the late 1840s and again in 1853. Still more revisions of detail followed the premiere, which took place at Weimar on February 17, 1855, with Liszt at the piano and Berlioz conducting.

understanding the concerto

Liszt’s lifelong exploration of musical form was most extraordinarily, most richly rewarded in his B-minor Piano Sonata of 1852-53, a work in which nobility of spirit, intellectual power and fascinatingly virtuosic writing exist in perfect equipoise. If the First Piano Concerto has never shared the intellectual respectability of the Sonata, or even of Liszt’s Second Piano Concerto of 1857-61, it is a piece pianists have always enjoyed playing and one that audiences love to hear.

It is said that Liszt and his son-in-law, the brilliant pianist and conductor Hans von Bülow, put words to the First Piano Concerto’s two opening measures: “Das versteht ihr alle nicht—haha!” (The German words conform to the rhythm, though the English translation does not: “None of you understand this—ha-ha!”)

The story sounds believable. Certainly Bülow never passed up an opportunity to express his sense of superiority. I cannot say what exactly he and Liszt had in mind. It is easy to be dazzled by the flying octaves in this concerto (after all, that is what they are for) and to take note of the unusual prominence accorded the triangle (and for some to take umbrage as well), and perhaps the point that Liszt and Bülow were trying to make, even if they were only talking to each other, is that there is more to the E-flat Concerto than that—more invention, more wit and more poetry. Liszt may have been one of the 19th century’s most exasperating underachievers, to say nothing of committing the unforgivable sin of success on a staggering scale, but he was a genius.

the music: ambiguous harmony, passion and drama

allegro maestoso. “Das versteht ihr alle nicht”—as goes Liszt and Bülow’s lyric—is a simple and powerful phrase for strings in octaves; “haha!” is a firm punctuation mark added by woodwinds and brass. Liszt repeats the phrase a step lower, leading to a startlingly different harmony. At this point, widening the harmonic horizons still further, the pianist makes his presence known in an imposing cadenza. There, in essence, is Liszt’s method for this astonishing movement, which is filled with harmonic ambiguity. Again and again he returns to his opening phrase; and each time it leads to something new, to a recitative, to a lyric melody, to thundering octaves, and finally to weightlessly glittering  passagework that ends the movement in a puff of smoke.

quasi adagio–allegretto vivace–allegro marziale animato. Liszt connects the second, third and fourth movements together without pause. He does not specify attacca in the transition from the first movement to the second, but it is clear that this is what he means. The strings lead off and suggest a melody that the piano then sings for us in full. This is one of Liszt’s most beautiful inspirations, full of passion and poetry.

When the passions have calmed, woodwind soloists present a new idea against a decorative background provided by piano and strings. But when the clarinet offers to bring back the great melody from the beginning of the movement, there is an interruption: silence, the ping of a triangle, and the dancing reply of plucked strings. Berlioz, on the podium at the concerto’s premiere, must have been delighted by this bow to his Faustian goblins.

Liszt breaks off this scherzo for a cadenza. The pianist recalls the beginning of the concerto, and suddenly those pages loom large again in a dramatic and developing restatement, which in turn opens the way for the martial finale.

Instrumentation: solo piano with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani, cymbals, triangle and strings

Program note excerpted from the late Michael Steinberg’s The Concerto: A Listener’s Guide (Oxford University Press, 1998), used with permission.

Robert Schumann

Born: June 8, 1810, Zwickau, Germany
Died: July 29, 1856, Endenich (near Bonn), Germany

Symphony No. 2 in C major, Opus 61

As Robert Schumann entered his 30s, he had established himself as a family man; thanks to an honorary degree from the University of Jena he was now Herr Doktor Schumann; and, no doubt with plenty of urging from his wife Clara, he was eager to prove himself in the more ambitious calling of the larger forms of the symphony, the string quartet and the oratorio.

Here we encounter the influence of Beethoven, as we will almost anywhere in a study of 19th-century instrumental music. In Schumann’s Symphony No. 1, the Spring Symphony, the debt to Beethoven is less direct, but more than once we hear echoes of Beethoven’s Fourth. In his great Symphony No. 2, Schumann confronted Beethoven the symphonist head-on. Like Beethoven’s Fifth, Schumann’s Second traces a course from adversity to triumph that most listeners in the day had no difficulty in recognizing. Schumann’s boldness was rewarded: This became the greatest of his symphonies, a judgment about which most mid-19th-century listeners found themselves in ready agreement.

The symphony’s premiere, however, was not a happy event. Felix Mendelssohn conducted the first performance at the Gewandhaus in Leipzig on November 5, 1846. The concert’s first half consisted of excerpts from Weber’s Euryanthe and Rossini’s William Tell, and Schumann’s symphony was performed by a tired orchestra and conductor to an audience too tired to absorb this difficult new work. Moreover, the William Tell Overture had been encored, and Schumann’s rancorous supporters accused those who had demanded the encore—and even Mendelssohn—of sabotaging his symphony.

music from convalescence

Schumann’s Symphony No. 2 is music written in convalescence. The composer began work on it in the latter part of 1845 and completed it the following year. He had suffered his first bout of what was then called “melancholia” in 1828, and more such sieges, many of them accompanied by frighteningly concrete suicide fantasies, followed in 1830, 1831, 1833, 1837, 1838, 1839 and 1842. His breakdown in August 1844, with trembling, tinnitus and phobias (especially with regard to heights and sharp metallic objects) was the worst of any.

Several years after this misery, he wrote to D. G. Otten, a conductor in Hamburg, that he feared the “semi-invalid state [could] be divined from the music [of the Second Symphony]. I began to feel more myself when I wrote the last movement and was certainly much better when I finished the whole work. All the same, it reminds me of dark days.”

the music: beautiful and enigmatic, with nods to the past

sostenuto assai–allegro ma non troppo. The Second Symphony starts with a slow introduction—not one that exudes assurance, but one that is troubled. Brass instruments sound a summons, but the music of the wandering strings casts strange shadows across it. The summons itself, the keynote and fifth note of the scale, is so simple as to be virtually a cliché. The Allegro, which this dark exordium struggles to find, is a jagged thing, pierced even on its last pages by the summons of the first measures.

This is an interestingly eccentric movement. The first theme is sharply rhythmic, with biting accents on the second of the three beats in each measure. The harmonies veer far to the flat side before settling in the dominant, G major, with a new theme, smooth in outline, urgent in expression. The exposition is very short, and the development, mostly concerned with material from the later part of the exposition, is about two and a half times as long. Schumann, I suspect, had been studying Beethoven’s Eroica. Similarly, the coda is extraordinarily and powerfully expansive.

scherzo: allegro vivace. To offset the intensity of the first Allegro, Schumann brings not the slow movement we expect, but a Scherzo. Like the one in the Spring Symphony, it has two trios. The first one here is rustic, while the other offers a touching blend of the dreamy and the learned.

The second trio also presents, first shyly, then with growing confidence, the name BACH (B-flat/A/C/B-natural, if you use the German names for the notes). Schumann had spent the recuperative months of 1845 in an intensive study of Bach, which he felt had greatly contributed to his recovery, and his two sets of fugues, Opus 72 and Opus 60 (the latter also on the name BACH), date from that time. On the Scherzo’s last page, the fanfare rings out in triumph. The Scherzo itself is the only out-and-out virtuoso piece among Schumann’s symphonies. In all probability, every violinist in every major orchestra today has had to play its opening page at his or her audition.

adagio espressivo. Neither of the two Schumann symphonies that preceded this one (the Spring and the first version of what we now know as No. 4) had a true slow movement; here Schumann gives us one of heart-stopping beauty.

allegro molto vivace. The finale is an original and extraordinary conception in expression and structure, and, I would say, a sign of marvelous mental health. It begins with a fierce rush of energy—to be specific, a scale followed by four chords—which clears the path for an athletic, jolly and perhaps surprisingly neutral first theme.

Next, the melody of the Adagio is revisited at high speed. The first theme returns briefly, after which the initial scale, followed now by six chords, provides fuel for a vigorous development, in which remembrances from the first and third movements also have a part to play.

This driving music sings to a quiet, spacious close in C minor. What follows is one of the most tenderly poetic moments in the whole symphonic literature. It turns out that the oboe had listened carefully, as we perhaps did not, to the way the four chords of the opening gesture turned into six. At any rate, it now transforms those macho chords into a lyric melody of the most poignant sweetness, the sense of distance and mystery being enhanced by the strangeness in this context of the key, E-flat major.

After a tremendous building over rolling drums and rushing scales, the melody appears in the strings as an all but literal quotation from Beethoven’s song cycle An die ferne Geliebte (To the Distant Beloved). This song had poignant significance in Schumann’s personal life. He had cited the same phrase in the glorious Piano Fantasy of 1836—a year of enforced physical separation from Clara. Now, in the mid-1840s, they were together as husband and wife, as parents of four children. But in some painful way, there was still a void between Lover and Beloved.

Nevertheless, the tender melancholy of this allusion is swept aside by gestures of triumph, by the sound of the C-major summons with which this beautiful and enigmatic symphony began. It might be some time before you realize that, while the opening four measure flourish assumed greater and greater significance throughout the finale, the “official” first and second themes had vanished from circulation altogether.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani and strings

Program note excerpted from the late Michael Steinberg’s The Symphony: A Listener’s Guide (Oxford University Press, 1996), used with permission.

Minnesota Orchestra launches new Mauer recording project

The Minnesota Orchestra and Music Director Osmo Vänskä on Sunday announced a brand-new initiative to record the music of Minnesota Twins first baseman Joe Mauer.

The new project follows on the heels of the Orchestra’s critically-acclaimed albums of symphonies by Beethoven, Sibelius and Mahler, and marks a bold new direction for the Orchestra, which is known for recording the music of major classical orchestral composers rather than music by former American League MVPs and three-time batting champions.

At an April 1 press conference, Minnesota Orchestra President and CEO Kevin Smith emphasized that the Mauer project is an extension of the Orchestra’s “Minnesota Model” strategic plan, which focuses on community engagement and a willingness to break industry molds with exciting, experimental undertakings. “We’ve been thrilled with the reaction to our collaborations with Minnesota natives like Dessa and Cloud Cult,” Smith said. “We think the Twin Cities community will respond enthusiastically to this cutting-edge partnership with one of our most famous homegrown talents: a brilliant singer-songwriter and part-time professional baseball player with killer sideburns, Joe Mauer.” Smith added that Mauer often sits out the Twins’ afternoon games on days that follow night games, which frees up time for him to rehearse at Orchestra Hall.

The Orchestra will hold the first Mauer recording sessions during the All-Star Break in mid-July 2018. Contingency plans are set in case Mauer is selected as a Twins representative at the All-Star Game in Washington, D.C.: in this event, the Orchestra would travel with Mauer to the nation’s capital and hold recording sessions at the Kennedy Center during the Home Run Derby. The sessions are scheduled to include Mauer’s orchestral arrangements of baseball standards such as Take Me Out to the Ballgame and The Star-Spangled Banner, along with the 2001 number one draft pick’s regular walk-up music What You Know by rapper T.I., plus original Mauer compositions including Target Field Tango, The Ex-Catcher’s Capriccio and Symphony No. 7 in E minor. The Orchestra will pay Mauer an undisclosed amount for a projected series of eight albums.

“When I first heard that we were going to record music by Joe Mauer, I wasn’t so sure,” said Music Director Osmo Vänskä. “He had so many hit singles in the first ten years of his career, but then there were some injuries. But he was very good again last year, and he even played a one-night-only gig in New York’s Yankee Stadium in October. So now is the perfect time to work with him.”

Mauer, who is busy this weekend on a concert tour in Baltimore, was unavailable for comment.

The events, personnel, recording projects and Major League Baseball activities portrayed above are strictly satirical. Article posted April 1, 2018.

Remember the Titans

by guest blogger Mandy Meisner

As the first tease of spring arrived with much anticipation, a friend and I spent the evening of March 16 at Orchestra Hall for a night of Weill and Mahler.

Project Opera greets us in the lobby, where a young soprano sings alone like a nightingale, perched before a flock of fellow songbirds. We gather in admiration, our hats and coats still on. It is a perfect prelude before we make our way to our seats.

Project Opera performing in the Orchestra Hall lobby.

The wind orchestra for Kurt Weill’s Violin Concerto looks small on stage, bringing a sense of intimacy. Erin Keefe walks out gracefully, her deep aqua coat flutters behind, complementing her auburn hair. The opening phrases weave intricately in and out from one another as the violin starts out very rhythmically and with determination. The music picks up speed, feeling frantic and urgent while the horn calls in ominous foreboding. The dark chaos gives way to lovely moments of vulnerability and reflection. We are overcome by the passion, adaptability and stamina demonstrated as the piece continues. We can see several hairs from her bow break free; they sway and punctuate as she plays to the interesting and turbulent end.

Concertmaster Erin Keefe at center stage in Weill’s Violin Concerto.

As the musicians enter the stage for Mahler’s Titan Symphony, we know it will be powerful. The second violins and cellos have swapped their usual places. Unexpectedly, there is more than the usual complement of trombones, but there are fewer trumpets. We quickly find out why when the symphony begins, wonderfully lush and mellow, as muted trumpets sound from afar in majestic call—from offstage. The effect is curious. The music feels like a leisurely ride on horseback, with a pastoral backdrop of rolling hills and birdsong. It works up into a climactic wash of sound, only to recede and grow again, we all sigh and hold our breath in wonder and gratitude.

From left to right: Clarinetist Timothy Zavadil, Associate Principal Clarinet David Pharris, Principal Clarinet Gabriel Campos Zamora and Principal Bassoon Fei Xie performing Mahler’s First Symphony.

The second movement starts with much energy, evolving into gooey phrases that stretch and arc before us, ending in joyful strength.

The third movement throbs with the heartbeat of the timpani as somber voices join in. It feels dark and mocking, and somehow familiar, though we don’t know why. It changes to the lilting sway of a dance, dying in near silence.

The final movement is frenzied disarray. It resolves to sweet, long phrases of melancholy, diminishing to mere whispers of sound, only to jump up in abrupt disbelief once again. The far-off, majestic horns call out, reminding us of more peaceful times. But this peaceful memory is not where we land; instead the music builds to an emotionally charged end that leaves our eyes shining.

The symphony speaks to this audience with raw emotion. We go absolutely wild, jumping to our feet, clapping furiously and shouting our adoration as if the musicians were rock stars.

Afterwards, we compose ourselves. We stand in a long line that snakes through the lobby, dreamily holding Mahler Sixth Symphony CDs to be signed by Music Director Osmo Vänskä.

Music Director Osmo Vänskä and Concertmaster Erin Keefe signing CDs for audience members. All photos with this story are by Greg Helgeson.

The anticipation of spring is replaced by the aftermath of incredible beauty.

Cloud Cult’s “Live Like You Mean It” Exhibit

In conjunction with Cloud Cult’s performances with the Minnesota Orchestra on April 7 and 8, Cloud Cult has created an interactive “Live Like You Mean It” art exhibit in Orchestra Hall’s lobby, free and open to the public on April 7 and 8.

This project, which is focused on the same topics as the April 7 and 8 concerts, was designed and created by Cloud Cult with support from the Minnesota Orchestra’s OH+ (Orchestra Hall Plus) program. The exhibit is intended to be experienced in sequence, starting with “The Walk of Ancestors” and ending with “The Wall of Joy.” The film installation “8 Minutes of Afterlife” overarches the exhibit.

8 Minutes of Afterlife (Near-Death Experience Film Installation)

The dictionary defines near-death experience as: “An unusual experience taking place during the process of death and recounted by a person after recovery, typically an experience that is described as ‘out-of-body.’”

On the main film screen you will see four individuals with different life backgrounds and from different parts of the world simultaneously sharing their near-death experiences. We chose these individuals from the archives of interviews of dozens of near-death experiences from around the world and compiled them together into this short film. The purpose is not only to contrast and compare their experiences, but also to highlight individuals who had not previously held a belief system that included any kind of afterlife. Although the details of each experience may vary, similar elements have been found to exist in nearly all near-death experiences, and in the individuals’ worldviews after recovery. Specifically, the most common ingredients in the actual experience include:

  1. A feeling of interconnectedness
  2. Unconditional love
  3. Timelessness

The most common changes to a person’s approach to life upon recovery are:

  1. An increased desire to live selflessly
  2. Gratitude
  3. Presence

Research of near-death experiences shows that even though there are differences in what is witnessed at the time of the experience, or what happens upon being “brought back,” that essentially the core foundations of the human experience of death are not that dissimilar. Even more so, there are many commonalities that seem connected, indicating that we may be more similar than we are different, even at the time of death.

The Walk of Ancestors

The “Walk of Ancestors” begins 100,000 generations ago when we were walking on two legs, and our brain size had grown substantially, allowing us to perceive the world in a whole new way. As you walk forward in this art installation, 40,000 years passes with every foot. But thousands of other lifeforms had already been evolving on the planet for nearly 3.8 billion years prior to the arrival of what we recognize as the first people. On this scale, if you would have started this 50 foot walk when all of life began, it would have been nearly 18 miles away. The end of this timeline is Modern Day, with the average lifespan representing about the width of a single hair.

The Wind Telephone

In Otsuchi, Japan, there is an art installation of a phone booth on a hill overlooking an area which was devastated by the tsunami of 2011 and the Great Japan Earthquake. The art piece was originally created by Itaru Sasaki to serve as a sort of memorial and communal space for families to connect with their ancestors and lost loved ones. The phone is meant to be a form of one-way communication. Visitors dial in their relative’s number and catch them up on their current life or express the feelings of missing them, loving them and wishing them well. Many find comfort in the hope that their loved one might hear them. This video is a collection of excerpts from an NHK World TV documentary titled The Phone of the Wind: Whispers to Lost Families and is meant, in part, to serve as an opening to the following installation.

Send a Message to Eternity

Inspired by Sasaki’s Wind Telephone installation, we’ve expanded on the idea to create a working sound booth in which you can speak into a phone we have specially designed to broadcast your personal message into outer space at the speed of light. Due to the vacuum of space, your transmission will continue to travel further and further out into the cosmos indefinitely. (NOTE: THIS BOOTH IS PRIVATE AND IS NOT MONITORED—your messages are between you and the Great Unknown). The phone is wired so that whatever a person wants to say, whether that message be to a deceased loved one or to any potential life out there, gets uplinked to an offsite 20-foot parabolic reflector that transmits a low-frequency electromagnetic wave into space at very high power (500-plus watt block up-converters).

Your message will travel at the speed of light which is 186,000 miles per second, or 5.8 trillion miles per year. Your message will take one second to get to the moon. In 8 minutes and 20 seconds, the transmission will reach the sun. It’ll take just a little over a day for your message to pass all of the planets and leave the solar system, and in 4 years it’ll reach the nearest star system Alpha Centauri. The electromagnetic wave will travel through the Milky Way Galaxy and into the distant heavens forever.

The Wall of Joy

The “Live Like You Mean It” exhibit concludes with an opportunity to share with your fellow concert-goers what matters most to you. Take a minute to think about what brings you true joy, or share something you’d like to accomplish yet in this life, be it specific goals of self-betterment, or some kind of experience you want to have in this life. We hope in doing so, that you are compelled to embrace the things you truly prioritize most from this life, and work towards giving them the attention they deserve. The goal is also to have a full wall of these wishes so we all can be inspired by seeing the priorities of our fellow human beings. As an end of the night snapshot of the evening, this wall highlights the best parts of humanity. Cloud Cult will save and compile these notes while the band brings this exhibit and concert to other orchestras around the nation.

Courage: A New Research Project

In addition to the exhibit, please also consider taking part in a new research project led by Professor Grace Yukich, a cultural sociologist who teaches at Quinnipiac University in Connecticut. Professor Yukich asks: What are you afraid of? What makes you feel courageous? “Courage in Uncertain Times” is a new research project exploring how people define fear and courage, and what inspires fear and courage in people’s lives. The project is looking for Cloud Cult fans to share their stories and reflections about fear and courage. Stop by Professor Yukich’s table in the lobby to learn more about the project, sign up for an interview, or participate in a short survey. You can also share your story by reaching out to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

If you or someone you know is going through a hard time, call the Crisis Hotline at 775-784-8090. The hotline is free and its representatives are there to help 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Cloud Cult thanks the Minnesota Orchestra for making this show happen!

Q&A with Symphony Ball Chairs Karen and Lloyd Kepple

Lights, camera, action! Symphony Ball 2018, “Sounds of the Cinema,” is bringing Hollywood magic to Orchestra Hall on Saturday, May 12, for a gala evening of film music, dining, auctions, dancing and good company, all for a great cause: your Minnesota Orchestra. Ball Chairs Karen and Lloyd Kepple share thoughts on Symphony Ball—the Orchestra’s largest annual fundraiser.

How did you pick the theme “Sounds of the Cinema”?

It came from our memories of all those special movies that have spoken to us and moved us. When we later hear the scores from those movies, perhaps on Saturdays on Minnesota Public Radio, the same emotions are summoned, and we’re reminded of how essential the score is to the overall impact of the movie. All sorts of fantastic ideas flowed from there.

How will this theme come to life?

We’re planning a red carpet experience, literally and figuratively! From walking on the red carpet, to a sumptuous meal in a Hollywood-style ballroom, to beautiful and exciting movie scores performed by our beloved Minnesota Orchestra, it will be a special and magical evening. We’ll also add a local twist as the Orchestra collaborates with the phenomenal jeremy messersmith. Other musicians and partners will tie in to the theme as well, including the Bryan Nichols Trio, Synergy, DJ Ander Other and Trivia Mafia.

Tell us about a few of your favorite film scores.

Our love of film music started with the Disney movies of our distant youth—Cinderella, Snow White, Pinocchio. More recently, that love relates to special films that hit an emotional sweet spot. For baseball-loving Lloyd, it’s Field of Dreams—especially the swell of James Horner’s magnificent score when Kevin Costner plays catch with his father. For Karen, it’s West Side Story, Dances with Wolves, The Sound of Music, and the classic song and dance movies of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. And then there are the Hitchcock films in which the music is the dramatic effect. We also love Dave Grusin’s score from On Golden Pond, which was released about the time we were married. We watch it together every few years—seeing it through a different lens each time as our marriage and life experiences evolve and mature.

What have been your connections to the Orchestra over the years?

When Lloyd was a young boy, his mother took him (by the ear) to hear the Orchestra in 1960, Stanislaw Skrowaczewski’s first year as music director. Karen’s parents also took their family to the Orchestra and insisted on each kid choosing at least one instrument to learn to play. Our shared love of music led us to attend many Orchestra concerts over the years. Then in 2009, Lloyd joined the Orchestra’s Board of Directors and our involvement increased significantly. As our connections have deepened, we’ve come to appreciate the fine musicians and the broader team that make the Orchestra a robust jewel of our community.

An especially wonderful moment came a few years ago when we, along with Lloyd’s mother, joined the Orchestra onstage for a rehearsal with Skrowaczewski conducting. It was 55 years after Lloyd’s mother took him to that first concert conducted by Stan, and this time Lloyd was able to return the favor with Stan still at the podium. As this year’s Symphony Ball Chairs, we’re honored to have the opportunity to give back to the broader community by leading our wonderful committee (including many musicians) in planning the Orchestra’s primary fundraising event.

Members of the 2018 Symphony Ball committee. Front row (left to right): Margee Bracken, Nancy Lindahl, Marilyn Carlson Nelson, Lloyd Kepple, Karen Kepple, Allison Hillman, Sue Zelickson, Emily Sumners Pyne and Mary Sumners. Back row (left to right): Warren Mack, Gary Cunningham, Laurie Greeno, Lynn Smith, Melodie Bahan, Douglas Wright, Kathy Junek, John Wilgers, Linda Murrell, Trudy Wilgers, Lisa Paradis, Rob Spikings, Akiko Fujimoto, Maureen Conroy, Grant Meachum, Bryan Pyne, Sarah Grimes, Desralynn Cole, Beatrice Blanc, Amy Lamphere, Michael Sutton, Marni Hougham, Charlie Anderson, Sanja DeGarmo, Paula DeCosse and Wendy Williams. Photo by Frank Merchlewitz.

What have you learned about film music from your experience as Ball Chairs?

One thing we’ve noticed since we chose the “Sounds of the Cinema” theme for is that we’ve been listening more carefully to the music in movies we’ve watched.  Rather than it being more subliminal, the music has become a focal point in our enjoyment of movies, even those for which the music isn’t overtly the focus, but is still just as essential. The movie experience would be incomplete without the musical score.

Are newcomers welcome at Symphony Ball?

Of course! This is a special and inclusive party to celebrate and support our world-renowned Orchestra and the wonderful community which we serve. This event is your event—open to all music lovers. Members of the community can support and join the celebration at multiple price points. Orchestra Hall is the place to be on May 12, 2018!

Visit for more information and to purchase tickets.

“The Best Conversation I Ever Had”

Assistant Conductor Akiko Fujimoto shares thoughts on her new Minnesota Orchestra position, running a good rehearsal, and the best conversation she ever had.

By Dan Wascoe

In the long history of orchestra conductors, Akiko Fujimoto can claim this unique distinction: During her debut leading the Minnesota Orchestra last November, she was ordered by a stripe-shirted referee into an on-stage penalty box. Her offense: delay of game caused by mischievous musicians. Her reaction: Holding her head in her hands and apparently weeping in despair.

It was, of course, scripted schtick. Minutes later, she returned to the podium to finish the concert in front of hundreds of school kids bused to Orchestra Hall. And although she couldn’t see them while she directed the musicians, several girls in the audience imitated her conducting gestures.

Such is the role of the Orchestra’s new assistant conductor—not only wielding a baton to keep scores of skilled musicians playing together with feeling, but doing the kind of community engagement that builds future audiences. If that requires a bit of slapstick by melding sports and music, that comes with the territory. So does introducing young listeners to musical chestnuts such as Flight of the Bumblebee and the da-da-da-DAH of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony.

About six weeks after Fujimoto’s debut, she led a mini-seminar for much older concert-goers by interviewing Principal Cello Tony Ross before an all-Tchaikovsky program. But there, too, she added a populist touch—playing a seldom-heard recording of Frank Sinatra singing an adaptation of a Tchaikovsky symphonic theme.

Problem Solving through Rehearsals

As the newest member of the conducting staff, Fujimoto nevertheless has enough experience to understand what she needs to succeed with various audiences, including the Orchestra itself.

“You can never be the one who’s stressed out,” she said, and orchestra members can tell in a hurry. She believes rehearsals should be a blend of priorities, sense of humor and a banishment of boredom. “To manage the sounds they create, you must be positive all the time,” she said. “Rehearsal is a time to come together.”

That’s not always easy because of the limited time available for rehearsals, so “I have to know what I want to address. It’s important to know what not to spend time on,” she said.

An example: She doesn’t dwell on “technical problems” of how musicians are playing—uniformity of bowing strokes by the strings or articulation by the winds—because at this level the musicians can resolve them on their own, perhaps with guidance from principal players in each section.

Because “there are infinite ways of performing even one note,” the crux of rehearsals is to “see where the disagreements are,” she said. Playing in an orchestra is “really a selfless act because you’re constantly accommodating someone else’s opinion….My job is problem-solving in the best way.” And because the orchestra is “very organized” with its own hierarchy, members must play as a team, she said: “There’s no room for prima donnas. They don’t last.”

Building a Life in Music

Born in Japan, Fujimoto began her music education with piano lessons. Then came general music appreciation, playing in a brass band and singing in a children’s chorus in elementary school. After moving to California with her family at age 14, she continued playing the trombone and singing in choruses. In high school, the faculty director “figured out that I could lead the choir in rehearsal and even let me conduct some Christmas carols in performance.” The same director suggested Fujimoto consider a career in music and conducting. It wasn’t an idea that bore immediate fruit.

“I laughed it off because I didn’t know what a career in music would look like,” she said. At that point she was more interested in child psychology.

But when she applied to Stanford University and was asked to write an essay about “the best conversation I’d ever had,” she drew on her Christmas carol performance experience.
“I described the magic moment when I felt connected with the musicians,” she said. Connecting nonverbally with eyes and hands was “the purest form of communication—the best ‘conversation’ I’d ever had.”

By her second year at Stanford “my psych grades were terrible,” she said, and she began taking introductory conducting classes. Gradually, she said, “the scale started to tip” toward music. After a summer conducting workshop before her junior year, the teacher said Fujimoto had potential and “that fall I switched to a music major.”

After Stanford, she attended a two-year program at the Eastman School of Music in New York where she earned a Master’s degree in conducting. The level of performance and creativity there “opened my eyes at a level I hadn’t experienced before. It was a huge shock, in a great way.”

Two more years at Boston University—and another Master’s degree—included “a lot of podium time” with the school’s orchestras. She also became assistant conductor of a mixed choir at Harvard University. Next came work with one of the student orchestras at Harvard. That led to a joint conducting position at the College of William and Mary and the Virginia Symphony.

The next step was five and a half seasons as associate conductor of the San Antonio (Texas) Symphony, a “really formative” experience because she conducted a wide range of music, including classics, pops, baroque and ballet and notably a program featuring violinist Gil Shaham playing Brahms’ Violin Concerto.

Fujimoto figures she’s “quite unusual — someone with this much experience coming into this job” with the Minnesota Orchestra. She also considers it unusual that she accrued 10 years of conducting in a liberal arts university setting rather than starting from a music conservatory base. Success here will mean growing professionally by “doing what the Orchestra needs me to do,” she said. That includes “covering” for subscription concerts by learning the music and preparing to substitute, if needed, for a scheduled conductor. She describes it as a combination of pinch-hitting, understudying and serving as an insurance policy.

So far, she said, “nobody’s missed a flight.”

Speaking of flights, one outcome of moving to Minnesota is living farther from her husband, Israel Getzov, a conductor and professor in Arkansas. They met during a conducting workshop but have never lived in the same place, she said.

Until that happens, she hopes that during her Minnesota tenure the Orchestra sees “that I have matured in my artistic expression.”

A Fabulous Fit

Roma Duncan, the Orchestra’s piccolo player, said that in Fujimoto’s short time in Minnesota, “One of the things I admire about her is that she really does have confidence and poise.”

That’s important, Duncan said, because “one of the tougher things a conductor does is to interact with soloists. The best can let the soloist’s vision come through.” After one rehearsal for that first November concert, in which Duncan had a solo, “she made me feel very confident. She was very adept, neither really leading or following us as much as she was with us,” imparting an organic “sense of ease.”

Women are showing up more frequently these days on orchestra podiums—Sarah Hicks, for example, is the Minnesota Orchestra Principal Conductor of Live at Orchestra Hall— and Duncan said, “I am really delighted Akiko is here. She’s very approachable, a pleasant person.”

She added that during final auditions for the new assistant conductor, Orchestra members “evaluated her as a conductor, not as a woman conductor.”

She is “a fabulous fit for our Orchestra,” said Duncan.

Jessica Leibfried, the orchestra’s director of education and community engagement, said the assistant conductor’s ability to handle many moving parts—including a script with an onstage penalty box—is important. For her first concert, Fujimoto helped tweak the script and asked for an additional rehearsal with the actors on the program.

“She came in with a clear plan about how to use her time,” Leibfried said. “She’s very calm and collected.”

Leibfried added that the assistant conductor’s role as a community ambassador in kids’ concerts and touring performances demands someone who “knows what she’s doing off the podium. The job doesn’t stop at the door.”

It helps, she said, that Fujimoto believes in collaboration, remembers names, greets board members and trusts the Orchestra staff to help her understand “what’s best for students.”

And, Fujimoto said she doesn’t mind if her young listeners applaud before a piece is over or even nod off. “It’s just great,” she said, “It’s so visceral.”


Dan Wascoe is a retired reporter and columnist for the Star Tribune in Minneapolis and co-founder of Nuance/a duo with vocalist Baibi Vegners.

Vikings Halftime Performance

The last time The Steeles played with MN Orch it was on the fifty-yard line! Watch it here in this tribute to Prince at the opening of the U.S. Bank Stadium.
And don't miss The Steeles performing w/Charles Lazarus and MN Orch in Our Love is Here to Stay, Apr 6. Only a few seats remain >>


Silver Linings

by Adam Kuenzel

When I got word that I had won the audition for principal flute in the Minnesota Orchestra, I felt like I’d won the lottery. Things seemed pretty straightforward: all I had to do from then on was play beautiful music with one of the best orchestras in the U.S. But I’m happy to find that it’s become more complex than that.

One of the most rewarding aspects of playing in this orchestra is getting to know members of the audience. I enjoy strolling around the Orchestra Hall lobby before a performance, welcoming concertgoers to the orchestra’s home. It’s inspiring to hear how profoundly our patrons revere the orchestra. Many of them speak about what we musicians add to their lives, and our conversations often center around accounts of earliest memories of attending concerts.

I joined the orchestra in 1990, a decade and a half after Orchestra Hall was built. I’ve spoken with many who began their relationship with the orchestra long before that, back when Northrop Auditorium was its home and Antal Dorati was music director in the late ’50s. Every conversation I have with an audience member adds to the rich mosaic of my experience with the orchestra. My favorite comment came from a longtime subscriber who was delighted to tell me in person how much she has enjoyed my playing since I joined the orchestra. And it only took us a quarter-century to meet face to face!

Often when I introduce myself, I’m met with surprise that an orchestra musician is taking time to greet patrons. And there are several of us. My colleague and fellow audience engagement enthusiast Brian Mount and I encourage and challenge one another to show up before concerts and welcome folks. It’s evolved into a friendly competition, in fact, complete with the associated boasting and teasing.

A silver lining resulting from the orchestra’s 16-month lockout was that my colleagues and I realized we depended upon the audience far more than we’d previously been aware. We would like everyone who comes to the Hall to feel that they are an honored guest, without whom the orchestra would be irrelevant.

I’m especially gratified to see newcomers (and relative newcomers) at our concerts. Occasionally someone will apologetically explain to me that they don’t really know or understand enough about “classical music.” My response is: “That’s okay! I didn’t know anything about music either when I started going to concerts.” In fact, after having been in the profession for 33 years, I think a listener without much technical knowledge is at an advantage in being able to receive the most visceral and emotional impact of the music.

Conversations sometimes aren’t about music or the orchestra. I recently spoke with a civil engineer at a Thursday morning concert and asked him about his impressions of the lobby. He pointed out the structural techniques utilized to maximize open space in a multilevel area. While everyone has their own perspective, I think the design achieves at least one important goal: to provide a spacious and welcoming area where people can meet and relax before a performance.

Even the auditorium itself does double duty—primarily as our performance space, but also as a place to gather socially after our casual “Symphony in 60” concerts. Following these one-hour performances, my colleagues and I invite the audience onstage to meet and mingle. Bassist Kathryn Nettleman shared with me that she’s happiest playing concerts when she has a chance to meet and talk with listeners before or afterward. She said it reminds her of what’s most important about what we do.

Adam Kuenzel, right, and tuba player Jason Tanksley, center, meeting Minnesota All-State Orchestra students in the Orchestra Hall lobby in February 2018. Photo by Tony Nelson.

The history of the Minnesota Orchestra can be read as a list of accomplishments; a succession of music directors, musicians, board members and administrators; a legacy of tours and recordings. But that’s only part of the story. The history that lives are the moments when audience and orchestra together experience the music that we cherish. Learning your personal stories and offering my sincere gratitude for your participation is valuable and enriching. Aside from playing the flute, it’s my favorite part of the job.

Adam Kuenzel at center stage in a performance of Bach’s Orchestral Suite No. 2 in November 2017. Photo by Courtney Perry.

Principal Flute Adam Kuenzel joined the Minnesota Orchestra in 1990 and is regularly featured as a soloist, including in world premieres of music by Stanislaw Skrowaczewski and Manuel Sosa. He recently premiered Laura Schwendinger’s Aurora for flute and piano, which was commissioned by the National Flute Association for its convention in Minneapolis.

Program Notes: Vänskä Conducts Mahler's Titan Symphony

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Weill: Violin Concerto

Weill reimagines the concerto as a dialogue between violin and wind band, incorporating Baroque and contemporary influences for a cool 1920s edge. The solo violin is alternately singer and master of fireworks.


Mahler: Symphony No. 1, Titan

Mahler’s First Symphony opens with evocations of birdsong and nature, then gives way to rhythms of a rustic dance, alternately vigorous and graceful. Darker themes rise, but so do exquisite melodies (and a wonderful minor-key nod to Frère Jacques), as energy builds toward the thrilling conclusion.

Full program notes:

Kurt Weill

Born: March 2, 1900, Dessau, Germany

Died: April 3, 1950, New York City

Concerto for Violin and Wind Orchestra, Opus 12

Weill composed his Violin Concerto in April and May of 1924. The 24-year-old composer could not have imagined what lay ahead: his ever-troubled but essential marriage, the stunning success of The Threepenny Opera, Hitler, emigration, struggles in Hollywood, and his triumphant reinvention of himself as the American composer of Lady in the Dark, One Touch of Venus and Street Scene.

a young composer finds his voice

If I were challenged to come up with a capsule characterization of Weill’s Violin Concerto, I might say “thoroughly and diversely engaging, quirky at times, with touching pages that perhaps take you by surprise.” Yet when the ink was scarcely dry, Weill described it as a “somewhat rough, abstract, completely dissonant piece,” adding for good measure that one needed to have “willingly digested a good portion of Schoenberg” in order to understand the music—an indication of how much Weill was then under the Viennese composer’s spell.

Weill, the son of a cantor, had studied in Berlin with Ferruccio Busoni, from whom he got a rock-solid technical foundation, a sense of artistic integrity and something of his own neo-Classic ideal. His hope had been to work with Schoenberg, but he could not afford the move to Vienna. The young Weill’s technical adroitness and elegance are Schoenbergian, and you can understand why that tough master was eager to take the young man on as a pupil. But I hear no direct musical influence from that source, and the music does not sound in the least like Schoenberg’s. A voice that might come to mind is Paul Hindemith’s. Like many composers of his generation, Weill found Hindemith a stimulating model, and if Weill’s Concerto has a close cousin, the place to find one would be among Hindemith’s series of delightful Kammermusiken (Chamber Musics) for various solo instruments with small orchestra, his “Brandenburgs.”

Not surprisingly, Weill’s choice of instrumentation—the stringless orchestra except for double basses—does much to define the special character of his Violin Concerto. Stravinsky’s Concerto for Piano and Winds comes from 1924 and perhaps helped turn Weill’s mind in this direction. That predominant wind sonority is “1920s cool,” and the solo violin, when it is not engaged in super-athleticism, contributes a sound—and with that sound a feeling—that raises the temperature, the intensity, a certain immediacy with each entrance. The harmony is sturdily tonal at the skeleton level, but on the surface Weill is not shy about using all 12 notes of the chromatic scale. The athletic soloist, whether negotiating the Bach-like jungle gyms of broken chords or whizzing up and down scales with dazzling bravura, will be particularly aware of that.

The concerto was premiered on June 11, 1925, in Paris by Marcel Darrieux and the Orchestre des Concerts Walther Straram, with Straram conducting. There are three movements, though I found it interesting, in a way even clarifying, when I read a review of the premiere, in which the writer, the eminent Henri Prunières, described the concerto as a two-movement work with a long intermezzo (actually longer than the two “real” movements).

the concerto in brief

Weill begins with a sweetly melancholic duet for clarinets, a few winds and snare drums softly marking the beat beneath. (If you know The Seven Deadly Sins you will recognize the sound.) At the surface level the music becomes faster and faster, finally to subside into the opening clarinet music again, now heard and felt as an epilogue. The violinist alternates in the roles of master of fireworks and of singer. The English writer David Drew, who knows more about Weill than Weill himself did, hears strains of the Gregorian Dies irae in this movement: I myself can barely detect this, but gladly yield to his greater knowledge.

What Prunières heard as an intermezzo is a miniature three-movement suite: Notturno, Cadenza, Serenata. (In making a chain of three more or less standard movement types, is Weill wittily in debt to the tango-waltz-ragtime sequence in Stravinsky’s Soldier's Tale?) The Notturno, far from a Chopinesque or Debussyian nightscape, approaches the moods of The Threepenny Opera. The trumpet has much to do in the accompanied or at least much punctuated cadenza. The Serenata is rhythmically playful. The blurred borders between the ghostly and the humorous suggest that the spirit of Mahler is not far away. The finale is crisp, brilliant, dancy.


solo violin with orchestra comprising 2 flutes (2nd doubling piccolo), oboe, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, trumpet, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, triangle, xylophone and double basses

Program note by the late Michael Steinberg, used with permission.

Gustav Mahler

Born: July 7, 1860, Kalischt, Bohemia

Died: May 18, 1911, Vienna, Austria

Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Titan

Mahler’s First Symphony is one of the most impressive first symphonies ever written, and it gave its young creator a great deal of trouble. He began it late in 1884, when he was only 24, and completed a first version in March 1888. But when it was first performed—to a mystified audience in Budapest on November 20, 1889—it had a form far different from the one we know today. Mahler would not even call it a symphony. For that first performance, when he called it Symphonic Poem, it was in two huge parts: three movements that made up “Days of Youth” and two more for what he called the “Human Comedy.”

Mahler had a love-hate relationship with verbal explanations of his music, denouncing them one moment and releasing new ones the next. As Mahler revised the symphony, he began to let slip quite different hints about the “meaning” of this music. At one point he called it the Titan, borrowing the title of Jean Paul Richter’s novel about a wild young hero who feels lost in this world. He also inserted several themes from his just-completed Songs of a Wayfarer, which are about his recovery from an ill-fated love affair.

But when he finally published this symphony in 1899, he had cut it to four movements, greatly expanded the orchestration, and suppressed all mention of the Titan or any other extra-musical associations. Now it was simply his Symphony No. 1.

the music: an epic journey

langsam, schleppend (slow, dragging). The very beginning—Mahler asks that it be “like a nature-sound”—is intended to evoke a quiet summer morning, and he captures that hazy, shimmering stillness with a near-silent A six octaves deep. The effect is magical, as if we are suddenly inside some vast, softly-humming machine. Soon we hear twittering birds and morning fanfares from distant military barracks. The call of the cuckoo is outlined by the interval of a falling fourth, and that figure will recur throughout the symphony, giving shape to many of its themes. Cellos announce the true first theme, which begins with the drop of a fourth—when Mahler earlier used this same theme in his Wayfarer cycle, it set the disappointed lover’s embarking on his lonely journey: “I went this morning through the fields, dew still hung upon the grass.” A noble chorus of horns, ringing out from a forest full of busy cuckoos, forms the second subject, and the brief development leads to a mighty restatement of the Wayfarer theme and an exciting close.

kräftig bewegt (with powerful movement). The second movement is based on the ländler, the rustic Austrian waltz. Winds and then violins stamp out the opening dance, full of hard edges and stomping accents, and this drives to a powerful cadence. Out of the silence, the sound of a solo horn rivets our attention—and nicely changes the mood. The central section is another ländler, but this one sings beautifully, its flowing melodies made all the more sensual by graceful slides from the violins. The movement concludes with a return of the opening material.

feierlich und gemessen, ohne zu schleppen (solemn, measured, without dragging). In Mahler’s original Symphonic Poem, this movement opened the second part of the symphony. Deliberately grotesque, this music was inspired by a woodcut picturing the funeral of a hunter, whose body is borne through the woods by forest animals—deer, foxes, rabbits, shrews, birds—celebrating his death with mock pageantry. Over the timpani’s quiet tread, solo bass violin plays a lugubrious little tune that is treated as a round, a minor-key variation of the children’s song Frère Jacques.

The first episode lurches along sleazily over an oom-pah rhythm; Mahler indicates that he wants this played “with parody,” and the music echoes the klezmer street bands of Eastern Europe. But a further episode brings soft relief: muted violins offer another quotation from the Wayfarer songs, this time a theme that had set the words “By the wayside stands a linden tree, and there at last I’ve found some peace.” In the song cycle, these words marked the disappointed lover’s escape from his pain and his return to life. The march returns, and the timpani taps this movement to its nearly silent close.

stürmisch bewegt (with violent movement). Mahler said of this violent music: “the [last] movement then springs suddenly, like lightning from a dark cloud. It is simply the cry of a deeply wounded heart, preceded by the ghastly brooding oppressiveness of the funeral march.” Mahler’s original title for this movement was “From Inferno to Paradise,” and this description does reflect the progress of the finale, which moves from the seething tumult of its beginning to the triumph of the close.

Longest by far of the movements, the finale is based on two main themes: a fierce, striving figure in the winds near the beginning and a gorgeous, long-lined melody for violins shortly afterwards. The development pitches between extremes of mood as it drives to what seems a climax but is in fact a false conclusion. The music seems lost, directionless, and now Mahler makes a wonderful decision: back comes the dreamy, slow music from the symphony’s very beginning. Slowly this gathers energy, and what had been gentle at the beginning now returns in glory, shouted out by seven horns as the symphony smashes home triumphantly in D major, racing to the two whip-cracks that bring it to a thrilling conclusion.

conflicting signals

What are we to make of Mahler’s many conflicting signals as to what this symphony is “about”? Is it about youth and the “human comedy”? Is it autobiographical, the tale of his recovery from an unhappy love affair?

Late in his brief life, when he conducted this work with the New York Philharmonic in 1909, Mahler suggested yet another reading. He wrote to his disciple Bruno Walter that he was “quite satisfied with this youthful sketch….What a world this is that casts up such reflections of sounds and figures! Things like the Funeral March and the bursting of the storm which follows it seem to me a flaming indictment of the Creator.”

In the end, we must throw up our hands in the face of so much contradictory information. Perhaps it is best just to settle back and listen to Mahler’s First Symphony for itself—and the mighty symphonic journey that it is.

Instrumentation: 4 flutes (3 doubling piccolo), 4 oboes (1 doubling English horn), 4 clarinets (1 doubling bass clarinet and E-flat clarinet, 1 doubling E-flat clarinet), 3 bassoons (1 doubling contrabassoon), 7 horns, 5 trumpets, 4 trombones, tuba, 2 timpani, bass drum, cymbals, gong, triangle, harp and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.


Program Notes: Debussy's La Mer

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Lyadov: The Enchanted Lake
Lyadov loved writing about “the realm of the non-existing”—here, a magical lake, misty, moonlit and shimmering.

Rachmaninoff: Piano Concerto No. 3
This concerto balances moments of song-like simplicity and thunderous virtuosity. The opening Allegro is subtle and soulful, while the latter movements offer catchy themes, ingenious variations and a feather-light waltz.


Respighi: The Fountains of Rome

Respighi desired to make the fountains of Rome sing in his four-movement symphonic poem that ranges from plaintive and gentle to triumphant and bold. Each movement celebrates a particular fountain and its own unique environment, and each at a different moment of day from dawn to dusk.

Debussy: La Mer

Debussy’s classic oceanic portrait recreates the feeling of a visit to the sea. Two slower movements surround a scherzo as a kaleidoscopic stream of musical fragments eventually builds to a stormy, dissonant close.

Full program notes:

Anatol Lyadov

Born: Born: May 11, 1855, St. Petersburg, Russia

Died: August 28, 1914, Novgorod, Russia

The Enchanted Lake, Opus 62

Born into a musical family in St. Petersburg, Anatol Lyadov studied with Rimsky-Korsakov and was invited to join the faculty of the St. Petersburg Conservatory at age 23. However, for all his talent and training, he was notoriously unable to produce music. Some of this was the product of self-doubt—but he was also lazy. In the most infamous illustration of this, Lyadov had been Diaghilev’s original choice to compose the music for the Ballets Russes’ new production of The Firebird in 1910. But when Lyadov could not deliver, Diaghilev turned to an unknown young composer named Igor Stravinsky, and the course of music was changed.

“give me a fairy tale…”

As a composer, Lyadov was essentially a miniaturist, best remembered for his short piano pieces like The Musical Snuffbox. Perhaps understandably, the larger forms proved difficult for him: he wrote no operas, no symphonies, no concertos, no chamber music—his output consists exclusively of a few brief orchestral works, choral music, songs and piano pieces. Lyadov, who was very interested in Russian folk music, was happiest when he could enter the magical dream-world of folk legend. He once said: “My ideal is to find the unearthly in art. Art is the realm of the non-existing. Art is a figment, a fairy tale, a phantom. Give me a fairy tale, a dragon, a water sprite, a wood demon—give me something that is unreal, and I am happy.”

In about 1905, Rimsky-Korsakov, trying to get Lyadov to produce something worthy of his talents, suggested that he write an opera on folk legends. Lyadov liked the idea and made some sketches. And though he abandoned the project, those sketches turned into two brief orchestral pieces that have become his most popular works: both The Enchanted Lake and Kikimora spring from that “realm of the non-existing” where Lyadov was happiest.

The Enchanted Lake, first performed in 1909, is a mood-piece, muted and evocative rather than crowded with incident or drama—and one can understand why Diaghilev thought Lyadov might have been right for The Firebird. The shimmering sounds of the opening set exactly the right mood for Lyadov’s portrait of the magical lake, and throughout this brief piece he shifts colors deftly, so that his lake is by turns misty, moonlit and murmuring as the music makes its way to the subdued close.

Instrumentation: 3 flutes, 2 oboes, 3 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, timpani, bass drum, harp, celesta and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Sergei Rachmaninoff

Born: April 1, 1873, Semyonovo, district of Starorusky, Russia

Died: March 28, 1943, Beverly Hills, California

Concerto No. 3 in D minor for Piano and Orchestra, Opus 30

In October 1906 Rachmaninoff moved from Moscow to Dresden with his wife and their daughter, Irina, aiming to take himself out of circulation. He was a busy pianist and conductor—he had just concluded two years as principal conductor at the Bolshoi Opera—and he longed for time just to write. But as offers to play and conduct kept coming in, he decided to accept an invitation to visit the United States. It was for this tour that he wrote his Third Piano Concerto, and on November 28, 1909, he introduced it with Walter Damrosch and the New York Symphony. Soon after he played it again, and to his much greater satisfaction, with the New York Philharmonic under Gustav Mahler, another conductor struggling to find time to compose.

the music: from simplicity to virtuosity

allegro ma non tanto. Rachmaninoff invented arresting beginnings for all his works for piano and orchestra. In the first measure of the Third Concerto we find a quality we do not usually associate with Rachmaninoff: simplicity. For two measures, clarinet, bassoon, horn, timpani and muted strings set up a pulse against which the piano sings—or is it speaks?—a long and quiet melody, the two hands in octaves as in a Schubert piano duet. It is a lovely inspiration, that melody unfolding in subtle variation, just a few notes being continually redisposed rhythmically. Once only, to the extent of a single eighth note, does melody exceed the range of an octave; most of it stays within a fifth.

The accompaniment cost Rachmaninoff considerable trouble. He was thinking, he said, of the piano singing the melody “as a singer would sing it, and [finding] a suitable orchestral accompaniment, or rather, one that would not muffle this singing.” What he found invites, for precision and delicacy, comparison with the workmanship in Mozart’s concertos. The accompaniment does indeed let the singing through, but even while exquisitely tactful in its recessiveness, it is absolutely specific—a real and characterful invention, the fragmentary utterances of the violins now anticipating, now echoing the pianist’s song, the woodwinds sometimes and with utmost gentleness reinforcing the bass or joining the piano in a few notes of its melody. The further progress of the movement abounds in felicities and ingenuities, sharply imagined and elegantly executed.

intermezzo: adagio. “Intermezzo” is a curiously shy designation for a movement as expansive as this, though we shall discover that it is in fact all upbeat to a still more expansive Finale. It is a series of variations, broken up by a feather-light waltz. The clarinet-and-bassoon melody of the waltz is close cousin to the concerto’s principal theme, and the piano’s dizzying figuration, too, is made of diminutions of the same material.

finale: alla breve. When the Intermezzo yields to the explosive start of the Finale, we again find ourselves caught up in a torrent of virtuosity and invention. Rachmaninoff gives us the surprise of a series of variations on what pretends to be a new idea but is in fact an amalgam of the first movement’s second theme and the beginning of the finale. His evocations of earlier material are imaginative and structural achievements on a level far above the naive quotation-mongering of, say, César Franck or even Dvořák.

Rachmaninoff was anxious to put his best foot forward in America. His Second Concerto had already been played in New York, and Rachmaninoff wanted his new work to convey a clear sense of his growing powers as composer and pianist. It does have features in common with the Second: the sparkling, dense, yet always lucid piano style, a certain melancholy to the song, an extroverted rhetorical stance, the apotheosized ending, even the final YUM-pa-ta-TUM cadential formula that is as good as a signature. But the differences are even more important, and they are essentially matters of ambition and scope. The procedures that hold this work together are far beyond the capabilities of the composer of the Second Concerto eight years earlier.

Also, much more is asked of the pianist. The Third Concerto makes immense demands on stamina, the orchestral passages that frame the Intermezzo being the soloist’s only moments of respite. Rachmaninoff sees the soloist not merely as someone who can sing soulfully and thunder imposingly, but as an alert, flexible, responsive musician who knows how to listen, blend and accompany. And even in this non-prima-donna role the challenge is greater here than in the Second Concerto.

Instrumentation: solo piano with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, suspended cymbal and strings

Program note excerpted from the late Michael Steinberg’s The Concerto: A Listener’s Guide (Oxford University Press, 1998), used with permission.

Ottorino Respighi

Born: July 9, 1879, Bologna, Italy

Died: April 18, 1936, Rome, Italy

The Fountains of Rome

Ottorino Respighi’s three sets of Roman tone poems—The Fountains of Rome (1916), The Pines of Rome (1924) and Roman Festivals (1928)—are among the most popular of all orchestral works, but their early success was precarious, and the discouraged composer almost abandoned the concept. In 1916 Respighi, then a professor of composition at the Conservatory of St. Cecilia in Rome, composed a suite for orchestra inspired by four of Rome’s striking fountains. The composer had high hopes for this music, but with an apparently indifferent performance, it fell flat at its premiere in March 1917.

When Arturo Toscanini saw the score he asked to perform it at a concert in Rome to benefit Italian artists wounded in World War I. Respighi was too demoralized to attend, and predictably, Toscanini’s performance in February 1918 was so incandescent that it swept the audience away. The firm of Ricordi published the score, and The Fountains of Rome quickly established an international reputation for its surprised composer.

expressing “sentiments and visions”

The influences on the Roman trilogy have often been noted. Respighi’s studies with Rimsky-Korsakov show up in the sumptuous sound of the orchestra, while Richard Strauss’ tone poems provide the model for this sort of orchestral pictorialism. Yet Respighi transcends those influences: he writes for a larger, more varied orchestra than Rimsky-Korsakov ever used, and his musical aims are different from those of Strauss. While Strauss used the orchestra to tell a story, Respighi is not so much interested in musical narrative as he is in creating atmosphere.

And Respighi was a master at evoking atmosphere. He made his intentions clear in a preface to the score: “In this symphonic poem the composer has endeavored to give expression to the sentiments and visions suggested to him by four of Rome’s fountains, contemplated at the hour in which their character is most in harmony with the surrounding landscape, or in which their beauty appears most impressive to the observer.”

synopses from the composer

In the score, Respighi also provided brief synopses of the four movements of The Fountains of Rome, which are played without pause.

the Fountain of Valle Giulia at dawn. The first part of the poem, inspired by the Fountain of Valle Giulia, depicts a pastoral landscape; droves of cattle pass and disappear in the fresh, damp mists of a Roman dawn.

the Triton Fountain in the morning. A sudden loud and insistent blast of horns above the trills of the whole orchestra introduces the second part, the Triton Fountain. It is like a joyous call, summoning troops of naiads and tritons, who come running up, pursuing each other and mingling in a frenzied dance between the jets of water.

the Fountain of Trevi at mid-day. Next there appears a solemn theme, borne on the undulations of the orchestra. It is the Fountain of Trevi at mid-day. The solemn theme, passing from the woodwinds to the brass instruments, assumes a triumphal character. Trumpets peal; across the radiant surface of the water there passes Neptune’s chariot, drawn by seahorses and followed by a train of sirens and tritons. The procession then vanishes, while faint trumpet blasts resound in the distance.

the Villa Medici Fountain at sunset. The fourth part, the Villa Medici Fountain, is announced by a sad theme, which rises above a subdued warbling. It is the nostalgic hour of sunset. The air is full of the sound of tolling bells, birds twittering, leaves rustling. Then all dies peacefully into the silence of the night.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, English horn, 2 clarinets, bass clarinet, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, cymbals, suspended cymbal, triangle, glockenspiel, chimes, 2 harps, piano, celesta, organ and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

Claude Debussy

Born: August 22, 1862, Saint-Germain-en-Laye, France

Died: March 25, 1918, Paris, France

La Mer

In the summer of 1903, the 41-year-old Debussy took a cottage in the French wine country, where he set to work on a new orchestral piece inspired by his feelings about the sea. To André Messager he wrote, “I expect you will say that the hills of Burgundy aren’t washed by the sea and that what I’m doing is like painting a landscape in a studio, but my memories are endless and are in my opinion worth more than the real thing, which tends to pull down one’s ideas too much.”

the sea as a concept

Had Richard Strauss written this work, he would have made us hear the thump of waves along the shoreline, the cries of wheeling sea-birds, the hiss of foam across the sand. Debussy’s aims were far different: he wanted this music to give us the feeling of being in the ocean’s presence, to feel the idea, particularly his own idea, of the ocean. Thus La Mer sets out not to make us see whitecaps—but to awaken in us a sense of the sea’s elemental power and beauty.

La Mer consists of two moderately paced movements surrounding a scherzo, created from seeming fragments of musical materials. We discover hints of themes, rhythmic shapes and flashes of color that reappear throughout the work, like kaleidoscopic bits in an evolving mosaic of color and rhythm.

from dawn to noon on the sea. The work begins with a murmur, quiet yet strong. Out of darkness, glints of color and motion emerge, and solo trumpet and English horn share a fragmentary tune that will also return in the final movement. As the morning brightens, the music becomes more animated, and a wealth of ideas follows: swirling rhythms, a noble horn chorale, a dancing figure for the cello section. At the movement’s close, the horn chorale builds to an unexpectedly powerful climax. Out of this splendid sound, a solitary brass chord winds the music into silence.

play of the waves. Opening with shimmering swirls of color, the second movement is brilliant, dancing and surging throughout—it has a sense of fun and play, as a scherzo should. One moment it can be sparkling and light, the next it will surge up darkly. In the delicate close, solo instruments seem to evaporate into the shining mist.

dialogue of wind and sea. The mood changes sharply at the beginning of the final movement, which Debussy specifies should sound “animated and tumultuous.” The ominous growl of lower strings prefaces a restatement of the trumpet tune from the very beginning, and soon the horn chorale returns as well. Woodwinds sing gently and wistfully before the music builds to a huge explosion. Moments later their tune returns in a touch of pure instrumental magic: against rippling harps and the violins’ high harmonics, solo flute brings back this melody with the greatest delicacy. The effect is extraordinary—suddenly we feel a sense of enormous space and calm. Yet within seconds this same shape roars out with all the power of the full orchestra. Earlier themes are recalled and whipped into the vortex as the music hurtles to a tremendous climax, with dissonant brass shrieking out the final chord.

Debussy may be popularly identified as the composer of “impressionistic” moods, full of muted color and subtle understatement. The conclusion of La Mer, however, is anything but the music of water lilies: it is driven by a force beyond human imagination. The normally understated Debussy makes us feel that wild strength in the most violent ending he ever wrote.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, English horn, 2 clarinets, 3 bassoons, contrabassoon, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 2 cornets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, bass drum, cymbals, tamtam, triangle, glockenspiel, 2 harps and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.

I'm No Expert

Something funny has happened. People assume I know a lot about music.

Maybe I shouldn’t be surprised. After all, I’ve been regularly writing about the Minnesota Orchestra for the online version of Showcase, recapping concerts, interviewing musicians and even observing a rehearsal. Understandably, people might think I have expertise in this field—but really, I don’t.

It’s not that I’m completely ignorant. I went to an arts high school as a music student, managed to play flute in the top-level orchestra of Minnesota Youth Symphonies, and studied with some amazing teachers. But I was a bit of a laggard, only getting serious about my studies in my later years of high school. That was a long time ago, and it’s pretty much where my music education ended.

Fast-forward to the present. I’d been blogging for years, covering topics of interest to various communities, but never on a consistent theme. Feeling nostalgic one day, I wrote about my MYS days playing under Manny Laureano, the Minnesota Orchestra’s principal trumpet. I pitched it to the Orchestra’s editor and was invited to write more.

Repeatedly writing about a specific subject—particularly an art form and an ensemble I revered—was intimidating, and it was something I had never done before. But I decided to embrace my good luck, get over my nerves and give it my all.

I started telling people about my blogs. About our Orchestra. About our musicians. And then the questions started coming. What did I know about the Orchestra’s history, or the music’s structural elements, or critiques of past performances? I had no idea about these things, no good answers.

So, if I’m not a music expert, then what exactly am I doing? Just this: I write about how the music feels, and I write for the people who, like me, are head over heels in love with music.

My time at Orchestra Hall has connected me with people who can’t read a single note of music or tell you a thing about the composer. (Even though some have been coming for enough decades to remember when the Orchestra played at Northrop at the University of Minnesota.) We come to the Hall and mingle in the lobby, an assorted throng of the casual and the sophisticated, and take our seats in the auditorium.

We may start side by side as strangers, but as we hold our breath together, we become silent comrades as the music washes away our daily trials. We listen to notes that sound first like a thousand butterflies—uncontainable and magnificent in their abundance—then give way to something mysterious, lush and rounded and dark. We experience moments when the music is so sweet and pure and fleeting, we want to weep for its existence.

Sometimes, when I can’t make it to Orchestra Hall, I sit alone in the dark and listen to the Orchestra on Minnesota Public Radio. Without the grandeur of the Hall’s space and my high heels, the broadcast feels like an intimate conversation with an old friend.

These are the things I write about.

I like to think it’s universal and why music exists. To know what beauty is. And now when people ask me about my expertise in music, I finally have a good answer, one I say with heartfelt enthusiasm every time.

I’m not a music expert. I’m a music lover.

Program Notes: Beethoven's Emperor Concerto

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance | Read Kenny Broberg Bio (pdf)

One-minute notes:

Beethoven: Piano Concerto No. 5, Emperor

Beethoven’s last and best-known piano concerto, the Fifth, is permeated with power, nobility, and energy. After a grand first movement full of wide leaps and frequent cadenzas, a reflective Adagio and a dance-like Rondo cap this touchstone of the piano literature, composed in Vienna near the time of Napoleon’s siege of the city in 1809.


Shostakovich: Symphony No. 10

Shostakovich’s Tenth is a work of great extremes, requiring delicate strands of sound from a massive ensemble, framing tiny movements with huge ones, communicating darkly but rising to a high-spirited conclusion. Many assumed this enigmatic symphony was a protest against Stalin and his oppression, but the composer would acknowledge only that his wish was “to portray human emotions and passions.”.

Full program notes:

Ludwig van Beethoven

Born: December 16, 1770, Bonn, Germany

Died: March 26, 1827, Vienna, Austria

Concerto No. 5 in E-flat major for Piano and Orchestra, Opus 73, Emperor

In the spring of 1809 Napoleon, intent upon consolidating his hold on Europe, went to war with Austria. He laid siege to Vienna in May, and after a brief bombardment the city surrendered to the French and was occupied through the remainder of the year. The royal family fled early in May and did not return until January 1810, but Beethoven remained behind throughout the shelling and occupation, and it was during this period that he completed his Fifth Piano Concerto.

noble and powerful

Some critics have been ready to take their cue from the French occupation and to understand the concerto as Beethoven’s response to it. But Beethoven was not swept up in the fervor of the fighting: he found the occupation a source of stress and depression. During the shelling, he hid in the basement of his brother Caspar’s house, where he wrapped his head in pillows to protect his ears. “The course of events has affected my body and soul,” he wrote to his publishers. “Life around me is wild and disturbing, nothing but drums, cannons, soldiers, misery of every sort.”

Thus the concerto Beethoven wrote during this period is noble and powerful despite the military occupation rather than because of it. In fact, Beethoven had done much of the work on the concerto before the French army entered Vienna: his earliest sketches date from February 1809, and he appears to have had the concerto largely complete by April, before the fighting began.

Beethoven’s hearing, which was deteriorating rapidly at the time he wrote this concerto, had become so weak that he knew he could not give the first performance of the work; thus it is the only piano concerto he wrote but did not premiere as soloist. That honor went instead to Archduke Rudolf, Beethoven’s patron and pupil, in a performance on January 13, 1811, at the Palace of Prince Joseph Lobkowitz in Vienna.

the music: defying expectations

allegro. Beethoven defies expectations from the opening instant of this music. The Allegro bursts to life with a resplendent E-flat major chord for the whole orchestra, but this is not the start of the expected orchestral exposition. Instead, that chord opens the way for a cadenza by the solo piano, a cadenza that the orchestra punctuates twice more with powerful chords before sweeping into the movement’s main theme and the true exposition.

This first movement is marked by a spaciousness and grandeur far removed from Beethoven’s misery over the fighting that wracked Vienna. Here is music of shining sweep, built on two main ideas, both somewhat in the manner of marches: the strings’ vigorous main subject and a poised second theme, sounded first by the strings, then repeated memorably as a duet for horns. After so vigorous an exposition, the entrance of the piano feels understated, as it ruminates on the two main themes, but soon the piano part, full of octaves, wide leaps and runs, becomes as difficult as it is brilliant. At a length of nearly 20 minutes, this is one of Beethoven’s longest first movements, longer than the final two movements combined. Beethoven maintains strict control: he does not allow the soloist the freedom to create his own cadenza but instead writes out a brief cadential treatment of themes before the movement hurtles to its powerful close.

adagio un poco mosso. The second movement transports us to a different world altogether. Gone is the energy of the first movement; now we seem in the midst of sylvan calm. Beethoven moves to the remote key of B major and mutes the strings, which sing the hymn-like main theme. There follow two extended variations on that rapt melody. The first, for piano over quiet accompaniment, might almost be labeled Chopinesque in its expressive freedom, while the second is for winds, embellished by the piano’s steady strands of 16ths.

rondo: allegro. The second movement concludes on a low B, and then Beethoven drops everything a half-step to B-flat. Out of that unusual change, the piano begins, very gradually, to outline a melodic idea, which struggles to take shape and direction. And suddenly it does—as if these misty imaginings have been hit with an electric current that snaps them to vibrant life as the movement’s main theme. Lyric episodes alternate with some of Beethoven’s most rhythmically energized writing: this music seems to want to dance. Near the close comes one of its most striking moments, a duet for piano and timpani, which taps out the movement’s fundamental rhythm. Then the piano leaps up to energize the full orchestra, which concludes with one final recall of the rondo theme.

a note on the title

Today we use the nickname Emperor almost reflexively—but it did not originate with the composer, and Beethoven’s denunciation of Napoleon’s self-coronation suggests that he would not have been sympathetic to it at all. It is almost certain that Beethoven never heard it applied to the concerto, and its source remains unknown.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani and strings

Dmitri Shostakovich

Born: September 25, 1906, St. Petersburg, Russia

Died: August 9, 1975, Moscow, Russia

Symphony No. 10 in E minor, Opus 93

Shostakovich and other Russian composers were pilloried at the infamous 1948 Congress of the Union of Soviet Composers, a showcase inquisition put on by a government intent on keeping its artists on a short leash. Shostakovich was dismissed from his teaching positions and forced to read a humiliating confession. Then, as he supported his family by writing film scores and patriotic music, he privately composed the music he wanted to write and kept it back, waiting for a more liberal atmosphere. Soon after Stalin’s death on March 5, 1953, he set to work on his Tenth Symphony, which was completed that October and premiered by Yevgeny Mravinsky and the Leningrad Philharmonic that December 17.

a matter of debate

This imposing work, dark and somber, touched off a firestorm in Russia, where it was regarded as a challenge to Soviet control of Russian artists. A conference was called in Moscow in the spring of 1954 to try to come to terms with music that was so politically incorrect. After three days of debate, the conference came to a compromise approval of this music, declaring—with considerable mental gymnastics—that the Shostakovich Tenth represented “an optimistic tragedy.”

the music: struggles, signatures and shifts

moderato. The music begins quietly and ominously, with rising and falling patterns of three notes. More animated material follows: a wistful tune for solo clarinet and a dark waltz for solo flute. Simple figures explode violently across the span of this movement, which rises to a series of craggy climaxes. After so much mighty struggle, the movement vanishes on the most delicate strands of sound: solo piccolo, barely audible timpani rolls and widely spaced pizzicato strokes.

allegro. The second movement, brief and brutal, rips to life with frenzied energy and does not stop until it vanishes on a whirlwind. Listeners will detect the rising pattern of three notes that opened the first movement, but here they are spit out like bursts of machine-gun fire. Some view this movement as a musical portrait of Stalin, but the composer’s son Maxim has specifically denied this.

allegretto. After the fury of the second movement, the third begins almost whimsically. The violins’ opening gesture repeats the three-note phrase that underpins so much of this symphony, and we move to what is distinctive about this movement: one of the earliest appearances of Shostakovich’s musical signature in his works. High woodwinds toot out the four-note motto D/E-flat/C/B. In German notation, E-flat is S and B is H, and the resulting motto spells DSCH, the composer’s initials in their German spelling: Dmitri SCHostakovich. This musical calling card would appear in many subsequent Shostakovich works, at times seeming to be an assertion of Shostakovich’s existence and his independence. Also notable is this movement’s horn call, ringing out 12 times across its span. In this enigmatic movement, one senses a private drama being played out. The music slides into silence with lonely woodwinds chirping out the DSCH motto one final time.

andante – allegro. The finale opening returns to the mood of the very beginning, with somber low strings beneath lonely woodwind cries. When our sensibilities are thoroughly darkened, Shostakovich suddenly shifts gears. Solo clarinet offers a taut call to order, and the violins launch into an Allegro that pushes the symphony to an almost too conventional happy ending.

What are we to make of this conclusion, apparently shaped by the requisite high spirits of Socialist Realism? It has unsettled many listeners, who feel it a violation of the powerful music that preceded it. The source of the power of this work continues to elude our understanding, even as we are swept up in its somber strength.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo (1 flute also doubling piccolo), 3 oboes (1 doubling English horn), 3 clarinets (1 doubling E-flat clarinet), 3 bassoons (1 doubling contrabassoon), 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, tambourine, tamtam, triangle, xylophone and strings

Program notes by Eric Bromberger.


Meet a Musician: Fei Xie

Minnesota Orchestra member since: September 2017
Position/section: Principal Bassoon
Tang Shan, China
M.M., Rice University, B.M., Oberlin College

What is currently on your music stand?
On my stand, I always have the music for the next 2 to 3 weeks of orchestra programs, plus some etudes and French solo bassoon pieces. 

Do you come from a musical family?
Yes, my parents are both Peking Opera musicians, and my uncle is a composer who introduced me to classical music at the age of three.

How did you choose to play the bassoon?
The bassoon kind of chose me. I started playing piano when I was three years old, and I studied it until I was 12 years old. When I finished elementary school, I wanted to audition for the middle school attached to the Central Conservatory of Music, one of the best music schools in China. After taking a lesson with one of the professors, she told me that I would not be accepted that year as a pianist, but that I should try to audition for the wind department if I really wanted to get into the school. The wind department would sometimes accept students who had musical talent but hadn’t learned to play any particular wind instrument yet. I went to the audition and one very nice lady asked if I would consider learning the bassoon. I had no idea what the bassoon was at that time. It wasn't until the next day, when I brought my parents to meet the professor, that I first saw and heard the bassoon, and I fell in love with its beautiful sound! Now I am here!  

Fei Xie with bassoonist J. Christopher Marshall onstage at Orchestra Hall

Where did you play before coming to Minnesota?

I always knew that I wanted to play in an orchestra, so I started taking orchestral auditions when I was in college. My very first job was as the principal bassoon of Mansfield Symphony in Ohio, while I was a junior at Oberlin. My second job was as the second bassoon of the Houston Grand Opera. I won that position while I was a graduate student at Rice University. One year after I graduated from Rice University, I won the second bassoon job in Baltimore Symphony, and later won the principal bassoon audition there. After serving 5 years as principal bassoon in Baltimore, I joined the Minnesota Orchestra.

Which moment in the bassoon’s orchestral repertoire is your favorite?
I love them all! The bassoon doesn't get as many solos as the other woodwind instruments, so I love it anytime one is written for bassoon. I really have an interest in story-telling, so if I had to pick one, I’d choose the solo from Scheherazade by Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov.

Principal Oboe John Snow and Principal Bassoon Fei Xie (both at center) after a masterclass with students at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, January 2018

What Minnesotan activity are you excited to try for the first time?

Since I am new to Minnesota, I am trying my best to adapt to the weather. One of the things I have never done but am looking forward to is skiing. I just signed my son up for ski lessons, and I hope I will also become a skier soon.

What would you recommend to audience members here?
Come to as many concerts as you would like. The Minnesota Orchestra really puts on variety of music. You can find so many different genres of music in the concert hall.

Fei Xie with a student at University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, January 2018

What upcoming performances are you looking forward to?

I am really looking forward to the Mahler symphonies we are playing and recording this season. I am also looking forward to the collaboration with Pink Martini. I love that group. 

What do you like to do when you aren’t performing? 
I love to cook, particularly authentic home-style Chinese food. I think cooking is so much like making music. Everyone can look at the same notes, but you play it differently. With cooking, everyone is working with the same ingredients and yet the food always comes out a little bit different. I like to apply things I learn while cooking to music-making, and vice versa. I probably would have become a chef or had a cooking show if I wasn’t a musician. 

Click here to read more about Fei Xie. 

Program Notes: West Side Story

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

Full program notes:

Leonard Bernstein

Born: August 25, 1918, Lawrence, Massachusetts
Died: October 14, 1990, New York City

West Side Story

In 1947, choreographer/director Jerome Robbins approached Leonard Bernstein with what the composer called in his diary “a noble idea: a modern version of Romeo and Juliet set in slums at the coincidence of Easter-Passover celebrations. Feelings run high between Jews and Catholics… Street brawls, double death – it all fits.” The idea lay dormant until 1955, when a Los Angeles newspaper headline about Latino gang problems inspired an exciting new path. With the hiring of 25-year-old composer Stephen Sondheim, who reluctantly signed on to provide lyrics only, the final pieces fell into place.

After two years of rewriting and struggles to raise financing, West Side Story’s 1957 Broadway opening elicited reactions that ranged from passionate raves to stunned walk-outs. The latter were sparked by the musical’s depiction of gang warfare and prejudice, and its near unprecedented body count for a musical on the Great White Way. The show was largely snubbed at the Tony Awards in favor of a more accessible rival, The Music Man.

Nevertheless, audiences in New York and London (where the show was an instant smash) quickly caught up with the innovations of Robbins’ explosive, character-driven choreography, Arthur Laurents’ ingenious transposition of Shakespeare, and the thrilling Bernstein score, with lyrics by Sondheim, that included “Tonight” and “Maria.” When Jerome Robbins and Robert Wise joined forces to co-direct the 1961 screen version for United Artists, starring box office favorite Natalie Wood and Richard Beymer (The Diary of Anne Frank), the result was one of the decade’s greatest commercial and critical triumphs.

The film’s co-stars, George Chakiris (Bernardo) and Rita Moreno (Anita), took home Academy Awards for Best Supporting Actor and Actress. In all, the film won 10 Academy Awards: for Best Art Direction–Set Decoration, Color; Best Cinematography, Color; Best Costume Design, Color (the winner, Irene Sharaff, also worked on the Broadway original); Best Film Editing; Best Music, Scoring of a Musical Picture; Best Sound; Best Director (for both Robbins and Wise, the first time this award was shared); and Best Picture. Jerome Robbins also received an honorary Academy Award “for his brilliant achievements in the art of choreography on film.”

a state-of-the-art live performance

Fifty-seven after its original release, the motion picture West Side Story will be presented today in a format that brings its own innovations. MGM has created a restored, high-definition print of the film that reveals details unseen since 1961. A new sound technology developed by Paris-based Audionamix and utilized by Chace Audio by Deluxe, one of the film industry’s top restoration companies, has isolated vocal tracks from the feature, using new source-separation technology that separates elements within a monophonic soundtrack.

In the case of West Side Story, Audionamix “taught” its technology to recognize and then remove orchestral elements on the sound- track while retaining vocals, dialogue, and effects. This allows the Minnesota Orchestra and today’s conductor, David Newman, to accompany the vocals. Newman and the Los Angeles Philharmonic gave the first-ever live performance of this production in 2011.

Although the original musical materials for the movie arrangements were lost, 14 months of research by Eleonor M. Sandresky of The Leonard Bernstein Office brought to light a trove of important finds in private collections and library archives around the country. From materials discovered in the papers of orchestrator Sid Ramin, as well as in the archives of conductor/music supervisor Johnny Green, director Robert Wise and producer Walter Mirisch, she was able to assemble a mock-up short score of the complete film. Garth Edwin Sunderland, Senior Music Editor for the Bernstein Office, restored and adapted the orchestration for live performance. At the same time, Sunderland oversaw the creation of a brand new engraving of the entire film score, right down to last-minute modifications made on the scoring stage in 1961.

The final result is a presentation of West Side Story unlike any in the history of this screen musical.

Program note by Steven Smith, an Emmy-nominated documentary producer, journalist, and author of the biography A Heart at Fire’s Center: The Life and Music of Bernard Herrmann.

Program Notes: Fauré Requiem

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Rigel: Symphony No. 4
This brief symphony comes from a composer who was well-respected in the musical circles of 18th-century France; yet much of Rigel’s work was hidden in the shadow of Haydn and is little-known today. The outer movements drive ahead with intensity, while the central Andantino offers a simple, elegant arc.

Mozart: Symphony No. 31, Paris
To please the Parisian audiences that were known to love bold and dramatic new music, Mozart used all of the resources available to him when scoring his Paris Symphony for the largest orchestra he had yet used—with added personnel in the strings and a full contingent of wind instruments.


Fauré: Pavane
Graceful in melody and airy of texture, this music is distinguished by the restraint of its emotional display and its gentle solo woodwinds. Today’s performance features the rarely-heard version with chorus.

Fauré: Requiem
Fauré’s Requiem is the gentlest of all settings of the Mass for the Dead, casting aside the darkness of the Dies Irae emphasized by other composers in favor of a vision that assumes salvation, ultimate redemption and rest. Instrumental colors are generally from the darker lower spectrum, as in the opening of the Agnus Dei, where violas play one of the most graceful melodies ever written for the instrument. In the finale, the soprano section takes the part of the angels who draw us into paradise.

Full program notes:

Henri-Joseph Rigel

Born: February 9, 1741, Wertheim am Main, Germany
Died: May 2, 1799, Paris, France

Symphony No. 4 in C minor, Opus 12, No. 4

For someone in the business of musical archeology (if that’s indeed a thing), the experience of unearthing a forgotten, yet first-rate composer must be the find of a lifetime; even a career-making thing. After all these years, can there possibly be excellent composers still left to discover from the days of Haydn and Mozart?

Apparently, there’s at least one: consider the case of Henri-Joseph Rigel, who spent most of his career in Paris. Those involved in the rediscovery of the German-born Rigel deserve our thanks, because his music is full of imagination and individuality. Personally, I was astonished to learn about him. During my 30 years in the Minnesota Orchestra’s viola section, not once has his name come up, even in passing. In fact, these concerts mark Rigel’s first appearance on any program in the Orchestra’s 115-year history, so you’ll be forgiven for wondering, mid-performance, how Rigel has escaped detection all these years. Perhaps that is where we should begin.

a time of tectonic shifts

Paris at the time of Monsieur Rigel’s residency—about 1760 through the century’s end—was a terribly confusing place to live for a composer, or for any citizen, for that matter. It was a time of tectonic shifts in French politics (a euphemism for the very bloody French Revolution), and the highly-respected Rigel had the misfortune to die at 58, right in the middle of the chaotic collapse of the Republic. As a result, his posthumous reputation was probably doomed, as his music was neglected for many years.

But there is another layer to this story. Tectonic shifts were simultaneously happening in the musical tastes of the Parisian public, and Rigel happened to align with the losing side of musical history. The flavor of the day had become the Austrian Franz Joseph Haydn, whose sophisticated, poised symphonies had become immensely popular in Paris in relatively short order. 

One historian posits that the success of Haydn in Paris “nearly dealt a death blow” to French symphonists. Indeed, Rigel actually quit writing symphonies after completing 20, bowing to the forces of changing tastes and Haydn’s success.

But Rigel’s output remained high: he also wrote 14 operas, dozens of harpsichord pieces and at least six string quartets, among other works. In fact, he was a well-loved and highly respected composer during his time—he was a founder of the Paris Conservatoire—and his conducting talents led him to become head of the resident orchestra there and teacher of young César Franck. In summary, Rigel was, at one time, a really big deal.

music of drama, intensity and beauty

Rigel’s music is especially notable for its “Sturm und Drang” style (literally “Storm and Stress”), a movement popular with Parisian audiences who favored bigger orchestras and more dramatic music. That is audible from the first bars of his Fourth Symphony, which jumps off the page with crackling intensity. Rigel was a naturally gifted melodist; witness the slow movement, as beautiful, simple and tuneful as anything Schubert would write. The three-movement affair closes with a finale of effervescent energy driven forward by the irrepressible strings.

for further fun…

At home, consider putting on a recording of some Rigel for friends—especially those who think they know a lot about classical music. This is a “guess-the-composer” quiz they are doomed to fail! (Some honorable mention answers: Schubert, C.P.E. Bach and Johann Baptist Vanhal—or for bonus points, František Benda.)

Instrumentation: 2 oboes, bassoon, 2 horns and strings

Program note by Michael Adams.

Wolfgang Amadè Mozart

Born: January 27, 1756, Salzburg, Austria
Died: December 5, 1791, Vienna, Austria

Symphony No. 31 in D major, K. 300a [K. 297], Paris

Between 1774 and 1778, his eighteenth to twenty-second years, Mozart did not write a single symphony. He composed nearly 100 other works during this period, but not until his visit to Paris in the spring of 1778 did he have occasion to write another symphony—inevitably, of course, given the moniker Paris.

Mozart took care to write a work tailored to the prevailing Parisian taste. One feature of the Symphony No. 31 that sets it apart from most others in his catalog, including all 30 that preceded it, is the size of the orchestra. It requires a full wind complement of pairs of flutes, oboes, clarinets (used for the very first time in a Mozart symphony) and bassoons, plus horns, trumpets and timpani. In addition, the string section Mozart had at his disposal in Paris was far larger than what he was used to in Salzburg: reportedly 40 members strong at the symphony’s premiere on June 12, 1778.

a symphony catered to French tastes

In structuring the symphony, Mozart omitted the minuet movement, which was not yet accepted in Parisian symphonies, and kept the harmonic scheme simple throughout.

allegro assai. A notable feature of the first movement is the premier coup d’archet (first stroke of the bow), which in French style meant a loud, big chord from the full string section. Mozart obliged the French by including all the winds as well.

andantino. The central movement has been the subject of considerable debate, for Mozart wrote two entirely different movements to go with this symphony. The man behind the commission, Joseph (also known as Jean) Le Gros, was dissatisfied with the movement played at the symphony’s premiere, so the composer humored the man’s questionable judgment and wrote another shortly thereafter. However, due to confusion regarding tempo markings and autograph versus published scores, we are not certain today which was really the “original” movement. The only means of identifying them unequivocally is by meter: 6/8 or 3/4. Many orchestras today play the movement in 6/8; that version is heard at tonight’s performance. (Stay tuned, though, for a word from the conductor before intermission.)

allegro. Atypically for a Mozart symphony, the final movement begins softly, and the composer gauged its effect correctly. The audience at the first performance was still chattering away following the conclusion of the slow movement (audience behavior is markedly different today!), so when the music was perceived through the din, there were cries of “Hush! Hush!” Just about the point where everyone was “hushed,” the full orchestra came crashing in with overflowing joy and exuberance. The audience immediately broke out in applause at being caught off guard like this—another departure from modern concert decorum.

Mary Ann Feldman, former Showcase editor and annotator, offers this verdict: “Brilliant and capricious rather than profound, the Paris Symphony brings to mind, in paraphrase, what Goethe said about his short-lived contemporary: Nothing can explain the phenomenon of Mozart but genius—and it is through such genius that God works his miracles.”

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani and strings

Program note by Robert Markow.

Gabriel Fauré

Born: May 12, 1845, Pamiers, France
Died: November 4, 1924, Paris, France

Pavane in F-sharp minor, Opus 50

When discussing some French composers, the same words turn up again and again: precision, craft, elegance and—not the least—restraint. With such a piece as Gabriel Fauré’s Pavane, they are no doubt appropriate. The music reflects the man, who was refined, discerning and invariably described as “aristocratic,” though his career gave him little in the way of leisure or affluence.

organist, teacher, composer—and harmonic pioneer

The youngest of six children in a family of modest means, Fauré first attended a school housed in a medieval convent. From his earliest years he developed a penchant for ancient music that later would be reflected in his fusion of old modality with the 19th-century harmonic system—a direction that made him one of the pioneers of 20th-century harmony.

Starting at age 21, Fauré took a series of church organ positions first in Rennes, then Paris. His lengthiest affiliation was with the famous church of the Madeleine on the Place de la Concorde, where he started out in 1874 as deputy for the principal organist, Camille Saint-Saëns. Twin career triumphs came in 1896, when Fauré was named principal organist at Madeleine and was appointed professor of composition at the Paris Conservatoire. There he was revered by his pupils, including Maurice Ravel and Nadia Boulanger, for cultivating an atmosphere of artistic freedom.

Despite the exhausting demands of a double career as organist and teacher, Fauré composed a substantial number of works, most of them during his summer holidays, all of them in an idiom distinctively his own, fundamentally untouched by the Wagnerisms of the day. He was by nature averse to extravagant orchestral effects, and he produced relatively few works for orchestra, instead focusing primarily on art songs and chamber music. Today’s concert offers two of the Frenchman’s works for vocalists and orchestra: the Pavane and the Requiem.

the spirit of the past

Many French composers of Fauré’s time recreated the spirit of the past, especially in fragile, evocative pieces that recalled the elegance and artifice of the rococo, or Late Baroque—the early-18th century artistic movement that reacted against the strict restrictions of the Baroque, instead emphasizing a more graceful approach. Fauré’s Pavane dates from 1887 (characteristically composed during summertime), when he was called upon to contribute music for an entertainment at the Opéra-Comique that was conceived in the pastoral spirit of a painting by the rococo artist Jean-Antoine Watteau.

Graceful in melody and airy of texture, this work is also distinguished by the restraint of its emotional display. Fauré’s use of solo woodwind is as gentle and refined as the pastel colorations of rococo art. The title itself suggests a nostalgia for the past, one far preceding the rococo: the pavane was a slow, dignified court dance of the 16th century thought to have originated in Spain.

with or without voices?

Two versions of Fauré’s Pavane premiered in quick succession in November 1888: one for orchestra alone, and the other with a chorus added on top of the same instrumentals. The choral lyrics were written by Robert de Montesquiou, a French poet, art collector and intellectual of Fauré’s time. Although the Pavane is nowadays seldom performed with voices, these concerts feature the version with chorus included.

Instrumentation: four-part mixed chorus with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns and strings

Program note by Mary Ann Feldman.

Requiem, Opus 48

Setting the Requiem Mass for the Dead to music is a challenge which makes certain composers reveal their deepest nature, and when we hear their Requiem settings, we peer deep into their souls. From the self-conscious pageantry of the Berlioz Requiem to the lyric drama of Verdi, from the independence of Brahms (who chose his own texts to make it a distinctly German Requiem) to the anguish of Britten’s War Requiem, a setting of the Requiem text can become a spectacularly different thing in each  composer’s hands.

the gentlest of settings

What most distinguishes the Requiem of Gabriel Fauré is its calm, for sure this spare and understated music is the gentlest of all settings. Where Berlioz storms the heavens with a huge orchestra and chorus, Fauré rarely raises his voice above quiet supplication. Verdi employs four brilliant soloists in an almost operatic setting, but Fauré keeps his drama quietly unobtrusive. 

While Brahms shouts out the triumph of resurrection over the grave, Fauré calmly fixes his eyes on paradise. Britten is outraged by warfare, but Fauré remains at peace throughout.

Much of the serenity of Fauré’s Requiem results from his alteration of the text, for he omits the Dies Irae (Day of Wrath) of the traditional text. Berlioz and Verdi evoke the shrieking horror of damnation, but Fauré ignores it—his vision of death foresees not damnation, but only salvation. While he reinserts a line from the Dies Irae in the Libera me, the effect remains one of quiet confidence in redemption. Fauré underlines this by concluding with an additional section, In Paradisum—that title reminds us of the emphasis of the entire work, and Fauré brings his music to a quiet resolution on the almost inaudible final word “requiem” (rest).

the Requiem’s evolution

The Fauré Requiem has become one of the best-loved of all liturgical works, but it took shape very slowly. The mid-1880s found Fauré struggling as a composer. He had achieved modest early success with a violin sonata and piano quartet, but now, in his 40s, he remained virtually unknown as a composer. For more than 25 years he supported himself by serving as choirmaster and organist at the Madeleine, and it was during these years—particularly following the death of his father in 1885—that Fauré began to plan his Requiem setting. He was just completing the score when his mother died on January 31, 1887. The first performance took place at the Madeleine two weeks later, on February 16.

But the music performed on that occasion was very different from the version we know today. It was scored for a chamber ensemble and was in only five movements rather than seven. Over the next decade, Fauré returned to the score several times and changed it significantly. The orchestration began to grow, and he added two movements: the Offertorium in 1889 and the Libera me in 1892. The “final” version dates from about 1900.

the music: “from a twilight world”

The Fauré Requiem seems to come from a twilight world. There are no fast movements here (Fauré’s favorite tempo markings, which recur throughout, are Andante moderato and Molto adagio), dynamics are for the most part subdued, and instrumental colors are generally from the darker lower spectrum. Violin sections were added only in the final version, and even here they remain silent in three of the seven movements. In the Introit and Kyrie, the chorus almost whispers its first entrance on the words “Requiem aeternam,” and while the movement soon begins to flow, this prayer for mercy comes to a pianissimo conclusion.

At this point in a Requiem Mass should come the Dies Irae, with its description of the horrors of damnation, the admission of man’s unworthiness, and an abject prayer for mercy. Fauré skips this movement altogether and goes directly to the Offertorium with its baritone solo at “Hostias.” This movement, which Fauré composed and added to the Requiem the year after its original premiere, comes to one of the most beautiful conclusions in all the choral literature as the long final Amen seems to float weightlessly outside time and space. Fauré does finally deploy his brass instruments in the Sanctus, but even this movement comes to a shimmering, near-silent close.

The Pie Jesu brings a complete change. In his German Requiem, Brahms used a soprano soloist in only one of the seven movements, and Fauré does the same thing here. The effect—almost magical—is the same in both works: Above the dark sound of those two settings, the soprano’s voice sounds silvery and pure as she sings a message of consolation.

At the start of the Agnus Dei the violas play one of the most graceful melodies ever written for that instrument, a long, flowing strand of song that threads its way through much of the movement. Tenors introduce the text of this movement, which rises to a sonorous climax, and at the point Fauré brings back the Requiem aeternam from the very beginning; the violas return to draw the movement to its close.

The final two movements set texts from the Burial Service rather than from the Mass for the Dead. The Libera me was composed in its earliest form in 1877, and Fauré adapted it for the Requiem in 1892. Over pulsing, insistent pizzicatos, the baritone soloist sings an urgent prayer for deliverance. The choir responds in fear, and the music rises to its most dramatic moment on horn calls and the sole appearance in the entire work of a line from the Dies Irae. But the specter of damnation passes quickly, and the movement concludes with one last plea for salvation.

That comes in the final movement. Concluding with In Paradisum points at the special character of the Fauré Requiem: It assumes salvation, and if Fauré believed that death was “a happiness beyond the grave,” he shows us that in his concluding movement. There is a surprising parallel between the conclusions of the Fauré Requiem and the Mahler Fourth Symphony, composed in 1900: Both finales feel consciously light after what has gone before, both offer a vision of paradise, and in both cases it is the sound of the soprano voice that leads us into that world of innocence and peace. Mahler’s soprano soloist presents a child’s unaffected vision of heaven, while Fauré has the soprano section take the part of the angels who draw us into paradise. Fauré “wanted to do something different” with his Requiem, and he achieves that in a finale that quietly arrives at “eternal happiness.”

Fauré’s Requiem has been called pagan rather than Christian, no doubt by those who miss the imminence of judgment. But it is hard to see this gentle invocation of Christ and the mercy of God—and confidence in paradise—as pagan. Rather, it remains a quiet statement of faith in ultimate redemption and rest, one so disarmingly beautiful as to appeal to believer and non-believer alike.

Instrumentation: four-part mixed chorus with soprano and baritone vocal soloists, plus orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani, harp, organ and strings

Program note by Eric Bromberger.


Midwest Tour 2018: Chicago

The Midwest tour concluded on Sunday afternoon with a performance at the Chicago Symphony Center, home of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra. This concert marked the Orchestra’s first performance on Chicago’s Orchestra Hall stage in over 50 years; the last was in 1966 under then-Music Director Stanislaw Skrowaczewski.

After the ensemble traveled from Urbana, Illinois, to downtown Chicago on Saturday, the musicians and staff spent the remainder of the day sightseeing in the Windy City, connecting with former classmates and colleagues, or just resting up for the final concert. Many of the musicians chose to attend the Chicago Symphony Orchestra’s evening performance of Mahler’s Symphony No. 5. In return, Chicago’s musicians appeared throughout the audience on Sunday afternoon.

Before the Orchestra’s final quick rehearsal, musicians arrived earlier than usual, taking time to explore the acoustics and aesthetics at Orchestra Hall. Many had performed here in the past, but for some, it was a dream come true, having never performed in Chicago or on that stage, which was built in 1904 -- just one year after the Minneapolis Symphony Orchestra was founded!

Osmo Vänskä, the Orchestra musicians, and pianist Inon Barnatan gave a dazzling performance of Sibelius, Tchaikovsky, and Beethoven, and after a long standing ovation, they added a delightful encore of Sibelius’ Tanz-Intermezzo. The concert capped a weeklong tour that included a true Minnesota blizzard, countless connections with students in Indiana and Illinois, concerts at some of the Midwest’s most beautiful venues, and a long-awaited return to the Chicago Symphony Center.

The Orchestra returned to Minneapolis late Sunday night, greeted by crowds and excitement of a different kind: Super Bowl LII!

Photos by Greg Helgeson.

Midwest Tour 2018: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Orchestra musicians and staff were warmly welcomed to the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign this week.

The two-day residency began on Thursday evening with a concert at the beautiful Krannert Center for the Performing Arts. Osmo Vänskä led the musicians in a performance that included an encore, Tanz-Intermezzo by Jean Sibelius, book-ending the concert with music by the Finnish composer.

Assistant Conductor Akiko Fujimoto visited Urbana High School on Friday afternoon to work with students in their orchestra classes. She conducted two ensembles of ninth through twelfth graders and then held a Q&A session with the students from both groups. She was asked about her musical background, her favorite pieces and which ones are still on her "Conducting Bucket List" (such as Beethoven's Missa Solemnis). Several students had attended the Orchestra performance on Thursday night and had follow-up questions about the music and the instruments onstage.

Continuing the Orchestra's tradition of rehearsing side-by-side with student ensembles as it travels the world, the members of the University of Illinois Symphony shared music stands with the Minnesota Orchestra musicians on Friday afternoon, filling the auditorium's stage for a rehearsal of Brahms' First Symphony.

Masterclasses for every instrument in the orchestra were held across campus on Friday morning.

Photos by Greg Helgeson.

Midwest Tour 2018: Indiana University

Just as the Minnesota Orchestra was scheduled to head off on its Midwest tour, a blizzard hit Minneapolis, leaving hundreds of flights grounded. Many of the musicians would have to wait another day to begin their journey to Indiana.

However, a small group of Orchestra members made it out before the storm and started the tour as scheduled with a set of masterclasses at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana.

The weather delays in Minnesota made Tuesday an exciting day of travel with many of the musicians arriving at Indiana University Auditorium just in time to change into their concert attire and quickly warm up for the performance. Students and community members from Bloomington, Indiana, filled the expansive hall to hear the Orchestra perform music by Sibelius, Tchaikovsky and Beethoven.

Music Director Osmo Vänskä conducts Sibelius’ En Saga.

Pianist Inon Barnatan performs as soloist in Tchaikovsky's Piano Concerto No. 1.

The Orchestra receives a standing ovation after their concert at Indiana University.

Indiana University President Michael McRobbie welcomed the musicians and staff at a reception following the concert.

Wednesday's residency activities at the IU Jacobs School of Music included events with all of the Orchestra musicians and many of the IU's students and faculty.

The morning began with a violin masterclass led by Concertmaster Erin Keefe and Principal Second Violin Peter McGuire, a panel discussion about community engagement, and a rehearsal of the IU Philharmonic guest conducted by Music Director Osmo  Vänskä. The ensemble was working on Bartók's Concerto for Orchestra.

After the rehearsal, student comments included:

"We grew a ton in that single rehearsal." — Brian, violinist

"It was super inspiring. I think we played with many new colors today." — Ethan, concertmaster

"It was a lot of fun. Osmo Vänskä is full of energy!" — Alex, bass trombone

In the afternoon, a string quartet of Orchestra members performed for students at Fairview Elementary. Violinists Sarah Grimes and James Garlick, violist David Auerbach and cellist Silver Ainomäe played music by Mozart, Dvořák and Ravel. Many of the students listening are part of a new strings program at their school where they are learning to play the violin. During the one-hour session, they were also introduced to the viola and cello and they asked many questions about what life is like as a professional musician.

Afterwards, some of the youngest students stayed to meet the musicians and measure their height in relation to Silver's cello!

Across campus, several of the Orchestra staff and musicians presented about the Minnesota Model at a luncheon at the Hutton Honors College.

The full Orchestra returned to the Auditorium stage to rehearse side-by-side with IU's Symphony Orchestra. Totaling more than 150 musicians onstage, the group filled the hall with incredible sound as they played Hindemith's Symphonic Metamorphosis with Osmo Vänskä conducting.

"At break, I thought it was great that almost no one left their seats. We all wanted to stay and learn more from the Minnesota Orchestra musicians!” — Grace, bassoon

Thank you for the warm welcome, Indiana University!

Photos by Greg Helgeson, Emma Plehal, Chris Marshall, Mele Willis, and Kari Marshall.

Meet the Annotator: Q&A with program note writer Eric Bromberger

When you attend a Minnesota Orchestra concert, you may start out by reading program notes. Learn more about who writes program notes and their unique backgrounds and perspectives in our new “Meet the Annotator” Q&A series. First up is Eric Bromberger, who most recently wrote program notes for our Tchaikovsky Marathon.

How long have you been writing program notes for the Minnesota Orchestra?

I’ve written for this Orchestra since 2000, when I was recommended by the renowned musicologist and writer Michael Steinberg, the late husband of former Minnesota Orchestra concertmaster Jorja Fleezanis. It’s been a good relationship ever since!

What was your initial background and training in music?

I started out as a performer. I grew up in Southern California, learned to play the violin as a boy and graduated from the University of Redlands. I was drafted in 1968 and spent a year in Vietnam with the First Cavalry Division. After I returned, I completed a Ph.D. in American literature at UCLA. For 10 years I taught literature and writing courses at Bates College in Maine and at San Diego State University.  Then I left teaching to devote myself to writing about music.

Your performing experience must help in your writing.

Yes, being a musician has aided me immeasurably, since I’ve learned the classical repertory in the best possible way: by playing it. I’ve been lucky to play in some very good orchestras, and played through the symphonic literature, from the Saint Matthew Passion through Xenakis, Glass, and Adams. I’ve always played second violin, and I love playing second violin, in both orchestras and string quartets. That lets me learn the music from the inside out. I like being inside the music, hearing the harmonies shift, feeling the cross-rhythms, and having to master the challenges of music by quite different composers. That’s quite a different way of learning music from hearing it out in the hall.

What do you think makes a good program note?

As an annotator, I feel that I have one job: to give an audience the tools to listen for themselves. My job is not to tell an audience how to feel about a piece of music, but to help them listen. Every program note should give certain basic information—like where a work comes in a composer’s career, what he or she said about it, why it’s distinctive or important, any good stories associated with it—but a note should also pique listeners’ interest, make them want to hear the music, and give them some things to listen for or ways to approach a piece. And I like the challenge of having only about 90 seconds of the audiences’ time to do all those things.  I know that not everyone is going to like every piece of music, and that's fine: I like audiences to listen well, and also to listen for themselves and be honest in their response to a particular piece, whether they like it or not.

Tell us a bit about your favorite composers to write about.

My own special interests are the great symphonic tradition of Haydn through Shostakovich, the music of Bartók, and American music in general.  One thing I’ve enjoyed about writing for the Minnesota Orchestra is that it’s pushed me in directions I haven’t been before. This Orchestra has played some very unusual music, and I like learning music that's new to me.

What other ensembles and organizations do you write for?

I’m also the annotator for the San Diego Symphony, Washington Performing Arts at the Kennedy Center, San Francisco Performances, La Jolla Music Society, Santa Fe Chamber Music Festival and the Chicago Symphony’s chamber series, among others.

What do you do when you’re not writing?

Much of it involves family. My wife is a pediatrician who specializes in newborn intensive care. She’s done a number of medical projects overseas, and I’ve gone with her on extended projects in Ghana, Vietnam and Ethiopia. Our three children have careers in quite different places (London, New York City and San Francisco), so we travel a lot to see them.  We live in Los Osos, on California’s central coast, and work as docents at Morro Bay and Montana de Oro State Parks. At the top of this interview is a photo taken on the edge of Morro Bay.

Stay tuned in coming months for profiles of the Orchestra’s other annotators.

Winter Dreaming

Guest blogger Mandy Meisner rings in 2018 at Orchestra Hall.

I can’t remember the last time I went out on New Year’s Eve. Even in my youth, when the allure of all that glitters was strong, being amid a crowd on this holiday never appealed to me. I much prefer to stay at home, puttering in the kitchen and sipping a good red wine. But, as my love for the Minnesota Orchestra has grown this past year, so has my curiosity—and I decided to welcome 2018 in style at Orchestra Hall.     

We hearty Minnesotans didn’t let 30-below windchills keep us away. We come bundled in down coats and wool scarves; underneath we’re bejeweled and well-heeled, modestly and practically attired. The lobby is aglow with a 16-foot Christmas tree, and in the Target Atrium oversized star lanterns drip from the ceiling in white light. From somewhere on the second balcony, bubbles float down in shimmering waves.

Instagram photo by @johnpanning

The Orchestra musicians walk onstage, dotted with bold dashes of fuchsia and teal, burgundy and sequins. Osmo Vänskä gives the downbeat, and Tchaikovsky’s Winter Dreams Symphony starts as light and crisp as the first snowfall. At times the music is as quiet as a whisper, and we lean forward with our breath held to listen. Dancers from Minnesota Dance Theatre garbed in gossamer and velvet dresses flicker across the stage periodically, pale outstretched arms and long lines of leg accenting the music. It ends with the stunning energy of a dying star.

We know Tchaikovsky’s Serenade will be different from the beginning. The strings stand alone, unconducted. They sway and slant to lengthy romantic phrases as the music moves from lush to delicate to fiery, as deep and broad as the Mississippi River. We marvel at the beauty of it.

Inon Barnatan looks a mere mortal as he walks onstage to sit at the grand piano. When he starts to play the Tchaikovsky Concerto No. 1, he is transformed into something else entirely. Instantly we are mesmerized by the famous opening measures; later we become breathless at his complete mastery of the music’s tenderness and virtuosity. His physicality is captivating. He bends over the piano with fierce intent, only to look up and away in peaceful repose as the piece shifts. His fingers release the notes as light and fast as fireflies in peals of unbelievable music. When it ends, we are standing on our feet, our hands getting weary from the appreciation.

If we were getting tired, then the energy of the lobby soon revives us. Various morsels are offered on silver trays, hats and bobbles are quickly grabbed and put on in festive delight, and glasses of Champagne float about in steady hands. We fill the balconies and hang from stairways to listen to Belle Amour croon out jazz. And the Orchestra musicians mingle all night shaking hands, posing for pictures, graciously receiving adoration from their fans.

Belle Amour performing in the lobby.

We wait together for midnight, and as the New Year arrives, hundreds of gold streamers slink down on us from high above. And for a lovely pause, no matter what kind of year we might have had, we are open and joyful, completely in the moment of what is possible.

A clean slate granted to all.

Mandy Meisner, center, with first-time concertgoer Tracy David at right.

Program Notes: Tchaikovsky Symphony No. 3 and Piano Concerto No. 3

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

Tchaikovsky Marathon: Hardly failures
At first glance, this program might seem to offer a collection of Tchaikovsky’s misfires. It opens with his least-familiar symphony, continues with a piano concerto he assembled from an abandoned symphony, and concludes with a ballet score that brought down on the poor composer the most painful failure he ever endured professionally. Though these three works were not immediate triumphs for Tchaikovsky, they clearly flow from the pen of a master, and are most worthy of listening.

It may seem incomprehensible that Tchaikovsky’s music for Swan Lake could have been attacked for its complexity or derided for being “too Wagnerian,” yet it was. Today it ranks as one of his most popular ballets (and in recent years, crossed paths with cinema through its central focus in the film Black Swan). The Third may be the least-played of Tchaikovsky’s symphonies, but it offers distinct pleasures of its own: it is Tchaikovsky’s only symphony in a major key, and one senses its kinship with ballet throughout. Tchaikovsky composed a symphony in 1892, but abandoned it. Rather than burning his manuscript, though, he converted the symphony’s first movement into a piano concerto. This concerto is rarely played, so enjoy this performance—Tchaikovsky himself never heard it.

One-minute notes:

Tchaikovsky: Symphony No. 3
The Third Symphony by Tchaikovsky is an oddity among the composer’s collection, straying from many of the structures expected of a symphonic work. It contains a German waltz, carries the Polish nickname, but is especially Russian in character. It is the composer’s only symphony based in a major key, yet it begins with a funeral march. Tchaikovsky even ventured away from routine by adding a fifth movement to the standard four-movement form.

Piano Concerto No. 3
Tchaikovsky’s one-movement Piano Concerto No. 3 offers moments of chamber-like intimacy as well as grand theatrics, with a glittering cadenza at its core.


Suite from Swan Lake
In the fairy tale on which the worldwide audience favorite Swan Lake is based, Prince Siegfried triumphs over an evil sorcerer, rescuing his beloved Odette and other maidens who had been transformed into swans. Music Director Osmo Vänskä has selected a suite for today’s performance that includes the famous Waltz marking the Prince’s birthday celebration, the delicate Dance of the Swans and the fiery Mazurka, among other evocative movements.

Full program notes:

Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Born: May 7, 1840, Votkinsk, Russia
Died: November 6, 1893, St. Petersburg, Russia

Symphony No. 3 in D major, Opus 19

Premiered: November 19, 1875

Following the Moscow Conservatory’s spring term in 1875, Tchaikovsky spent a relaxed summer visiting friends and relatives in Russia and the Ukraine. That summer he began his Third Symphony, but he was in no hurry. To friends he wrote that he was “working in a leisurely way…I don’t sit for hours at a time, but walk a great deal.” Nevertheless, the 35-year-old composer had the symphony complete by August 12, and Nikolai Rubinstein led the premiere in Moscow at a concert of the Russian Music Society on November 19. The work had a reasonable success, but the perpetually self-critical composer offered his own ambivalent review to his fellow Russian composer Rimsky-Korsakov: “It seems to me that the symphony doesn’t present any particularly successful ideas—but technically it’s a step forward.”

The Third is the most unusual of Tchaikovsky’s six numbered symphonies—it is the only one in a major key and the only one with five movements—yet it remains the least familiar of that cycle. The standard criticism is that the Third demonstrates Tchaikovsky’s problems with symphonic form: development tends to ramble, the movements do not depend on contrast and organic growth, and there seems little relation between the five movements. Yet the cheerful Third Symphony has virtues that will continue to please audiences for years to come: its three central movements are extremely attractive, the symphony offers some of Tchaikovsky’s most infectious melodies, and the music—at many points reminiscent of Tchaikovsky’s ballet scores—is brightly-colored and energetic.

the music: charming inner movements and an

energetic finale

introduzione ed allegro–moderato assai (tempo marcia funebre). The symphony may nominally be in D major, but it begins in D minor with a slow introduction that Tchaikovsky specifies should be “In the tempo of a funeral march.” This music hardly sounds funereal, however, and it gradually accelerates to the sturdy Allegro brillante main idea, now firmly in D major. The second theme—a falling lyric melody for oboe marked molto espressivo—is especially effective. Tchaikovsky develops both of these at length and drives the movement to a full-throated conclusion.

alla tedesca: allegro moderato e semplice. The three inner movements are cut from entirely different material, and each has a different charm. Tchaikovsky himself felt that the symphony had two scherzo movements, but few would call the second movement a true scherzo. Tchaikovsky marks it Alla tedesca (“In the German style”), and it is in fact a graceful waltz, introduced by woodwinds over pizzicato strings; a middle section based on chattering triplets leads to the return of the opening material and a quiet close.

andante: elegiaco. This “elegy” returns to D minor as flutes sing the delicate main opening; consolation comes in the second section, a warm and flowing idea for strings that Tchaikovsky specifies should be molto espressivo.

scherzo: allegro vivo. The fourth movement is the true scherzo, and it has occasioned much comment. Tchaikovsky was apparently aiming for the kind of shimmering rush that Mendelssohn achieved in his scherzos, and he succeeds admirably in this movement, built on whirling, skittering textures. The music itself is virtually athematic; Tchaikovsky’s contemporary César Cui noted that this movement is “interesting only as sound, almost without musical content.”

finale: allegro con fuoco (tempo di Polacca). The energetic finale bursts to life as the full orchestra shouts out the spirited opening. A firm woodwind choir brings the second section, but the opening theme will dominate this movement. Perhaps anxious to show off his developing symphonic technique, Tchaikovsky anchors the development on fugal treatments of the opening theme. The splendid coda, though, makes use of both themes and drives the Third Symphony to its powerful concluding chords.

a note on the title

Tchaikovsky’s Third Symphony has for many years been tagged with a completely spurious nickname: Polish. Tchaikovsky marked the last movement “tempo di Polacca,” but this music bears no relation to Polish themes or rhythms. That marking, though, did inspire the English conductor Sir August Manns to “discover” an elaborate program for this music, which he felt depicted “Poland mourning in her oppression and rejoicing in her regeneration.” This interpretation, which came six years after Tchaikovsky’s death and inspired the nickname, is nonsense, and the subtitle Polish should be forgotten.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani and strings

Concerto No. 3 in E-flat major for Piano and Orchestra, Opus 75

Premiered: January 19, 1895

Throughout his life Tchaikovsky worried that he had dried up as a composer. After his Fourth Symphony of 1877, he fell into a long creative trough and did not write his Fifth Symphony until 11 years had passed. In May 1892 he moved to a new house in Klin, outside of Moscow, and there he tried to write another symphony. Almost immediately he ran into trouble, noting in a letter to a friend: “I have begun to compose a symphony but it doesn’t go as smoothly as I might wish. I’m afraid that this is the beginning of the end, i.e., that is that I’ve written myself out.” Tchaikovsky pressed on with the symphony across all of 1892, and by December he had it sketched and partially orchestrated. But at that point the despondent composer gave up: he said that the “impression it creates is far from flattering” and decided to destroy it.

transforming the music

But Tchaikovsky did not destroy the manuscript for the symphony. Instead, he concluded that while it might not be successful as a symphony, it could be converted into music for solo piano and orchestra, and he re-cast its opening movement as his one-movement Piano Concerto No. 3. Tchaikovsky died suddenly in November 1893 without ever having heard this work. Its premiere did not take place until January 19, 1895, when Sergei Taneyev was the soloist in St. Petersburg, and since then the Third Piano Concerto has remained one of the least-familiar of Tchaikovsky’s major works.

Transforming a symphonic movement into a concerto movement brings particular challenges. In a symphonic movement, the emphasis is on the development of the musical argument, while a concerto movement is conceived from the beginning to spotlight a soloist’s virtuosity. To insert a piano soloist into the first movement of what had been intended as a symphony, Tchaikovsky had to re-write a number of orchestral passages for solo piano, sometimes changing the register and the rhythm of the music to suit the piano. And to compensate for the absence of a high-profile part for the soloist, Tchaikovsky composed a massive and very difficult cadenza. The result may be a hybrid, but the Third Piano Concerto contains some very appealing music and deserves to be heard more often.

lone movement, with a brilliant cadenza

The piano enters almost unobtrusively as part of the orchestra’s opening exposition, but Tchaikovsky soon gives it a soloistic profile, with much of the writing in brilliant octaves. The espressivo second subject had been scored for clarinet in the symphony, but now Tchaikovsky transforms this into a lovely passage for solo piano. The movement builds to what in a symphonic movement would be the start of the recapitulation, and here—as if to compensate for a lack of high-profile solo writing—Tchaikovsky supplies his soloist with a lengthy, brilliant, and episodic cadenza based on themes introduced earlier. The orchestra rejoins the pianist, and this one-movement concerto races to its conclusion along a Vivacissimo coda.

Instrumentation: solo piano with orchestra comprising 3 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani and strings

Suite from Swan Lake, Opus 20 (Suite amalgamated by Osmo Vänskä)

Premiered: March 4, 1877

Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake is such a favorite of audiences around the world that it comes as a surprise to learn that the ballet was an abject failure at its premiere. Tchaikovsky, then a young composition teacher at the Moscow Conservatory, had been commissioned by the Imperial Theater to write music for a production of this new ballet at the Bolshoi, and he worked on the score from August 1875 until April 1876. The first performance, on March 4, 1877, was a disaster: it had poor scenery, costumes, and dancing, and—worst of all—it had a conductor so alarmed by Tchaikovsky’s striking music that he cut large sections of it, substituting “safe” music by other composers in their place.

The reviews were scathing, one critic declaring: “I must say that I have never seen a poorer presentation on the stage of the Bolshoi Theatre. The costumes, decor and machines did not hide in the least the emptiness of the dances.” The same critic conceded that the music showed “the hand of the true master,” but that did Tchaikovsky little good: he never heard the music again and died believing that it would always be a failure. To the contrary: a revival in January 1895—14 months after the composer’s death—launched Swan Lake on its way to the acclaim it enjoys today.

a story of eternal charm

Swan Lake tells a story of eternal charm: Prince Siegfried discovers a flock of beautiful white swans on the lake in a forest. Their queen Odette tells him that they are all maidens who have been transformed by the evil sorcerer Von Rothbart. Though deceived by Von Rothbart and his daughter Odile (the black swan) during the climactic ball in Act III, Siegfried eventually triumphs over the sorcerer and is united with Odette.

Because Tchaikovsky never arranged the music from Swan Lake into orchestral suites, conductors are free to make their own selections. For today’s performance, Music Director Osmo Vänskä has assembled a suite of eight excerpts, drawn from all four acts of the ballet and performed in chronological order.

The rarely-heard Introduction is the anticipatory music heard just before the curtain comes up, and this is followed by two excerpts from Act I. The Scene, full of excitement and expectancy, introduces Prince Siegfried and his friends drinking wine before a beautiful setting: in the distance are a castle and a bridge across a stream. The famous Waltz is danced as part of the celebration of Prince Siegfried’s birthday.

Next come three excerpts from Act II. The Scene that opens this act, with its plangent and wistful oboe solo, has become some of the most characteristic music of this ballet, and it sets the complex mood here perfectly. This is followed by the Dance of the Swans, during which Siegfried and his fellow hunters discover the swans on the forest lake. The Pas d’action, for Odette and the Prince, begins with a long harp, followed by a deservedly-famous duet for solo violin and harp.

Act III brings the ball in the Great Hall of Siegfried’s castle; it is during this ball that Von Rothbart tricks Siegfried into choosing his daughter Odile over Odette, triggering the events of the final act, when Siegfried finally swears his devotion to Odette and the evil Von Rothbart is vanquished and dies.   Tchaikovsky had a particular flair for national dances, and this concert offers the energetic Mazurka, a dance from Poland. This suite concludes with music from the very end of Act IV. In this Final Scene the prince enters and the ballet comes to its grand conclusion.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 2 cornets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, bass drum, cymbals, castanets, tambourine, tamtam, triangle, glockenspiel, harp and strings

Program notes by Eric Bromberger.


Program Notes: Tchaikovsky Symphonies No. 2 & 5

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

Tchaikovsky Marathon: Influences
We think of Tchaikovsky as so original, so unique, that it comes as a surprise to recognize that there were strong influences on his music. The first of these was Russian folk music. Like many other Russian composers of his generation, Tchaikovsky felt the charm of the music he heard sung around him on the streets and in the fields. His Second Symphony—which opens this program—incorporates a number of ancient folksongs from the Ukraine. Another (and quite unexpected) influence on Tchaikovsky was the music of Mozart. Those two may seem very different people and composers, but Tchaikovsky admired the clarity and emotional balance of Mozart’s music; the Rococo Variations represent his effort to write this kind of music. The Fifth Symphony, however, finds Tchaikovsky speaking in a voice that is very much his own.

One-minute notes:

Tchaikovsky: Symphony No. 2
A single horn sings the opening solo of Tchaikovsky’s Second Symphony, which—in typical Tchaikovsky fashion—quotes a variety of Eastern European folk tunes. Traditional melodies from  Ukraine, or “Little Russia,” as it was then called, inspired both the musical ideas and the nickname for this work.

Variations on a Rococo Theme
From an original theme in the cello, through seven variations and a lively coda, Variations on a Rococo Theme is light, elegant and full of charm. When Franz Liszt first heard it performed, he simply exclaimed, “This is indeed music!”


Symphony No. 5
Tchaikovsky’s popular Fifth Symphony—whose primary theme, he wrote, represents “complete resignation before fate”—is filled with wonderful mottos, orchestral color, balletic beauty and high drama. Watch for the finale’s false conclusion, a great climax that tricks many listeners into thinking the performance is complete.

Full program notes:

Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Born: May 7, 1840, Votkinsk, Russia
Died: November 6, 1893, St. Petersburg, Russia

Symphony No. 2 in C minor, Opus 17, Little Russian

Premiered: February 7, 1873

Relations between Tchaikovsky and “The Five,” that influential band of Russian nationalist composers, were always a little tender. Those five—Mussorgsky, Borodin, Cui, Balakirev and Rimsky-Korsakov—admired Tchaikovsky’s talents but were suspicious of his conservatory training and his use of Western forms. Tchaikovsky’s Second Symphony, in fact, occasioned one of their few moments of cordial contact.

Tchaikovsky composed this symphony between June and November 1872, and it was first performed in Moscow on February 7, 1873. The symphony seemed to have a popular success, but César Cui, a member of The Five, savaged it in a review. Always vulnerable to criticism, Tchaikovsky was stung by this review, and seven years later he came back to the symphony and revised it. He was now a better composer, and he knew it. To his patron Madame von Meck he wrote: “Today I set out to remodel my Second Symphony. It went so well that before lunch I had made a rough draft of nearly half of the first movement…How much seven years can mean when a man is striving for progress in his work!”

a symphony infused with folk songs

The Second is Tchaikovsky’s shortest symphony, but what makes this music distinctive is his use of folk tunes for some of its themes. This was a technique favored by The Five, and Rimsky-Korsakov in particular was impressed when Tchaikovsky played this music for him on the piano. The authentic folk tunes that Tchaikovsky employed here come from the Ukraine, a region sometimes known as “Little Russia.” The nickname Little Russian, however, did not originate with the composer. It was coined by the music critic Nicholas Kashkin, and in Russia that nickname would have been understood to mean simply “Ukrainian.”

andante sostenuto–allegro vivo. The first movement opens with a long solo for French horn based on the Ukrainian folksong “Down by Mother Volga.” The music leaps ahead at the Allegro vivo, which itself sounds folksong-derived. Tchaikovsky may have had difficulty with symphonic form, but this movement is beautifully-made: the development treats both the main theme of the exposition and the horn theme from the introduction.

andantino marziale, quasi moderato. The second movement was originally the wedding march from Tchaikovsky’s ill-fated opera Undine. Over the timpani’s steady tread, woodwinds sing the little march tune; a more lyric second idea follows.

scherzo: allegro molto vivace. The third movement is a propulsive scherzo in ABA form. Metric units are quite short here: the outer sections are in 3/8, the trio in 2/8.

finale: moderato assai. Tchaikovsky’s brassy opening theme of the finale bears a striking resemblance to the “Promenade” theme of Mussorgsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition, though the Tchaikovsky was written first—but it is in fact a derivation of the Ukrainian folk tune “The Crane.” This theme accelerates until it suddenly is transformed into the athletic main idea, and Tchaikovsky offers a lilting second idea in the violins. It is no surprise that this finale—with its imaginative ideas about structure, unusual harmonic progressions, and use of folk tunes—should have delighted Rimsky-Korsakov. This movement was, in fact, Tchaikovsky’s own favorite.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, bass drum, cymbals, tamtam and strings

Variations on a Rococo Theme, for Cello and Orchestra, Opus 33

Premiered: November 30, 1877

If we automatically identify Tchaikovsky with colorful and emotional music, we need to remember that he was also drawn to the formal clarity of eighteenth-century music and loved Mozart above all other composers. One of the finest examples of this attraction is his Variations on a Rococo Theme, composed in December 1876. The immediate impulse to write it came in a commission from the cellist Wilhelm Fitzenhagen, one of Tchaikovsky’s good friends. When Fitzenhagen asked Tchaikovsky to write a piece for cello and orchestra for him, the composer responded with a set of variations based on what he called a “rococo” theme and scored for what was essentially Mozart’s orchestra (pairs of woodwinds and horns, plus strings).

the music: lyric, athletic and ingenious

A briefly orchestral introduction (how light and clear this music sounds!) gives way to the entrance of the solo cello, which sings the “rococo” theme. That theme, Tchaikovsky’s own, is marked espressivo on its first appearance and falls into two eight-bar phrases. Seven variations follow. These are nicely contrasted: some are lyric, some athletic. Some emphasize the cello, while others vigorously toss the theme between soloist and orchestra. Tchaikovsky varies key and meter throughout the set, and he ingeniously turns the final variation into an exciting coda.

Instrumentation: solo cello with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 2 horns and strings

Symphony No. 5 in E minor, Opus 64

Premiered: November 17, 1888

In the winter of 1887-88, Tchaikovsky made a tour of Western Europe, conducting his own works in Leipzig, Hamburg (where he met Brahms), Berlin, Prague, Paris and London. Those audiences responded enthusiastically to his music (Brahms was an exception), and Tchaikovsky returned to Russia ready to attempt a new symphony. In April 1888, he moved into a villa in Frolovskoye, northwest of Moscow, where he could work on his new symphony and take long walks in the woods. His Fifth Symphony was done by August, and Tchaikovsky led the premiere in St. Petersburg on November 17, 1888.

“resignation before fate”

The Fifth Symphony—full of those wonderful Tchaikovsky themes, imaginative orchestral color, and excitement—has become one of his most popular works. As he did in the Fourth, Tchaikovsky builds this symphony around a motto-theme, and in his notebooks he suggested that the motto of the Fifth Symphony represents “complete resignation before fate.” But that is as far as the resemblance goes, for Tchaikovsky supplied no program for the Fifth Symphony, nor does this music seem to be “about” anything. The motto theme returns in each of the four movements, but it may be best to understand this motto as a unifying device rather than as anything so dramatic as the Fourth Symphony’s “sword of Damocles.”

the music: a wealth of melodies, excitement—and a false ending

andante–allegro con anima. Clarinets introduce the somber motto-theme at the beginning of the slow introduction, and gradually this leads to the main body of the movement, marked Allegro con anima. Over the orchestra’s steady tread, solo clarinet and bassoon sing the movement’s surging main theme, and there follows a wealth of thematic material. This lengthy movement is built on three separate-theme groups, full of those soaring and sumptuous Tchaikovsky melodies.

andante cantabile con alcuna licenza. Deep string chords at the opening of the Andante cantabile introduce one of the great solos for French horn, and a few moments later the oboe has the graceful second subject. For a movement that begins in such relaxed spirits, this music is twice shattered by the return of the motto-theme, which blazes out dramatically in the trumpets.

valse: allegro moderato. Tchaikovsky springs a surprise in the third movement—instead of the expected scherzo, he writes a lovely waltz. He rounds the movement off beautifully with an extended coda based on the waltz tune, and in its closing moments the motto-theme makes a fleeting appearance, like a figure seen through the mists.

finale: andante maestoso–allegro vivace–moderato assai e molto maestoso. However misty that theme may have seemed at the end of the third movement, it comes into crystalline focus at the beginning of the finale. Tchaikovsky moves to E major here and sounds out the motto to open this movement. The main body of the finale, marked Allegro vivace, leaps to life, and the motto-theme breaks in more and more often as it proceeds. The movement drives to a great climax, then breaks off in silence. This is a trap, and it often tricks the unwary into premature applause, for the symphony is not yet over. Out of the ensuing silence begins the real coda, and the motto-theme now leads the way on constantly-accelerating tempos to the (true) conclusion in E major.

Instrumentation: 3 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani and strings

Program notes by Eric Bromberger.

Program Notes: Tchaikovsky Symphony No. 6

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

Tchaikovsky Marathon: Slavic heritage
Like so many Russian composers, Tchaikovsky was proud of his Slavic heritage. “I love passionately the Russian character in all its expression,” he said, a sentiment that would be echoed by The Mighty Five—Cui, Balakirev, Borodin, Mussorgsky, and Rimsky-Korsakov—and by many other Russian composers. This program begins with two works, both written when Tchaikovsky was in his thirties, that make that passion clear. His Marche Slave (Slavic March) had a frankly political purpose: Tchaikovsky was enlisted to aid the effort to get the Russian government to intervene militarily to protect their Serbian cousins. The Violin Concerto had no such purpose, but this music—in a purely classical form—is infused with a Russian character all its own, as a hostile critic was quick to point out. Eduard Hanslick, doyen of the Viennese musical establishment, recoiled before the concerto’s “Russian-ness.” Today we value it precisely for that distinct character.

One-minute notes:

Tchaikovsky: Marche Slave
Marche Slave, constructed using motives from high-spirited Serbian folksongs and the Russian national anthem, was a resounding success at its premiere in 1867 and rapidly became a cherished symbol of Slavonic patriotism.

Violin Concerto
Tchaikovsky’s dazzling Violin Concerto, once called “unplayable,” is now the vehicle of great virtuosos. It is noted equally for bravura passagework and the pure romantic realism for which the composer is known, with soulful melodies yielding to folk-like dance tunes and rhythms in the exhilarating Finale.


Symphony No. 6, Pathétique
Darkly, tenderly, beautifully, Tchaikovsky’s Sixth and final symphony communicates a mood of deep suffering. Brilliant touches include a waltz in 5/4 time, a dramatic scherzo and a lamenting melody that sinks away to silence.

Full program notes:

Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Born: May 7, 1840, Votkinsk, Russia
Died: November 6, 1893, St. Petersburg, Russia

Marche Slave, Opus 31

Premiered: November 17, 1876

In the summer of 1876 Tchaikovsky’s friend Nikolai Rubinstein asked the composer for an orchestral work to be performed at a concert to benefit Serbian victims of Turkish aggression. Part of the motive for this concert was to help generate pro-Slavonic sentiment in Russia, so that the larger nation would enter the war on the side of the Serbs.

dark beginning to triumphant close

Tchaikovsky completed the score to his Marche Slave on October 7, 1876, and the premiere took place at the benefit concert six weeks later, on November 17. The title needs to be understood carefully. It does not mean “Slave March,” but rather “Slavic March.” In this piece Tchaikovsky set out to underline the bond between the Russians and the Serbs by using musical materials from their common Slavic heritage.

Musically, Marche Slave proceeds from a dark beginning to a triumphant close, doubtless an optimistic look ahead to the victory of the Serbian cause. Tchaikovsky marks the beginning “in the manner of a funeral march,” and this somber theme is derived from a Serbian folk tune. Gradually the pace quickens, and Tchaikovsky introduces several more folk tunes; he also makes clear the connection between the Serbs and Russians by incorporating an old Tsarist anthem into the progression of these Serbian tunes. The music gradually casts off its funereal beginning, becomes stronger and more confident, and drives to a triumphant conclusion.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, 2 piccolos, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 2 cornets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, tamtam and strings

Concerto in D major for Violin and Orchestra, Opus 35

Premiered: December 4, 1881

Tchaikovsky wrote his Violin Concerto in Switzerland during the spring of 1878, sketching it in 11 days and completing the scoring in two weeks. Without asking permission, he dedicated it to the famous Russian violinist Leopold Auer, concertmaster of the Imperial Orchestra. Tchaikovsky promptly ran into a bad surprise. Auer refused to perform the concerto, reportedly calling it “unplayable.” The concerto had to wait three years before Adolph Brodsky gave the premiere in Vienna on December 4, 1881.

an infamous review

That premiere was the occasion of one of the most infamous reviews in the history of music. Eduard Hanslick savaged the concerto, saying that it “brings to us for the first time the horrid idea that there may be music that stinks to the ear.” He went on: “The violin is no longer played. It is yanked about. It is torn asunder. It is beaten black and blue…The Adagio, with its tender national melody, almost conciliates, almost wins us. But it breaks off abruptly to make way for a Finale that puts us in the midst of the brutal and wretched jollity of a Russian kermess. We see wild and vulgar faces, we hear curses, we smell bad brandy.”

Hanslick’s review has become one of the best examples of critical Wretched Excess: the insensitive destruction of a work that would go on to become one of the best-loved concertos in the repertory. But for all his blindness, Hanslick did recognize one important feature of this music—its “Russian-ness.” Tchaikovsky freely—and proudly—admitted his inspiration in this concerto: “My melodies and harmonies of folk-song character come from the fact that I grew up in the country, and in my earliest childhood was impressed by the indescribable beauty of the characteristic features of Russian folk music; also from this, that I love passionately the Russian character in all its expression; in short, I am a Russian in the fullest meaning of the word.”

the music: drama and Russian spirit

allegro moderato. The orchestra’s introduction makes a gracious opening to the concerto, and the solo violin quickly enters with a flourish and settles into the lyric opening theme, which had been prefigured in the orchestra’s introduction. A second theme is equally melodic—Tchaikovsky marks it con molt’espressione—but the development of these themes places extraordinary demands on the soloist, who must solve complicated problems with string-crossings, multiple-stops, and harmonics. Tchaikovsky himself wrote the brilliant cadenza, which makes a gentle return to the movement’s opening theme; a full recapitulation leads to the dramatic close.

canzonetta: andante; finale: allegro vivacissimo. Tchaikovsky marks the second movement Canzonetta (Little Song) and mutes solo violin and orchestral strings throughout this movement. It leads without pause to the explosive opening of the finale, marked Allegro vivacissimo, a rondo built on two themes of distinctly Russian heritage. These are the themes that reminded Hanslick of a drunken Russian brawl, but to more sympathetic ears they evoke a fiery, exciting Russian spirit. The very ending, with the violin soaring brilliantly above the hurtling orchestra, is one of the most exciting moments in this—or in any—violin concerto.

Instrumentation: solo violin with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani and strings

Symphony No. 6 in B minor, Opus 74, Pathétique

Premiered: October 28, 1893

Tchaikovsky began a new symphony in February 1893. It grew out of a note he had written to himself the previous year: “The ultimate essence of the plan of the symphony is LIFE. First movement—all impulsive passion, confidence, thirst for activity. Must be short. (Finale DEATH—result of collapse.) Second movement love; third disappointments; fourth ends dying away (also short).”

This note was the seed for Tchaikovsky’s Sixth Symphony, though the plan would be considerably modified in the course of composition. To his nephew Tchaikovsky wrote, “I had an idea for a new symphony, this time with a program—but a program of a kind that will remain an enigma to all. Let them guess it who can…This program is permeated with subjective feeling…While composing it in my mind, I wept frequently.”

Clearly, the new symphony was important to its creator, and he wished to take measure of its emotional significance with a suitable nickname. His brother Modest suggested Pathétique, and the composer agreed immediately. The term pathétique is difficult to translate into English—Tchaikovsky understood it to mean “emotional” or “passionate.” Yet the “meaning” of this symphony remains elusive.

the music: beginning and ending in darkness

adagio–allegro non troppo. The Pathétique begins in darkness. Solo bassoon sings the somber opening melody, and this smoothly evolves into the movement’s main subject at the Allegro non troppo. The second episode is a heartfelt falling melody for strings that Tchaikovsky marks “tenderly, singing, expansive.” The exposition trails off into silence, but out of that silence the orchestra explodes, and the tumultuous development centers on the opening theme. The climax comes on two huge smashes of sound—the first like a crack of thunder, the second exhausted and falling away—and a noble brass chorale draws this movement to its consoling close.

allegro con grazia. The second movement is a waltz, but instead of writing it in the waltz meter of 3/4, Tchaikovsky casts this one in 5/4. Despite the sour critic who claimed that this waltz could be danced only by someone with three feet, this is graceful music.

allegro molto vivace. This music, one of Tchaikovsky’s most exciting movements, is both scherzo and march. It opens with skittering triplets, and solo oboe quickly sounds the sharp-edged march tune. This movement is beautifully controlled: Tchaikovsky gradually builds these simple materials into a powerful march that drives to a smashing close. It is a close that inevitably brings a burst of applause, but the true ending is still to come.

finale: adagio lamentoso. The symphony concludes with a grieving slow movement that Tchaikovsky significantly marks Adagio lamentoso. It rises to an agitated climax, then slowly slips back into the blackness from which the symphony began.

Tchaikovsky led the premiere on October 28, 1893, before a St. Petersburg audience that could make little sense of so unexpected an ending. Nine days later Tchaikovsky was dead at the age of 53. At a second performance of this symphony 12 days after his death, the audience was overwhelmed by music that had left them mystified earlier, and the proximity of Tchaikovsky’s death to the premiere of this dark music gave rise to all kinds of interpretations of its meaning. Tchaikovsky himself gave no indication beyond his cryptic comment: “Let them guess it who can.”

Instrumentation: 3 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, bass drum, cymbals, tamtam and strings

Program notes by Eric Bromberger.

Program Notes: Tchaikovsky Symphony No. 4

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

Tchaikovsky Marathon: Tchaikovsky and Italy
All three pieces on this program have a connection to Italy, and all three were at least partially composed there. The connection with Capriccio italien is clear: the music was inspired by Tchaikovsky’s visit to Rome in 1880. He fell in love with that great city and incorporated some of its music into the Capriccio. The other two works come from a less happy moment in Tchaikovsky’s life, the aftermath of his disastrous marriage, when the stunned composer left Moscow and fled to Western Europe. He did some of the work on the Second Piano Concerto in Rome and completed the Fourth Symphony in San Remo, on the shores of the Mediterranean. Italy is much less an “influence” on these two works than on the Capriccio, but the fact that Tchaikovsky—at a moment of great personal distress—would choose to live and work in Italy may tell us all we need to know about his feelings for that country.

One-minute notes:

Tchaikovsky: Capriccio italien
A delightful ode to Rome, Capriccio italien opens with a striking military bugle call and continues with episodes based on Italian songs, both lyrical and lively, before the work closes with a sizzling tarantella dance.

Piano Concerto No. 2
A thundering march launches the Second Piano Concerto, which initially segregates soloist and orchestra. The middle movement offers a surprise—the hint of a triple concerto with violin and cello—while the finale has the spirit of a high-stepping country dance.


Symphony No. 4
Tchaikovsky’s Fourth Symphony, like Beethoven’s Fifth, presents a Fate motif at the outset. This is an adventurous work carrying us through lyrical episodes as well as high drama on the way to the exuberant conclusion.

Full program notes:

Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Born: May 7, 1840, Votkinsk, Russia
Died: November 6, 1893, St. Petersburg, Russia


Capriccio italien, Opus 45

Premiered: December 18, 1880

Tchaikovsky spent the winter of 1880 in Rome, and he fell in love with that city. It was carnival season, and life blazed around him: crowds, dancers, fireworks, music, the smell of food—all these were part of his impressions of the Eternal City, and suddenly Tchaikovsky felt like writing music. He turned the tunes he heard around him to good use and began writing Capriccio italien soon after his arrival. To his  patroness Nadezhda von Meck back in Russia, he explained his method: “I am working on a sketch of an ‘Italian Fantasia’ based on folk songs. Thanks to the charming themes, some of which I have heard in the streets, the work will be effective.”

brilliant Italian episodes

The term “capriccio” has no formal musical meaning. It is more a suggestion of atmosphere, indicating something unexpected (the “caprice”) or—more often—something spicy and animated. It is in the latter sense that Tchaikovsky intends the title. Formal structures were never his strong point, and he makes his “Italian Caprice” out of a series of sections in different meters and keys. The resulting structure is episodic, but few have complained—this music, based on the tunes Tchaikovsky heard around him on the streets of Rome, is just too much fun.

Capriccio italien opens with a striking military bugle call. Tchaikovsky’s lodgings in Rome were at the Hotel Constanzi, next to the barracks of the Royal Italian Cuirassiers, and he woke to this summons every morning. A series of episodes based on Italian tunes follows. Throughout, Tchaikovsky’s keen orchestral sense is always in evidence: this music is brilliantly orchestrated, and Capriccio italien just plain sounds good. Tchaikovsky rounds matters off with a tarantella, a blazing Italian dance in 6/8.

Instrumentation: 3 flutes (1 doubling piccolo), 2 oboes, English horn, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 2 cornets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, bass drum, cymbals, tambourine, triangle, glockenspiel, harp and strings

Concerto No. 2 in G major for Piano and Orchestra, Opus 44

Premiered: November 12, 1881

Tchaikovsky’s First Piano Concerto had caused a serious rift between Tchaikovsky and one of his closest friends, the pianist Nikolai Rubinstein (as detailed here). Both wanted to mend fences, and the composer decided to do this by writing a new concerto, tailored to Rubinstein’s fabulous abilities as a pianist. The compositional process spanned a variety of locales: Tchaikovsky began the concerto in October 1879 at his family’s summer estate in Ukraine, then brought the manuscript with him for further work in Paris and Rome, and then back to Russia, where he completed the concerto in March 1880.

the music: grand, intimate and virtuosic

allegro brillante e molto vivace. The Second Piano Concerto gets off to an impressive start on the grand stride of the orchestra’s opening statement, with the pianist quickly picking this up as a huge chordal melody. Tchaikovsky offers some quick interplay between soloist and orchestra before an expectant tremolo from the strings sets the stage for the second subject. This falls into two parts: solo clarinet and horn share what might be called an opening phrase, and the piano responds with the tune-like second half. Tchaikovsky develops these over a huge span, and along the way there are two separate cadenzas for the soloist.

andante non troppo. The atmosphere changes completely in this movement, which is—for long periods—simply chamber music. Piano alone announces the principal idea, but is soon joined by solo violin and solo cello, making this movement essentially a concerto for piano trio.

allegro con fuoco. The concluding movement has a rondo-like structure based on two completely different ideas. Tchaikovsky gives the pianist a truly virtuoso part, and the themes are so appealing and the music so energetic that they sweep everything before them as the concerto thunders to its close.

Instrumentation: solo piano with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, timpani and strings

Symphony No. 4 in F minor, Opus 36

Premiered: February 22, 1878

The Fourth Symphony dates from the most tumultuous period in Tchaikovsky’s difficult life. In July 1877, Tchaikovsky married one of his students at the Moscow Conservatory, Antonina Ivanovna Milyukova. The marriage was an instant disaster. Tchaikovsky abandoned his bride, tried to return, but retreated again. He fled to Western Europe, finding relief in the quiet of Clarens in Switzerland and San Remo in Italy. It was in San Remo—on the sunny shores of the Mediterranean and far from the chaos of his life in Moscow—that he completed the Fourth Symphony in January 1878.

The Fourth Symphony has all of Tchaikovsky’s considerable virtues—great melodies, primary colors, and soaring climaxes—in this case fused with a superheated emotional content. Tchaikovsky said that the model for his Fourth Symphony had been Beethoven’s Fifth, specifically in the way both symphonies are structured around a recurring motif, though perhaps also in the sense that the two symphonies begin in emotional turmoil and eventually win their way to release and triumph in the finale.

the music: a duel with fate

andante sostenuto–moderato con anima. The symphony opens with a powerful brass fanfare, which Tchaikovsky described as “Fate, the inexorable power that hampers our search for happiness. This power hangs over our heads like the sword of Damocles, leaving us no option but to submit.” The principal subject of this movement, however, is a dark, stumbling waltz in 9/8 introduced by the violins. Like inescapable fate, the opening motto-theme returns at key points in this dramatic music, and it finally drives the movement to a furious close.

andantino in modo canzona. The two middle movements bring much-needed relief. The Andantino, in ternary-form, opens with a plaintive oboe solo and features a more animated middle section. Tchaikovsky described it: “Here is the melancholy feeling that overcomes us when we sit weary and alone at the end of the day. The book we pick up slips from our fingers, and a procession of memories passes in review…”

scherzo: pizzicato ostinato. The scherzo has deservedly become one of Tchaikovsky’s most popular movements. It is a tour de force for strings, which play pizzicato throughout, with crisp interjections first from the woodwinds and then from brass. The composer noted: “Here are only the capricious arabesques and indeterminate shapes that come into one’s mind with a little wine…”

finale: allegro con fuoco. Out of the quiet close of the third movement, the finale explodes to life. The composer described this movement as “the picture of a folk holiday” and said, “If you find no pleasure in yourself, look about you. Go to the people. See how they can enjoy life and give themselves up entirely to festivity.” Marked Allegro con fuoco, this movement simply alternates its volcanic opening sequence with a gentle tune that is actually the Russian folk tune “In the field there stood a birch tree.”

Given the catastrophic events of his life during this music’s composition, Tchaikovsky may well have come to feel that Fate was inescapable, and the reappearance of the opening motto amid the high spirits of the finale represents the climax—musically and emotionally—of the entire symphony. This spectre duly acknowledged, Tchaikovsky rips the symphony to a close guaranteed to set every heart in the hall racing at the same incandescent pace as his music.

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, bass drum, cymbals, triangle and strings

Program notes by Eric Bromberger.


Program Notes: Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 1

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

Tchaikovsky Marathon: Music by a (mostly) young composer
Some composers achieve success effortlessly. Others struggle for years. Tchaikovsky was in the latter camp. He made his first attempt at composition at age 4, but his apprenticeship was long and difficult. Compounding the problem was Tchaikovsky’s sensitivity to criticism, both from others and from continual self-doubt. Yet even as a young composer he produced some radiant scores, and this concert offers two pieces that had to overcome much opposition. The First Symphony attracted so much criticism while still in manuscript that Tchaikovsky could get only individual movements performed and had to wait years for a complete performance. The First Piano Concerto provoked the most destructive criticism the composer ever faced. But it also revealed a tough confidence beneath his perpetual self-doubt: Tchaikovsky refused to make any changes, and the concerto went on to become one of his best-loved works.

One-minute notes:

Tchaikovsky: Symphony No. 1, Winter Dreams
Tchaikovsky’s First Symphony, nicknamed Winter Dreams, begins with harmonies that evoke the crispness of a fresh winter’s snow; the work grows with a fiery energy that burns brilliant until the final note.


Serenade for Strings
Tchaikovsky’s Serenade for Strings is the composer’s nod back to Mozart and his music of the same genre. Throughout the serenade’s four movements, the strings sparkle and dance, are graceful yet  animated, relaxed but incredibly beautiful. The first chorale theme makes a remarkable return at the very end of the work.

Piano Concerto No. 1 
Like Beethoven, who angrily removed Napoleon’s name from his Eroica Symphony, Tchaikovsky furiously scratched out the name Nikolai Rubinstein, the intended dedicatee of his famous First Piano  Concerto—and it became an instant success in the hands of the man he then honored with the dedication, Hans von Bülow. It begins with high drama, retreats to a place of calm and rushes toward its close in a mood of white-hot energy

Full program notes:

Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky
Born: May 7, 1840, Votkinsk, Russia
Died: November 6, 1893, St. Petersburg, Russia

Symphony No. 1 in G minor, Opus 13, Winter Dreams

Premiered: February 15, 1868

In December 1865, Tchaikovsky graduated from the St. Petersburg Conservatory and took the only steady job he ever had. The Rubinstein brothers—composer Nikolai and pianist Anton—invited him to join the faculty of the Moscow Conservatory, and Tchaikovsky moved to Moscow in January 1866 to become a professor of harmony. Nikolai led a successful performance in March 1866 of Tchaikovsky’s Overture in F major, and the brothers encouraged him to take on the most imposing of orchestral forms, the symphony. It was a daunting prospect for a young composer still uncertain about his abilities, and the composition of what would become his first symphony proved harrowing.

stress, then success

Tchaikovsky made a first draft between March and August 1866, but when he showed his manuscript to Anton, the reaction was so caustic that Tchaikovsky went back and completely rewrote it. In fact, the stress was so great that Tchaikovsky came near to collapse—he was doubtless relieved when his doctors ordered him to put the work aside for awhile and collect his faculties. He had the score done by December 22, but the symphony had to wait a year for its premiere. It was worth the wait: that performance, which took place in Moscow on February 15, 1868, was a great success.

Tchaikovsky’s First Symphony has not really held a place in the repertory, but this music—youthful, melodic, and far from the tortured intensity of some of Tchaikovsky’s later scores—has pleasures of its own. It also has a curious nickname, one for which Tchaikovsky himself was partially responsible. This is not programmatic music, as Tchaikovsky was intent on mastering the symphony on its own terms. He did, however, give the first two movements subtitles, and the one he gave the first movement (“Dreams on a wintry road”) has been transformed into a general nickname for the symphony: Winter Dreams (sometimes rendered as Winter Daydreams). That is an evocative title, but it may not make for an ideal entry into this music, which at moments is full of a fire and excitement far removed from our usual sense of winter.

the music: wintry inspiration and a folksong finale

allegro tranquillo. Certainly no one would on his or her own guess that the first movement should be subtitled “Dreams on a wintry road,” and listeners should take this at most as a suggestion of general atmosphere. This sonata-form movement gets off to a wonderful start: over rustling strings, solo flute and bassoon in octaves outline the main theme, and Tchaikovsky quickly spins a rhythmic sub-theme from this. Solo clarinet has the second subject, and these two theme-groups develop at some length.

adagio cantabile ma non tanto. Tchaikovsky’s subtitle for the second movement, “Land of gloom, land of mist,” is misleading, for this lovely music is so appealing that it has occasionally been performed by itself. Once again, it is based on two theme-groups, which Tchaikovsky simply alternates across the span of the movement. Muted strings make for a lush beginning, and solo oboe introduces what at first seems a melancholy second subject, but the cellos quickly pick this up and make it dance.

scherzo: allegro scherzando giocoso. Neither of the final two movements has a subtitle; perhaps at this point Tchaikovsky had abandoned the wintry inspiration. His performance marking for the Scherzo is worth noting: he wants this movement not just scherzando (jesting) but also giocoso (happy). Its energetic main idea tumbles and cascades along the 3/8 meter. The trio section has been called the first of Tchaikovsky’s great orchestral waltzes. He preserves the 3/8 meter of the scherzo, and this waltz dances energetically.

finale: andante lugubre–allegro moderato–allegro maestoso. The finale begins with a slow introduction based on the old Russian folk tune “The Garden Bloomed,” and which he specifies should be lugubre (gloomy). But sunlight shines through at the Allegro moderato, and Tchaikovsky deftly transforms the folk tune of the slow introduction into the spirited second subject.

Tchaikovsky’s First Symphony is rarely performed today, but he remembered it fondly. Late in his relatively brief life, he described it as “better than many of my other more mature works.”

Instrumentation: 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, tuba, timpani, bass drum, cymbals and strings

Serenade in C major for Strings, Opus 48

Premiered: December 3, 1880 (private performance); October 30, 1881 (public performance)

In the fall of 1880, Tchaikovsky set to work simultaneously on two very different pieces. One was the Serenade for Strings; the other was the 1812 Overture. The composer loved the first of these, but had no use for the second.

To his benefactress, Madame Nadezhda von Meck, he wrote: “I have written two long works very rapidly: the festival overture and a Serenade in four movements for string orchestra. The overture will be very noisy. I wrote it without much warmth or enthusiasm; and therefore it has no great artistic value. The Serenade on the contrary, I wrote from an inward impulse: I felt it; and I venture to hope that this work is not without artistic qualities.”

In a way, the two pieces are opposites, for the Serenade—lyric, open, relaxed—is everything the bombastic 1812 Overture is not, and it comes as no surprise that Tchaikovsky had such fondness for this music.

the music: Tchaikovsky at his friendliest

pezzo in forma di sonatina: andante non troppo–allegro moderato. Tchaikovsky intended this work’s opening movement as an homage to one of his favorite composers: Mozart. Although Tchaikovsky called the composition a serenade and specifically set the first movement in sonatina form—both of which  suggest an absence of rigorous formal development—this music is nevertheless beautifully unified. The powerful descending introduction quickly gives way to the Allegro moderato, based on two subjects: a broadly-swung melody for full orchestra and a sparkling theme for violins. Tchaikovsky brings back the introductory theme to close out the movement.

walzer: moderato–tempo di valse. Waltzes were a specialty of Tchaikovsky, and this movement is one of his finest. It gets off to a graceful start, grows more animated as it proceeds, then falls away to wink out on two pizzicato strokes.

elégie: largetto elegiac. The third movement, titled Elegie, begins with a quiet melody that soon grows in intensity and beauty. The mood here never becomes tragic—the Serenade remains, for the most part, in major keys—but the depth of feeling with which this Larghetto elegiaco unfolds makes it the emotional  center of the entire work.

finale (tema Russo): andante–allegro con spirito. The finale has a wonderful beginning. Very quietly the violins play a melody based on a Russian folk tune, reputedly an old hauling song from the Volga River, and suddenly the main theme bursts out and the movement takes wing. The Allegro con spirito  theme is closely related to the introduction of the first movement, and at the end Tchaikovsky deftly combines these two themes to bring one of his friendliest compositions to an exciting close.

Instrumentation: strings alone

Piano Concerto No. 1 in B-flat Minor, Opus 23

Premiered: October 25, 1875

Tchaikovsky drafted this most famous of piano concertos in November and December 1874, when he was a young professor at the Moscow Conservatory. Only modestly talented as a pianist and insecure about his handling of larger forms, Tchaikovsky sought the advice of Nikolai Rubinstein, head of the Conservatory and the man to whom he intended to dedicate the concerto. Rubinstein listened in silence as Tchaikovsky played the new work through, and then, as the composer later recounted:

“There burst from Rubinstein’s mouth a mighty torrent of words. He spoke quietly at first, then he waxed hot, and finally he resembled Zeus hurling thunderbolts. It seems that my concerto was utterly worthless, absolutely unplayable. Certain passages were so commonplace and awkward they could not be improved, and the piece as a whole was bad, trivial, vulgar. I had stolen this from somebody and that from somebody else, so that only two or three pages were good for anything and all the rest should be wiped out or radically rewritten.”

a triumphant premiere

Stung (and furious), Tchaikovsky refused to change a note, erased the dedication to Rubinstein, and instead dedicated the concerto to the German pianist-conductor Hans von Bülow, who had championed his music. Bülow promptly took the concerto on a tour of the United States, and it was in Boston on October 25, 1875, that Tchaikovsky’s First Piano Concerto was heard for the first time.

It was a huge success on that occasion, and Bülow played it repeatedly in this country to rhapsodic reviews. A critic in Boston, taking note of that success, described the concerto as an “extremely difficult, strange, wild, ultra-modern Russian Concerto,” but back in Russia the composer read the press clippings and was beside himself with happiness: “Think what healthy appetites these Americans must have! Each time Bülow was obliged to repeat the whole finale of my concerto! Nothing like that happens in our country.”

Rubinstein eventually saw the error of his initial condemnation and became one of the concerto’s great champions. (It should be noted, though, that in 1889— perhaps more aware of Rubinstein’s criticisms than he cared to admit—Tchaikovsky did in fact take the concerto through a major revision, and it is in this form that we know it today).

the music: a famous, ephemeral opening

allegro non troppo e molto maestoso. The concerto has one of the most dramatic beginnings in all the literature, ringing with horn fanfares and cannonades of huge piano chords, followed by one of Tchaikovsky’s Great Tunes, in which that horn fanfare is transformed into a flowing melody for strings. This opening has become extremely famous, but this introductory section has many quirks. It is in the “wrong” key (D-flat major), and—however striking it may be—it never returns in any form: Tchaikovsky simply abandons all this tremendous material when he gets to the main section of the movement.

This “real” beginning, marked Allegro con spirito, is finally in the correct key of B-flat minor, and the piano’s skittering main subject is reportedly based on a tune Tchaikovsky heard a blind beggar whistle at a fair in the Ukraine. The expected secondary material quickly appears—a chorale-like theme for winds and a surging, climbing figure for strings—though Tchaikovsky evades expectations by including multiple cadenzas for the soloist in this movement. The piano writing is of the greatest difficulty (much of it in great hammered octaves), and the movement drives to a dramatic close.

andantino semplice. The Andantino semplice is aptly named, for this truly is simple music in the best sense of that term: over pizzicato chords, solo flute sings the gentle main theme, an island of calm after the searing first movement. A scherzo-like central episode marked Prestissimo leads to the return of the opening material and a quiet close.

allegro con fuoco. The finale is also well named, for here is music full of fire. It is a rondo based on the piano’s nervous, dancing main theme, and while calmer episodes break into this furious rush, the principal impression this music makes is of white-hot energy, and this “strange, wild, ultra-modern Russian Concerto” rushes to a knock-out close that is just as impressive to audiences today as it was to that first Boston audience in 1875.

Instrumentation: solo piano with orchestra comprising 2 flutes, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, 2 bassoons, 4 horns, 2 trumpets, 3 trombones, timpani and strings


Chopin, the Piano and Me

by Al Sicherman

I’m taking piano lessons—as a grownup (if, at 63, that’s what I am). And, surprisingly, it’s working!

The last time I “took” piano was in a public-school group class in first or second grade, and to say I was terrible greatly understates the situation: I was stubborn, too. Notably, I refused to accept the teacher’s stultifying notion that particular notes should be played with particular fingers.

To prove her wrong, I went home and sort-ofmemorized some piece of music, and although I played it absolutely wretchedly, I did so with an entirely free-style approach to fingering. The result was an abrupt (but satisfying) conclusion to my piano education. For the next 50-some years.

Now and then in my adult life, I’ve thought of resuming my piano career (I have schlepped my grandmother’s piano from house to house through my last seven moves), but I never did so. I think I assumed it would be like my grade-school experience, but without the sailor suit. In any case, it never happened until a friend who’s an accomplished pianist raved about her teacher and prodded me to call her.

There are many ways that taking piano lessons as an adult differs from doing it as a kid. Two big ones are that I’m paying, so I’m practicing, and that when I ask questions—at least with my teacher, Stephanie Wendt, who is wonderful—I get very good, thoughtful answers. (Sometimes, if I’m really not ready for the lesson, I’ll ask a question that deserves a long answer.)

Anyway, after a couple of years I was playing simple pieces—works that don’t require using very many fingers at once, and that contain the agony to one page. That might not sound like much, but I’d started from zero, and I was pretty pleased.

One day I was at a friend’s house and a Chopin CD was playing. I don’t know many pieces of classical music beyond the William Tell Overture and what Tommy Smothers called “Clyde DeBussy’s immoral Clune de Bune,” but when the Nocturne No. 2 in E-flat started, I realized not only that I knew it (I think it must have been on one of the RCA Victor Red Seal 78s kept in the wind-up phonograph on my parents’ back porch in Milwaukee), but also that I have always loved it. And at my next lesson, what the heck, I asked Stephanie if there was any way I could learn to play it. I expected a pleasant but firm outline of the many hurdles between me and Chopin, and a suggestion that, having somehow made it from A to B, we should continue our steady, measured progress toward C, and that we’d get to Chopin somewhere around Q, if I was still alive.

This is the very best thing about adult piano— and about having a wonderful teacher: what she actually said was that, well, it would take quite a while, and it would be the first time she’d used a Chopin nocturne to teach using the pedal, but if I really wanted to play it, that’s what we’d do.

Stephanie was right. It took about a year, and it’s still far from polished, but it’s recognizably (and not very wretchedly) a Chopin nocturne. And I can play it for myself whenever I want. Which is five or six times a week.

I can’t play it for anyone else without freezing up, but public performance was nothing I’d wanted— and I’ve discovered that I can play it in public if people eat and talk while I play, so they can’t hear me.

Stephanie and I agreed recently that although I haven’t exactly defeated the E-flat Nocturne I have at least fought it to a draw, and I need to move on to another piece.

I picked another Chopin nocturne. I think I have time.

The late, much-loved Al Sicherman, who died in August 2017, wasn’t known for writing about music: for decades he charmed Star Tribune readers with his columns on food and on, as he put it, “the endless variety of human failings.” We’re grateful that Al made time not only to learn Chopin nocturnes, but to share his experience in this Showcase essay, first published in 2005.

Meet an Artist: Alejandro Vega

On December 21, the Minnesota Orchestra presents two performances of a new concert called  Home for the Holidays. Middle-schooler Alejandro Vega —who is a bright, young actor and singer — makes his Minnesota Orchestra debut in these performances. We took some time to get to know Alejandro and talk about his role in this new show as we prepare for the concerts. 

Home for the Holidays was conceived and directed by Peter Rothstein, written by Kevin Kling, features music by composers Robert Elhai and Peter Ostroushko, and is conducted by Sarah Hicks. A talented cast of Minnesota-based actor-singers will join the Orchestra onstage to share holiday stories and music that are uniquely Minnesotan. 

How would you describe Home for the Holidays in 5 words or less?
Quirky family holiday experiences

What is your role in this new holiday show?
In a way, I am an assistant to Kevin Kling’s narrating—I am a younger version of Kevin Kling. It helps to have the perspective of what an older person (Kevin) would think and what a child (me) would experience or think in different situations.

Do you have a favorite song or scene?
My favorite song in the show is probably is In Praise of MN Foods—the music and the singing are complex (at least for me they are), and it really brings another comedic and melodic level to the show.

Alejandro in Peter Pan at The Children's Theatre. Photo credit: Dan Norman

Of all of your onstage roles, which has been your favorite and why?
I played Albert Grissom at the Guthrie in 7th House Theater’s The Passage or What Comes of Searching in the Dark. I enjoyed the role because I got to be extremely imaginative. I played a kid who changed a very dark personal experience into a creative game to try to save his dad from an inevitable death. In some way Albert was in denial, but to save his childhood he needed to embrace it.  

What holiday traditions do you have with your friends or family?
When we go to Mexico for Christmas to spend time with family, it is so much fun. There is a whole week of pre-Christmas parties called Posadas when we reenact the journey of Mary and Joseph looking for lodging. Each night the celebration ends with a piñata. On Christmas Eve, we go to church and then our huge family gets together—but it starts really late, like around 9 pm. We open presents, and we have dinner at midnight after everyone hugs and kisses to celebrate the birth of Jesus. Then Santa Claus comes on Christmas Day. A week after New Year’s, the Reyes Magos (Three Wise Men) come and leave presents in our shoes.

What is on your holiday wish list this year?
Nintendo Switch, clothes, rock climbing shoes, my 2 front teeth. 

Alejandro in The Shining with Minnesota Opera. Photo courtesy Minnesota Opera. 


Do you have a favorite Minnesota activity or food?
Fishing at the cabin with my dad and uncle, and eating alligator and corn on the cob at the Minnesota State Fair.

If you were programming your own Minnesota Orchestra concert, what music would you have them play?
Green Day.

Do you have other upcoming performances you are looking forward to?
I am really excited about a show I am doing this April at Theater Latté Da called Five Points. It’s a world premiere. The music and lyrics are so good. Even though it takes place during the U.S. Civil War, the message is really important today.

Alejandro in The Shining with Minnesota Opera. Photo courtesy of Minnesota Opera. 

ALEJANDRO VEGA is excited to be making his Minnesota Orchestra debut in Home for the Holidays. Alejandro has performed with Theater Latté Da in Oliver!, Gypsy, and the NEXT Festival 2017. He appeared in The Shining (Danny Torrance) with the Minnesota Opera, Damn Kids These Days in the MN Fringe Festival, The Passage with 7th House Theater/Guthrie Theater, and in Hennepin Theater Trust’s Spotlight Showcase. Alejandro has also performed with the Children’s Theatre Company in The Abmoninables, Peter Pan The Musical and The Wizard of Oz. Besides theater, Alejandro enjoys anime and manga, kendamas, listening to music, dance, soccer, surfing, skateboarding, math and science. Ale is in 7th grade at Minnetonka Middle School East in the Chinese immersion program. He will next be seen in the world premiere of Five Points at Theater Latté Da.

Top Photo Credit: Stephan Kistler

Program Notes: A Christmas Oratorio

Download program page (pdf) | Buy tickets to this performance

One-minute notes:

Bach: Christmas Oratorio

The Christmas season of 1734–35 in Leipzig, Germany, included a multi-day unveiling of newly-composed music by Bach that we now know as the Christmas Oratorio. Each of its six cantatas was designated for a specific day spanning Christmas and the Epiphany, and together the set forms the narrative of the birth of Christ through the arrival of the Wise Men. These concerts feature the first three cantatas. In the first, the orchestra, choir and soloists jubilantly celebrate the birth of Christ with regal chorale melodies and arias, punctuated by the addition of trumpets and drums. The second cantata, marking the Angel’s announcement to the shepherds, opens with a pastoral orchestral sinfonia—the only one of its kind that Bach includes in the oratorio. Elation is apparent in the third cantata as brilliant choruses and trumpet fanfares depict the shepherds’ adoration of the newborn King. 

Full program notes:

Johann Sebastian Bach

Born: March 21, 1685, Eisenach, Germany

Died: July 28, 1750, Leipzig, Germany

Christmas Oratorio, BWV 248, Cantatas I, II and III

In the 18th century, the town of Leipzig celebrated the birth of Jesus and the events surrounding it not with a single feast day, but with a “season” of six special commemorations occurring between Christmas Day and the Feast of the Epiphany. These were the birth of Jesus (December 25), the announcement to the shepherds by a host of angels (December 26), the adoration of the baby by the shepherds (December 27), the circumcision and naming of Jesus (New Year’s Day), the coming of the Magi from the East to find the child “born King of the Jews” (the Sunday after New Year’s Day), and finally the Magi’s worship with their gifts (January 6). On each of these six days near the mid-1730s, Johann Sebastian Bach’s congregation was filled with inspiration by a cantata that recounted one of these stories, commenting and reflecting upon the events and their meanings for the Christian individual and community.

a unique oratorio for the season

Bach’s Christmas Oratorio, completed around Christmastime of 1734, is not an oratorio in the usual sense. Instead the format is that of a cantata. Like the composer’s Matthew and John passions, it includes a tenor Evangelist who narrates the story of the birth of Christ as it appears in the Gospels of Luke and Matthew. In order to keep clear what is narrative and what is commentary, all the Evangelist recitatives—the Gospel texts—are secco (dry, with simple chords from the cello and organ), while the other recitatives are paired with more complex instrumental lines or string accompaniment. These recitatives are unified by lyrical meditations, or arias. The rich, imaginative harmonizations of the ten chorales reflect the voice of the people, as they were hymn tunes mostly well known to Bach’s congregation, the oratorio’s initial audience.

The compiler of the libretto remains unknown, but most scholars believe that Christian Friedrich Henrici (under the pseudonym Picander), a German poet and the librettist for many of Bach’s Leipzig cantatas, probably gathered and arranged the texts.

Bach had already composed virtually all of his cantatas when he came to assemble the Christmas Oratorio. In fact, many of the movements are paraphrases from two earlier secular cantatas i dating from 1733, the year before he produced the Christmas Oratorio. Because of this, it is difficult to judge the extent to which Bach viewed the work as an entity. However, one might point to the unifying aspect of the same chorale used in the first and last cantatas. Equally convincing is the fact that all of the opening choruses are composed in triple meter—an understood symbol of the Holy Trinity—and the oratorio commences and concludes in D major. Yet, there is no one consistent structural pattern uniting these cantatas. Five of them begin with a rousing major-key chorus, and one with a sinfonia. All but one end with a chorale, but there is no homogeneity in their presentation, ranging from the unadorned four-part setting of the fifth to the resplendent, chorale-fantasia of the sixth.

Today’s concert features the first, second and third cantatas of the Christmas Oratorio, thus condensing three days of celebration, as Bach’s original audience would have experienced this music, into a single performance.

the cantatas in brief

On the First Day of the Festival of Christmas (The Nativity). The opening chorus of the Christmas Oratorio is a paraphrase, taken from the secular birthday cantata for Maria Josepha, Queen of Poland and Electress, BWV 214, from which Bach subsequently parodied a number of movements for the oratorio. The text for the original chorus called upon drums, trumpets and strings to fill the air. Bach’s transformation of this material to wonderful and idiomatic Christmas music is a marvel. The opening chorus begins with the drums and is followed up by a mighty rush with the strings and winds to the dazzling entrance of the trumpets. Surrounded by two oboes d’amore, the mezzo recitative expresses contentment with the impending birth, leading us to the first aria, a paraphrase from BWV 213, a cantata originally composed for the House of Saxony. The original text, a denunciation of lust and the serpents of sin, now becomes a call to action: prepare yourself Zion, to behold the fairest.

The first and final chorales of the oratorio are a setting of the Passion chorale, which we usually associate with Lent. However, Bach’s congregations would have been familiar with it as it exists in previously-heard cantatas. The movement that follows for bass soloist and the sopranos of the choir is among one of the most interesting movements in Bach’s entire cantata canon. Bach gives the sopranos four chorale phrases, each in a different key, and each is preceded and followed by an instrumental ritornello framing the entire movement. Furthermore, the chorale statements are extended by the bass’s additional explanatory comment. This unique hybrid structure leads us to the powerful bass aria, another paraphrase from BWV 214, whose original form was a song of homage to the queen. A wonderful and grand setting of Vom Himmel hoch, da komm ich her (From heaven above to earth I come), with trumpets and drums punctuating each cadence, ends the first cantata.

On the Second Day of the Festival of Christmas (The Annunciation to the Shepherds). This is the only one of the six Christmas Oratorio cantatas not to begin with a celebratory chorus but rather with an expansive sinfonia. With the oboes as shepherds accompanied by flutes and strings as the heavenly choir of angels, the gently undulating dotted rhythms shape a lush, pastoral effect.

The Evangelist then paints the picture of the shepherds in the fields when the Angel of the Lord appears. The unsophisticated, yet beautiful chorale Brich an, o schönes Morgenlicht (Break forth, o lovely light of morning) contemplates the child’s radiance. Two short recitatives act as a bridge to the first aria of the cantata, the first accompanied by strings and the second by the oboe choir. In the first the Angel, encompassed by a halo of sustained strings, announces the birth of the savior. The bass, backed by emphasizing woodwind chords, brings a reminder of the ancient promise. The tenor and flute aria is a call for them to gather, hasten and see for themselves the child who can refresh both body and spirit, as depicted by sweeping melismas (multiple notes extending the same syllable) in the voice and flute.

The Evangelist then describes the infant Jesus in the manger. The chorale tune Vom Himmel hoch (From heaven above), one of the most beloved of the chorales, paints a darkish picture of the child in the gloomy stable where oxen once fed setting the scene for the gorgeous slumber aria for mezzo, flute and strings. Notice how the flute hovers above the mezzo voice like a halo. The chorus then sings, without instrumental introduction, the energetic “Glory to God” chorus. There are two stunning moments when “peace on earth” is called for, compelling the choir to sing in hushed tones while the primarily eighth-note-driven continuo line temporarily subsides. The section ends with Vom Himmel hoch, this time accompanied by motives from the opening sinfonia.

On the Third Day of the Festival of Christmas (The Adoration of the Shepherds). The third cantata completes the narrative wherein the shepherds and others hasten to the manger, extolling Jesus’ powers. It begins with a brilliant chorus, again recycled from an earlier secular cantata, with trumpets and drums. The Evangelist tells of the shepherds making their way to Bethlehem. These words are encapsulated in the following chorus, less fully orchestrated and even shorter than the first. One of Bach’s typically energized bass lines suggests determination while the flowing flute and violin melody intimates a flurry of activity.

A rather lengthy contemplative section follows. The first of the three plainly harmonized chorales Gelobet seist du, Jesu Christ (Praise be to You, Jesus Christ) offers a summation of what the shepherds have been told. The jaunty, rustic duet for bass, soprano, and two oboes d’amore is addressed to the child, placing emphasis upon love and devotion. The Evangelist continues telling of the shepherds finding Mary, Joseph and the Child. The mezzo then sings an aria with violin describing Mary’s innermost feelings of the miracle of the birth. The shepherds retreat, praising God for what they have witnessed. The final chorale is the only one in a minor mode and is, perhaps, the most potent of the hymn tunes used in the oratorio so far. It is serious, direct, and delivers an authoritative message of great significance. The opening chorus is repeated to close the cantata.

Program notes ©Craig Smith and Ryan Turner, courtesy of Emmanuel Music,


Hope Never Sounded So Good

On October 7th, guest blogger Mandy Meisner went to the “Send Me Hope” concert conducted by Roderick Cox. How was this concert different than the usual fare? Read on to find out.

Community. It’s a word I use often. It’s a rally cry and the great unifier among diversity. And community is also overwhelming challenge and profound heartache. It is all these things simultaneously, and we are responsible for shaping it into something good, while shedding light into the dark corners to see what is there.

Last month’s “Send Me Hope” concert is an intriguing proposition, incorporating cultural awareness, mixed art forms and difficult history. Throw in the venue of Orchestra Hall, a place that traditionally hosts the music of Mozart and Bach, and this unusual offering holds great appeal. Its origins extend back a year ago with a collaborative “Spirit of the Season” concert in north Minneapolis at Shiloh Temple International Ministries. Associate Conductor Roderick Cox led their church choir in a joint performance of the Handel’s Hallelujah Chorus with the Minnesota Orchestra, and the room-shaking experience demanded an encore.

From the very beginning of the “Send Me Hope” evening, the energy is palpable. Men and women crowd the lobby, a large number of them African American. Young children look crisp in their finest as they are pulled excitedly by their parents, and laughter bounces off in deep throaty cannons.

I take my seat and make acquaintance with the people around me; some have never been to Orchestra Hall before. They are beaming. When Roderick Cox enters the stage, you can feel the collective adore from the audience and performers alike. He says a few words that are heartfelt and welcoming, making the large space feel intimate. As he conducts the opening Ballade in A minor by Samuel Coleridge-Taylor, I see the crimson lining of his jacket peek out in the wake of his passionate gestures.

The kids of the Shiloh Temple Drummer Boys and MacPhail Northside Youth Orchestra line on stage, as still as mice. Their faces are arranged in serious expressions, and one arcs his head to see the full scope of their fans, his eyes wide. When the drumming starts, they play their music with deep focus, their small arms piston in furious motion, producing incredible syncopation.

Nygel Witherspoon, the young cellist for the Dvořák Concerto, sits calmly on stage waiting for his entrance under a cloud of tight curls. He plays with confidence and agility, as undisturbed as a pool of still water. There is a tenderness to his sound. It is sweet and refreshing, everything that youth should be.

The next piece is the gospel choir. I am not familiar with gospel music, having instead the experience of Catholic mass, a more restrictive form of worship often held under giant panes of stained glass and the white curls of incense. Here We Are is introduced as a commemorative work by Dr. Henry Panion III, giving remembrance to the four little girls killed in the bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church in 1963. This will be followed by its partner, Send Me Hope, about reflecting, honoring and moving forward.

Here We Are is powerful music. As voices shout out “where are the girls?!” I feel the tragedy press against me. But this piece does not dwell in the anguish, it quickly moves to we are here—in a better place, watching over you, the love remains. The largeness of this is deeply moving.

As the vocals continue, the pure joy and talent and vitality of the choir rushes over us in waves. We don’t wait for the end of the concert to give a standing ovation, we are on our feet after nearly every piece, whooping and clapping, laughing and smiling, the tide of energy flowing back to the performers. We all go wild during More Abundantly.

Taiyon J. Coleman’s last spoken word of the night enchants and activates us. Her clear voice fills the hall, its deep timbre as solid and strong as oak. Her message is clear: that we have power to influence in small and meaningful ways, no matter how dark. Her words seep into us, make us somber in their truth and importance.

The concert closes the night with Total Praise, a simple melody with a simple message, sung with heartfelt devotion and abandonment by this beautiful Minneapolis gospel choir. “You are the source of my strength. You are the strength of my life. I lift my hands in total praise to you.”      

Hope never sounded so good.